- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The Deputy Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes, Kakinada v. Sri Pentapaty Lakshmana Swamy
Factual and Procedural Background
This Full Bench opinion, delivered by Satyanarayana Raju, J., addresses a referred question concerning the construction of rule 18 of the Turnover and Assessment Rules framed under the Madras General Sales Tax Act (the Act). The specific question referred was whether the deduction permitted by sub-rule (2) of rule 18 is conditional upon the assessee complying with the requirement contained in sub-rule (3) of that rule.
The opinion analyzes the relevant statutory framework: definitions in the Act (including "dealer" and "turnover"), the provisions of section 3 (empowering rules for turnover determination and returns), the proviso to section 3(5) (allocating tax on either buyer or seller), sections 5, 6, 15 and 19 (exemptions, rules-making power, offences/penalties), and the Turnover and Assessment Rules 1939 made under the Act (which have statutory force). The material rules examined include rule 4(1)-(2), rule 5(1)(k), and rule 18(1)-(3A).
Procedurally, the question was referred to the Full Bench, which after analysis answered in the affirmative. Following that Full Bench decision, a revision before the Court was allowed with costs and an advocate's fee was fixed at Rs. 250/-. The order records the conclusion and the grant of revision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the deduction referred to in sub-rule (2) of rule 18 of the Turnover and Assessment Rules (under the Madras General Sales Tax Act) is conditional upon the assessee complying with the requirement contained in sub-rule (3) of that rule.
Arguments of the Parties
Assessee's Arguments
- The assessee contended that rule 18(3) is directory and not mandatory — i.e., failure to comply with the procedural requirement (submission of Form A-9 by the 25th of each month) should not defeat the substantive right to the deduction under rule 18(2).
- It was argued that the tax is on net turnover and the rules merely prescribe the procedure for claiming the deduction; therefore the entitlement to the deduction is absolute and should not depend upon strict fulfilment of the prescribed procedure.
- The assessee relied upon the policy aim of avoiding double taxation (taxation on both purchase of groundnut/kernel and sale of oil) to support a liberal view allowing the deduction despite procedural default.
- The assessee pointed to judicial support in State Of Madras v. Hajee M.S.A. Meeran Sahib Co. (67 L.W. 660) where it was suggested that, absent clear language making exercise of a right depend upon performance of a duty, the requirement should not be read as a condition.
The opinion does not set out in detail the Revenue's separate arguments as distinct party submissions; rather, the Court's analysis addresses statutory language, scheme and precedent that bear on the respondent's position.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State Of Madras v. Hajee M.S.A. Meeran Sahib Co., 67 L.W. 660 | Suggested that, unless clear language makes a right dependent on fulfilment of a duty, the requirement should not be read as a condition (supporting a directory construction). | The opinion notes this decision as supportive of the assessee's contention that rule 18(3) could be directory; it is considered but weighed against other authorities and the language of the rules. |
| The State of Madras v. Nallam Jaggaiah, 1954 2 M.L.J 670 | Holds that such a deduction could be allowed only if all conditions specified in rule 18 were satisfied. | Referenced as judicial authority taking a stricter view — the Court considered it as countervailing precedent indicating that conditions must be satisfied for the deduction. |
| Boddu Pydanna Sons v. The State of Andhra (Appeal No. 293 of 1951) — Division Bench (unreported; decision dated 1st Aug 1955) | Concluded rule 18(3) is absolute and peremptory and that the exemption under rule 18(2) cannot be claimed otherwise; deduction is conditional on compliance with rule 18. | The Full Bench expressly agreed with this Division Bench conclusion and adopted it in answering the referred question in the affirmative. |
| P.A Raju & Brothers v. Commissioner of Income-tax, I.L.R 1949 Mad. 644 | Establishes that statutory provisions creating special assessment schemes must be strictly and rigidly complied with; equitable considerations cannot substitute for strict compliance. | The Court relied on this authority by analogy to support strict interpretation and enforcement of the conditions in rules granting the special privilege (deduction) to registered manufacturers. |
| Cape Brandy Syndicate v. Inland Revenue Commissioners | Principle that in taxing Acts one must look to what is clearly said; no presumption or implication in favour of tax or exemption — clear words are necessary. | The Court invoked this principle to emphasize that taxing statutes and rules must be read by reference to clear language; nothing should be read in or implied contrary to the plain words. |
| Howard v. Bodington | Sets out the approach to distinguishing mandatory from directory provisions — consider the subject matter, importance of the provision disregarded, and its relation to the general object to decide whether imperative or directory. | The Court applied this test to rule 18(3), concluding that given the peremptory language and the object of the provision, the requirement is mandatory (i.e., the deduction is conditional on compliance). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by construing the Act and the relevant rules in their statutory context and in light of the purpose of the special deduction. Key elements of the analysis were:
- The overall taxing scheme is multipoint taxation: turnover-based taxation with rules determining whether buyer or seller is taxed for the same sale, and avoiding double taxation where a dealer has been taxed in respect of purchase under the rules.
- Rule 4 ordinarily takes gross turnover as sales amount, but for certain goods (including groundnut) gross turnover is the amount for which goods are bought; rule 5(1)(k) and rule 18 create a special deduction for registered manufacturers of groundnut oil and cake to avoid double taxation where both purchase and sale might otherwise be taxed.
- Rule 18(1) requires registration as a manufacturer; rule 18(2) grants the deduction but makes it explicitly available to “every such manufacturer” and adds express conditions (the oil being manufactured and sold by the registered manufacturer and inclusion of sale amount in turnover). Rule 18(3) requires monthly submission of Form A-9 to the registering authority by the 25th.
- The Court noted that sub-rule (3-A) (enabling condonation by the Commercial Tax Officer) was added later (10th February 1949), which bears on the administration of the Rule and on consequences of omission.
- Applying established principles of construction for taxing statutes and for exemptions, the Court emphasized two interrelated points:
- Exemptions and special privileges in taxing statutes must be clearly shown and are construed strictly against the claimant; the claimant bears the burden of establishing entitlement to the exemption.
- In taxing Acts there is no room for intendment — one must look at the clear language used; nothing is to be read in or implied.
- The Court also applied the test from Howard v. Bodington for distinguishing mandatory and directory provisions — considering the subject matter, the importance of the requirement, and its relation to the object of the Act — and concluded that the language of rules 5(1)(k) and 18(2) and (3) is peremptory and absolute.
- On this basis, and in light of the precedents (including the Division Bench decision in Boddu Pydanna Sons, which the Court followed), the deduction in sub-rule (2) of rule 18 was held to be conditional upon compliance with the requirements specified in sub-rule (3).
The Court weighed authorities both for a directory construction (Hajee M.S.A. Meeran Sahib Co.) and for a stricter construction (Nallam Jaggaiah; Boddu Pydanna Sons; P.A. Raju & Brothers), and, applying the statutory language and the cited construction principles, concluded that strict compliance is required.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The deduction referred to in sub-rule (2) of rule 18 is conditional upon the assessee complying with the requirements prescribed in sub-rule (3) of rule 18.
Direct consequences and immediate effect:
- The Full Bench answered the referred question in the affirmative (i.e., the deduction is conditional on compliance with rule 18(3)).
- Following this Full Bench decision, the revision before the Court was allowed with costs; an advocate's fee was fixed at Rs. 250/-. The Order records that the revision is allowed.
Broader implications:
- The opinion emphasizes that special privileges or exemptions in taxing statutes and subordinate rules are to be strictly observed and that a claimant must comply with procedural and substantive conditions to obtain the benefit. Beyond that strict interpretive stance, the opinion does not elaborate further policy or doctrinal implications beyond the direct effect on the entitlement to the deduction and the disposition of the revision before the Court.
Satyanarayana Raju, J.:— The following question has been referred to us:
“Whether the deduction referred to in sub-rule (2) of rule 18 of the Turnover and Assessment Rules framed under the Madras General Sales Tax Act is conditional upon the assessee complying with the requirement contained in Sub-rule (3) of that rule?”
3. The answer to this question depends on the construction of the relevant provisions of the Madras General Sales Tax Act (hereafter referred to as “the Act”), which, by reason of section 53 of the Andhra State Act, is in force in the territory now forming part of the State of Andhra. The descriptive title of the Act is “An Act to provide for the levy of a general tax on the sale of goods in the State of Madras.”
The provisions of the Act, so far as they are now relevant, run as follows:
Section 2(b) “‘Dealer’ means any person who carries on the business of buying or selling goods.”
Section 2(i) “‘Turnover’ means the aggregate amount for which goods are either bought by or sold by a dealer whether for cash or for deferred payment………”
4. Section 3 provides that the turnover for all purposes of the Act shall be determined in accordance with, and the tax shall be assessed, levied and collected in such manner and in such instalments as may be prescribed by the Rules made by the State Government in that behalf. Every dealer whose turnover is Rs. 10,000/- or more for a year shall submit such return or returns of his turnover in such manner and for such periods as may be prescribed under sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) of section 3.
5. There is a proviso to section 3(5) which contains the following clauses:
“(i) in respect of the same transaction of sale, the buyer or the seller, but not both as determined by such rules as may be prescribed, shall be taxed:
(ii) Where a dealer has been taxed in respect of the purchase of any goods in accordance with the rules referred to in clause (i) of this proviso he shall not be taxed again in respect of any sale of such goods effected by him.”
6. Section 5 provides for exemptions and reduction of tax in certain cases. Section 6 empowers the Government to make an exemption or reduction in rate, in respect of any tax payable under the Act, on the sale of any specified class of goods at all points or at a specified point or points in the series of sales by successive dealers. Section 15 provides for offences and penalties, among which is wilful submission of an untrue return or failure to submit a return as required by the provisions of the Act or the rules made thereunder. Section 19 empowers the State Government to make rules to carry out the purposes of the Act, and requires that all rules made under the section shall be published in the Gazette, which, upon such publication, shall have effect as if enacted in the Act.
7. Under Section 3(2), the State Government made rules which are called “The Madras General Sales Tax (Turnover and Assessment) Rules 1939,” and under section 19, further rules which are called “The Madras General Sales Tax Rules 1939”. These rules are of an elaborate and comprehensive character, and by reason of sections 3(4), 3(5) and 19(5) they have statutory force.
8. None of the provisions in the Madras General Sales Tax Rules is relevant for our present purpose, but some of the provisions of the Turnover and Assessment Rules require to be noticed.
9. They are:
“4(1). Save as provided in sub-rule (2) the gross turnover of a dealer for the purposes of these rules shall be the amount for which goods are sold by the dealer.
(2) In the case of the under-mentioned goods the gross turnover of a dealer for the purposes of these rules shall be the amount for which the goods are bought by the dealer.
(a) groundnut…………………………”
“(5)(1) The tax or taxes under section 3 or 5 or the notification or notifications under Section 6(1) shall be levied on the net turnover of a dealer……………
(k) all amounts which a registered manufacturer of groundnut oil (other than refined groundnut oil) and cake may be entitled to deduct from his gross turnover under rule 18 subject to the conditions specified in that rule.”
10. The other relevant provision is contained in rule 18, which runs thus:
“(1) Any dealer who manufactures groundnut oil and cake from groundnut and/or kernel purchased by him may, on application to the assessing authority having jurisdiction over the area in which he carries on his business, be registered as a manufacturer of groundnut oil and cake.
(2) Every such manufacturer shall be entitled to a deduction under clause (k) of sub-rule (1) of rule 5 equal to the value of the groundnut and (or) kernel purchased and converted by him into oil and cake provided that the amount for which the oil is sold is included in his turnover.
(3) Every such manufacturer shall submit so as to reach the registering authority not later than the 25th day of every month a statement in Form A-9 in respect of the transactions relating to the previous month.
(3-A). If any such manufacturer fails to submit the statement in Form A-9 within the time specified in Sub-rule (3) or if he omits to furnish any of the particulars required by that form, the Commercial Tax Officer, may, in his discretion after making such enquiry as he considers necessary, condone the delay or omission or both………….”
11. It may be noted here that the above sub-rule (3-A) was added on 10th February 1949.
12. The general scheme of taxation adopted under the Act and the rules made thereunder, is multipoint taxation. Tax is levied at specified rates on the total turnover of a dealer if it exceeds a specified limit. In respect of the same transaction of sale, the buyer or seller but not both, as determined by the rules, shall be taxed. Where a dealer has been taxed in respect of the purchase of any goods in accordance with the rules, he shall not be taxed again in respect of any sale of goods effected by him.
13. Generally the amount for which the goods are sold by a dealer constitutes his gross turnover. But in the case of certain specified goods, such as groundnuts, etc. the gross turnover of a dealer shall be the amount for which the goods are bought by him. Thus in the case of groundnuts and other goods specified in sub-rule (2) of rule 4 tax is levied on the purchase turnover.
14. Any dealer who manufactures groundnut oil and cake from groundnut or groundnut kernel, purchased by him, may register himself as a manufacturer of groundnut oil and cake. Such manufacturer of groundnut oil (other than refined groundnut oil) and cake is entitled to a deduction from his gross turnover, of an amount equal to the value of the groundnut and or kernel purchased and converted by him into oil and cake, provided that the amount for which the oil is sold is included in his turnover and subject to the conditions specified in rule 18. Normally the manufacturer of groundnut oil and cake who sells them have to pay tax on the sales turnover. But if the gross turnover of oil is subject to tax, the manufacturer would be paying tax both on the groundnut and kernel purchased by him and also on the sale of oil manufactured therefrom. In order to obviate this hardship, a special privilege or exemption is conferred on a dealer in groundnut who registers himself as a manufacturer of groundnut oil and cake.
15. The right to claim this exemption is, however, subject to certain conditions specified in rules 5(1)(k) and 18. Under rule 5(1)(k), all amounts which a registered manufacturer of groundnut oil and cake may be entitled to deduct from his gross turnover under rule 18, shall be subject to the conditions specified in that rule. Rule 18(1) requires any dealer who manufactures groundnut oil and cake to be registered as a manufacturer. Rule 18(2) which allows the deduction, makes explicit reference to every such manufacturer, that is to say, a manufacturer of oil who gets himself registered under rule 18(1). Rule 18(2) imposes two further conditions viz., that the oil should have been manufactured and sold by the dealer who has registered himself as a manufacturer and that the amount for which the oil is sold should be included in his turnover. It is only when these conditions are fulfilled that deduction equal to the value of the groundnut and kernel purchased by him and converted into oil and cake is permissible. There is a further obligation under rule 18(3), viz., that every such manufacturer shall submit so as to reach the registering authority not later than the 25th day of every month, a statement in Form A-9 in respect of the transactions relating to the previous month. This is to enable the assessing authority to allow deduction or to fix the amount thereof under rule 18(2). This exemption is allowed only in the case of unrefined groundnut oil but does not apply to refined oil.
16. Now it is contended on behalf of the assessee that he is entitled to the deduction provided for by rule 18(2) of the Turnover and Assessment Rules despite the fact that he failed to submit a return in Form A-9 which is the requirement contained in Sub-rule (3) of rule 18. The argument of the learned Counsel for the assessee may be stated thus: The provisions of rule 18(3) are only directory and not mandatory. What is liable to tax is the net turnover. The rules merely prescribe the procedure to be followed by the assessee in making his claim for deduction. The right to have a deduction is an absolute one and does not depend upon the fulfilment of the procedure prescribed, and this is also in consonant with the basic idea that double taxation has to be avoided.
17. This contention receives support from a decision of Basheer Ahmed Sayeed, J. in State Of Madras v. Hajee M.S.A. Meeran Sahib Co. 67 L.W 660. There the learned Judge, after considering the relevant statutory provisions reached the conclusion that if the intention behind the rules was to make the exercise of a right to depend upon the fulfilment of the duty referred to in Sub-rule (3) appropriate language should have been used so as to make the meaning beyond dispute. In a later decision reported in The State of Madras v. Nallam Jaggaiah 1954 2 M.L.J 670 the same learned Judge held that such a deduction could be allowed in favour of an assessee only if all the conditions specified in rule 18 were satisfied.
18. In an unreported decision of this Court in Boddu Pydanna Sons v. The State of Andhra (Appeal No. 293 of 1951) decided on 1st August 1955 a Division Bench consisting of one of us, Viswanatha Sastry, J. and Krishna Rao, J., after an exhaustive discussion of all the material provisions of the Act and the rules has held that the language of rule 18(3) is so absolute and peremptory that it has to be construed as laying down by necessary implication that the exemption under rule 18(2) cannot be claimed in any other manner and that the deduction referred to in sub-rule (2) of rule 18 of the Turnover and Assessment Rules is conditional upon the assessee complying with the requirements of rule 18.
19. The general rule of construction is that exemptions from tax granted by a statute should be given full scope and amplitude and should not be whittled down by importing limitations not inserted by the Legislature. If under the provisions of a taxing statute an assessee claims an exemption, it is for that person to show that he has been exempted. Therefore provisions providing for exemption may be properly construed strictly against the person who makes the claim of an exemption. In other words, before exemption can be recognised, the person or property claimed to be exempt must come clearly within the language apparently granting the exemption. (Vide Crawford on the Construction of Statutes page 506).
20. The same principle has been laid down by a Division Bench of the Madras High Court in P.A Raju & Brothers v. Commissioner of Income-tax I.L.R 1949 Mad. 644 where Rajamannar, C.J and Yahya Ali, J. observed thus:
“It is manifest, therefore, that Sec. 26-A as well as the rules and the particulars required in the form have all been designed to enable the assessment to be done on registered firms in the manner provided under sub-sec. (5)(a) of Sec. 23. It is for this purpose of the utmost importance that the real partner should be disclosed and the precise shares of each of the partners should be mentioned and these particulars should represent the real state of affairs. The purpose of the entire scheme of the assessment of registered firms will be defeated if it is found that either the firm is not genuine or that the shares mentioned therein are not true. A strict and rigid compliance with the requirements of Sec. 26-A and the rules is, in our opinion, essential and there is no scope for any, of the equitable considerations put forward by the learned Advocate-General.”
21. These observations would apply with equal force to the interpretation of Rules 5(i)(k) and 18(2) and (3) of the Turnover and Assessment Rules which confer a special privilege on a registered manufacturer of groundnut oil who complies with the prescribed conditions.
22. In Cape Brandy Syndicate v. Inland Revenue Commissioners Rowlatt, J. made the following observations which are pertinent:
“It is urged by Sir William Finlay that in a taxing Act clear words are necessary in order to tax the subject. Too wide and fanciful a construction is often sought to be given to that maxim, which does not mean that words are to be unduly restricted against the Crown or that there is to be any discrimination against the Crown in those Acts. It simply means that in a taxing Act one has to look merely at what is clearly said. There is no room for any intendment. There is no equity about a tax. There is no presumption as to a tax. Nothing is to be read and nothing is to be implied. One can only look fairly at the language used.”
23. We may also bear in mind the difference between a mandatory and a directory provision. The former must be obeyed or fulfilled exactly while it is sufficient if the latter is obeyed or fulfilled substantially. The decision in Howard v. Bodington lays down the following principle:
“…….as far as any rule is concerned, you cannot safely go further than that in each case you must look to the subject matter; consider the importance of the provision that has been disregarded and the relation of that provision to the general object intended to be secured by the Act, and upon a review of the case in that aspect, decide whether the enactment is what is called imperative or only directory.”
24. Construing rules 5(1)(k) and 18 (2) and (3) in the light of the foregoing principles and having regard to the peremptory and absolute language in which these rules are couched, it is manifest that the deduction referred to in sub-rule (2) of rule 18 is conditional upon the assessee complying with the conditions prescribed under Sub-rule (3) of that rule.
25. For the above reasons, we are in agreement with the conclusion reached by the Division Bench of this Court, in Boddu Pydanna Sons v. The State of Andhra (Appeal No. 293 of 1951).
26. The answer to the question referred to the Full Bench is, therefore in the affirmative.
27. The petition coming on for hearing after the decision of the Full Bench before the Hon'ble The Chief Justice and The Hon'ble Mr. Justice Bhimasankaram, the Court delivered the following.
ORDER.
28. Following the Full Bench decision the revision is allowed with costs. Advocates fee Rs. 250/-.
T.A.B
29. Revision allowed.
Alert