Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Arvind Kumar Singh Petitioner v. State Of U.P

Allahabad High Court
Aug 28, 2010
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Hon. Ram Aautar Singh, J. (Order dated 28.8.2010)

Factual and Procedural Background

An F.I.R. was lodged on 15.9.1987 by Dinesh Kumar Tiwari at P.S. Sigra, Varanasi, alleging that an advertisement published in Dainik Jagran (dated 11.8.1987) invited applications with bank drafts of Rs. 20/- for posts in Jan Kalyan Sansthan, Lallapur. Complainant deposited his application and bank draft at the institution's office; after an altercation between applicants and employees, one employee identified himself as Arvind Kumar Singh and allegedly confessed that the institution intended to encash the received drafts and abscond.

A case under sections 419 and 420 IPC was registered and investigated. The police searched the office on 16.9.1987, arrested Arvind Kumar Singh and Izharul Hasan, and seized registers, bank drafts, seals, receipt books, application forms, envelopes with drafts, and other materials. A charge-sheet was submitted under sections 419 and 420 IPC. Charges under section 420 read with section 511 IPC were framed on 28.6.1990. The prosecution examined five witnesses (P.W.1 to P.W.5). The accused statements were recorded under section 313 Cr.P.C.; no defence evidence was adduced.

The trial court found both accused guilty under section 420 read with section 511 IPC and sentenced them to one year simple imprisonment. The accused appealed (Criminal Appeals No. 10 of 2000 and 15 of 2000). The appellate court dismissed the appeals on merits but reduced the sentence to six months R.I. each and imposed a fine of Rs. 500/- each (with two months R.I. in default). The present criminal revisions challenge the common judgment and order dated 10.7.2001 of the Additional Sessions Judge, Varanasi, upholding conviction but modifying sentence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the findings of guilt recorded by the trial and appellate courts under section 420 read with section 511 IPC were unsupported or perverse on the evidence on record.
  2. Whether the appellate court erred in its reliance on prosecution witnesses (notably P.W.1, P.W.2 and P.W.4) regarding the identity and office-bearer status of the accused.
  3. Whether the prosecution failed to produce or prove materially important documents (such as the list of office-bearers) and whether such omission vitiates the conviction.
  4. Whether this revisional court can re-appreciate the same evidence and substitute its own findings for concurrent findings of the courts below in the absence of a shown illegality, perversity or miscarriage of justice.

Arguments of the Parties

Revisionists' (Appellants') Arguments

  • The appellate court wrongly recorded that P.W.4 (Rama Shankar Singh) stated Arvind Kumar Singh was Chairman and Izharul Hasan was Secretary of the society; P.W.4 never made such statements.
  • The statements of P.W.1 (Dinesh Kumar Tiwari) and P.W.2 (Lolarak Nath Tiwari) were unreliable and inadmissible, and the appellate court wrongly relied on them to infer office-bearer status.
  • The prosecution did not produce the list of office-bearers of the institution—only a list of office-bearers of a society was filed—and therefore the prosecution failed to prove that the accused were office-bearers of the institution.
  • Arvind Kumar Singh was neither Chairman nor had any concern with Jan Kalyan Sansthan, and the courts below arbitrarily held otherwise.

Respondent / Prosecution Position (as reflected in the record)

  • The prosecution adduced eyewitness testimony (P.W.1–P.W.3) that the accused were involved in the scheme to collect bank drafts and intended to encash them and abscond; witnesses identified or stated the name of one accused during the incident.
  • Police recovered registers, bank drafts, postal orders, seals, receipt books, application forms, envelopes containing drafts, and the signboard from the accused's office; recovery memoranda and production of recovered articles were placed on record.
  • Documentary evidence and registers were exhibited and proved in accordance with law. Forensic Science Laboratory report (No. 352 Doc-88 dated 25.8.1988) indicated the handwriting and signatures of the revisionists on recovered documents.
  • No evidence of alleged enmity or false implication was established by the defence despite the accused raising the plea under section 313 Cr.P.C.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the findings of both the trial court and the appellate court and framed its analysis around the admissibility and reliability of prosecution evidence and whether any irregularity, illegality or perversity existed warranting revisional interference.

On the contention regarding P.W.4, the Court examined P.W.4's statement and held that P.W.4 did not term Arvind Kumar Singh as Chairman nor Izharul Hasan as Secretary; thus the revisionists' specific complaint on that point was incorrect.

The Court addressed the challenge to the reliability of P.W.1 and P.W.2 by noting that nothing was shown as to why their statements should be considered unreliable. The trial court had accepted their testimony that an accused attempted to flee and disclosed his name; there was no evidence that these witnesses knew the accused prior to the incident or that false implication due to enmity had occurred. The accused had not provided details of any enmity in their section 313 Cr.P.C. statements, nor adduced evidence to prove enmity.

Regarding the absence of a produced list of office-bearers of the institution, the Court relied on concurrent findings that the list of office-bearers of the society was recovered from the disputed office; thus the contention was rejected.

The Court highlighted the recovery of registers, bank drafts, fake seals and other materials from the accused's office which were produced and exhibited at trial. It specifically noted the Forensic Science Laboratory report (No. 352 Doc-88 dated 25.8.1988) showing that handwriting and signatures of the revisionists were found on recovered documents. On this basis, the Court concluded that the prosecution had established the complicity of both accused and the dishonest/malafide intention of the office-bearers.

The Court emphasized the limited scope of revisional jurisdiction: it cannot re-appreciate evidence and record different findings on the same material when concurrent findings have been recorded by courts below, absent a shown glaring feature or gross miscarriage of justice. As no discrepancy, illegality or perversity was pointed out, the Court declined to interfere with the findings of the lower courts.

Holding and Implications

Holding: These criminal revisions are dismissed.

Implications:

  • The convictions and the appellate court's modification of sentence remain undisturbed: the courts below had convicted the revisionists under section 420 read with section 511 IPC and the appellate court reduced the sentence to six months R.I. each and imposed a fine of Rs. 500/- each (with two months R.I. in default). By dismissing the revisions, the revisional court left those orders intact.
  • Copies of this judgment and order were directed to be sent to the trial court for compliance forthwith.
  • No new legal principle or precedent was laid down by this decision; the Court affirmed the conclusions of the courts below and reiterated the limited scope of revisional jurisdiction.
Show all summary ...

Hon. Ram Aautar Singh, J.

These criminal revisions have been directed against the common judgment and order dated 10.7.2001 passed by Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 2, Varanasi in Criminal Appeal N0. 10 of 2000 (Izharul Hasan v. State of U.P) and Criminal Appeal No. 15 of 2000 (Arvind Kumar Singh v. State of U.P) by which both appeals have been dismissed with the direction to reduce the sentence imposed by the trial court on the revisionists.

The brief facts arising out of the case are that an F.I.R was lodged by complainant Dinesh Kumar Tiwari on 15.9.1987 at 15.10 P.M at P.S Sigra of District Varanasi with this allegation that an advertisement was got published by Sachiv, General Manager Jan Kalyan Sansthan, Lallapur, Varanasi, U.P in Dainik Jagran dated 11.8.1987 inviting applications alongwith bank drafts of Rs. 20/- each for the posts of Office Superintendents and Supervisors, for which complainant Dinesh Kumar Tiwari also deposited his application and bank draft of Rs. 20/- in the said office situated at C-15/79 Lallapur, Varanasi, which was entered at serial no. 907 in the register. The complainant at the time of depositing his application suspected some foul play from conversation going on between the employees of the office, at which some applicants requested the employees to return their applications and bank drafts, which gave rise to an altercation between them and in the meantime one of the employees took him to lonely place and agreed to return his application with this assurance that he would not inform the police in this regard. All the applicants present in the office then asked the employees to disclose their names, at which one of them tried to flee from the office but he was caught by the applicants and on being asked he disclosed his name as Arvind Kumar Singh resident of Gopalpur, P.S Meh Nagar, District Azamgarh and confessed to his guilt that they after receiving all the bank drafts would encash them and would leave the place. The complainant along with all applicants then came to know of the cheating being committed by the persons including accused Arvind Kumar Singh, who claimed himself to be the Chairman of the said institution.

A case was registered under sections 419 and 420 I.P.C against the revisionist Arvind Kumar Singh and other employees of Jan Kalyan Sansthan, Lallapur on the basis of written report of complainant Dinesh Kumar Tiwari at P.S Sigra and investigated by the police. The investigating officer then checked the said office on 16.9.1987 at 4.00 P.M, arrested accused Arvind Kumar Singh and Izharul Hasan, who also claimed himself to be the Secretary of the said institution. The police then conducted search and recovered application register, meeting register, bank drafts, postal orders, seals of institution, eight receipt books, application forms, envelopes containing bank drafts, sign board of institution displayed on the front of office and then sealed the office as well as prepared recovery memo. The police on completion of investigation submitted charge sheet against the revisionists under sections 419 and 420 I.P.C

The charges under section 420 read with section 511 of I.P.C were framed against the revisionists on 28.6.1990, who did not plead guilty and claimed to be tried. In order to prove the charge prosecution examined P.W.1 Dinesh Kumar Tiwari, P.W 2 Lolarak Nath Tiwari, P.W.3 Mohd. Rozan Ansari, P.W.4 Rama Shankar Singh and P.W.5 Rajan Prasad Pandey. The statements of the accused persons were recorded under section 313 Cr.P.C, in which they denied the prosecution evidence and claimed to be falsely implicated due to enmity but no evidence in their defence was adduced.

The learned trial court found both the revisionists guilty under section 420 read with section 511 of I.P.C and sentenced them to under go simple imprisonment for one year. The revisionists then preferred Criminal Appeals No. 10 of 2000 and 15 of 2000 against above judgment and order. The learned appellate court neither found any illegality or irregularity in the judgment passed by the trial court nor the same was found to be perverse, consequently both appeals were dismissed but the sentence imposed by the trial court was reduced to six months R.I each and in addition to above sentence each of the appellants was directed to pay Rs. 500/- as fine and in default they were further directed to under go additional R.I for two months. The revisionists then preferred these revisions against the judgments passed by the courts below.

The learned counsel for the revisionists has contended that the appellate court has recorded wrong finding that P.W 4 Rama Shankar Singh, Registrar of the said institution stated that the revisionist Arvind Kumar Singh was Chairman of the registered society, while P.W.4 Rama Shankar Singh never made such statement. This contention raised on behalf of the revisionists is found to be incorrect. A perusal of statement of P.W.4 Rama Shankar Singh goes to show that P.W.4 Rama Shankar Singh has nowhere termed revisionist Arvind Kumar Singh to be Chairman of the said institution and Izharul Hasan to be its Secretary.

It is further contented that the appellate court has wrongly relied on the statements of P.W 1 Dinesh Kumar Tiwari and P.W 2 Lolarak Nath Tiwari to this effect that the revisionist Arvind Kumar Singh was Chairman and Izharul Hasan was Secretary of the registered society, while the statements of these witnesses have neither been found reliable nor admissible in evidence. This contention of learned counsel cannot be accepted because nothing has been shown as to why the statements of these witnesses cannot be said to be reliable. The learned trial court has categorically appreciated the statements of these witnesses, who have stated that the revisionist Arvind Kumar Singh tried to flee from his office when a crowd of applicants, who had gone to deposit their applications asked to return their applications and bank drafts and all of them then surrounded him, who disclosed his name before them. Nothing has been found on record that these witnesses knew this accused before this occurrence and thus the question of his false implication due to alleged enmity could not arise. The details of so called enmity has not been given in the statements of revisionists under section 313 Cr.P.C No evidence regarding alleged enmity has been adduced in defence. P.W.2 Lolarak Nath Tiwari has also corroborated the prosecution case and categorically stated that the investigating officer has recovered the above mentioned articles from the office of revisionists. The learned appellate court also observed that nothing has been found on record to discard the testimony of these witnesses. In view of concurrent findings of both the courts below, this Court has no option except to accept the above findings of the learned courts below.

The learned counsel for the revisionist has also contended that the prosecution has not produced the list of office bearers of the institution and only the list of office bears of the society has been filed. This contention raised on behalf of the revisionist is found worthless in view of concurrent findings recorded by both the courts below in this regard that the list of office bearers of the society has been recovered by the police from the disputed office.

It has been vehemently contended that the revisionist was neither Chairman nor had any concern with the said society, namely, ?Jan Kalyan Sansthan?, Lallapur, Varanasi and he has pleaded before the trial court in this regard, but the courts below have arbitrarily held that he was Chairman of the society. This contention is inconsistent with the findings recorded by the courts below, because the prosecution has been able to establish on the basis of evidence that the revisionist Arvind Kumar Singh was Chairman of the society ?Jan Kalyan Sansthan?, Lallapur, Varanasi at the relevant time and he along with co-revisionist induced unemployed educated candidates to move applications for appointment along with required bank drafts and they deposited their applications alongwith the bank drafts in his office because the revisionists intended to get these bank drafts encashed and thereafter flee from the said office after closing the same.

The learned courts below categorically recorded findings to this effect that on the basis of the evidence on record it was proved that the registers, bank drafts, fake seals and other fake materials were recovered by the police from the office of the revisionists. The recovered articles were produced during the statements of the witnesses and exhibited in trial court. Under these circumstances this contention cannot be accepted that the prosecution did not produce alleged recovered bank drafts and forms which were sealed on the spot. Nothing has been found on record to disbelieve the statements of the prosecution witnesses nor any enmity has been proved between the complaint and the revisionists. Consequently the courts below have not committed any illegality or factual error in relying on the testimony of the witnesses.

This revisional court cannot act as if it is hearing an appeal. No doubt this Court can call for and examine the record of any proceedings for the purpose of satisfying itself as to the correctness, legality or propriety of any finding, sentence or order, but it cannot record different findings on the basis of same evidence on record and substitute the findings recorded by the courts below. No discrepancy or illegality in the conduct of trial vitiating the same has been pointed out on behalf of the revisionists. No scope is found for using revisional jurisdiction to interfere with the findings recorded by the courts below. On the basis of re-appreciation of evidence there is no possibility to come to a different conclusion than the one arrived at by the courts below and thus there is no scope whatsoever to interfere with the orders passed by the courts below.

The learned courts below have categorically recorded a finding to this effect that there is evidence on record that the revisionists have made an attempt to cheat the persons, who have deposited their applications alongwith bank drafts or postal orders and thus there is material on record, on the basis of which the courts below have found these revisionists guilty of the offences under section 420 read with section 511 of I.P.C The complicity of the revisionist Izharul Hasan has been established on the basis of evidence. No doubt P.W 4 Rama Shankar Singh has made his statement to this effect that the society has been registered in accordance with law and rules, but on the basis of the evidence on record the intention of the revisionists being office bearers of the society has been found dishonest and malafide. The direct and circumstantial evidence available on record are sufficient to establish that the revisionists are involved in attempting to commit cheating the witnesses and unemployed educated candidates.

Various registers relating to the offence committed by the revisionists and bank drafts have been recovered by the police from the office of the institution and the same have been exhibited during trial. All the documentary evidence have been found to be proved in accordance with law. The report No. 352 Doc-88 dated 25.8.1988 of Forensic Science Laboratory, U.P, Mahanagar, Lucknow is found on record of trial court, which is evident to show that the handwriting and signatures of revisionists have been found on the documents recovered from their office, on the basis of comparison made by the experts.

It would not be out of place to mention at this stage that this Court hearing these revisions cannot re-appreciate the evidence on record and come to its own conclusion on the same evidence when the same has already been appreciated by the courts below, unless any glaring feature is brought to the notice of this Court which would otherwise tantamount to gross miscarriage of justice. The findings recorded by the courts below cannot be said to be perverse. Nothing has been shown on behalf of the revisionists that the findings recorded by the courts below are perverse or illegal.

In view of the foregoing discussions, these revisions lack merits and are liable to be dismissed. Consequently, these revisions are dismissed.

Let copy of this judgment and order be sent to the trial court for compliance forthwith.

Order Date :- 28.8.2010