- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Smt. Krishna Kumari Talwar v. Debt Recovery Tribunal .
Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
Respondents (Punjab and Sindh Bank, GT Road, Ghaziabad) granted a cash credit (hypothecation) facility initially of Rs. 15 lakhs to respondents Nos. 3, 4 and 5. The petitioner, Smt. Krishna Kumari Talwar, stood as a guarantor and executed an equitable mortgage of the property in question in favour of the Bank. The credit limit was later enhanced to Rs. 20 lakhs and other properties were hypothecated to the Bank pursuant to the enhancement. When the borrowers failed to repay, the Bank sent a demand notice for Rs. 41,23,793.33. A civil suit was filed and subsequently transferred to the Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT), Lucknow (respondent No. 1).
By an order dated 12-01-2004 (reproduced as annexure No.1 to the writ petition), the DRT issued a recovery certificate against the defendants jointly and severally for Rs. 41,23,793.33 together with pendentelite and future interest at 23.25% per annum with quarterly rest, until realisation, together with costs. The DRT ordered that all hypothecated and mortgaged properties remain attached and restrained the defendants from selling, transferring or alienating those properties. The DRT directed that the amount be recovered from sale of hypothecated/mortgaged property and the balance, if any, from the defendants by other means available under law.
The petitioner filed the present writ petition challenging the DRT order. She asserted she is a 75-year-old woman who was cheated by respondents Nos. 2–5 in connivance with bank officers, that she never intended to mortgage or had mortgaged her house (No. 57 Arya Nagar, Ghaziabad), that she never signed any document as guarantor, and that the DRT did not hear her on the merits nor hear her recall application.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the writ petition under Article 226 is maintainable when an alternative statutory remedy (appeal) is available under Section 17(2) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act/Ordinance (the Act).
- Whether Article 226 should be invoked where disputed questions of fact exist that an appellate forum is competent to decide (i.e., whether extraordinary writ jurisdiction should be used when facts are disputed).
- Procedural issue arising under Section 17(2) of the Act concerning deposit requirements for entertaining an appeal (i.e., the requirement to deposit 75% of the amount claimed and the DRT's power to waive or reduce that deposit).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner contended she was aged 75 and had been cheated by respondents Nos. 2–5 in collusion with bank officers.
- She asserted she never intended to mortgage, never mortgaged her house No. 57 Arya Nagar, Ghaziabad, and never signed any document as a guarantor.
- She alleged the DRT (respondent No. 1) did not hear her on the merits and did not hear a recall application.
- Counsel for the petitioner urged that the High Court could exercise extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 despite the availability of a statutory remedy under Section 18/other provisions of the Act.
Respondent's Arguments (Bank / Respondent No. 6)
- Learned counsel for the respondents-bank submitted that an alternative statutory appellate remedy is available to the petitioner under Section 17(2) of the Act (deposit of 75% of the claimed amount to entertain an appeal, subject to the DRT's power to waive or reduce the deposit for reasons to be recorded in writing).
- The Bank argued that the appellate forum is fully empowered to decide factual disputes and alleged illegality; therefore, the writ petition is not maintainable and the statutory route must be exhausted.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Dwarka Prasad Agarwal v. Ramesh Chander Agarwal, (2003) 6 SCC 220 (AIR 2003 SC 2696) | Where disputes are civil in nature, the Civil Court (or statutory forum) should adjudicate such disputes rather than the High Court exercising extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226. | The Court relied on this authority to emphasize that civil/contractual disputes should be decided by the competent forum and not normally via writ jurisdiction; supports dismissal of writ when statutory remedy exists. |
| Sahebgouda v. Ogeppa (referenced) | Burden is on the party asserting ouster of Civil Court jurisdiction; bar of jurisdiction requires strict interpretation. | Cited within discussion of Dwarka Prasad to underline principles about retention of civil jurisdiction and strict interpretation of statutory bars. |
| Dipak Chandra Ruhidas v. Chandan Kumar Sarkar, (2003) 7 SCC 66 (AIR 2003 SC 3701) | An appellate authority's power is wider than that of the High Court or Supreme Court in certain respects; scope of appeal is wider than judicial review. | Applied to show that the appellate forum under the Act has ample power to examine both factual and legal issues, supporting the view that the petitioner should pursue statutory appeal. |
| Bimal N. Desai v. State of Karnataka, (2003) 5 SCC 395 (AIR 2003 SC 2246) | The existence of an alternative statutory remedy (including conditions like limitation, court-fee, deposit) ordinarily cannot be bypassed by seeking relief under Article 226; exhaustion of statutory remedies is the norm except in exceptional circumstances. | Relied upon to reinforce that statutory appeal must be resorted to before seeking relief under Article 226, absent exceptional circumstances such as lack of jurisdiction or violation of fundamental rights. |
| National Highway Authority of India v. Ganga Enterprises, (2003) 7 SCC 410 (AIR 2003 SC 3823) | Disputes relating to contracts should not be agitated under Article 226; contractual disputes are not the proper subject of writ relief. | Used to support the proposition that the petitioner's liability arising from mortgage/guarantee (contractual) is not properly the subject of writ proceedings and should be pursued via statutory/appellate remedies. |
| Kerala SEB v. Kurien E. Kalathil, (2000) 6 SCC 293 (AIR 2000 SC 2573) | Contracts and contractual disputes are generally not to be entertained under Article 226. | Cited (within National Highway discussion) to support the general principle restricting Article 226 in contractual disputes. |
| State of U.P. v. Bridge and Roof Co. (India) Ltd., (1996) 6 SCC 22 (AIR 1996 SC 3515) | Similar principle that contractual disputes are not to be agitated under Article 226. | Referred to underpin the view that contractual matters should normally be resolved by competent civil/statutory fora. |
| Bareilly Development Authority v. Ajai Pal Singh, (1989) 2 SCC 116 (AIR 1989 SC 1076) | Another authority reinforcing limitations on writ jurisdiction for contractual disputes. | Cited in the same thematic context to bolster the rule against using Article 226 for purely contractual issues. |
| Secretary, Minor Irrigation Rural Engineering Services v. Sahngoo Ram Arya, (2002) 5 SCC 521 (AIR 2002 SC 2225) | The existence of an alternative tribunal remedy must be availed of even if the tribunal lacks power to grant interim relief; inability to grant interim orders is not a ground to bypass the tribunal initially. | Applied to reject the petitioner's submission that the forum should bypass the statutory appellate route on the ground that the appellate/tribunal lacks interim powers. |
| Union of India v. Ingersoll Rand (India) Ltd., (2001) 10 SCC 617 | High Court cannot disregard statutory procedures and grant relief (e.g., refund) without requiring pursuit of the remedies provided in the relevant statute; statutory remedies should not be bypassed. | Relied upon to underline that statutory remedies must ordinarily be exhausted before invoking writ jurisdiction; supports dismissal of the writ petition. |
| Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, (1997) 5 SCC 536 (referenced) | High Court should not exercise Article 226 to give directions in disregard of statutory provisions governing a remedy. | Referred within the Ingersoll Rand discussion to demonstrate settled precedent requiring exhaustion of statutory remedies. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeded along these principal lines:
- Statutory Remedy Exists: The Court noted the availability of a statutory appellate remedy under Section 17(2) of the Act (which requires deposit of 75% of the amount claimed in the notice, subject to a discretionary waiver or reduction by the DRT for reasons recorded in writing). Because this statutory appeal route exists, the writ petition is prima facie barred as an alternative remedy must be exhausted.
- Disputed Questions of Fact: The Court observed that the petitioner's allegations (for example, she did not sign as guarantor or did not intend to mortgage) raise disputed questions of fact. The Court found that such factual disputes are appropriately resolved by the appellate authority after scrutiny of the original record/paper book, rather than by exercise of extraordinary writ jurisdiction.
- Precedential Support: The Court relied on multiple Supreme Court authorities to support the general legal principles that (a) civil/contractual disputes are ordinarily to be decided by the competent forum rather than by writ jurisdiction (Dwarka Prasad; National Highway; others); (b) appellate forums often possess broader powers to reassess facts and law (Dipak Chandra Ruhidas); and (c) statutory remedies should not be bypassed except in exceptional circumstances such as lack of jurisdiction, violation of fundamental rights, or actions ultra vires (Bimal N. Desai; Bimal Desai principles reproduced).
- Procedural Conduct in the Original Proceedings: The Court recorded that the proceedings in the original suit were interrupted and prolonged at times because of non-cooperation by the petitioner and respondents Nos. 2–5, which bears on the propriety of invoking extraordinary writ relief in the face of an available statutory appeal.
- Application of Authorities on Interim Relief and Tribunal Powers: The Court invoked Sahngoo Ram Arya to indicate that the mere absence of an interim power in the tribunal/appeal forum is not a sufficient reason to bypass the statutory route; an aggrieved party may pursue interim relief later if and when appropriate.
- Conclusion from Reasoning: Synthesising the statutory position and precedents, the Court concluded that the writ petition was not maintainable and should be dismissed because the petitioner has an efficacious alternative remedy of appeal under the Act which can address both factual and legal issues.
- Protective and Procedural Directions: Although dismissing the writ, the Court granted procedural latitude to the petitioner: if she files an appeal within one month, the appellate authority shall not reject it on the ground of limitation and must decide the appeal on merits; the petitioner may apply for interim relief before the appellate authority which should be considered expeditiously (preferably within one month); until the interim relief application is decided, the recovery proceedings may continue but the petitioner's house shall not be put to auction/sale unless other mortgaged properties fail to satisfy bank dues; and the appellate authority is directed to decide the appeal preferably within four months of filing.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The writ petition is DISMISSED on the ground that an alternative statutory remedy (appeal) is available to the petitioner under the Act.
Direct Implications and Orders
- The petitioner is permitted to prefer an appeal within one month from the date of the Court's order; if she does so within that period, the appellate authority shall not reject the appeal on the ground of limitation and shall decide it on merits in accordance with law after considering the petitioner's contentions.
- The petitioner may move the appellate authority for interim relief; that application should be considered expeditiously, preferably within one month from filing.
- Pending consideration of any interim relief application by the appellate authority, the recovery proceedings may continue, but the petitioner's house shall not be auctioned or sold unless the other mortgaged properties fail to satisfy the bank dues.
- The appellate authority is directed to decide the appeal expeditiously, preferably within four months from the date of filing.
Broader Legal Consequences
The Court applied established precedent emphasising exhaustion of statutory remedies and the limits of writ jurisdiction in contractual/civil disputes. The order enforces the principle that where a statutory appeal exists and is capable of addressing factual and legal grievances, a writ under Article 226 should not ordinarily be entertained. The opinion does not announce any new legal doctrine; it applies existing Supreme Court authorities to the facts at hand and provides procedural directions to protect the petitioner's opportunity to be heard on appeal.
1. Heard Shri Ashit Kumar Chaturvedi on behalf of petitioner and Shri V.L Verma on behalf of respondent No. 6.
2. Brief facts of the case is that, respondents Punjab and Sindh Bank Branch Officer at GT Road, District Ghaziabad, U.P had offered to grant of cash credit (hypothecation) limit of Rs. 15 lakhs to respondents Nos. 3, 4 and 5. The petitioner Smt. Krishna Kumari Talwar stood as guarantor along with others. The petitioner had also executed an equitable mortgaged of the property in question in favour of respondents bank. The credit limit was enhanced up to Rs. 20 lakhs, at later stage. Several other properties were also hypothecated to the bank in pursuance of enhanced cash credit limit. Since the defendant failed to make the repayment of loan, the respondents bank had sent the demand notice for payment of Rs. 41,23,793.33 paise. In the event of default of payment the civil suit was filed, which was later on transferred to Debt Recovery Tribunal, Lucknow (respondent No. 1). After hearing the parties, the respondent No. 1 by the impugned judgment and order dated 12-1-2004, a copy of which has been filed as annexure No. 1 to the writ petition, has issued recovery certificate against the defendants of the suit, jointly and severally for the recovery of the sum of Rs. 41,23,793.33 together with pendentelite and future interest @ 23.25 per cent per annum with quarterly rest, till realisation together with costs. It has been also provided by the respondent No. 1 that all property hypothecated and mortgaged will remain attached under the jurisdiction of Tribunal and defendant of the suits were restrained not to sale, transfer or alienate any of the mortgaged/hypothecated properties. Respondent No. 1 further directed that the said amount shall be recovered from the sale of hypothecated/mortgaged property and the balance of amount shall be recovered from the defendant otherwise as per law. Feeling aggrieved with the impugned order, the present writ petition has been filed by the petitioner that she is an old lady of 75 years and she has been cheated by respondents Nos. 2 to 5 in connivance with the officers of the Punjab and Sindh Bank. It has been submitted by the petitioner that she had never intended to mortgage nor she had mortgaged her house No. 57 Arya Nagar District Ghaziabad. According to learned counsel for the petitioner, the petitioner had never signed any paper as guarantor and the respondent No. 1 had not heard the petitioner on merit, nor the recall application was heard.
3. On the other hand, the evidence discussed by the Tribunal shows that on one of other pretext the proceeding of the suit was interrupted from time to time and prolonged on account of non-co-operation on part of the petitioner as well as respondents Nos. 2 to 5 of the present writ petition. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents bank submits that the alternative appellate remedy is available to the petitioner under Section 17(2) of the Securitisation and reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Ordinance, 2002 (in short here in after referred as Act). For convenience sub-section (2) of Section 17 is reproduced as under:
“……17(2). Where an appeal is preferred by a borrower, such appeal shall not be entertained by the Debts Recovery Tribunal unless the borrower has deposited with the Debts Recovery Tribunal seventy-five per cent of the amount claimed in the notice referred to in sub-section (2) of Section 13:
Provides that the Debt Recovery Tribunal may, for reasons to be recorded in writing, waive or reduce the amount to be deposited under this section.”
4. Since statutory remedy is available to the petitioner and the appellate Court is fully empowered to decide the factual dispute as well as illegality alleged to be committed by the opposite party No. 1, the present writ petition is not maintainable.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that under Section 18 of the Act there is no absolute bar and this Court may entertain the writ petition against the impugned order under the extraordinary power conferred by Article 226 of Constitution of India. No doubt this Court may exercise extraordinary power under Article 226 of Constitution of India but that power should be used sparingly and normally in those cases where there is no disputed question of fact existing for adjudication. In the present case the submission of the petitioner requires to decide the disputed question of fact which can be well appreciated by the appellate Court after summoning the paper book of the original case from respondent No. 1.
6. In a case reported in (2003) 6 SCC 220 : (AIR 2003 SC 2696), Dwarka Prasad Agarwal v. Ramesh Chander Agarwal. Supreme Court held that in a case where the disputes between the parties were eminently of civil nature Apex Court ruled that where the Code of Civil Procedure confers jurisdiction on the Civil Court to determine a dispute of Civil nature, unless the same is barred under a statute either expressly or by necessary implication, the controversy should be adjudicated upon by the Civil Court itself not by exercising the extraordinary power by the High Court.
7. For convenience relevant portion from para 22 of the said judgment reproduced as under:—
“….The dispute between the parties was eminently a civil dispute and not a dispute under the provisions of the Companies Act. Section 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure confers jurisdiction upon the Civil Courts to determine all disputes of civil nature unless the same is barred under a statute either expressly or by necessary implication. Bar of jurisdiction of a Civil Court requires strict interpretation. The Court, it is well settled, would normally lean in favour of construction, which would uphold retention of jurisdiction of the Civil Court. The burden of proof in this behalf shall be on the party who asserts that the Civil Court's jurisdiction is ousted. (See Sahebgouda v. Ogeppa). Even otherwise, the Civil Court's jurisdiction is not completely ousted under the Companies Act, 1956.”
8. In the present case there is statutory right of appeal and the appellate Court has got ample power to decide the present dispute.
9. In another case, reported in (2003) 7 SCC 66 : (AIR 2003 SC 3701), Dipak Chandra Ruhidas v. Chandan Kumar Sarkar, Supreme Court held that the power of appellate Court is much wider than power conferred to High Court or Supreme Court and the appellate authority has got wide power to go into, interfere and discuss to decide the controversy in question.
10. For convenience para 15 of the said judgment is reproduced as under:—
“Section 116-A provides for ah appeal. The said provision must be given a liberal and purposive construction. The scope of an appeal should be held to be wider than an application for judicial review or a petition under Article 136 of the Constitution of India.”
11. The Apex Court in a case, reported in (2003) 5 SSC 395 : ((2003) 5 SCC 395 : AIR 2003 SC 2246), Bimal N. Desai v. State of Karnataka, ruled that the alternative remedy of statutory appeal cannot be bypassed for conditions like limitation, payment of Court-fee or deposit of some amount or fulfilment of some other conditions for entertaining the appeal.
12. For convenience para 13 of the said judgment is reproduced as under:—
“It has been settled by a long catena of decisions that when a right or liability is created by a statute, which itself prescribes the remedy or procedure for enforcing the right or liability, resort must be had to that particular statutory remedy before seeking the discretionary remedy under Article 226 of Constitution. This rule of exhaustion of statutory remedies is no doubt a rule of policy, convenience and discretion and the Court may in exceptional cases issue a discretionary writ of certiorari. Where there is complete lack of jurisdiction for the officer or authority or tribunal to take action or there has been a contravention of fundamental rights or there has been a violation of rules of natural justice or where the Tribunal acted under a provision of law, which is ultra vires, then notwithstanding the existence of an alternative remedy, the High Court can exercise its jurisdiction to grant relief. In the present case, the alternative remedy of challenging the judgment of the Court was not before some other forum or tribunal. On the contrary, by virtue of sub-section (3) of Section 27 of the Act, the order passed by the Court amounted to a decree against which an appeal lay to the High Court. When the party had statutory remedy of assailing the order passed by the Court, District Court by filing an appeal to the High Court itself, he could not by pass the said remedy and take recourse to proceedings under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution. Such a course of action may enable a litigant to defeat the provisions of the statute which may provide for certain conditions for filing the appeal, like limitation, payment of Court-fee or deposit of some amount or fulfilment of some other conditions for entertaining the appeal.”
13. In the present case the petitioner's liability to repay the amount in question is on account of mortgage of the property as she stood as a guarantor. The liability of the petitioner emerges virtually on account of an agreement or contract entered into between the parties by way of mortgage deed.
14. Against the Apex Court in a case, reported in (2003) 7 SCC 410 : (AIR 2003 SC 3823), National Highway Authority of India v. Ganga Enterprises held that the contractual matters should not be agitated in a proceedings under Article 226 of Constitution of India. The relevant portion of the said judgment is reproduced as under:—
“…….It is settled law that disputes relating to contracts cannot be agitated under Article 226 of Constitution of India. It has been so held in the cases of Kerala SEB v. Kurien E. Kalathil ((2000) 6 SCC 293 : AIR 2000 SC 2573); State of U.P v. Bridge and Roof Co. (India) Ltd. ((1996) 6 SCC 22 : AIR 1996 SC 3515) and Bareilly Development Authority v. Ajai Pal Singh ((1989) 2 SCC 116 : AIR 1989 SC 1076). This is settled law. The dispute in this case was regarding the terms of offer. They were thus contractual disputes in respect of which a writ Court was not the proper forum.”
15. In the case of Secretary, Minor Irrigation Rural Engineering Services v. Sahngoo Ram Arya, reported in (2002) 5 SCC 521 : (AIR 2002 SC 2225) Apex Court of the country held that the alternative remedy of Tribunal cannot be bypassed on the ground that Tribunal lacks power to pass interim order. Relevant portion of the case of Sahngoo Ram (Supra) is reproduced as under:—
“Mr. Sunil Gupta, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner contended that the remedy before the Tribunal under the U.P Public Services (Tribunal) Act is wholly illusory inasmuch as the Tribunal has no power to grant an interim order. Therefore, he contends that the High Court ought not to have relegated the petitioner to a fresh proceeding before the said Tribunal. We do not agree with these arguments of the learned counsel. When the statute has provided for the constitution of a Tribunal for adjudicating the disputes of a Government servant, the fact that the Tribunal has no authority to grant an interim order is no ground to bypass the said Tribunal. In an appropriate case after entertaining the petitions by an aggrieved party if the Tribunal declines an interim order on the ground that it has no such power then it is possible that such aggrieved party can seek remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution but that is no ground to bypass the said Tribunal in the first instance itself.”
16. While giving emphasis to avail the statutory remedy before filing a writ petition, Supreme Court in a case reported in (2001) 10 SCC 617, Union of India v. Ingersoll Rand (India) Ltd., held that the alternative statutory remedy should not be bypassed while a writ petition for the redressal of grievances. The relevant portion of the said judgment is reproduced as under:—
“By the impugned Judgments the Karnataka High Court has allowed the writ petitions filed by the respondents and has directed the appellants to refund the amount of excise duty paid by the respondents without requiring the respondents to pursue the remedy available under the statutory provisions governing the refund of the duty paid. The matter is covered by the decision of the larger Bench of this Court in Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India (1997 (5) SCC 536) wherein this Court has laid down that the High Court in exercise of its power under Article 226 of Constitution cannot give direction for refund in disregard of the provisions contained in the Central Excises and Salt Act.”
17. In view of above, the present writ petition is devoid of merit on account of availability of alternative remedy of statutory appeal.
18. Accordingly, writ petition is dismissed on account of availability of appellate remedy. In case petitioner prefers an appeal within a period of one month from today, the appeal shall not be rejected by the appellate authority on the ground of limitation and shall be decide on merit in accordance with law after considering the entire facts and circumstances raised by the petitioner.
19. It shall be open for the petitioner to move an application for interim relief before the appellate authority, which shall be considered by the authority expeditiously preferably within a period of one month from the date of filing of application.
20. Till the application of interim relief is considered and decided by the appellate authority it is provided that in pursuance to impugned order dated 12-1-2004 though the recovery proceedings may go on but petitioner's house in question may not be put to auction and sale unless the other mortgaged properties failed to satisfy the bank dues.
21. The appellate authority is further directed to decide the appeal expeditiously, preferably within a period of four months from the date of filing of appeal in accordance to law.
22. Petition dismissed.
Alert