Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dharam Pal v. Second Addl. District Judge

Allahabad High Court
Sep 23, 2004
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner has filed a writ petition under Article 226 challenging an order of the revisional court which allowed a revision and set aside a trial court order on the question of jurisdiction — specifically whether the suit is triable by a civil court or by a revenue court.

The underlying suit arose from allegations that Khedoo was a co-bhumidhar of the land in dispute. After Khedoo's death, his widow, Smt. Sohbatta (respondent No. 3), remarried and, according to the plaintiffs, thereby ceased to have bhumidhari rights. Smt. Sohbatta executed three sale deeds (dated 7.12.1965, 7.12.1965 and 15.2.1975) transferring her co-bhumidhari rights first to respondent No. 2, who later sold the land to respondent No. 4. The plaintiffs contended the sale deeds were void because an executant who had remarried had no subsisting right to execute them, and sought cancellation of the sale deeds and, alternatively, ejectment of transferees in possession.

Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 (respondents in the writ) contested the suit. They pleaded, among other defences, protection under Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act and that the suit was barred by Section 5 of the Consolidation of Holdings Act. The trial court framed eight issues and decided jurisdiction as a preliminary issue. The trial court (by order dated 4.9.1981) held that because the sale deed was alleged to be void ab initio, the suit would lie in civil court; the trial court ultimately decreed the suit on the ground that Smt. Sohbatta had no right to execute the sale deeds and that she was a recorded tenure holder, rendering the sale deeds void. The defendants preferred a revision; the revisional court allowed the revision and set aside the trial court's order. This writ petition challenges the revisional court's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit in question is triable by the civil courts or by the revenue (consolidation) authorities/courts (i.e., the jurisdictional question of civil court vs. revenue court for a suit seeking cancellation of sale deeds alleged to be void).
  2. Whether a recorded tenure holder (or an executant or his successor) can institute a suit for cancellation of an allegedly void sale deed in a civil court, or whether such a remedy must be pursued in the revenue courts.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners / Plaintiffs

  • The plaintiffs alleged that the sale deeds were void ab initio because Smt. Sohbatta, who had remarried, had no subsisting bhumidhari rights and therefore had no right to execute the sale deeds.
  • They sought cancellation of the sale deeds and, in the alternative, ejectment of any transferees in possession.
  • Before the High Court, the petitioner relied upon recent authoritative decisions (including the Supreme Court decision in Shri Ram and Anr. v. First Additional District Judge and Ors.) and Allahabad High Court Full Bench decisions to support the proposition that suits for cancellation of void documents can properly be brought in civil courts by recorded tenure holders.

Defendants / Respondents

  • Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 pleaded protection under Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act (i.e., equitable protection for certain transferees in possession).
  • They also contended that the suit is barred by Section 5 of the Consolidation of Holdings Act, implying that the matter falls within the jurisdiction or exclusive competence of consolidation/revenue authorities.
  • On revision, the revisional court allowed revision against the trial court's order on jurisdiction, indicating it accepted the position that the matter should be addressed in revision/revenue proceedings (the precise reasoning of the revisional court is not set out in this opinion excerpt).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court in this Opinion
Shri Ram and Anr. v. First Additional District Judge and Ors., 2001 (1) AWC 862 (SC) : 2001 ACJ 497 Cited by the petitioner as a recent Supreme Court decision relevant to jurisdictional questions concerning cancellation of documents and the proper forum. The petitioner relied on this Supreme Court decision in support of the proposition that suits to cancel void documents can lie in civil courts; the Court considered this reliance in reaching its conclusion to set aside the revisional court's order.
Ram Padarath v. Second Additional District Judge, Suttanpur, 1989 (1) AWC 290 (LB) : 1989 ACJ 1 (Full Bench, Allahabad High Court) The Full Bench examined jurisdictional aspects and held that Indra Dev v. Smt. Ram Pyari was correctly decided; it indicated that suits for cancellation of void documents will generally lie in the civil court and criticized the proposition that such suits must lie in revenue courts. The opinion treats the Full Bench decision as authoritative and notes that its correctness has not been challenged; the Court relied on the Full Bench view in determining that the revisional court's order should be set aside.
Indra Dev v. Smt. Ram Pyari Referenced by the Full Bench as a correctly decided authority supporting the proposition that cancellation of void documents is for civil courts. The opinion records that the Full Bench regarded Indra Dev as correctly decided and did not require reconsideration; this supports the Court's conclusion about proper forum.
Dr. Ayodhya Prasad v. Gangotri Prasad (Division Bench) Concerned with jurisdiction of consolidation authorities; the Full Bench opinion considered that, insofar as it held that suits in respect of void documents lie in revenue court, that is not sound law. The opinion cites the Full Bench's criticism of this decision to support the proposition that suits for cancellation of void documents generally lie in civil courts rather than revenue courts.
Gorakh Nath Dube v. Hari Narain Singh and Ors., 1990 All CJ 179 (Apex Court) The Apex Court observed that where a document's legal effect can be removed only by setting it aside or cancellation, consolidation authorities may have no power to cancel it and therefore such document remains binding until cancelled by a court competent to cancel. The High Court relied on the quoted observation from the Apex Court (para 7) to support the view that cancellation of deeds is within the competence of courts and that recorded tenure holders with prima facie title need not be directed to revenue courts to seek cancellation.
Kishori Prasad v. IIIrd Addl. District Judge, Varanasi and Ors., 2002 (5) AWC 4269 : 2003 (94) RD 36 Held that a recorded tenure holder can institute a suit for cancellation of a deed in civil court; an executant or successor can also sue in civil court; a third person who is not a recorded tenure holder or executant/predecessor/successor cannot sue in civil court and must resort to revenue courts. The Court relied on the holding in Kishori Prasad (para 12) to reinforce that a recorded tenure holder may pursue cancellation in civil court and used this to justify setting aside the revisional court's order and remanding for reconsideration in accordance with these principles.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded by reference to binding and persuasive authorities addressing (a) the jurisdictional boundary between civil courts and revenue/consolidation authorities and (b) whether persons with recorded tenure or executants/successors may seek cancellation of alleged void sale deeds in civil courts.

Key elements of the Court's reasoning (as set out in the opinion) are:

  1. The central procedural question was jurisdiction: whether a suit alleging a sale deed is void ab initio (because the executant had remarried and thereby lost bhumidhari rights) must be tried in civil courts or in revenue/consolidation fora.
  2. The Court observed that a Full Bench of the Allahabad High Court in Ram Padarath (citing Indra Dev) held that suits for cancellation of void documents generally lie in civil courts and that the Division Bench decision in Dr. Ayodhya Prasad (to the extent it held such suits belong in revenue court) did not lay down correct law.
  3. The Court relied on the Apex Court's observation in Gorakh Nath Dube that where the legal effect of a document can be taken away only by cancellation by a competent court, consolidation authorities lack power to cancel the deed and therefore such a deed remains binding unless cancelled by a court competent to do so.
  4. The Court also relied on the subsequent decision in Kishori Prasad, where it was held that a recorded tenure holder can institute a suit for cancellation of a deed in civil courts, and that an executant or successor can similarly sue; but a third person who is not a recorded tenure holder or executant/successor is not competent to sue in civil court and should resort to revenue courts.
  5. Applying these authorities to the facts before it — where the trial court had found Smt. Sohbatta to be a recorded tenure holder and had decreed cancellation on the basis that she had no right to execute the sale deeds — the High Court concluded that the revisional court's order taking the opposite view on jurisdiction was not sustainable in law.
  6. Accordingly, the Court set aside the revisional court's order, allowed the writ petition, and remanded the matter to the revisional court to be decided in accordance with law and in the light of the observations made in this judgment, directing expedition because of the age of the matter.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Court held that the revisional court's order is to be set aside and the writ petition is allowed. In the words of the opinion, the view taken by the revisional court "deserves to be set aside and is hereby set aside."

Immediate Effect on the Parties: The order of the revisional court is set aside; the matter is remanded to the revisional court for fresh decision in accordance with law and in light of the authorities and observations discussed in this opinion. The revisional court was directed to decide the matter within three months from the date of presentation of a certified copy of this order.

Wider Implications: The opinion applies and follows existing High Court Full Bench and Supreme Court authority regarding the proper forum for cancellation of documents alleged to be void and the right of recorded tenure holders (and executants/successors) to seek cancellation in civil courts. The judgment does not state that it is laying down a new precedent; rather, it relies on and applies existing decisions (Ram Padarath, Gorakh Nath Dube, Kishori Prasad and the cited Supreme Court authority) to resolve the jurisdictional question in this case.

Note: This summary is prepared strictly from the content contained in the provided opinion. No information not present in the opinion has been added.

Show all summary ...

1. This writ petition is filed by the petitioner under Article 226 of the Constitution of India being aggrieved by the order passed by the revisional court whereby the revisional court allowed the revision and set aside the order passed by the trial court on the issue of jurisdiction as to whether the suit in question is triable by civil court or by revenue court,

2. The facts in brief are that the petitioner filed a suit on the allegation that Khedoo was co-bhumidhar of the land to dispute which is mentioned at the foot of the plaint, a copy whereof is annexed as Annexure-1 to the writ petition. Khedoo died and his interest was inherited by his widow Sohbatta, respondent No. 3 in the writ petition, Respondent No. 3, Sohbatta, remarried with Rajbali, resident of Devapar. Consequently her bhumidhari rights came to an end from the date of her remarriage. Smt. Sohbatta by three sale deeds dated 7.12.1965, 7.12.1965 and 15.2.1975 transferred her co-bhumidhari rights to respondent No. 2 and respondent No. 2 sold the same land to respondent No. 4, Bhadesar. The plaintiffs case was that all the sale deeds were void and the defendant who had already remarried had no right to execute the said sale deeds. Secondly, decree for cancellation of the said sale deeds was prayed for in the plaint. Another prayer in the alternative was that if the transferees have come into possession of the land purchased by him they may be ejected from the land in dispute.

3. The suit was contested by defendant Nos. 1 and 2, i.e., respondent Nos. 2 and 4 in the present writ petition. Subsequent purchasers of the land defendant Nos. 1 and 2, have pleaded by filing written statement that protection of section 53a of the transfer of properties act is available to them. Another defence was taken that the suit is barred by Section 5 of Consolidation of Holdings Act. The trial court, on the basis of pleadings of the parties, framed as many as eight issues and decided issue of jurisdiction as a preliminary issue. The trial court by its order dated 4.9.1981, found that since the pleading is that sale deed is ab initio void inasmuch as Smt. Sohbatta who had admittedly remarried has no right subsisting in the land, therefore, the sale deed is void and if the sale is void the suit will lie in the civil court. The defendants contested this claim. The trial court, however, decreed the suit on the ground that Smt. Sohbatta has no right to execute the sale deed and further that Smt. Sohbatta was recorded tenure holder. Therefore sale deeds are void. Aggrieved thereby the defendants preferred revision. The revision was allowed by the revenue court.

4. Before me relying upon recent Supreme Court decision in Shri Ram and Anr. v. First Additional District Judge and Ors., 2001 (1) AWC 862 (SC) : 2001 ACJ 497, it is argued that the view expressed by Full Bench in Ram Padarath v. Second Additional District Judge, Suttanpur, 1989 (1) AWC 290 (LB) : 1989 ACJ 1, a Full Bench of Allahabad High Court considered this aspect of the matter and held thus :

"We are of the view that the case of Indra Dev v. Smt. Ram Pyari has been correctly decided and the said decision requires no consideration, while the Division Bench case, Dr. Ayodhya Prasad v. Gangotri Prasad is regarding the jurisdiction of consolidation authorities, but so far as it holds that suit in respect of void document will lie in the revenue court it does not lay down a good law. Suit or action for cancellation of void document will generally lie in the civil court and a party cannot be deprived of his right getting this relief permissible under law except when a declaration of right or status and a tenure holder is necessarily needed in which event relief for cancellation will be surpluses and redundant. A recorded tenure holder having prima facie title in his favour can hardly be directed to approach the revenue court in respect of seeking relief for cancellation of a void document which made him to approach the court of law and in such case he can also claim ancillary relief even though the same can be granted by the revenue court."

5. Thus, since the correctness of the Full Bench has not been challenged, in the subsequent case in Gorakh Nath Dube v. Hari Narain Singh and Ors., 1990 All CJ 179, it has been held by the Apex Court as under :

"............but, where there is a document the legal effect of which can only be taken away by setting it aside or its 'cancellation", it could be urged that the consolidation authorities have no power to cancel the deed, and, therefore, it must be held to be binding on them so long as it is not cancelled by a Court having the power to cancel it......"

6. Learned counsel for the party relied upon the observation of the Apex Court in para 7 which is reproduced below :

"On analysis of the decisions cited above, we are of the opinion that where a recorded tenure holder, having a prima facie title and in possession files suit in the civil court for cancellation of sale deed having obtained on the ground of fraud or impersonation cannot be directed to file a suit for declaration in the revenue court -reason being that in such a case, prima facie, the title of the recorded tenure holder is not under cloud. He does not require declaration of his title to the land. The position would be different where a person not being a recorded tenure holder seeks cancellation of sale deed by filing a suit in the civil court on the ground of fraud or impersonation. There necessarily the plaintiff is required to seek a declaration of his title and therefore, he may be directed' to approach the revenue court, as the sale deed being void has to be ignored for giving him relief for declaration and possession."

7. Learned counsel for the petitioner further relied upon a decision of this Court In Kishori Prasad v. IIIrd Addl. District Judge, Varanasi and Ors., 2002 (5) AWC 4269 : 2003 (94) RD 36, wherein learned single Judge of this Court in para 12 has held as under :

"12. Question 1 (a) is decided in affirmative and it is held that recorded tenure holder can institute suit for cancellation, if considered to be void in view of plaint allegations, in a civil court. Question No. 1 (b) is also decided in affirmative and it is held that an executant or his successor could file suit in civil court for cancellation of void document/ instrument. So far as question No. 1 (c) is concerned it is decided in negative and it is held that a third person, if he is not recorded tenure holder or executant of the sale deed or his predecessor/successor is not competent to institute suit in civil court in view of the fact that his claim necessarily involves declaration of his right, and the remedy lies in revenue courts only."

8. In this view of the matter the view taken by the revisional court deserves to be set aside and is hereby set aside. The writ petition succeeds and is allowed. The order passed by the revisional court is set aside. The matter is remanded to the revisional court to be decided in accordance with law and in the light of observations made in this judgment. Since the matter is very old the revisional court is directed to decide the matter within three months from the date of presentation of a certified copy of this order.