Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vijay Bahadur Pandey v. State Of U.P And Others

Allahabad High Court
Mar 18, 2005
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition challenges the order dated 28.2.2005 passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate (C.J.M), Mau, whereby an application filed by respondent No. 4 was allowed and a Non-Bailable Warrant (N.B.W) was issued against the petitioner. The respondent No. 4, Jai Nath Singh, had filed an application under section 156(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cr. P.C) requesting the Magistrate to direct the police to register a case and investigate. The learned C.J.M, Mau, on 1.9.2003, did not direct registration but sent the application to the Superintendent of Police (S.P), Mau for necessary action. Subsequently, an FIR was registered at Police Station Sarain Lakhansi under various IPC sections and the Criminal Law Amendment Act. The charge-sheet was submitted and cognizance was taken by the C.J.M, Mau on 30.7.2004. The petitioner challenged the initial order of 1.9.2003 by filing a Criminal Revision, which was allowed on 10.12.2004, setting aside the order and directing the C.J.M to pass a fresh order in accordance with law. The petitioner also challenged the FIR and charge-sheet before this Court, but both challenges were refused, with directions that bail applications be considered expeditiously. The respondent moved an application to review the 10.12.2004 order, which was refused on 19.2.2005, clarifying that the charge-sheet and cognizance remain unaffected. Pursuant to this, the respondent applied for issuance of N.B.W against accused persons not released on bail, leading to the impugned order dated 28.2.2005 issuing N.B.W against the petitioner and others.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order dated 28.2.2005 issuing N.B.W against the petitioner and others is legal and valid in light of the earlier orders setting aside the 1.9.2003 order?
  2. Whether the setting aside of the order passed under section 156(3) Cr. P.C affects the validity of the FIR, investigation, and charge-sheet submitted subsequently?
  3. Whether the learned Magistrate was obligated to pass a fresh order under section 156(3) Cr. P.C after the revisional court set aside the initial order?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The order dated 1.9.2003 by the learned C.J.M, Mau, which did not direct police registration but sent the application to the S.P, was set aside by the Revisional Court on 10.12.2004.
  • All subsequent proceedings based on the order dated 1.9.2003, including the impugned order dated 28.2.2005, have become null and void.
  • The impugned order dated 28.2.2005 issuing N.B.W is illegal and liable to be set aside.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • There is no illegality or irregularity in the impugned order dated 28.2.2005.
  • The Revisional Court on 19.2.2005 clarified that the order setting aside the 1.9.2003 order does not affect the charge-sheet or cognizance taken by the Magistrate.
  • The learned C.J.M, Mau rightly issued the N.B.W against the petitioner and others who had not obtained bail and issued summons to those who had obtained bail.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the procedural history and legal provisions regarding the registration of FIRs under section 154 Cr. P.C and the role of section 156(3) Cr. P.C. It noted that the learned Magistrate did not direct the police to register the FIR but sent the application to the Superintendent of Police, who then caused registration of the FIR. The Revisional Court rightly set aside the Magistrate’s order dated 1.9.2003 but directed a fresh order which was held to be unnecessary because the FIR was already registered and charge-sheeted. The Court emphasized that the registration of FIR under section 154 Cr. P.C is mandatory upon receiving information of a cognizable offence, and the order under section 156(3) Cr. P.C is not a prerequisite for FIR registration. Even if an FIR is registered pursuant to a Magistrate’s order under section 156(3) Cr. P.C and that order is later set aside, the FIR and subsequent investigation and charge-sheet remain valid. The Court found that the petitioner’s challenges to the FIR and charge-sheet were dismissed by this Court, and thus the petitioner must face trial. The issuance of N.B.W against the petitioner and others not released on bail was held to be proper and lawful. The impugned order was found to be well-reasoned and did not warrant interference.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

The petition challenging the order dated 28.2.2005, which issued N.B.W against the petitioner and others, is dismissed. The Court held that the FIR, investigation, and charge-sheet remain valid despite the setting aside of the Magistrate’s order under section 156(3) Cr. P.C. The decision affirms the law that FIR registration is mandatory under section 154 Cr. P.C and is not dependent on Magistrate’s directions under section 156(3) Cr. P.C. The direct consequence is that the petitioner and co-accused must face trial as per the impugned order. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing legal principles.

Show all summary ...

Ravindra Singh, J.:— Heard Sri Awdhesh Rai learned Counsel for the petitioner and learned A.G.A

2. This petition has been filed against the order dated 28.2.2005 passed by the learned C.J.M, Mau, whereby the application filed by the respondent No. 4 was allowed and N.B.W was issued against the petitioner.

3. The facts in brief of this writ petition are that an application under section 156(3) Cr. P.C was filed by respondent No. 4 Jai Nath Singh in the Court of learned C.J.M, Mau with a prayer to issue a direction to police station concerned to register the case and investigate the same. On that application, the learned C.J.M, Mau passed order dated 1.9.2003 observing that it is a lability of the police department to register the case. Therefore, the application was sent to the Superintendent of Police, Mau for taking necessary action. Thereafter, the FIR was registered at the police station Sarain Lakhansi in Case Crime No. 519-A of 2003 under sections 147, 148, 149, 307, 323, 336 IPC and section 7 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act. The matter was investigated and the charge-sheet was submitted by the I.O against the petitioner in the Court of the learned C.J.M, Mau on which the cognizance was taken by the learned C.J.M, Mau on 30.7.2004 and the petitioner was summoned to face the trial. The petitioner challenged the order dated 1.9.2003 passed by the learned C.J.M, Mau by way of filling of Criminal Revision No. 1 of 2003. The same was allowed on 10.12.2004 by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 1, Mau and the order dated 1.9.2003 was set aside and the learned C.J.M, Mau was directed to pass a fresh order on the application under section 156(3) Cr. P.C filed by the respondent No. 4, in accordance with the provisions of law.

4. Thereafter, the petitioner challenged the FIR lodged by the respondent No. 4 in Case Crime No. 519-A of 2003 by way of filling Criminal Misc. Writ Petition No. 5357 of 2003 before this Court. The same was finally disposed of by the Division Bench of this Court on 15.9.2003, whereby the prayer to quash the FIR was refused, but the direction was issued to the Courts below that in case the petitioner appears before the Court and applies for bail, the prayer for bail shall be considered expeditiously, if possible on the same day.

5. The FIR was registered against the petitioner was investigated by the I.O who submitted that charge-sheet and on the basis of that charge-sheet the learned C.J.M, Mau took the cognizance and summoned the petitioner on 30.7.2004 Thereafter, the petitioner and other co-accused persons challenged the charge-sheet before this Court by way of filling Criminal Misc. Application No. 8086 of 2004. The same was finally disposed of on 3.8.2004, whereby the prayer to quash the charge-sheet was refused, but again the observation was made by this Court that in case the petitioner appears before the Lower Court and moves bail application the same shall be considered expeditiously, if possible on the same day.

6. The respondent No. 4 Jai Nath Singh moved Criminal Misc. Application No. 1 of 2005 in the Court of learned Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 1, Mau with a prayer to review the order dated 10.12.2004 passed in Criminal Revision No. 1 of 2003. That application was disposed of on 19.2.2005 by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 1, Mau, whereby it was observed that there was no need to review the order dated 10.12.2004 but it was clearly observed that the judgment and the order dated 10.12.2004 will not affect the charge-sheet submitted by the police and the cognizance taken by the learned Magistrate and the order passed by this Court shall have a binding effect on the Lower Court. Thereafter, in pursuance of the order dated 19.2.2005 the respondent No. 4 moved an application in the Court of learned C.J.M, Mau with a prayer that the accused persons, who have not been released on bail, N.B.W may be issued against them and others may be summoned. On that application the objection was filed by the petitioner and accused Ram Badan. After considering the same the learned C.J.M, Mau passed the order dated 28.2.2005 and issued the N.B.W against the accused persons, who have not been released on bail and issued summons against the remaining co-accused persons, who have obtained the bail, for their appearance in the Court.

7. It is contended by the learned Counsel for the petitioner that the order dated 1.9.2003 passed by the learned C.J.M Mau, whereby no direction was issued to the police station concerned to register the case and investigate the same, but the copy of that application was sent to the S.P, Mau for taking necessary action, was set aside by the Revisional Court on 10.12.2004, also the further proceedings, which have been taken place in pursuance of the order dated 1.9.2003, have become null and void. In such circumstances the impugned order dated 28.2.2005 is illegal and is liable to be set aside.

8. It is opposed by the learned A.G.A by submitting that there is no illegality or irregularity in the impugned order dated 28.2.2005 because the Revisional Court itself has cleared the position in its judgment on 19.2.2005 that the order dated 10.12.2004, by which the order dated 1.9.2003 was set aside, will have no effect on the charge-sheet and the cognizance taken by the Magistrate, so the impugned order dated 28.2.2005 is perfect order, which requires no interference and the learned C.J.M, Mau has rightly issued the N.B.W against the petitioner and other co-accused persons, who have not obtained the bail and issued the summons to the remaining accused persons, who have obtained the bail, for their appearance in the Court.

9. From the perusal of the record, it appears that in the present case no direction was given by the learned Magistrate to the police station concerned to register the case and investigate the same vide order dated 1.9.2003 He has sent an application under section 156(3) Cr. P.C to the S.P, Mau for taking necessary action. This order was rightly set aside on 10.12.2004 by the Revisional Court but the direction issued to the C.J.M to pass a fresh order on application under section 156(3) Cr. P.C was illegal because FIR was already registered and the charge-sheet was submitted. The FIR was registered at the police station concerned on the direction of the S.P, Mau, and after its investigation the charge-sheet was submitted in the Court. Thereafter, the order dated 1.9.2003 passed by learned C.J.M was set aside on 10.2.2004, it will not affect the FIR its investigation and charge-sheet etc. In the present case the FIR was not registered in pursuance of any order under section 156(3) Cr. P.C In case any FIR is registered by the order of the learned Magistrate under section 156(3) Cr. P.C and subsequently, that order is set aside by the higher Court, it will not affect the FIR its investigation and charge-sheet, because under section 154 Cr. P.C an Officer Incharge of a police station concerned is under obligation to register the case on every information either oral or in writing, relating to the commission of the cognizable offence. The provisions of section 156(3) Cr. P.C are embodied in the Code for the purpose of checking the arbitrariness of the Officer In-charge of the Police Station concerned. For registering the FIR the order under section 156(3) Cr. P.C is not a necessary requirement. If the FIR is registered at the police station concerned on the basis of the order passed under section 156(3) Cr. P.C the purpose of the legislation to check the arbitrariness of Officer-in-charge of a police station concerned is fulfilled. The order directing the Officer-in-charge to register the case and investigate the same is not a necessary requirement for the FIR in cognizable offence, if any FIR is registered in pursuance of such order and if that order is set aside by any higher Court it will not affect the FIR and its investigation because without such order also the officer-in-charge was under obligation to register the FIR in cognizable offence.

10. In the present case also the petitioner challenged the FIR with a prayer to quash the same. Subsequently, the charge-sheet was challenged with a prayer to quash the same after considering all the facts and circumstances of the case and legality and illegality if any, this Court has refused to quash the FIR and charge-sheet submitted by the I.O against the petitioner had other co-accused persons. In such circumstances the petitioner and other co-accused persons have no option but to face the trial so the impugned order dated 28.2.2005 passed by the C.J.M, Mau is a perfect order by which N.B.W has been issued against the accused persons, who have not obtained their bail and the summon were issued against the remaining accused persons, who have obtained their bail, for their appearance in the Court. The impugned order is well-reasoned order. It requires no interference, therefore, it is affirmed.

11. In view of the facts and circumstances of the case and the submissions made by the learned Counsel for the petitioner and learned A.G.A and the reasons given above the prayer for quashing the above mentioned impugned order dated 28.2.2005 passed by the learned C.J.M, Mau in Criminal Misc. Case No. 2650 of 2004 is refused.

12. Accordingly the petition is dismissed.

Petition Dismissed.