- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Lal Harsh Deo Narain Singh And Another v. State Of U.P And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion (B.S. Chauhan, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners sought writ relief directing the respondents not to interfere with the petitioners' shop and plot and to prohibit trespass into their possession. The petitioners alleged that respondent No. 5 (a cousin) executed an agreement purporting to transfer rights in the disputed property to respondent No. 4 (Managing Director of Reliance India, Lucknow) and that respondent No. 4 began construction collusively, despite respondent No. 5 lacking authority to transfer such rights.
Procedurally, a civil suit between the parties concerning title to the property was pending in the Civil Court, Gyanpur, District Varanasi. Against an order in that matter, an F.A.F.O. No. Nil of 1984 was filed and this Court had, by order dated 10-05-1984, stayed further proceedings in the Civil Court. The Standing Counsel for the respondents submitted that because of the pending suit and the factual disputes concerning title, it would be undesirable for the High Court to interfere by entertaining the writ petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court should entertain the writ petition seeking prohibitory relief in respect of possession and alleged wrongful transfer when a civil suit concerning title is pending between the parties.
- Whether the petition raises disputed questions of fact (particularly title and competence to transfer) that render writ relief inappropriate.
- Whether the petitioners may be permitted to pursue parallel remedies/forums for the same subject-matter and relief.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners alleged that respondent No. 5 (their cousin) improperly executed an agreement transferring the disputed property to respondent No. 4 and that respondent No. 4 had started construction on the land despite respondent No. 5 lacking authority to transfer rights.
- They sought directions restraining respondents from interfering with their shop and plot and preventing trespass into their possession.
Respondents' Arguments
- The Standing Counsel for the respondents submitted that a civil suit between the parties on the same subject-matter was pending and that an F.A.F.O. was filed against an order in that suit and stayed by this Court on 10-05-1984.
- It was urged that the petition raises disputed factual questions of title and competence to transfer and therefore it would not be desirable for the High Court to interfere; the petitioners should litigate in the appropriate civil forum or seek appropriate relief in the pending proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| K.R. Rashid and Sons v. Income Tax Investigation Commission, AIR 1954 SC 207 | Where an alternative remedy is pending under a statute, a person may choose the remedy but cannot pursue both simultaneously. | The Court relied on the principle that a party cannot pursue two concurrent remedies and cited it to support non-interference because parallel proceedings exist. |
| Tilok Chand Moti Chand v. H.B. Munshi, (1969) 1 SCC 110 : AIR 1970 SC 898 | A writ court should entertain a petition only in rare cases where the ordinary process of law is inefficacious; caution against routine interference where alternative remedies exist. | The Court reiterated this caution and applied it to decline interference given the availability and pendency of ordinary remedies in the civil forum. |
| C.B. Gosain v. State of Orissa, (1963) 2 SCR 879 | Even where an alternative remedy has been exhausted, a party may pursue proceedings under Article 226 for the same relief. | The case was cited for the limited proposition about Article 226, but the Court emphasized that where an alternative forum is already approached, entertaining a writ may be inappropriate. |
| A.V. Venkateswaran, Collector of Customs, Bombay v. Ramchand Sobhraj Wadhwani, AIR 1961 SC 1506 | No rigid formula; the court must examine facts and circumstances to decide whether to entertain a writ; but where petitioner has already approached alternative forum, it is generally inappropriate to entertain the writ. | The Court applied this flexible approach, examined the facts and concluded it was inappropriate to entertain the petition since the civil suit was pending. |
| S.J.S Business Enterprises (P) Ltd. v. State of Bihar, 2004 Supp (2) JT (SC) 601 : (2004) 7 SCC 166 : AIR 2004 SC 2421 | Mere availability of an alternative forum does not by itself exclude High Court jurisdiction, but if a party has already availed the alternative remedy while invoking Article 226, it is not appropriate to entertain the writ. | The Court relied on this proposition to emphasize that because the petitioners had the pending civil remedy, the writ petition should not be entertained. |
| Jai Singh v. Union of India, (1977) 1 SCC 1 : AIR 1977 SC 898 | A person cannot be permitted to pursue two parallel remedies in respect of the same subject-matter at the same time. | The Court cited this to reinforce the bar on pursuing concurrent forums in respect of the same dispute and used it to support dismissal. |
| Bombay Metropolitan Region Development Authority v. Gokak Volkart Ltd., (1995) 1 SCC 642 : 1995 AIR SCW 808 | A writ petition filed during the pendency of an appeal/recourse before the statutory authority is not maintainable. | The Court applied the principle analogously to the present facts to hold that the presence of parallel proceedings militates against entertaining the writ. |
| Dr. Buddhi Kota Subbarao v. K. Parasaran, (1996) 5 SCC 530 : AIR 1996 SC 2687 | Access to justice must not be misused; litigants do not have a right to unlimited consumption of court time by filing misconceived and frivolous petitions. | The Court cited the observation to underscore that misuse of judicial process is impermissible and to justify refusal to entertain the writ. |
| K.K. Modi v. K.N. Modi, (1998) 3 SCC 573 : AIR 1998 SC 1297 | Reiterates the principle against misuse of judicial process and frivolous litigation. | Cited to support the Court's stance against unwarranted litigation and abuse of process. |
| Tamil Nadu Electricity Board v. N. Raju Reddiar, (1997) 9 SCC 736 : AIR 1997 SC 1005 | Filing successive misconceived or frivolous applications for clarification, modification or review interferes with administration of law and must be dealt with severely. | The Court invoked this authority in support of discouraging frivolous or abusive litigation practices, in the context of admonishing the petitioners' conduct. |
| Sabia Khan v. State of U.P., (1999) 1 SCC 271 : AIR 1999 SC 2284 | Filing totally misconceived petitions amounts to abuse of process of the Court; such litigants should not be treated lightly. | The Court cited it to justify refusal to entertain the petition and to support admonition of misconduct. |
| Abdul Rahman v. Prasony Bai, 2003 AIR SCW 14 : (2003) 1 SCC 488 : AIR 2003 SC 718 | Where the Court concludes the process of the Court is being abused, it is justified in refusing to proceed further and refuse the party from pursuing the remedy in law. | The principle was applied to validate refusal to entertain the writ in view of the pendency of alternative proceedings and perceived abuse. |
| R.D. Saxena v. Balram Prasad Sharma, (2000) 7 SCC 264 : AIR 2000 SC 2912 | The legal profession bears a social duty to act as a beacon light by conduct; advocates should not deprive litigants of statutory or constitutional rights for reasons of position. | The Court cited the passage to admonish the petitioners' counsel for scandalous allegations and reiterated the professional duty of advocates. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court considered the rival submissions and the record. It noted the following sequential points of analysis, as recorded in the opinion:
- Fact finding and scope: It was admitted that a civil suit between the parties concerning title to the disputed property is pending and that the present petition raises disputed questions of fact (title and the competence of respondent No. 5 to transfer rights).
- Doctrine and jurisdictional principle: The Court reviewed authorities establishing that while a litigant may choose a forum, he cannot pursue two parallel remedies simultaneously; writ jurisdiction is generally not to be exercised where alternate remedies are available and being pursued, subject to limited exceptions where ordinary remedies are inefficacious.
- Application of precedent: The Court applied the cited precedents to conclude that the petitioners' attempt to obtain writ relief while a suit on title was pending was improper. The Court emphasized public policy against forum shopping and abuse of process, and invoked the doctrine of lis pendens as applicable to the facts.
- Conduct of counsel and misuse: The Court addressed the conduct of the petitioners' counsel, who made scandalous allegations against civil court judges and prominent persons. The Court considered these allegations unwarranted and observed the professional obligations of advocates; it treated the conduct as serious enough to require disciplinary reference.
- Conclusion: Given the pendency of the civil suit, the disputed factual questions, and the risk of forum-shopping/abuse, the Court concluded it was not inclined to interfere and that dismissal of the petition was appropriate.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
DISMISSED
The petition was dismissed. The Court granted the petitioners liberty to approach the appropriate forum (i.e., to pursue relief in the civil proceedings or other appropriate remedy).
Implications and immediate consequences:
- Direct effect on parties: The petitioners' request for writ relief restraining interference with the shop and plot was refused; they are directed to pursue their remedies in the appropriate civil forum.
- Doctrine and precedent: The decision applies well-established principles (as cited) that writ relief is normally inappropriate where alternate statutory or ordinary remedies are available and being pursued; the opinion does not purport to create a new precedent beyond applying settled law.
- Professional discipline: Because of the gravity of the misconduct by the petitioners' advocate (scandalous allegations and unbecoming conduct), the Court referred the advocate Shri Sita Ram Singh to the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh under Section 35 of the Advocates Act and directed that a copy of the judgment be sent to the Secretary of the Bar Council for appropriate action.
This summary reflects only the information explicitly contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.
B.S Chauhan, J.:— This writ petition has been filed for directing the respondents not to interfere with the shop and plot of the petitioners and further prohibit the respondents not to trespass into the possession of the petitioners’ plot without having any right.
2. Petitioners’ grievance is that the respondent No. 5 who is his cousin brother, has executed an agreement with the respondent No. 4, the Managing Director of Reliance India, Lucknow in respect of the property in dispute, and the respondent No. 4 to start with the construction over the said land with the collusion of respondent No. 5, though the respondent No. 5 did not have any authority to transfer the rights in favour of the respondent No. 4. The learned Standing Counsel appearing for respondents has submitted that as a suit between the parties is pending, and against the order passed therein a F.A.F.O No. Nil of 1984 has been filed in which this Court vide order dated 10-5-1984 stayed the further proceedings in the Civil Court, Gyanpur, District Varanasi, this would not be desirable for this Court to interfere in the matter as the petitioners raise the disputed questions of fact, particularly, regarding the title, etc., and in case petitioners are aggrieved, they should file a suit or should make a prayer in the earlier suit after getting the disposal of the aforesaid F.A.F.O
3. We have considered the rival submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
4. Admittedly, suit is pending between the parties regarding the title over the property in dispute; and the petition raises the disputed questions of fact in respect of the title, etc. and the competence of the respondent No. 5 to transfer the rights in favour of the respondent No. 4. Thus, we are not inclined to interfere in the matter and petition is liable to be dismissed.
5. In K.R Rashid and Sons v. Income Tax Investigation Commission, AIR 1954 SC 207, a Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court considered the issue involved herein that when the remedy under Section 8(5) of the Taxation of Income Tax (Investigation Commission) Act, 1947 has been pending whether the High Court could entertain the writ petition. The Hon'ble Apex Court held that a person may choose/effect where it will proceed with the alternative remedy or with the writ petition, but both cannot be pursued simultaneously.
6. A similar view has been reiterated by another Constitution Bench in Tilok Chand Moti Chand v. H.B Munshi, (1969) 1 SCC 110 : AIR 1970 SC 898, however, the Hon'ble Apex Court cautioned that a writ Court should entertain a writ petition in rare cases where the ordinary process of law appears inefficacious that the writ Court interferes even where other remedies are available.
7. In C.B Gosain v. State of Orissa, (1963) 2 SCR 879 the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that even where an alternative remedy has been exhausted by a party, but that party could pursue any proceeding under Article 226 of the Constitution for the same relief.
8. A Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in A.V Venkateswaran, Collector of Customs, Bombay v. Ramchand Sobhraj Wadhwani, AIR 1961 SC 1506 held that even where a party has approached the alternative forum, the Court should entertain a writ petition or not, a straitjacket formula cannot be formulated. The Court may examine the facts and circumstances of the case and decide as to whether it was to entertain the petition or not. However, where the petitioner has already approached the alternative forum for appropriate relief, it is not appropriate that the writ petition should be entertained. The rule is based on public policy and motivating factor is that of existence of the parallel jurisdiction in another Court.
9. In S.J.S Business Enterprises (P) Ltd. v. State of Bihar, 2004 Supp (2) JT (SC) 601 : ((2004) 7 SCC 166 : AIR 2004 SC 2421) the Court held that mere availability of alternative forum for appropriate relief does not impinge upon the jurisdiction of the High Court to deal with the matter. Even if it is not a position to do so on the basis of the affidavits filed, however, if a party has already availed the alternative remedy while invoking the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution it will not be appropriate to the Court to entertain the writ petition.
10. In Jai Singh v. Union of India, (1977) 1 SCC 1 : AIR 1977 SC 898 the Hon'ble Supreme Court considered a case wherein the petitioner filed a writ petition which was dismissed in limine. Subsequently, he filed a suit agitating the same subject-matter. The Court held that suit was not maintainable as a person cannot be permitted to pursue two parallel remedies in respect of the same subject-matter at the same time.
11. In Bombay Metropolitan Region Development Authority, Bombay v. Gokak Volkart Ltd., (1995) 1 SCC 642 : (1995 AIR SCW 808), the petitioner therein had filed a writ petition during the pendency of the appeal before the Statutory Authority. The Hon'ble Apex Court held that such a writ was not maintainable.
12. Thus, in view of the above, the law can be formulated that the public policy demands that a person has a right to choose the forum for redressal of his grievance, but he cannot be permitted to choose two forums in respect of the same subject-matter for the same relief. There may be a case of forum hunting that a party who filed a suit, may not be able to get the interim relief. It may abandon the remedy before the civil Court and approach the remedy of filing the writ petition. Thus, it will amount to abuse of the process of the Court by forum hunting.
13. As the dispute regarding the title of the suit premises is pending before the civil Court and petitioner cannot be permitted to agitate the issue simultaneously at another forum. Moreso, the facts of this case attract the doctrine of lis pendens it is not desirable to interfere with in the facts and circumstances of the case.
14. In Dr. Buddhi Kota Subbarao v. K. Parasaran, (1996) 5 SCC 530 : AIR 1996 SC 2687, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed as under:—
“No litigant has a right to unlimited drought on the Court time and public money in order to get his affairs settled in the manner he wishes. However, access to justice should not be misused as a licence to file misconceived and frivolous petitions.”
15. Similar view has been reiterated by the Supreme Court in K.K Modi v. K.N Modi, (1998) 3 SCC 573 : (AIR 1998 SC 1297).
16. In Tamil Nadu Electricity Board v. N. Raju Reddiar, (1997) 9 SCC 736 : AIR 1997 SC 1005 the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that filing successive misconceived and frivolous applications for clarification, modification or for seeking a review of the order interferes with the purity of the administration of law and salutary and healthy practice. Such a litigant must be dealt with a very heavy hand.
17. In Sabia Khan v. State of U.P, (1999) 1 SCC 271 : (AIR 1999 SC 2284), the Hon'ble Apex Court held that filing totally misconceived petition amounts to abuse of the process of the Court and such litigant is not required to be dealt with lightly.
18. In Abdul Rahman v. Prasony Bai, 2003 AIR SCW 14 : ((2003) 1 SCC 488 : AIR 2003 SC 718) the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that wherever the Court comes to the conclusion that the process of the Court is being abused, the Court would be justified in refusing to proceed further and refuse the party from pursuing the remedy in law.
19. At this juncture, Shri Sita Ram Singh, learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the civil Courts are presided over by thoroughly corrupt, incompetent and inefficient judicial officers; and they are saleable commodities. Shri Anil Ambani, the proprietor of the Reliance India Mobile (not a party before us) is a powerful person. He keeps the Government of Uttar Pradesh in his pocket. Therefore, the civil Court cannot pass any order in favour of the petitioners.
20. We tried to explain him that he should not make such allegations, he told us that he had never seen this Court passing any order in favour of any petitioner; it is nothing but a slaughter house; and his case should be transferred to some other Court where he can get appropriate relief. He has wasted his life and reached the old age studying the constitutional law. He could not imagine that he has to make submissions before the Court where the Judges did not understand what is the constitutional law. In case his matter is not released and is dismissed, he would go to the Hon'ble Supreme Court against the judgment and would expose the Judges.
21. As a rule an Advocate, being a member of the legal profession, has social duty to show the people a beacon light by his conduct and actions, rather than being adamant on an unwarranted and uncalled for issue.
22. In R.D Saxena v. Balram Prasad Sharma., (2000) 7 SCC 264 : AIR 2000 SC 2912, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under (Para 42):—
“In our country, admittedly, a social duty is cast upon the legal profession to show the people beckon (sic beacon) light by their conduct and actions. The poor, uneducated and exploited mass of the people need a helping hand from the legal profession, admittedly, acknowledged as a most respectable profession. No effort should be made or allowed to be made by which a litigant could be deprived of his rights, statutory as well as constitutional, by an advocate only on account of the exalted position conferred upon him under the judicial system prevalent in the country.”
23. Thus, in view of the above, the Bench as well as the Bar has to avoid unwarranted situation or trivial issues, as it hampers the cause of justice and in interest of none.
24. Shri Sita Ram Singh seems to be habitual in making the scandalous allegations sparing none, as he considers it as a part of his profession, which cannot be justified by any standard.
25. In view of the above, we are not inclined to interfere in the matter as the petition raises the disputed questions of fact of title, etc.
26. Petition is, accordingly, dismissed with liberty to the petitioners to approach the appropriate forum. Considering the gravity of misbehaviour of Shri Sita Ram Singh, Advocate we are of the considered opinion that it is a fit case which requires to be referred to the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh under Section 35 of the Advocates Act and the reference is made accordingly. A copy of this judgment and order be sent to the Secretary of the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh by the Registry forthwith for appropriate action.
27. Petition dismissed.
Alert