- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Vashisht Kumar Jaiswal v. State Of U.P And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
This writ petition challenges the impugned order dated 3-7-2003 and a lease deed dated 25-7-2003 granted in favour of respondents No. 5 and 6 during the pendency of the petition. Respondents No. 5 and 6 were granted a mining lease for three years starting from 28th April 2000, which expired on 27th April 2003. The petition contests the extension of the lease beyond its expiry without a fresh public auction or tender process.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the lease granted to respondents No. 5 and 6 could be extended after its expiry on 27-4-2003 without conducting a fresh public auction or tender.
- Whether the procedure of granting or extending public contracts without advertising and public auction violates Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
- Whether Rules 6 and 8(i)(b) of the U.P Minor Mineral (Concession) Rules 1963 permit extension of mining leases in a manner consistent with constitutional mandates.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents relied on the Supreme Court decision in Beg Raj Singh v. State of U.P (2003) to support the extension of the lease.
- It was submitted that the grantee often invests a large amount of money, justifying an extension of the contract beyond its original term.
- Reliance was placed on Rules 6 and 8(i)(b) of the U.P Minor Mineral (Concession) Rules 1963 to argue that the lease period can be extended.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Beg Raj Singh v. State of U.P, 2003 (1) SCC 726 | Support for lease extension | Distinguished by the court as it did not consider Article 14 of the Constitution. |
| Ziauddin v. Commissioner, Moradabad, 2003 All LJ 1802 | Requirement of public auction and advertisement for public contracts | Followed as authority requiring advertisement and public auction to comply with Article 14. |
| A.S Advertising Company v. Nagar Nigam, Meerut, 2001 All LJ 274 | Necessity of public advertisement and fair tender process | Referred to support the principle of transparency and public auction. |
| Karan Singh v. State of U.P, 2001 All LJ 276 | Non-extension of lease period; public auction requirement | Agreed with and held that lease periods cannot be extended, requiring fresh auction after expiry. |
| Ram and Shyam Company v. State of Haryana, (1985) 3 SCC 267 | Need for advertising public contracts in newspapers with wide circulation | Applied to emphasize that public contracts should be granted by public auction after advertisement. |
| Shri Harminder Singh v. Union of India, (1986) 3 SCC 247 | Public contracts should be granted by advertisement and auction | Supported the principle of transparency in public contract grants. |
| Haji T.M Hassan Rawther v. Kerala Financial Corporation, (1988) 1 SCC 166 | Public auction as fair method to grant public contracts | Reinforced the requirement of public auction for public contracts. |
| Pashu Shav Chhedan Audyogic Utpadan Sahkari Samiti v. Nagar Palika, 1990 (1) UPLBEC 687 | Public auction as fair method for public contracts | Supported the principle of fair public auction. |
| Swatantra Bihar Sahkari Avas Samiti v. State of U.P, (1992) 1 All LR 32 | Public auction requirement | Reiterated the principle of granting contracts via public auction. |
| Air India Ltd. v. Cochin International Airport Ltd., (2000) 2 SCC 617 | Principles governing public contracts and tenders | Applied to emphasize the ordinary requirement of advertisement and public tender. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court reasoned that once the lease period granted to respondents No. 5 and 6 expired on 27-4-2003, no extension was permissible without following a fresh public auction or tender after adequate advertisement. This procedure is mandated to uphold the principles of equality and fairness enshrined in Article 14 of the Constitution. The court emphasized that the owner of the land is the State Government and not the Bhumidhar, who is merely a tenant, thereby reinforcing the State's authority to regulate leases transparently.
The court distinguished the respondents' reliance on Beg Raj Singh since that decision did not consider Article 14. It relied on several precedents, including Division Bench decisions and Supreme Court rulings, which uniformly held that public contracts must be granted through transparent procedures involving advertisement and public auction to prevent monopolies and arbitrariness.
The court rejected the argument that investments by the lessee justify extension beyond the contract term, stating that parties are aware of the fixed lease period at the time of contract and must plan investments accordingly. Further, the court held that subordinate legislation (such as the U.P Minor Mineral (Concession) Rules 1963) cannot override constitutional mandates. Article 14, being part of the Constitution, prevails over any conflicting delegated legislation.
The court noted that permitting extension of leases without fresh tenders would create monopolies and could imply collusion between grantees and authorities, which is impermissible. The court also referred to the dismissal by the Supreme Court of a Special Leave Petition challenging the Division Bench decision in Karan Singh v. State of U.P, reinforcing the binding nature of that precedent.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is allowed. The court quashed the lease granted to respondents No. 5 and 6 and directed the State Government to advertise the lease contract in two widely circulated newspapers and conduct a public auction or tender in which all eligible persons, including the petitioner and respondents No. 5 and 6, may participate.
As an interim measure, the District Magistrate may operate the lease until it is re-granted through the prescribed transparent process. The decision underscores the constitutional imperative of transparency and equality under Article 14 in the grant of public contracts and prohibits unauthorized extensions of leases, thereby preventing monopolies and promoting fair competition.
M. Katju, J.:— Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2. This writ petition has been filed against the impugned order dated 3-7-2003 (Annexure 1 to the petition) and lease deed dated 25-7-2003 in favour of respondents No. 5 and 6 during the pendency of the writ petition. The respondents No. 5 and 6 were granted mining lease for three years which started from 28th April, 2000 and hence it came to an end on 27-4-2003. We are not going into the various points urged before us because we are of the opinion that this petition deserves to be allowed on the short point that once the period of the lease in favour of respondents No. 5 and 6 expired on 27-4-2003 there is no question of extension of the lease, and instead there should have been a fresh public auction/public tender after advertising the same in well known newspapers having wide circulation. This procedure is essential, as otherwise Article 14 of the Constitution will be violated. Transparency in public administration also requires that such a procedure should be followed whenever any public contract is granted. It may be mentioned that the owner of the land is the State Government and a Bhumidhar under the U.P.Z.A and L.R Act is not the owner of the land, but he is only tenant, the owner is the State as the land is vested in it under Section 4 of the U.P.Z.A and L.R Act. Hence it is not correct to say that the land belongs to the Bhumidhar.
3. Learned counsel for the respondents relied on a decision of the Supreme Court in Beg Raj Singh v. State of U.P, 2003 (1) CRC 362 : ((2003) 1 SCC 726 : AIR 2003 SC 833). In our opinion this decision is wholly distinguishable as Article 14 of the Constitution has not been considered therein at all.
4. In Ziauddin v. Commissioner, Moradabad, 2003 All LJ 1802 a Division Bench of this Court has held that all contract of public property must ordinarily be granted by advertising in well known newspapers having wide circulation, and thereafter holding public auction/public tender so as to comply with Article 14 of the Constitution.
5. This view has been taken in A.S Advertising Company v. Nagar Nigam, Meerut, 2001 (1) UPLBEC 125 : 2001 All LJ 274 as well as in Karan Singh v. State of U.P, 2001 (1) UPLBEC 128 : 2001 All LJ 276. In these decisions we have referred to some earlier decisions of the Supreme Court and of this Court.
6. In Ram and Shyam Company v. State of Haryana, (1985) 3 SCC 267 : AIR 1985 SC 1147 and Shri Harminder Singh v. Union of India, (1986) 3 SCC 247 : AIR 1986 SC 1527 the Supreme Court held that ordinarily a theka should be granted after advertising it in well known newspapers having wide circulation. In Haji T.M Hassan Rawther v. Kerala Financial Corporation., (1988) 1 SCC 166 : AIR 1988 SC 157 and Pashu Shav Chhedan Audyogic Utpadan Sahkari Samiti v. Nagar Palika, 1990 (1) UPLBEC 687 : 1990 All LJ 300; Swatantra Bihar Sahkari Avas Samiti v. State of U.P, (1992) 1 All LR 32 : 1992 All LJ 634 : (AIR 1992 All 196) it was held that ordinarily a public auction is the fair way to grant public contracts.
7. In Ram and Shyam's case (supra) the Supreme Court held that ordinarily public contracts should not be given by public negotiations. The principles of granting such contracts was laid down by the Supreme Court in Air India Ltd. v. Cochin International Airport Ltd., (2000) 10 JT (SC) 481 : (2000) 2 SCC 617 : AIR 2000 SC 801 and ordinarily these principles should be followed. It has also been held that advertisement in an unknown or little known newspaper would also not be valid vide A.S Advertising Co. v. Nagar Nigam, (2001) 1 All WC 28 : 2000 All LJ 274. In the present case no good reason has been given for not advertising the theka for grant of Tehbazari, after the contract expired on 27-4-2003.
8. In our opinion there must be transparency in these matters of grant of public contracts, otherwise Article 14 of the Constitution will be violated. It is only in rare and exceptional cases, and for good reasons, that a public contract should be granted without advertising it in well known newspapers and holding public auction/public tender.
9. A Division Bench decision of this Court in Karan Singh v. State of U.P, Writ Petition No. 51206 of 2000 decided on 1-12-2000 (reported in 2001 All LJ 276) has held that the period of a lease cannot be extended. A Division Bench of this Court in Ram Narain Pandey v. State of U.P, Writ Petition No. 31712 of 1993 decided on 30-9-1993 and in Jata Shankar v. State of U.P, Writ Petition No. 13638 of 1993 decided on 5-10-1993 also took this view. We are in agreement with these decisions and we are also of the opinion that once a public contract has been granted for a specific period then on the expiry of the period there is no question of renewal and there must be public auction/public tender after advertising in well known newspapers having wide circulation, otherwise Article 14 of the Constitution will be violated and a monopoly may be created.
10. If it is held that even if the period of the contract has expired there can be extension of the contract then logically it would mean that a contract can go on for term after term and can be extended for 100 years or even more. This would create a monopoly in favour of a party, which would be illegal. It would also be against the interest of the State because in a public auction the State naturally can get higher amount of royalty for grant of the mining lease. In fact granting such extension creates an impression that there is some collusion between the grantee and the authorities.
11. It has been submitted by the learned counsel for the respondents that the grantee often invests a huge amount of money and hence he should be granted extension of the contract. We cannot accept this contention. When the contract is granted the party knows the period for which he has been granted the contract, and he also knows that his right exists only till the expiry of the contract. Hence whatever investment he wants to make should be from that point of view. He cannot claim extension just because he has invested a huge amount of money.
12. Learned counsel for the respondents has relied on Rules 6 and 8(i)(b) of the U.P Minor Mineral (Concession) Rules 1963 in aid of his submission that the period of the mining lease can be extended. We are of the opinion that no rule can violate the Constitution of India. It may be mentioned that in every country there is a hierarchy of laws as explained by the eminent jurist Kelsen in his ‘The Pure Theory of Law’ (see Kelsen's ‘The General Theory of the Law and State’). In our country the hierarchy is as follows:
(i) The Constitution of India;
(ii) Statutory law, which may be either Parliamentary law or law made by the State legislature;
(iii) Delegated legislation, which may be in the form of rules, regulations etc. made under the statute;
(iv) Administrative or executive instructions.
13. The general principle is that if there is a conflict between a higher law and a lower law, then the higher law must prevail. Article 14 is a part of the Constitution. Hence it is in the first layer of the hierarchy, whereas the rules in the U.P Minor Mineral (Concession) Rules are pieces of delegated legislation and thus belong to the third layer of the hierarchy. Obviously if there is conflict between the first layer and the third layer then the norm in the first layer will prevail, and the norm in the lower layer of the hierarchy will become ultra vires. Hence in our opinion, no rule can be made which violates Article 14 of the Constitution.
14. It may be mentioned that against the Division Bench decision of this Court in Karan Singh v. State of U.P (2001 All LJ 276) (supra) the State Government had filed an S.L.P before the Supreme Court being S.L.P (Civil) No. 4019 of 2001 which was dismissed on 11-7-2001. In fact the Supreme Court observed in that order:
“We see no reason as to why the State has filed the present S.L.P The S.L.P is dismissed.”
15. For the reasons given above, we quash the lease granted in favour of respondents No. 5 and 6 and direct the State Government to advertise the contract for the lease in question in two well known newspapers having wide circulation and thereafter hold public auction/public tender in which all eligible persons can apply.
16. If the petitioner or the respondents No. 5 and 6 are eligible they can also apply. Till the lease is granted in this manner the D.M, as an interim measure, can operate the lease.
17. The petition is allowed.
18. Petition allowed.
Alert