- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jamunabai v. Gampina Narayanamurty And Others .
Factual and Procedural Background
The opinion addresses two second appeals heard together by the court.
Second Appeal No. 1226 of 1954 (Landlord's recovery suit)
A landlord filed suit claiming Rs. 4,575 as arrears of rent from 1 July 1950 to 31 November 1952 at Rs. 175 per mensem. The defendants (Nos. 2 to 4), a partnership trading as Sri Krishna Ice Parlour and Bakery, had rented the premises. The rent was originally Rs. 80 per month until 30 November 1948; an agreement raised it to Rs. 125 from 1 December 1948 to 30 June 1950; a further agreement dated 1 July 1950 purportedly raised the rent to Rs. 175 per month. The defendants denied agreeing to pay Rs. 175 and contended the claim was contrary to the Madras Buildings (Lease & Rent) Control Act and that only the original rate was recoverable. The courts below found that the agreement to pay the enhanced rent was proved. The trial court held the plaintiff's right to claim the increased rent had arisen before the Rent Control Act and so was unaffected; the lower appellate court held that so long as fair rent had not been fixed the landlord could claim enhanced rent under an agreement. The tenant/defendant appealed to this court.
Second Appeal No. 1051 of 1954 (Tenant's recovery suit)
This appeal arose from a suit by a tenant seeking recovery of Rs. 1,317 as excess rent collected by the landlords after the fixation of fair rent. The trial court, relying on Section 6 of the Rent Control Act, held the enhanced rent was not warranted and decreed recovery in favour of the tenant. On appeal the subordinate judge reversed, concluding there had been no fixation of fair rent. The tenant then appealed to this court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an agreement between landlord and tenant for an enhanced rent (post-agreement increase to Rs. 175 per mensem) is enforceable or void under Section 6 (and related provisions) of the Madras Buildings (Lease & Rent) Control Act (referred to variously as the Act of 1946, 1949 and amended in 1951).
- In the tenant's suit (Second Appeal No. 1051 of 1954): whether fair rent had in fact been fixed by the Rent Controller, and if so, whether rent collected in excess of the fixed fair rent is recoverable by the tenant under Section 6 of the Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Second Appeal No. 1226 of 1954
Appellant's (tenant/defendant) Arguments
- Relying on A. Moses Pillai v. M.K. Govindan (1948 I M.L.J. 51), counsel argued that the provisions of Section 6 of the Rent Control Act apply despite contrary agreement between the parties.
- Specifically, it was contended that Section 6(2) is peremptory and imperative and therefore agreements in violation of that provision are unenforceable.
Respondent's (landlord/plaintiff) Arguments
- The landlord maintained that the agreement to pay the enhanced rent had been established and, in the absence of a fixation of fair rent, the parties were free to contract an increased rent.
- The respondent's position before the trial court included the view that the plaintiff's right to a higher rent had come into effect even before the Rent Control Act and therefore the Act could not affect that right.
Second Appeal No. 1051 of 1954
Appellant's (tenant/plaintiff in original suit) Arguments
- The tenant argued entitlement to recover the excess rent collected by the landlords after fixation of fair rent relying on Section 6 of the Rent Control Act; the trial court accepted this position.
Respondent's (landlord/defendant in original suit) Arguments
- The landlord (whose appeal was allowed by the subordinate judge) contended that there had been no fixation of fair rent and therefore the tenant was not entitled to a refund of the alleged excess rent.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| A. Moses Pillai v. M.K. Govindan (1948 I M.L.J. 51) | Interpreted clause 7(a) of the Madras Rent Control Order, holding that increased rent was permissible only where additions/improvements at landlord's expense had been made; held that the Rent Control provision permitted interference with contractual rights as a matter of policy. | The court described this decision and the appellant's reliance upon it; considered that the precise question in the present appeal did not arise in Moses Pillai and contrasted the Rent Control Order's wider prohibition with the subsequent Act's narrower prohibition where fair rent had been fixed. |
| George Oakes Ltd. v. The Chief Judge, Small Causes Court, Madras (1950 II M.L.J. 317) | Where the Rent Controller had fixed the fair rent and that fixed rent was higher than the rent being paid, the landlord could not claim the difference between the paid rent and the fair rent for periods anterior to the filing date of the application. | The court noted this decision as dealing with a distinct factual situation and as part of the line of authorities addressing the interplay between fixed fair rent and claims for enhanced rent. |
| Munagala Venkateswararao v. Mohd. Mohibullah Saheb (decision of Govinda Menon, J.) | Followed Moses Pillai and held that Sections 5 and 6 of the Madras Buildings (Lease & Rent) Control Act were peremptory and applied even where parties had contracted otherwise; any agreement for enhancement was not allowed unless conditions in Section 6 were complied with. | The court cited this authority to illustrate the line of decisions holding the statutory provisions restrictive; however, the present court compared the differing wording of the earlier Order and the later Act and applied the Act's terms to the facts before it. |
| Raja Chetty v. Jaganath Das Govind Das | Expressed that parties can agree to terms inconsistent with some provisions of an Act (as a general principle referenced in the opinion). | The court invoked this principle in support of the view that, where the statute permits, parties may contract for enhanced rent if fair rent has not been fixed under the Act. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court addressed the matters by separating the two appeals and by focussing on the precise statutory wording and the factual matrix in each case. The analysis proceeded by reference to the text of the earlier Madras House Rent Control Order, 1941 (clause 7(a)), and the later Madras Buildings (Lease & Rent) Control Act (variously referred to as the Act of 1946, Act 25 of 1949, and as amended in 1951).
Key steps in the court's reasoning:
- Identify the narrow legal question in the landlord's recovery appeal: because both courts below had found the agreement to pay the enhanced rent to be established, the only remaining point was whether that agreement offended Section 6 (and related provisions) of the Rent Control Act.
- Consider appellant's reliance on Moses Pillai and Munagala Venkateswararao, which had held restrictive interpretations of the earlier Rent Control Order provisions and interpreted comparable clauses as peremptory. The court recognised these authorities but examined whether they addressed the same statutory language.
- Perform textual comparison between clause 7(a) of the Madras House Rent Control Order, 1941 and Section 5(1) of the later Act: clause 7(a) prohibited increases after the Order except where specific additions/improvements at the landlord's expense had been made; Section 5(1) of the Act prohibited further increase only where a fair rent had been fixed under the Act.
- Derive the legal consequence of the textual difference: because Section 5(1) contains the qualification “when the fair rent of a building has been fixed under this Act,” if a fair rent had not been fixed, the Act did not prohibit agreements between parties to increase rent. The court emphasised that the narrower prohibition in the Act meant parties could contract for an enhanced rent when no fair rent had been fixed.
- Apply facts: in Second Appeal No. 1226, there was no application for fixation of fair rent and no fair rent had been fixed. The court therefore concluded the agreement for enhanced rent could not be declared void under the Act. The court relied on the principle that a statute intended to control contractual obligations must be strictly construed and that contracts are enforceable unless expressly prohibited by law or vitiated.
- In Second Appeal No. 1051 (tenant's recovery suit), the court examined the record and found that the Rent Controller's order of 21 February 1945 (proceedings L. Dis. 11853/44) showed that a petition for fixation of fair rent had been filed and the fair rent was fixed on 23 August 1944 at Rs. 19 per month. The landlord also admitted improving and electrifying the house after the fair rent was fixed.
- Conclude for No. 1051: because fair rent had in fact been fixed and it was not shown that the statutory conditions (repairs/additions as contemplated by Section 6) had been satisfied so as to permit enhancement, the enhanced rent collected was not warranted; the trial court's decree in favour of the tenant was therefore correct.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
- Second Appeal No. 1226 of 1954: The appeal was dismissed with costs. The court held that the agreement between landlord and tenant for enhanced rent was enforceable because no fair rent had been fixed under the Act; therefore the statutory provisions did not render the agreement void.
- Second Appeal No. 1051 of 1954: The appeal was allowed. The court set aside the subordinate judge's order, restored the trial court's judgment in favour of the tenant for recovery of excess rent, and directed that the appellant (tenant) be refunded the court fee paid in this Court (and that other costs be borne by each party respectively). The court also corrected a mistaken direction regarding payment of half the court fee.
Implications:
- The direct effects are limited to the parties: in No. 1226 the landlord's claim for arrears at the agreed enhanced rate was sustained; in No. 1051 the tenant was entitled to recover excess rent collected after the fixation of fair rent and to a refund of the court fee in this Court.
- The court's reasoning emphasises a textual approach: where the statute (the Act) conditions prohibition of increases upon fixation of fair rent, agreements between parties are not automatically void in the absence of such fixation. The opinion therefore distinguishes earlier decisions founded on the broader prohibition in the 1941 Order and applies the narrower terms of the later Act.
- The opinion does not state that it establishes a novel binding precedent beyond the resolution of the cases before it; its holdings are expressed as applications of the statutory text to the facts at hand.
Srinivasachari, J.:— These second appeals have been referred to a bench by our learned brother Umamaheswaram, J. Second Appeal No. 1226 of 1954 arises out of a suit filed for the recovery of Rs. 4575/- claimed by the landlord as arrears of rent due from 1st July 1950 to 31st November 1952 at the rate of Rs. 175/- per mensem. The plaintiff-landlord stated that the defendants Nos. 2 to 4 who formed a partnership carrying on business under the name and style of Sri Krishna Ice Parlour and Bakery took the suit premises on rent. It would appear that the rent fixed originally was Rs. 80/- per month and this continued till 30th November 1948 when there was an agreement to pay a higher rent, namely, Rs. 125/-. The rent was being paid at this rate from 1-12-1948 to 30-6-1950. On 1-7-1950 there was a further agreement to pay a higher rent, namely, Rs. 175/- per month. The plaintiff's case is that the defendant paid the rent till 30th June, 1950 and failed to pay subsequently. He therefore, claimed the arrears of rent on the basis of the increased rent at Rs. 175/-. The defendants 1 and 4 filed a Joint written Statement and denied that they had agreed to pay the rent at the rate of Rs. 175/- per mensem. It was stated that the rent was exorbitant and the plaintiff was entitled to recover only at the rate of Rs. 80/- per month, and it was also urged that the claim to a higher rent was contrary to the provisions of the Madras Buildings (Lease & Rent) Control Act and, therefore, such an agreement was not enforceable. Defendant No. 3 also pleaded the same defence to the suit. Although the courts below held that the agreement to pay the enhanced rent was proved, but with regard to the question as to whether the claim for the enhanced rent was against the provisions of the Madras Buildings (Lease & Rent) Control Act, the trial court held that the right of the plaintiff to claim a higher rent had come into effect even before the Madras Buildings (Lease and Rent) Control Act of 1946 and the Act could not affect the plaintiff's right to recover. The lower appellate court, however, came to the conclusion that so long as the fair rent had not been fixed there was nothing in the House Rent Control Act to debar the landlord to claim the enhanced rent under an agreement come to between himself and the tenant. The tenant has now come up in appeal.
2. The agreement to pay the enhanced rent having been found to have seen established by both the courts below, the question cannot be canvassed here. Therefore, the only point that arises for consideration here is as to whether the agreement between the landlord and tenant for an enhanced rent offended Section 6 of the Madras Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act of 1946 or 1949 as amended in 1951.
3. Relying upon a decision of the Madras High Court of Govindaraja Chari, J., in A. Moses Pillai v. M.K. Govindan . 1948 I M.L.J 51. it was argued on behalf of the appellant's counsel that the provisions of Section 6 of the Rent Control Act would apply despite the fact that the parties had contracted otherwise. The argument was that Section 6 Sub-section (2) of the Act was peremptory and imperative and it was not open to the landlord or the tenant to enter into a contract in violation of the above provisions. The facts of the aforesaid case were that the tenant in that case had executed a rent chit to say that the tenancy would last for a year first and that during that period a sum of Rs. 40/- would be paid every month. There was a further stipulation to say that if possession of the house was not delivered as agreed to within the prescribed period, the tenant would pay a rent of Rs. 45/- that is to say (an increased rent of Rs. 5/-) until possession was given. It was contended in that case that the excess of the sum of Rs. 5/-, the enhanced rent, could not be recovered from the tenant as that stipulation was un-enforceable in view of clause 7(a) of the Madras Rent Control Order of 1941. The learned Judge while interpreting the above clause came to the conclusion that provision in the Rent Control Order permitted the increase in rent only where some addition, improvement or alteration, such as was mentioned in that clause, had been carried out at the landlord's expense and that the clause permitted an increase in rent only in such a contingency. The learned Judge also held that the language employed indicated that the legislature was intending to interfere with the rights created under contracts entered into before or after the order, on grounds of high policy. In the result, the learned Judge upheld the contention of the tenant and rejected the claim of the plaintiff for a large rent.
4. The matter came up for consideration before the Madras High Court subsequently in the case of George Oakes Limited v. The Chief Judge, Small Causes Court Madras . 1950 II M.L.J 317.. In this case, the question did not arise in the same way as it did in the former case or in the case now before us. What was decided in that case was that where the House Rent Controller had fixed the rent and that happened to be higher than the rent that was being paid by the tenant it was not open to the land-lord to claim the difference between the rent that was being paid and the fair rent as fixed by the Rent Controller anterior to the date of filing of the application. A decision of Govinda Menon, J., in Munagala Venkateswararao v. Mohd. Mohibullah Saheb may also be adverted to in this connection. In this case the learned Judge following the decision of 1948 (1) M.L.J 51 held that the provisions of Sections 5 and 6 of the Madras Buildings (Lease and Rent) Control Act 1946, now Act 25 of 1949 were peremptory and would apply even though the parties had contracted to the contrary. This was also a case where the plaintiff-landlord claimed a higher rent and the claim was resisted by the tenant on the ground that the agreement to pay enhanced rent was null and void in view of the provisions of the Madras Buildings (Lease and Rent) Control Act of 1946. The courts below rejected the contention of the defendant and decreed the suit. On revision before the High Court, Govinda Menon, J., held that, the case fell within the decision in Moses Pillai v. M.K Govindan. He further held that there was no material difference between clause 7(a) of the Madras House Rent Control Order, 1941 and clause 6 of Rent Control Act 25 of 1949. In this view, he held that any agreement for enhancement was not allowed in law unless the conditions mentioned in section 6 of the Act were complied with. In effect the learned Judge opined that except under the circumstances pointed out in Section 6 of the Act, the rent could not be increased even by agreement between the parties. In order to appreciate the contentions raised by the respective counsel, it would be useful to refer to the relevant provisions of the Madras House Rent Control Order 1941 and the Madras Buildings (Lease and Rent) Control Act of 1946 and 1949. Clause 7(a) of the Madras House Rent Control Order of 1941 is to the following effect:—
“After the commencement of this order an increased rent shall be permissible only where some addition, improvement or alteration not included in the necessary repair or repairs which are usually made to houses in the local area, has been carried out at the landlord's expense since the rent was fixed”.
5. The relevant provision in the latter act (Act of 1946/1949) is as follows: Section 5(1):
“When the fair rent of a building has been fixed under this Act no further increase in such fair rent shall be permissible except in cases where some addition, improvement or alteration has been carried out at the landlord's expense and if the building is then in the occupation of a tenant, at his request”.
6. The words ‘in this Act’ were substituted by the amending Act of 1951. A comparison of the provisions of the Rent Control Order and the Act extracted above would show that while clause 7(a) of the Madras House Rent Control Order 1941 completely prohibited an increase in rent after the coming into force of the Control Order except under the circumstances mentioned in clause 7, Clause 5 of the subsequent Act prohibited an increase only where a fair rent had been fixed. It would, therefore, be evident from the term of the Section in the Act of 1946 that where fair rent has not been fixed, it was open to the parties to come to an agreement with regard to an increase in rent. This question did not arise in the case before Govindarajachari, J.
7. In a case of this kind where the tenant agreed to pay the enhanced rent it can be assumed from the agreement entered into by him with the landlord which has been held to be proved. As was observed in the case of Raja Chetty v. Jaganath Das Govind Das parties can always agree to be governed by the terms and conditions which may be inconsistent with some provisions of the Act. The record would show that in this case application for the fixation of fair rent was never made and no fair rent was fixed as a matter of fact. Under these circumstances, having regard to the clear words of Sec. 5(1) of the Act of 1946 it must be held that the agreement entered into between the landlord and the tenant for the enhanced rent could not be declared null and void as being in contravention of the provisions of the Act. The terms of a contract have to be observed by both the contracting parties A contract must be enforceable unless such contract is prohibited by law or vitiated by other circumstances. This apart, it may also be noted that where a statute seeks to control contractual obligations, such a statute must always be strictly construed. Courts will not be astute to construe an Act so as to avoid a contract, or a contract so as to bring it within the prohibition of a statute. Vide Craies Statute Law p. 236.
8. We must, therefore, hold that the contention raised by the learned counsel for the appellant that the agreement for the enhanced rent is unenforceable cannot be sustained and must be rejected. The appeal is, therefore, dismissed with costs.
SECOND APPEAL No. 1051 of 1954
9. This appeal arises out of a suit filed by the tenant for the recovery of a sum of Rs. 1317/- being the excess rent collected by the landlords after the fixation of fair rent. The trial court relying upon Section 6 of the Rent Control Act and taking all the circumstances of the case and the evidence on record came to the conclusion that the enhanced rent paid by the tenant was not warranted and, therefore, he was entitled to recover the amount. A decree, therefore, was passed in favour of the plaintiff-tenant. On appeal the subordinate Judge allowed the appeal holding that the tenant was not entitled to a refund of the excess rent because in the opinion of the learned Judge there was no fixation of fair rent by the Rent Controller. He, therefore, negatived the contention of the tenant and dismissed the suit. Hence this appeal.
10. We have gone through the record and we feel that the subordinate Judge has been under a misapprehension in regard to the matter as to whether there was a fixation of fair rent by the Rent Controller. In the order of the Rent Controller of 21st February 1945 in proceedings L. Dis. 11853/44 which is part of the record the Rent Controller has stated that a petition for the fixation of fair rent was filed and that on 23rd August 1944 the fair rent was fixed at Rs. 19/- per month. It would, therefore, be clear that as a matter of fact an application for the fixation of fair rent was made and that fair rent was fixed quite apart from this the landlord in his statement in the Rent Controller's court stated as follows:
“After the fair rent was fixed, I have improved the house and got it electrified”.
11. The landlord, therefore, also admits the fact of fair rent having been fixed. In the face of the observation of the Rent Controller and the statement of the defendant, landlord himself, it is not open to contend that there was no fair rent fixed, therefore, fair rent had been fixed and it had not been shown that repairs and additions as contemplated by Section 6 of the Act, had been carried out, there can be no enhancement of rent.
12. Under these circumstances, we allow the appeal, set aside the judgment of the Subordinate Judge and restore the judgment of the trial court. The appellant would be entitled to a refund of the court fee in this court. As regards other costs, each party will bear his own costs here.
13. This second appeal having been set down this day for being mentioned, the court made the following order:—
14. It is evidently a mistake for the direction to get half the court fee paid by the appellant from the other side. In other words, the appellant will get half the court-fee paid by her from the other side.
K.S.R
15. Appeal allowed.
Alert