- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramakrishna Transports v. Commissioner Of Income Tax
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Reference under Section 66(1) of the Income-tax Act 1929)
Factual and Procedural Background
The reference arises under Section 66(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1929. The specific question referred was:
“Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the firm of Ramakrisbna Transports, Kalahasthi was entitled to registration under Section 26(A) of the Act.”
The dispute concerned the assessment year 1959–60 (accounting year ending 31-3-1959). The assessee was a partnership firm (instrument dated 27-3-1955) carrying on bus transport. Two partners — Sri Venugopala Reddy and Ramakrishna Reddy — were co-parceners of a Hindu undivided family; each held 3 annas share in the firm. Two other partners (Sri Venku Reddy and Sri M. Veerabhadrayya) were strangers to the family, each holding 5 annas.
The firm had been registered under Section 26-A. Initially, the income corresponding to the two coparceners’ shares was assessed as income of the Hindu undivided family. For the assessment year 1959–60 the assessee contended there had been a family partition effective 1-4-1959 so that the two coparceners held their shares on behalf of their respective branches. This contention failed in the departmental proceedings and on appeal up to the Appellate Tribunal, which recognised the two partners as co-parceners of the Hindu undivided family.
The Income-tax Officer renewed the firm's registration on 30-10-1960. The Commissioner, taking the view that two coparceners representing a Hindu undivided family cannot validly enter into partnership with strangers, issued a notice under Section 33B and, after hearing the assessee, cancelled the registration by order dated 29-10-1962. The assessee appealed unsuccessfully and then moved the Appellate Tribunal under Section 66(1) to state a case; the matter is before the court on that reference.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the firm of Ramakrishna Transports, Kalahasthi was entitled to registration under Section 26A of the Income-tax Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Assessee / Appellant
- The firm was duly registered under Section 26-A and the partners' shares had been treated and assessed as family income in earlier years.
- For the assessment year 1959–60 the assessee asserted there had been a partition effective 1-4-1959 and that the two coparceners held their shares on behalf of their separate branches; registration should therefore stand.
- Alternatively, the two coparceners had entered into partnership with strangers as representatives of the joint family under recognised principles of Hindu law and partnership law; such representative partnerships are governed by the Partnership Act and are not ipso facto invalid for registration under Section 26A.
Revenue / Respondent
- The Commissioner took the view that two coparceners representing a Hindu undivided family cannot validly enter into partnership with strangers; on that ground he cancelled the firm's registration under Section 33B.
- Reliance was placed on observations in Firm Bhagat Ram v. E.P. Commissioner (and related authorities) to the effect that members of a coparcenary cannot, in relation to coparcenary property, be both coparceners and partners (inter se) so as to render the partnership invalid for purposes of Section 26A.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| P.K.P.S. Pichappa Chettiar v. Chokalingam Pillai (Privy Council) | Approved the statement that when a managing member of a joint family enters into partnership with a stranger the other members do not ipso facto become partners; only those who enter the contractual relation are partners and the Partnership Act governs that relationship. | The court relied on this approval to support the proposition that a family representative (or representatives) may contract with strangers and that the resultant partnership is governed by the Partnership Act rather than by Hindu coparcenary status alone. |
| Charan Das Haridas v. Commissioner of Income-Tax (Supreme Court) | Accepted the Privy Council's position that where members of a joint Hindu family enter into a partnership with strangers the family as a unit does not become partner; only contracting members are partners and partnership law applies. | Used to confirm that members acting in a representative capacity may be partners vis-à-vis strangers while the beneficial interest in profits remains a joint family asset for Hindu law and income-tax purposes. |
| Annamalai Chetty v. Murugesh Chetty (Privy Council) | Described the managing member's position when contracting on behalf of family as analogous to that of a trustee — a dual position (partner vis-à-vis outsiders and trustee/representative qua family). | Cited to explain the dual legal character of coparceners who enter partnership with outsiders: partnership rules govern relations with outsiders; Hindu law governs relations with family members. |
| Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Bagyalaxmi & Co. (Supreme Court) | Stressed the necessity of keeping in view three concepts — partnership law, Hindu law and income-tax law — and that these separate branches must be applied together where relevant. | Relied upon to emphasise the correct methodology: assess the issue by treating the distinct operation of partnership law, Hindu coparcenary law and income-tax law rather than conflating them. |
| Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Nandlal Gandalal (Supreme Court — minority observations of Hidayatullah, J.) | Explained that a coparcener who joins partnership is treated as individual partner for partnership law, while under Hindu law the benefits may belong to the family — illustrating the need to view the problem under separate branches of law. | Referred to for the proposition that the implications differ depending on the branch of law applied; used to support the court's multi-faceted approach. |
| Lachman Das v. Commissioner of Income-Tax (Privy Council) | Held that a coparcener can enter into partnership quoad his separate property and there is no reason to differentiate a coparcener from a stranger in respect of separate property. | Used to show that members can contract in their individual capacity with separate property; helped distinguish cases where coparceners act in representative capacity for joint family funds. |
| Sunder Singh Majitha v. Commissioner of Income Tax (Privy Council) | Held that nothing in the Income-tax Act prohibits members dividing properties while retaining joint status and carrying on business as partners in respect of those properties treated as capital. | Referred to in considering whether members could be partners in relation to certain properties while remaining coparceners; used in the Court's consideration of Firm Bhagat Ram. |
| Firm Bhagat Ram v. E.P. Commissioner (Supreme Court) | Observed tension where the partnership agreement asserted joint family status and karta acting for the family while other members were also partners in their individual capacity; noted it is difficult to reconcile such positions and that members cannot at the same time be coparceners and partners quoad coparcenary property. | The court relied on this authority to identify and then distinguish the revenue's contention: the present facts differ because the two coparceners entered as representatives and not as individual partners quoad separate property; accordingly Firm Bhagat Ram did not invalidate the registration in the present case. |
| Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Hukamchand Manna Lal & Co. (Madhya Pradesh High Court) | Considered instrumentation showing multiple persons representing family branches as partners and discussed whether two or more coparceners can become partners with outsiders; the High Court accepted that coparceners may contract and be accountable to the family for their shares. | Cited as authority where local High Court decisions proceeded on the basis that multiple adult members representing the family can enter into valid partnership with strangers; supports current court's conclusion. |
| Ramkumar Ramnivas of Manpara, In re (Allahabad High Court) | Expressed the view that adult members acting within their Hindu law rights may enter into partnership and make the entire joint family liable for partnership debts while being entitled to benefits. | Used as one of several High Court authorities affirming that more than one member acting within authority may represent family in partnership with strangers. |
| Laxmi Co. v. Commissioner of Income-Tax, U.P. & V.P. (Madras High Court) | Approved the principle that some members of a joint family representing the family can enter into partnership with a stranger. | Cited as supportive High Court authority for the proposition that representative partnerships by some members are valid. |
| Pitamberdas Bhikhabhai & Co. v. Commissioner of Income-Tax (Gujarat High Court) | Held that where purported gifts and partnership instruments attempted to treat coparcenary assets as separate and to make coparceners partners in their individual capacity, that was not permissible in relation to coparcenary property; coparceners cannot become partners inter se in relation to coparcenary property. | Distinguished by the court: PITAMBERDAS supports the rule that coparceners cannot convert joint family property into partnership shares among themselves without separation; but the present case involves coparceners contracting with strangers as family representatives, not coparceners becoming partners inter se on coparcenary property. |
| S.C. Mullick & Sons, In re (Allahabad High Court) | Held that persons cannot at the same time be members of a joint Hindu family in respect of joint family property and also be members of a firm of which such property forms the asset. | Cited to reinforce the general principle that coparcenary property cannot simultaneously form the asset of an inter se partnership among the coparceners; distinguished from representative partnerships with outsiders. |
| Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Ganesh Narayan Onkarmal (unreported, I.T. Ref. No. II of 1947) | Noted (per the court's summary) as a decision accepting the principle that two or more members of an undivided family can enter into partnership with strangers, being accountable to the joint family. | Mentioned as one of the decisions supporting the proposition that multiple coparceners may enter into partnerships with outsiders as representatives. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in these main steps, following the text closely and without adding external assumptions:
- The court framed the central issue as one of validity of registration under Section 26A, observing that registration changes the tax incidence from a firm-unit assessment to assessment on individual partners' shares and is hence materially important.
- It set out the legal distinction between coparcenary relations under Hindu law and partnerships under the Partnership Act: coparcenary relations arise by status (operation of law) and are not partnerships per se; Section 5 of the Partnership Act excludes a Hindu undivided family carrying on family business as such from the definition of "partner."
- The court explained how incidents of joint family business differ from partnership — survivorship, management authority vested in the karta or manager(s), different rules on accounts and agency — leading to potential conflict where both sets of rules may seem to apply.
- Next the court considered the principle, supported by Mayne's treatise and approved by the Privy Council and Supreme Court, that a managing member (karta) may enter into partnership with a stranger and that other family members do not thereby become partners ipso facto; only those who contract with the stranger are partners for partnership law purposes.
-
The court examined authorities (Lachman Das, Sunder Singh Majitha, Pitamberdas, Firm Bhagat Ram and others) to extract two well-recognised propositions:
- Where a managing member enters into partnership with strangers using joint family capital, only those family members who actually contract with the strangers are partners vis-à-vis the outsiders; the family retains beneficial interest and contractual partners are accountable to the family.
- Members may, in their personal capacity in respect of separate property, enter into partnership with the karta or outsiders (as held in Lachman Das), but such partnerships quoad separate property are distinct from partnerships involving coparcenary property.
- The court then confronted the revenue's reliance on Firm Bhagat Ram which emphasised that members cannot at the same time be coparceners and partners in relation to coparcenary property so as to undermine the joint family notion. The court interpreted Firm Bhagat Ram as clarifying that coparceners cannot be partners inter se in relation to coparcenary property in their individual capacities; but this did not preclude more than one coparcener from entering into partnership with outsiders in a representative capacity (i.e., where they, under family authority, represent the family).
- The court noted a line of High Court decisions (Allahabad, Madras, Bombay unreported, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat) that have accepted that two or more adult members, acting within their authority under Hindu law, can enter into partnership with strangers representing the family and be accountable to the family for their shares; the court found these decisions supportive of the position that representative partnerships by multiple coparceners are valid.
- The court applied these principles to the facts: in the present case the two coparceners had entered into the partnership as representatives of the family; the family (and the Department) accepted that their partnership shares were family assets and that income was being assessed as joint family income. The Tribunal did not impugn the genuineness of the partnership nor compliance with Section 26A and the rules under Section 59.
- On that basis the court concluded the Commissioner's cancellation of registration solely on the ground that the partnership was invalid in the light of Firm Bhagat Ram was not justified, because the factual situation in the present case was different (representative partnership by two coparceners) and within the principles approved by higher authorities.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
THE COURT ANSWERED THE REFERRED QUESTION IN THE AFFIRMATIVE: the firm of Ramakrishna Transports, Kalahasthi was entitled to registration under Section 26A.
Immediate implications and orders made:
- The cancellation of the firm's registration by the Commissioner was held to be unjustified on the ground relied upon.
- The Department was ordered to pay the costs of the assessee; the advocate's fee was fixed at Rs. 100/-. (These are the specific consequences directed by the court.)
Broader implications:
The court applied and clarified existing authorities to confirm that more than one coparcener may, within the authority of the joint family and acting as representatives, enter into partnership with strangers and that such a partnership is not invalid per se for purposes of registration under Section 26A. The opinion did not purport to announce a new principle of law beyond the application and reconciliation of prior authorities; its holding turns on the application of established authorities to the present facts.
Order: Question answered in the affirmative; Department to pay costs; advocate's fee fixed at Rs.100; orders accordingly.
1. This is a reference under Section 66(1) of the Income-tax Act 1929. The question referred for decision is in the following terms;
“Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the firm of Ramakrisbna Transports, Kalahasthi was entitled to registration under Section 26(A) of the Act.”
2. The dispute relates to the assessment year 1959–60, the relevant accounting year being the year ending on 31-3-1959. The assessee 19 a partnership firm constituted under an instrument of partnership dated 27-3-1955. It carries on business in bus transport. Two of the partners in this firm (1) Sri Venugopala, Reddy and (2) Ramakrisbna Reddy, holding 3 annas share each are the co-parceners of a Hindu undivided family, the Kartha being Sri A. Balarama Reddy. The only other two partners Sri Venku Reddy and Sri M. Veerabhadrayya holding 5 annas share each are strangers. The firm was duly registered under Sec. 26-A of the Income-Tax Act. The share income of Sri Venugopala Reddy and Ramakrishna Reddy were being offered for assessment as the income of the Hindu undivided family and assessed by the Income Tax Officer accordingly. Some years later the assessee came with the contention that there was a family partition as a result of which the two partners of the family became separated with effect from 1-4-1959 and that thereafter these two families held their shares on behalf of their respective branches, of the family to which they belong. This case, advanced for the first time for the assessment year 1959–60 did not find favour with the Department. The assessee went in appeal, but without success, upto the stage of the Appellate Tribunal. The two partners of the firm were recognised as before only as co-parceners of Hindu undivided family. The Income-tax Officer, Tirupati renewed the registration of the firm in the year 1959–1960 by his order dated 30-10-1960. Thereupon the Commissioner of Income-tax took exception as be was of the view that two coparceners representing the Hindu undivided family cannot enter into a valid partnership with strangers. He served a notice under Section 33B of the Indian Income-tax Act on 12-10-1962. Then after hearing the assessee, he cancelled the registration by his order dated 29-10-1962. Aggrieved by this order, the assessee went in appeal before the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal. On failure to get a favourable decision, he moved the Appellate Tribunal under Section 66(1) of the Income-tax Act to state the case. That is how the matter has come before us for decision.
3. The controversy turns mainly on the question of registration under Section 26A of the Indian Income-tax Act. The question of regitation is of vital importance to an assessee in view of certain special benefits accruing therefrom. An unregistered firm is invariably charged as a unit. But registration makes all the difference for in that event the tax is levied on each individual partner in respect of his share in the firm's profits. The gain to the assessee, thereby is not inconsiderable. In order to be entitled to this privilege it is however essential that a firm should conform to the conditions prescribed by Sec. 26A and rules 2 to 6(B) made under Section 59 of the Act, Further the authority concerned should be satisfied that the partnership is not only genuine but also a valid one. It is settled law that if a partnership is a genuine and valid one and the provisions of Section 26 and rules connected therewith are complied with, the income-tax authority shall have no power to reject its registration, We are in this proceedings concerned with the question of the validity alone nor it is only on the basis that the registration of the firm has been cancelled. Partnership being purely a creature of contract, the validity and legality must of course depend upon a number of factors. A partnership would be illegal and invalid if its object is forbidden by law or is opposed to public policy. The same would be the consequence if a partnership when permitted would defeat any provision of law. There are other grounds rendering the validity of a partnership open to question. It is unnecessary for us to consider all these grounds for on the facts and circumstances of the present case we are concerned with the limited question whether more than one coparcener representing a Hindu undivided family can enter into a valid partnership with strangers. The question involving as it does a consideration of the principles of Hindu law and also the Partnership Act steering clear of all possible conflict must necessarily present considerable difficulty. The coparceners of a Hindu undivided family are not partners within the meaning of that term in the Partnership Act. According to the Partnership Act, it is the relation between persons agreed to share the profits of the business carried on by all or any of them acting for all. The persons who have thus entered into the contract are called individually partners and collectively firm.
4. The relationship between coparceners in connection with joint family business is not based on contract but on status and is created by operation of law. That is why Section 5 of the Partnership Act excludes the members of a Hindu undivided family carrying on family business as such from the description of the partners. The members of a Hindu undivided family carrying on family business are therefore not partners. Nor is the joint Hindu family a firm within the meaning of the Partnership Act though that terminology may be used loosely in relation thereto. A joint Hindu family is a unit to which no outsider can be admitted by agreement; it is a status which can only be acquired by birth or adoption. Then again it must, as a unit, act through some person and the only person who can act is the Karta or manager who may be a single individual or several adult members, In relation to the family business in the nature of trade the rights and liabilities of coparceners constituting the family firm are therefore not to be determined by exclusive reference to the Partnership Act. So long as the trade is being carried on by them and no strangers are associated with them in any manner its incidents must be regulated essentially by Hindu Law. These incidents must vary substantially from those of a partnership. Whereas the death of a coparcener or the managing member does not dissolve the joint family firm and property passes by survivorship, the partnership under the Partnership Act is dissolved ordinarily by the death of a partner. A coparcener cannot ask for an account of past profits or losses. But it is otherwise in a partnership. In a joint family firm ordinarily it is only the managing member who can act on behalf of the family and bind his coparceners by his acts; but sometimes for the convenience of trade or business by arrangement amongst the members not only one manager but several persons with equal powers are entrusted with the duty of managership. In such a case the act of any one will bind all the coparceners, The Manager or managers of the joint family firm have implied authority to contract debts and pledge the properties and credit of the family for the Ordinary purposes of family business. No other person has such authority. But in partnership each is the agent of the other. There is also difference as to the extent of liabilities for debts contracted. These and other differences create considerable difficulty when the case on its particular facts and circumstances attracts the provisions of both the Hindu law and the law of partnership.
5. The instant case obviously is not one where the manager is carrying on family business with family funds without being associated with any stranger. It is in fact a case where two of the coparceners representing the family have entered into partnership with strangers in a business, the capital of which to the extent of their share agreed upon, is derived from the property of the joint family. It is settled law that it is competent to the manager of a joint family business acting on behalf of the family to enter into a partnership with strangers. The manager, by doing so, does not introduce the members of the undivided family into that partnership. Such members alone as have entered into partnership with the strangers are partners. The manager and such of these members are accountable to the family, lie law on this subject has been stated by Mayne in page 398 of his book “Maye on Hindu Law and Usage, 9th Edition” in the following terms:—
“Where a managing member of a joint family enters into a partnership with a stranger, the other members of the family do not ipso facto become partners in the business so as to clothe them with all the rights and obligations of a partner as defined by the Indian Partnership Act. In such a case the family as a unit does not become a partner but only such of its members as in fact enter into a contractual relation with the stranger. The partnership will be governed by the Act.”
6. This statement of law has been approved of by the Privy Council in P.K.P.S Pichappa Chettiar v. Chokalingam Pillai1. and also accepted by the Supreme Court in Charan Das Haridas v. The Commissioner of Income-Tax Bombay North, Kutch and Sourastra Ahmedabad2.. It is plain from the language used that the Karta or tha adult members of a joint Hindu family, where it is a trading family, may enter into a partnership with a stranger or stangers representing the joint Hindu family. The family as a unit on that account does not become a partner, but only such of its members as in fact enter into a contractual relation with the stranger, and the partnership will be governed by the Act. In the management of that business, therefore the other members of the family have no part to play, the only right that they have against the manager or the Karta or the other members who entered into partnership representing the family is to call upon him or them to give an account of the business that they have done with the joint family funds. The income and profits which the managing member or members have earned from such partnership would belong to the joint family and the other coparceners would have a right to share such profits with these members of the joint family as a joint family asset. The position of the manager or the managing members in this way, as pointed out by the Privy Council in Annamalai Chetty v. Murugesh Chetty3. is analogous to that of a trustee. He or they in such cases occupy a dual position. As between the parties to the contract they are partners and their relationship is regulated by the Partnership Act. They as a rule are personally liable for all the obligations under the contract as against the partner strangers. In relation to the family members they have a duty to account for the profits that they made. For purposes of income-tax the income derived is assessed to tax as the income of the Hindu undivided family. Thus the provisions of three distinct laws are attracted in view of the role that they occupy. In Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Bagyalaxmi & Co.4. the Supreme Court stressed on the necessity of always in such cases keeping in view the principles of the three laws. Their Lordships observed thus:
“If the distinction between the three concepts is borne in mind much of the confusion disappears. A partnership is a creature of contract. Under Hindu law a joint family is one of status and right to partition is one of its incidents. The Income-tax law gives the Income-tax Officer a power to assess the income of a person in the manner provided by the Act. Except where there is a specific provision of the Income-tax Act which derogates from any other statutory law or personal law, the provision will have to be considered in the light of the relevant branches of law. A contract of partnership has no concern with the obligation of the partners to others in respect of their shares of profit in the partnership It only regulates the rights and liabilities of the partners. A partner may be the karta of a joint Hindu family; he may be a trustee; he may enter into a sub-partnership with others; he may, under an agreement, express or implied, be the representative of a group of persons; he may be a benamidar for another. In all such cases he occupies a dual position. Qua the partnership, he functions in his personal capacity, qua the third parties in his representative capacity. The third parties, whom one of the partners represents, cannot enforce their rights against the other partners nor the other partners can do so against the said third parties. Their right is only to a share in the profits of their partner-representative in accordance with law or in accordance with the terms of the agreement, as the case may be.”
7. These observations were made in connection with the question of genuineness of partnership where it was said that two of the partners who were the members of a Hindu undivided family purporting to hold 7½ annas and 2½ annas share each by reason of the agreement with their family members were in fact beneficially interested in much lesser share, That is not exactly the question here. Bue the principle enunciated is alike applicable while judging the validity of the partnership. The distinct relationship under the Partnership Act and under the Hindu law has to be necessarily kept in view. In this connection we may also refer to the observations of Hidayatullah, J. in his minority judgment in Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Nandlal Gandalal which are to the following effect:
“Now, it is settled law that a Hindu undivided family cannot be a partner under the law of partnership. Such of the coperceners who join the partnership are regarded quoad the other partners, as individuals in their own names and rights. Yet, the benefits that accrue to them from the partnership belong to the family, and their rights are the asset of the family. We have recently held in Charandas Haridas v. Commissioner of Income-Tax (Civil Appeal No. 108 of 1957 decided on March 15, 1960) that in such a stituation the matter has to be looked at in the light of three separate and independent branchee of law. They are the law of partnership, the Hindu Law and the law relating to income-tax. The implications of a coparcener joining as partner with strangers are different when one views the matter from the angle of the law of partnership or from the angle of the Hindu law or the law of income-tax. In so far as the law of partnership is concerned, the coparcenary has no place in the partnership, and the coparcener partner is everything. But, viewed from the angle of Hindu law, the position is entirely different.”
8. The question before His Lordship in that case was different from what is posed now; but the principle laid down as to the method of approach applies with all its vigour to our case here.
9. While considering whether the partnership as entered into is against law or is invalid we cannot but bear in mind the principles of law relating to coparcenary and see whether it has been violated to any extent
10. We have noticed that under Hindu law it is open to the karta (whether one individual or several persons) on behalf of the family to enter into partnership with strangers. In that case only the person or persons entering into contract will be partners qua the strangers who are the contracting parties. The other members though beneficially interested in the profits of the shares of the managing members are not the partners. That such partners acting en behalf of the undivided family can be more than one is not open to doubt in view of the statement of law by Mayne and the pronouncement of the Privy Council and the Supreme Court in the cases cited above.
11. There may also be cases where the members not as coparceners or members of the family but in their personal character not with the aid of or detriment to the joint family funds but with their own separate funds enter into contract with Karta who represents the family. It is well settled that individual members qua their separate property can enter into a valid partnership with a karta representing the Hindu undivided family. In Lachman das v. Commissioner of Income-Tax, Punjab it was observed that when it is open to a Managing member of a Joint Hindu family to enter into partnership with a stranger, there is no reason why a coparcener could not in his individual capacity enter into partnership with the karta of the joint family. It is apt to quote here the words of their Lordships:
“……. on general principles they (their Lordships) cannot find any sound reason to distinguish the case of a stranger from that of a coparcener who puts into the partnership what is admittedly his separate property held in his individual capacity and unconnected with the family funds. Whatever the view of a Hindu joint family and its property might have been at the early stages of its development, their Lordships think that it is now firmly established that an individual coparcener, while reamining joint, can possess, enjoy and utilise, in any way he likes, property which was his individual property, not acquired with the aid of or with any deteriment to the joint family property. It follows from this that to be able to utilise this property at his will, he must be accorded the freedom to enter into contractual relations with others, including his family, so long as it is represented in such transactions by a definite personality like its manager. In such a case he retains his share and interests in the property of the family, while be simultaneously enjoys the benefit of his separate property and the fruits of its investment. To be able to do this it is not necessary for him to separate himself from his family……..
12. In this view of the Hindu law, it is clear that if a stranger can enter into partnership with reference to his own property, with a Joint Hindu family through its kartha, there is no sound reason in their Lordships view to withhold such opportunity from a coparcener in respect of his separate and individual property.”
13. In view of the above discussion two things may be aid down as well recognised general principles. The first is as stated by Mayne, where a managing member of a joint Hindu family enters into partnership with a stranger in relation to a business whose capital in whole or in part is derived from the property or funds of the joint family, the family as a unit or the entire body of the family members do not ipso facto become partners in that pertnership business. The partnership will be confined to the strangers and such of the members of the family who have actually entered into partnership with them. Secondly the members of the family in their personal or individual capacity can quoad their separate property enter into partnership with the kartha of the joint family who represents the joint family.
14. So far the law is well settled. Even so there arises a third question which in substance seeks to demand a further clarification of the above propositions in view of the basic rule of Hindu law that persons cannot at the same time be members of a joint Hindu family and be also members of the firm of which such property forms the asset. As already noticed Sec. 5 of the Partnership Act clearly lays down that the members of a Hindu undivided family carrying on family business as such are not partners in such business. The question for consideration is where some of the joint family members become partners (with-in the meaning of the term in the Partnership Act) in a partnership firm can they become so only in their individual character qua their separate property or they can as well become such partners, by reason of their contract with the strangers, representing the joint family by themselves or in conjunction with the karta? It is difficult to accede to the contention that the only way for the members of the joint family to become partners is to enter into contract in their individual or personal character. Of course they can do so qua their separate property. In that case vis-a-vis the karta representing the family they will take the same place as the strangers would occupy by any contract with him. But when it is open to the adult members acting within the authority conferred on them, whether express or implied, to represent the family, there is no reason why they along with the karta, if he is there, should not vis-a-vis the strangers figure as partners. The statement of law by Mayne as approved of by the Privy Council and the Supreme Court does permit such a contingency. The contracting members alone will be partners and they are responsible to the joint family in relation to their profits they make. They are in fact the representatives of the family and though their shares in the partnership are fixed as they should be even for purposes of Sec. 26 A the beneficial interest therein is of the joint family. Their actual shares may be much less. As representatives they are one body for purposes of Hindu law. As partners under the Partnership Act vis-a-vis the strangers and other partners they may be distinct. Whatever the rights and liabilities vis-a-vis the other partners, they have a common ground. With the family members in the coparcenary qua partnership, their relations are determined by the Partnership Act and qua coparcenary their relationship is governed by the Hindu law. The Income-tax law for purposes of registration etc cannot ignore the considerations which are relevant under the Partnership Act and the Hindu law. Thus each branch of law would have its operation in determining their various rights and liabilities. When the Hindu law on clear authority permits karta or manager who may be a single individual or several adult members to inter into a contract with strangers in a representative capacity the presence of more than one coparcener in the same partnership when it is in representative capacity cannot render the partnership void or invalid. There are several decisions of the various High Courts which have proceeded on the basis that the adult members in a representative capacity can enter in to a valid partnership with strangers in relation to a business whose capital in part consists of joint family property or funds. The Allahabad High Court in Ramkumr Ramnivas of Manpara, In re expressed the view that the adult members of the family acting within their rights under the Hindu law may be able to enter into partnership and make the entire joint family liable for the debts of the partnership and be entitled to the benefits thereof. The Madras High Court in Laxmi Co. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, U.P & V.P, Madras approved of the principle of some members of joint family representing the family entering into a partnership with a saranger. The Bombay High Court also has in an unreported ease The Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Ganesh Narayan Onkarmal (I.T Ref. No. II of 1947 decided on 16th March 1948) accepted the principle that two or more members of an undivided Hindu family can enter into a partnership with strangers rendering themselves accountable for their individual shares to the joint family. In Commissioner of Income Tax v. Hukamchand Manna Lal & Co. the Madhya Pradesh High Court has referred to this case. It was a case where the instrument of partnership showed that there were ten persons representing the four branches with different shares ??? as to give each branch a quarter share in the profits and loss of the business, It was contended that while the karta of a Hindu undivided family could enter into a partnership with a stranger, two or more members of the joint family could not in their individual capacity, enter into a partnership with outsiders. Chagla, C.J said:
“I do not see what is there opposed to principle or opposed or authority which would or should prevent two or three members of a joint family individually contracting with outsiders and entering into partnership. As far as their individual shares are concerned they would be accountable to their joint family. The profits which they would earn in respect of their individual shares would ultimately belong to the joint family but so far as the partnership with the outsiders is concerned they would be individual partners with their individual shares.”
15. Tendokar J. observed:
“It is now established that a member of a joint Hindu family can enter into a partnership with an outsider, may be that in such a partnership he represents the joint family of which he is a member and if so, he is accountable to the joint family for the profits of such business and cannot retain those profits for himself, but qua the partnership he is certainly a partner. The position is not any different when instead of one coparcener of the joint family two or more coparceners of that joint family enter into a partnership with the outsider. So far as the partnership is concerned, they have their individual shares in the partnership. It may be that in this partnership they represent the joint family or use joint family funds for the purposes of the partnership. They are accountable to the joint family for the profits made in the partnership. But the fact that the profits earned by a coparcener who is partner in a firm enure for the benefit of the joint family does not make it any the less partnership for purposes of section 26 A.”
16. The above observations are to the effect that a partnership with strangers entered into by more than one coparcener representing the family is valid in law for purposes of Sec. 26 A. It may be stated here that the expression “individual capacity” used here is not the same as personal capacity qua separate property
17. But then in this conection we may also refer to the following observations of the Supreme Court in Firm Bhagat Ram v. E.P Commissioner.
“In Lachman Das v. Commissioner of Income Tax (1948 P.C 8) it was held by the Judicial Committee that the Kartha of a joint Hindu family could enter into partnerahip with an individual member of the coparcenary quoad his separate property. It was alto held by the Privy Council in Sunder Singh Majitha v. Commisioner of Income Tax (1942-P.C. 57) that there was nothing in the Income Tax Act to prohibit the members of a joint Hindu family from dividing some properties, while electing to retain their joint status, and carrying on business as partners in respect of those properties treating them as its capital. But in the present case, the basis of the partnership agreement of 1940 is that the family was joint and that Mohanlal was its karta and that he entered into the partnership as karta on behalf of the joint family. It is difficult to reconcile this position with that of Chotalal and Banailal being also partners in the firm in their individual capacity, which can only be in respect of their separate or divided property.
If members of a coparcenary are to be regarded as having become partners in a firm with strangers they would also become under the partnership law partners “inter se” and it would cut at the very root of the notion of a joint undivided family to hold that with reference to coparcenary properties the members can at the same time be both coparceners and partner.”
18. On the basis of the above observations what is contended for on behalf of the Revenue is that where a kartha representing the family has entered into a partnership with strangers the other members of the coparcenary by reason of contract of their own cannot validly become partners in the same partnership. In order to appreciate the full implications of the above observations we may also bear in mind the further observations made by the Supreme Court in that connection which are to the following effect:—
“To get over this difficulty, it was suggested that all the three coparceners might be regarded as having entered into the contract of partnership as kartas of the joint family. But even if that could be done consistently with the principles of Hindu law, the very pleadings of the appellant are against such a supposition being made, affirming as they do that it was only Mohanlal that was the karta, not the other. The contention, therefore that Chotelal and Bansilal should be held to have become partners in the old firm under the agreement dated 23-8-1940 cannot be maintained.”
19. These observations, to our mind, but clarify the rule that the adult member of the joint Hindu family can become partners along with Karta only in a representative capacity. If the Karta alone represents the family they can become partners only in their personal character qua their self-acquired property as held in Lachman Das case. They cannot become partners quoad their share in the joint Hindu family. Of course there can be little difficulty if they together with the said Karta under authority of the family express or implied represent the family.
20. The Madhya Pradesh High Court in Commissioner of Income-Tax Madhya Pradesh v. Hukumchand Mannalal & Co. supra considered this question and accepted the contention that the above observations of the Supreme Court meant limply that with reference to coparcenary property the members of the joint family cannot become partners in their personal or individual capacity and not that if the Karta had entered into partnership, the coparceners could not also be partners as representatives of the family. The learned Judges construed the observations of the Supreme Court to mean that with reference to coparcenary property the members cannot at the same time be both coparceners and partners in their individual capacity as distinct from their capacities as representatives of the joint family. We find ourselves in respectful agreement with there observations.
21. In Pitamberdas Bhikhabhai & Co. v. Commissioner of Income-Tax the Gujarat High Court had to deal with a case where the father, Pithamberdas, purported to make a gift of Rs. 10,001/- to each of his sons, Ramanlal and Jayantilal. The purported gift was made by debiting a sum of Rs. 20,002/- in the books of the business to Pitamberdas Bhikhabhai and crediting a sum of Rs. 10,001 to Ramanlal Pitamberdas and a sum of Rs. 10.001/- to Jayantilal Pitamberdas Pitamberdas then took Ramanlal and Jayantilal as partners in the business executing a deed of partnership showing that he was the absolute owner of the assets of the business and that there was no ancestral business that he got. This stand taken by him in the deed of partnership was not true. The business did not belong to him absolutely but was an asset of the Hindu undivided family consisting of Pitamberdas, his wife and his sons and daughters. Eeve the sum of Rs. 10,001/- a piece, purported to have been gifted by Pitamberdas to Ramanlal and Jayantilal belonged to the said Hindu undivided family. So then the only question was whether in respect of a business belonging to a Hindu undivided family the coparceners can be taken as partners in the business in their individual capacity with specific shares. In this connection the learned Judges referred to the dicision of the Privy Council in Lachhman Das Babu Ram…Applicant; v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax…Opposite Party. Supra and also the observations of the Supreme Court in Firm Bhagat Ram Mohanlal v. Commissioner of Excess Profits Tax Supra and held that no such partnership is possible in relation to coparcenary property between the coparceners themselves. The principle laid down is unexceptionable for in relation to coparcenary property, the caparceners cannot become partners themselves. Sec. 5 of the Partnership Act makes this abundantly clear. The decision of the Allahabad High Court in S.C Mullick & Sons, In re is to the same effect, viz., that persons cannot at one and the same time be members of a joint. Hindu family in respect of joint family property and be also members of a firm of which such property forma the asset. It may be noted here that in both the cases mentioned above there was no element of strangers at all in the business.
22. The facts and circumstances of the present case are entirely different. There is of course a Karta of the family, but it is not he who had entered into the partnership, Instead the two adult coparceners had entered into partnership with strangers. Both of them entered into the agreement as representatives of the family. The family or the Department never disputed this position. Indeed their share in the partnership was an asset of the joint family and was being regarded as such. The income from such partnership was the income of the joint family and was being assessed in the hands of the family as such. It is therefore clear that the present case is not hit by any of the prohibitions or infirmities contemplated by the observations of the Supreme Court in Firm Bhagat Ram v. E.P Commisioner Supra. It is further clear that the partnership in question is quite consistent with the rule approved of by the Privy Council and accepted by the Supreme Court, viz, it is open to one or more coparceners representing the joint family to enter into partnership with strangers under the authority of the family. The cancellation of the registration in these circumstances was not justified in law. It is not the case of the Tribunal that the partnership is not genuine. Nor is it its case that there has been no compliance with the provisions of Sec. 26-A or the rules framed under Sec. 59 of the Income-tax Act. The only ground on which cancellation was made by the Commissioner was that the case was hit by the observations of the Supreme Court in the above case. As we have already pointed out that is not the position in this case.
23. We therefore answer the question in the affirmative.
24. The Department shall pay the costs of the assessee. Advocate's fee is fixed at Rs. 100/-.
25. Orders accordingly.
Alert