- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Smt. Misribai Legal ... v. The Income-Tax Offic...
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, wife and legal representative of the late Rameshwar Pershad, challenges the rectification of income-tax assessments for the years 1956–1957, 1957–1958, and 1958–1959. Rameshwar Pershad was initially assessed under the Income-tax Act, 1922, with his share of income from a firm tentatively fixed pending the firm’s assessment. After the firm's assessment was completed, the assessments of the petitioner’s husband were rectified on 7-3-1963, resulting in additional tax liabilities. The Income-tax Officer directed payment within a week of receipt of the order. The petitioner contends that no proper notice or demand was served as required by law, particularly under the Income-tax Act, 1961, which had come into force before the rectification order was passed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Income-tax Officer was obligated to serve a formal notice of demand under the Income-tax Act, 1961, before taking further action to recover tax following a rectification order passed after the new Act came into force.
- Whether the rectification order passed under Section 35 of the Income-tax Act, 1922, after the commencement of the Income-tax Act, 1961, requires compliance with the notice provisions of the new Act.
- Whether the absence of a notice of demand in the prescribed form invalidates the recovery proceedings initiated pursuant to the rectification order.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- No notice or demand was served on the petitioner as required by either the Income-tax Act, 1922 or the Income-tax Act, 1961.
- Since the rectification order was passed after the Income-tax Act, 1961 came into force, notice must be given under Section 156 of the 1961 Act.
- The absence of a notice of demand in the prescribed form under the new Act renders any recovery or penalty proceedings invalid.
Respondent’s Arguments
- The petitioner’s authorized representative consented to the rectification order, signing the order-sheet.
- The rectification pertains to assessment years prior to the new Act; hence, the old Act applies and notice under Section 29 of the 1922 Act suffices.
- No separate demand notice was served as the rectification order itself mentioned payment within a week, and the formal demand notice requirement was not strictly observed.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the applicability of the Income-tax Acts of 1922 and 1961 in light of the timing of the rectification order. Although the assessments concerned years before the new Act, the rectification order was passed after the Income-tax Act, 1961 came into force. The court emphasized the mandatory nature of serving a notice of demand in the prescribed form before any recovery or penalty action. Under Section 156 of the 1961 Act and Rule 15 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962, such notice must be served in Form No. 7, allowing 35 days for payment. Since no such notice was served on the petitioner, the court held that the recovery proceedings could not lawfully continue. The court rejected the respondent’s contention that the old Act applied and that the consent of the authorized representative obviated the need for a formal notice.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is allowed.
The court directed the respondent to forbear from taking any further proceedings, including collection of tax and levy of penalty pursuant to the rectification order dated 7-3-1963, unless and until a proper notice of demand is served under Section 156 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and in Form No. 7 under Rule 15 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962. No order as to costs was made. This decision directly affects the parties by halting recovery proceedings until procedural compliance is ensured. The court did not establish any new precedent beyond the immediate case.
1. The petitioner is the wife and the legal representative of late Rameshwar Pershad residing at Hyderabad, who is an assessee under the Income-tax Act. On 30-5-1959, Rameshwar Pershad was assessed for the assessment year 1958–1959 and on 30-9-1958 for the assessment year 1957–1958 and also for the assessment year 1956–1957 in, his individual status. He had also an interest in a firm caned “Kishanlal Oil Mills” and at the time of the original assessments, his share of the income therefrom was tentatively fixed with the proviso that the assessment would be rectified under Section 35 of the Income-tax Act, 1922 after the assessment of the firm would be completed. Subsequently, the assessment of the firm was completed and on the basis of that, the assessments of Sri Ramesnwar Pershad for the years 1956–1957, 1957–1958 and 1958–1959 were rectified on 7-3-1963. As a result of this rectification, the assessee had to pay Rs. 6,142-50 np. for the year 1956–1957, Rs. 8,074-53 np. for the year 195/- 53 and Rs. 2,283-44 np. for the year, 1958–1959. The Order, as I stated, was passed on 7-3-1963. On the order itself, the Income-tax Officer endorsed as follows:
“This should be paid within a week of receipt of the order.”
2. In the counter-affidavit filed by the Income-tax Officer, it is stated that the assessee's authorised representative had no objection to the proposed rectification and that in consent thereof, he signed the order-sheet on 7-1-1963 and that on the same day, similar opportunity was given to Shri Ghanshyamdas of S.G Dastgir and Co., cnarterea Accounants, who represented the assesses for the assessment years, 1956–1957 and 1957–1958 and also that the said gentleman gave his consent to the proposed revision of the assessment and that in token thereof, he also signed the order-sheet. So that, it must now be taken that there is no objection at all to the order passed under Section 35 of the Income-tax Act, 1922.
3. The point raised in the Writ Petition by the assessee's legal representative, who is his wife, is that no notice or demand as required by the Income-tax Ad, 1922 or the income-tax Act of 1961 was ever served on her. It is also further urged that as the rectification under Section 35 or the Income-tax Act, 1922 is made only on 7-3-63 after the income-tax Act of 1961 came into force, the notice or demand should be given under Section 156 of that Act. In paragraph 5 of the counter-affidavit it is admitted that no separate demand notice was served on the petitioner as the very order under Section 35 mentions in the end that the amount is payable within a week of the receipt of the order and that, as the order was passed with the consent of the assessee's authorised representative and further the order being one of rectification under Section 35, the formality of Issuing a demand notice was nor strictly observed.
4. In paragraph 4 of the counter-affidavit, it is stated that it is the old Act that applies to the present case as the assessment year was one which was prior to the coming into force of the new Act for the year 1961 and that therefore, notice of demand, if at all, has to be. Even as required by Sectors 29 of the Act of 1922 and that it is not necessary to give a notice under Section 156 of the new Act of 1961.
5. Under Section 29 of the Income-tax Act, 1922.
“When any tax, penalty or interest is due in consequence of any order passed under or in pursuance of this Act, the Income-tax Officer shall serve upon the assessee or other person liable to pay such tax, penalty or interest a notice of demand in the prescribed form specifying the sum so payable.”
6. This Section is mandatory and it is obligatory on the part of the Income-tax Officer to serve on the assessee or the person liable to pay the tax a notice’ of demand in the prescribed form. Rule 20 of the income-tax Rules, 1922 prescribed that the notice of demand under Section 29 shall be in the form which was specified below Wat rule. Admittedly, the Income-tax Officer did not serve any notice if that prescribed form on the petitioner and without serving any notice of demand, he could not take further steps to recover the tax from the petitioner or to levy any penalty or to take any father proceedings for the recovery of the tax.
7. It is further contended by Mr. Ranganadhachari, the learned counsel for the petitioner that, since the rectification order was passed after the coming into force of the Income-tax Act, 1961, notice under Section 156 of the new Act has to be given before further steps to recover the tax can be taken and before any penalty can be imposed, section 156 is substantially in the same language as Sec. 29 or the old Act and is as follows:
“When any tax, interest, penalty, fine or any other sum is payable in consequence of any order passed under this Act, the Income-tax Officer shall serve upon the assesses a notice of demand in the prescribed form specifying the sum so payable.”
8. This section also is clearly mandatory. Rule 15 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 prescribes that subject to the provisions of Rules 16 and 38 with which I am not now concerned, the notice of demand under Section 156 shall De in Form No. 7. Form No. 7 prescribed that it should no stated that the amount of the tax should be paid within 35 days of the service of the notice in that form or that the previous approval of the Inspecting Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax has been obtained for allowing a period or less than 35 days for the payment of the amount.
9. The Income-tax Act, 1922 is repealed by Section 297 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 and under Clause (j) of sun-section 2 of Section 297:
“Any sum payable by way of income-tax, super-tax Interest, penalty or otherwise under the repealed Act may’ be recovered under this Act, but without prejudice to any action already taken for the recovery of such sum under the repealed Act”.
10. In the present case, the order of rectification itself was passed after the coming into force of the income-tax Act, 1951. There is no proceeding pending which was already taken before the coming into force of the new Act for me recovery of the amount, for the simple reason that the order itself was caused after the commencement of the new Act. The amount due by the assessee late Rameshwar pershad and now payable by the Petitioner has to be recovered under the provisions of the new Income-tax Act, 1961. Therefore, a notice of demand under Section 156 of the new Act in Form No. 7 given under R. 15 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 calling upon the Petitioner to pay the amount due within 35 days of the service of the notice in that form has to be served by the income-tax Officer before he can take any further action for the recovery of the tax or for levying penalty. But such a notice admittedly has not been served on the Petitioner. Therefore, this writ petition is allowed and a direction will issue to the respondent to forbear from taking further proceedings inclusive of the collection of tax and the levy of penalty in pursuance of the Orders G.I.R 4/1-r dated 7-3-1963 for the assessment years, 1956–1957, 1957–1958 be and 1958–1959 unless and until he serves a notice on the Petitioner as prescribed by Section 156 of the income-tax Act, 1961 and in Form No. 7 under Rule 15 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962. I make no order as to costs in this Writ Petition.
LG/BGM/R.G.D
11. Petition allowed.
Alert