- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sardar Prem Singh v. Bank Of Baroda And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion concerns a petition filed by the petitioner challenging a recovery action by the respondent Bank of Baroda involving more than Rs. 60 lacs. The petition appears to be the seventh writ petition filed by the petitioner contesting the same recovery, which the Division Bench of the Court has previously identified as an abuse of the Court’s process. The petitioner has sought a one-time settlement of the loan, which the Court has considered in light of the procedural history and prior orders, including a detailed order dated 7.11.2000.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a party has a legal right to claim a one-time settlement of a loan from a bank.
- Whether the Court under Article 226 of the Constitution can direct a bank to grant a one-time settlement or reschedule a loan.
- The enforceability of Reserve Bank of India guidelines on recovery of non-performing assets against a borrower.
- The legal status and enforceability of purely administrative or executive instructions in a Court of Law.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner prayed for a one-time settlement of the loan amount.
- The petitioner relied on the Reserve Bank of India guidelines for recovery of non-performing assets, as referenced in the respondent Bank’s letter dated 24.8.2000, to support the claim for one-time settlement.
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent Bank of Baroda opposed adjournments citing repeated illness slips filed by the petitioner.
- The Bank maintained that granting a one-time settlement is a discretionary act of the Bank and not a right enforceable by the Court.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| M.M Accessories v. U.P Financial Corporation, 2002 46 ALR 261 | There is no legal right to claim a one-time settlement of a loan. | Used to establish that the petitioner cannot claim a one-time settlement as a matter of right. |
| G.J Fernandez v. State of Mysore, AIR 1967 SC 1753 Para 12 | Purely administrative instructions are not enforceable in Court. | Supported the Court’s view that RBI guidelines are executive instructions without statutory force. |
| State of Maharashtra v. Lok Shikshan Sanstha, AIR 1973 SC 588 Para 27 | Administrative instructions lack enforceability in judicial proceedings. | Reinforced the non-binding nature of RBI guidelines on the borrower. |
| Union of India v. Maiji, AIR 1977 SC 257 Paras 31–36 | Administrative instructions do not create legal rights enforceable in Court. | Applied to confirm that RBI guidelines cannot be basis for legal claims by borrowers. |
| Jt. Chief Controller v. Aminchand, AIR 1966 SC 478 Para 6 | Administrative instructions are not judicially enforceable. | Supported the Court’s reasoning about the non-enforceability of RBI guidelines. |
| State of Assam v. Ajit Kumar, AIR 1965 SC 1196, 1200 | Administrative instructions do not confer enforceable rights. | Used to affirm the Court’s position on RBI guidelines and administrative instructions. |
| Satyanarain v. Mallikarjun, AIR 1960 SC 137, 142 | Purely executive instructions lack judicial enforceability. | Referenced to support the conclusion on RBI guidelines. |
| Rowther v. S.T.A.T, AIR 1959 SC 896 | Administrative instructions do not create legal rights. | Reiterated the principle that RBI guidelines are not enforceable rights. |
| Nagendra v. Commissioner, AIR 1958 SC 398 | Executive or administrative instructions are not judicially enforceable. | Used to bolster the Court’s reasoning on RBI guidelines’ non-binding nature. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court observed that this petition was the seventh writ petition filed by the petitioner challenging the recovery, which constituted an abuse of the Court’s process. It noted that the respondent Bank of Baroda’s recovery claim exceeded Rs. 60 lacs and expressed unwillingness to grant further adjournments despite illness certificates. The Court clarified that a one-time settlement essentially amounts to a rescheduling of the loan, a prerogative solely vested in the Bank and not subject to judicial direction under Article 226 of the Constitution. The Court emphasized that it can only interfere if there is a violation of law, which was not demonstrated by the petitioner.
The petitioner’s reliance on the Reserve Bank of India’s guidelines for recovery of non-performing assets was rejected, as these guidelines are internal executive instructions intended for banks and financial institutions, and do not confer any enforceable rights on borrowers. The Court supported this position by citing multiple precedents establishing that administrative or executive instructions lack judicial enforceability. Consequently, the petitioner’s claim to a one-time settlement based on these guidelines was dismissed.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED
The petition challenging the recovery and seeking a one-time settlement is dismissed. The Court’s decision directly affects the parties by denying the petitioner relief in the form of a one-time settlement and upholding the bank’s right to proceed with recovery without judicial interference. No new precedent was established; rather, the Court reaffirmed settled legal principles regarding the non-enforceability of administrative guidelines and the limited scope of judicial intervention in loan rescheduling.
M. Katju, J.:— In this petition the name of Sri Kuldeep Saxena has been shown for the petitioner. Sri Pradeep Kumar, learned Counsel for the respondent Bank of Baroda states that whenever the case is listed and illness slip is sent by the petitioner. Since the impugned recovery is of more than Rs. 60 lacs (sixty lacs) we are not inclined to adjourn this petition.
2. The order sheet of the case of 7.11.2000 shows that there is a detailed order of the Division Bench of this Court stating that this is the 7th writ petition filed be the petitioner challenging the recovery. In our opinion this is clear abuse of the process of the Court. In order dated 7.11.2000 it has also been stated that prima facie the allegations of the respondents appear to be correct.
3. The petitioner has prayed for one time settlement, but it is well settled that there is no right to a party to get one time settlement vide M.M Accessories v. U.P Financial Corporation . 2002 46 ALR 261..
4. Granting one time settlement is really re-scheduling of the loan, and only the Bank can do that. This Court under Article 226 of the Constitution cannot direct for one time settlement. The Court can only interfere when there is violation of law, but no such violation had been pointed out.
5. Learned Counsel for the petitioner has referred to the guidelines of the Reserve Bank of India for recovery of non-performing assets mentioned in the letter of respondent No. 1 dated 24.8.2000 (Annexure-1 to the petition). In our opinion these guidelines are only for the internal guidance of the Banks and the Financial Institutions, but a party who has taken the loan cannot derive any benefit from these guidelines, and these guidelines of the Reserve Bank of India do not confer any right on a party which has taken the loan to get one time settlement. These guidelines are purely executive instructions and not statutory directions. Hence, no right can be claimed by any one on their basis.
6. It is well-settled that purely administrative instructions are not enforceable in a Court of Law vide G.J Fernandez v. State of Mysore . AIR 1967 SC 1753 Para 12., State of Maharashtra v. Lok Shikshan Sanstha . AIR 1973 SC 588 Para 27., Union of India v. Maiji . AIR 1977 SC 257 Paras 31–36., Jt. Chief Controller v. Aminchand . AIR 1966 SC 478 Para 6, State of Assam v. Ajit Kumar . AIR 1965 SC 1196 1200., Satyanarain v. Mallikarjun . AIR 1960 SC 137 142., Rowther v. S.T.A.T . AIR 1959 SC 896., Nagendra v. Commissioner . AIR 1958 SC 398. etc.
7. For the reasors given above, this petition is dismissed.
Petition Dismissed.
Alert