- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Smt. Rita Devi v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Others
Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner seeks an order directing the respondents to appoint her as a Class IV employee on compassionate grounds and to pay a regular monthly salary. Her claim arises from the death of her husband, late Vikram Singh, who had been deployed as a part-time tubewell operator in the Irrigation Department from 7 June 1982 until his death on 14 May 1997. The petitioner challenged an administrative rejection (order dated 29/30 December 1998) of her representation on the ground that there is no provision for appointment of dependants of part-time tubewell operators under the Uttar Pradesh Recruitment of Dependent of Government Servant Dying-in-Harness Rules, 1974 ("Rules, 1974").
The petition references an earlier collective writ petition (Writ Petition No. 11556 of 1989) filed by similarly situated dependants of part-time tubewell operators, which was allowed on 8 December 1995 directing regularisation/pay-scale parity for 11 part-time tubewell operators. The petitioner contends that, while similarly situated persons were regularised following that order, her husband died before he could be regularised. During pendency of the present writ petition, the petitioner discovered the administrative rejection of her representation (Annexure C.A.1) and challenged that rejection by amendment.
The respondents filed a counter-affidavit acknowledging that the petitioner's husband was not regularised but asserting that there is no specific provision to extend compassionate appointment benefits to dependants of a worker deployed as a part-time tubewell operator.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a dependent (the petitioner) of a deceased part-time tubewell operator is entitled to appointment on compassionate grounds under the Uttar Pradesh Dying-in-Harness Rules, 1974, when similarly situated workers were regularised but the deceased was not regularised before his death.
- Whether the absence of a specific provision addressing dependants of part-time tubewell operators in the Rules, 1974, precludes granting appointment on compassionate grounds where the deceased had long continuous service and juniors were regularised.
- Whether any age or qualification limitations affect the petitioner's entitlement to appointment under the Dying-in-Harness Rules, 1974.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner is the legally wedded wife and dependent of late Vikram Singh, a part-time tubewell operator who served from 7 June 1982 until his death on 14 May 1997.
- Similarly situated tubewell operators were regularised following this Court's order dated 8 December 1995; her husband, however, died before he could be regularised.
- The petitioner claims entitlement to appointment on compassionate grounds under the Dying-in-Harness Rules, 1974, relying on this Court's decisions in Santosh Kumar Mishra v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2001), Smt. Saroj Devi v. State of Uttar Pradesh (1999), and Smt. Maya Devi v. State of Uttar Pradesh (1998).
- The petitioner asserts that vacancies are still available, her financial condition is poor, and her case is genuine and should be considered in light of the cited precedents.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents acknowledge that the petitioner's husband was not regularised.
- They contend there is no specific provision for extending the benefit of appointment on compassionate grounds to dependants of a worker deployed as a part-time tubewell operator under the Rules, 1974.
- The counter-affidavit does not deny that other similarly situated persons were regularised, but the respondents rely on the absence of specific provision to justify rejection of the petitioner's representation.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Santosh Kumar Mishra v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 2001 (4) E.S.C. (All.) | Held that denial of appointment on compassionate grounds under Dying-in-Harness Rules was illegal where the deceased had been a daily-wager/work-charge employee with continuous service and similarly situated juniors were regularised; reliance on Rule 2 definitions and principles allowing compassion appointment despite non-regular status where equities exist. | The Court relied on Santosh Kumar Mishra to support that the petitioner (a dependant of a part-time worker who was not regularised but had long service and whose juniors were regularised) could be entitled to appointment on compassionate grounds under Rule 2. |
| Raj Narain Prasad v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (1998) 8 S.C.C. 473 | Cited in Santosh Kumar Mishra as a relevant Supreme Court authority concerning treatment of non-regular employees and principles applicable to regularisation/entitlement. | Referred to by the Court (via Santosh Kumar Mishra) as part of the legal backdrop validating compassionate appointment where long-standing non-regular employees have been treated as entitled to benefits. |
| Smt. Pushpalata Dixit v. Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad, 1991 (18) A.L.R. 509 | Supports the proposition that the Dying-in-Harness Rules may apply to persons not regularly appointed who have long service and died-in-harness; principle that the rule's main object is to provide employment to the family of the person who died in harness. | Cited by the Court (directly and via other cases) to reinforce that long-standing daily-wagers/work-charge employees' dependants can be entitled to compassionate appointment despite absence of formal regular appointment. |
| Smt. Saroj Devi v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 1999 (3) A.W.C. 2443 | Recognised entitlement to employment on compassionate grounds where the husband died while working on temporary basis against a substantive vacancy; supports applying Dying-in-Harness Rules to non-regular status in appropriate circumstances. | The Court relied on Saroj Devi to hold that a widow cannot be denied appointment merely because her deceased husband was not a regular employee if other conditions of the rule and equitable considerations are met. |
| Smt. Maya Devi v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 1998 (3) L.L.N. 633 | Held that a daily-wager who worked for many years and died in harness entitled the dependant to benefit under Dying-in-Harness Rules; relied on Pushpalata Dixit to apply the rule to non-regular employees with prolonged service. | Used by the Court as an authority supporting compassionate appointment for dependants of long-serving daily-wagers/work-charge employees who died while in service. |
| Meena Devi Chaudhary v. Chief Engineer, U.P. P.W.D., Lucknow, 2000 (2) U.P.L.B.E.C. 1421 | Held that a woman cannot be denied appointment under the Dying-in-Harness Rules on the ground that her deceased husband was not a regular employee; also noted that when a dependant attains age for appointment it should not be counted as delay. | Cited to support the proposition that non-regular status of the deceased does not automatically bar a dependant's compassionate appointment and to address delay issues in seeking appointment. |
| Smt. Anju Mishra v. General Manager, Kanpur Jal Sansthan, Writ Petition No. 18172 of 1994 (order dated 26 September 2003) | Applied Article 14 and the Rules, 1974 to direct appointment of a dependant where a daily-wager who rendered many years of service died before regularisation and another dependant had been given appointment; emphasized equal treatment. | Referenced by the Court as a similar instance where a dependant of a long-serving daily-wager was given appointment to ensure parity with another dependant who had already been accommodated. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by examining the statutory definitions, factual matrix and relevant precedents:
- Statutory framework: The Court reproduced and relied on Rule 2 and Rule 5 of the Uttar Pradesh Dying-in-Harness Rules, 1974. Rule 2 provides the definition of "Government servant" to include, inter alia, a person who though not regularly appointed has put in three years' continuous service in a regular vacancy. Rule 5 prescribes that when a government servant dies-in-harness, a dependent who is otherwise eligible should be given suitable employment in relaxation of normal recruitment rules, subject to qualifications and a five-year application window (with provision for relaxation where hardship is shown).
- Precedential support: The Court examined and relied upon a sequence of decisions (including Santosh Kumar Mishra, Saroj Devi, Maya Devi, Pushpalata Dixit, Meena Devi Chaudhary, and Anju Mishra) establishing that dependants of long-serving daily-wagers/work-charge employees who died in harness may be entitled to compassionate appointment even where the deceased was not formally regularised, particularly when similarly situated persons or juniors have been regularised or accommodated.
- Factual application: The Court noted that similarly situated persons who worked alongside the petitioner's husband had been regularised and that the petitioner's husband had worked for a long period (more than 15 years) but died before regularisation. The respondents did not deny that others were regularised; they relied instead on the absence of a specific provision addressing part-time tubewell operator dependants.
- Equity and consistency: Building on the precedents, the Court emphasized that where the State itself regularised juniors or similarly situated employees and thereby created an inconsistency, it would be inequitable to deny the petitioner the compassionate appointment that flows from the Rules and precedents.
- Conditions for relief: The Court clarified that the petitioner would be entitled to compassionate appointment provided that a vacancy exists, and that she possesses the minimum qualifications and age required for a Class IV post. The Court specified the permissible age range for appointment under this order: not below 18 years and not more than 58 years (with the note that age shall not debar appointment provided the petitioner is not below 18 and not above 58).
- Relief ordered: In view of the facts, statutory provisions and binding/precedential authorities, the Court disposed of the writ petition by directing the respondents to consider the petitioner's case for appointment to Class IV within three months from production of a certified copy of the order before the Executive Engineer, Tubewell Division 1, District Allahabad.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the respondents to consider the petitioner's claim for appointment to a Class IV post on compassionate grounds within three months from production of a certified copy of this order before the Executive Engineer, Tubewell Division 1, District Allahabad.
The Court further held that such appointment may be given if a vacancy exists and the petitioner satisfies the minimum qualification and age conditions (the petitioner should not be below 18 years and should not be more than 58 years).
Implications:
- Direct effect: The respondents are required to reconsider and decide the petitioner's application for compassionate appointment within the specified timeframe; no order as to costs was made.
- Scope: The decision applies to the petitioner's specific circumstances—dependant of a long-serving part-time tubewell operator who died before regularisation where similarly situated persons were regularised. The Court applied existing precedents and statutory provisions to afford relief; the opinion does not purport to lay down a new overarching precedent beyond applying and synthesising prior authorities to the facts of this case.
Disposition
The writ petition is disposed of in accordance with the directions stated above. No order as to costs.
1. Heard Sri Dilip Singh learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri S.S Sharma, learned Standing Counsel.
2. In this petition prayer has been made for commanding the respondents to appoint the petitioner as Class IV employee on compassionate grounds and for payment of regular salary month to month.
3. By amendment application the petitioner has challenged the order, dated 29/30 December, 1998, rejecting the representation of the petitioner on the ground that there is no provision for appointment of the dependants of the part-time tubewell operator died under the Uttar Pradesh Recruitment of Dependent of Government Servant Dying-in-Harness Rules, 1974, in short called Rules, 1974, hereinafter.
4. As contended on behalf of the petitioner late Vikram Singh was working as part-time tubewell operator by virtue of his deployment in the Irrigation Department from 7 June, 1982 till he died on 14 May, 1997. Similarly situated persons with the husband of the petitioner approached this Court collectively by filing Writ Petition No. 11556 of 1989 which was allowed on 8 December, 1995 (Annexure 1 to the writ petition) whereby as many as 11 part time tubewell operator parties to the writ petition were directed to be paid same allowances and pay-scale as are being paid to the other regular tubewell operators.
5. According to the petitioner as contended in the Para. 6 of the writ petition consequent upon the order, dated 8 December, 1995, similarly situated tubewell operators were regularised in service, however, it was irony of fate that before regularisation of petitioner's husband, he died on 14 May, 1997. The petitioner being the dependent, legally wedded wife of late Sri Vikram Singh approached for appointment on compassionate grounds and when no heed was taken, she preferred, the present writ petition and during the pendency of the writ petition she came to know that the representation of the petitioner was rejected by the order, dated 29/30 December, 1998, enclosed as Annexure C.A 1 which has also been challenged.
6. Counter-affidavit has been filed. According to the learned counsel for the respondents undoubtedly, the petitioner's husband was not regularised, however, in Para. 6 of the counter-affidavit there is no denial that the other similarly situated persons named in the Writ Petition No. 11556 of 1989 were not regularised. It has only been indicated in Para. 6 to the counter-affidavit as contended on behalf of the respondents that there is no specific provision for extending benefit of appointment on compassionate grounds in respect of the dependants of a worker deployed as a part-time tubewell operator thereafter.
7. Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that she is entitled to be given employment in reference to the decision of this Court in Santosh Kumar Mishra v. State of Uttar Pradesh, [2001 (4) E.S.C (All.)] and in reference to Smt. Saroj Devi v. State of Uttar Pradesh, [1999 (3) A.W.C 2443], and in reference to Smt. Maya Devi v. State of Uttar Pradesh, [1998 (3) L.L.N 633].
8. According to the petitioner the vacancies are still available and the petitioner's grievance and poor financial condition is still persisting, therefore, petitioner's case is extremely genuine to be considered in the light of the above mentioned decisions of the Court.
9. In Santosh Kumar Mishra, (vide supra) this Court referring the case of Raj Narain Prasad v. State of Uttar Pradesh, [(1998) 8 S.C.C 473], and in reference to Smt. Pushpalata Dixit v. Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad, [1991 (18) A.L.R 509] and Smt. Maya Devi v. State of Uttar Pradesh and in reference to Smt. Saroj Devi v. State of Uttar Pradesh, [1999 (3) A.W.C 2443] (vide supra), has observed that the writ-petitioner Santosh Kumar Mishra when claimed the appointment on compassionate ground under the Dying-in-Harness Rules on the death of his father, while working initially as daily-wager/muster-roll employee with effect from 15 June, 1986 and subsequently deployed as work-charge employee on 13 August, 1997 and was continuously in deployment and working till 31 March, 1999 and died in harness on 1 April, 1999, however was denied the benefit of regularisation, whereas juniors to the father of writ-petitioner and other similarly situated persons were regularised ignoring the claim of his father but the denial of appointment to Santosh Kumar Mishra on compassionate ground under Dying-in-Harness Rules on the ground that his father while in service before death was not regular employee, however, such denial of appointment was held to be illegal and this Court has further observed that the petitioner Santosh Kumar Mishra to be entitled for appointment on the compassionate ground in reference to rule 2 of Dying-in-Harness Rules.
10. For convenience the extract of relevant rules of “Dying-in-Harness Rules” provides as below:
“2. Definitions.—In these rules, unless the context otherwise requires:
(a) ‘Government servant’ means a Government servant employed in connection with the affairs of Uttar Pradesh who—
(i) was permanent in such employment; or
(ii) though temporary had been regularly appointed in such employment; or
(iii) though not regularly appointed, had put in three years’ continuous service in regular vacancy in such employment.
Explanation. — ‘Regularly appointed’ means appointed in accordance with the procedure laid down for recruitment to the post or service, as the case may be;
(b) ‘deceased Government servant’ means a Government servant who dies while in service;
(c) ‘family’ shall include the following relations of the deceased Government servant:
(i) Wife or husband;
(ii) sons;
(iii) unmarried and widowed daughters;
(iv) if the deceased was unmarried Government servant, brother, unmarried sister and widowed mother dependent on the deceased Government servant;
(d) ‘Head of office’ means head of office in which the deceased Government servant was serving prior to his death.
5. Recruitment of a member of the family of the deceased.—(1) In case a Government servant dies-in-harness after the commencement of these rules and the spouse of the deceased Government servant is not already employed under the Central Government or a State Government or a Corporation owned or controlled by the Central Government or a State Government, one member of his family who is not already employed under the Central Government or a State Government or a Corporation owned or controlled by the Central Government or a State Government shall, on making an application for the purposes, be given a suitable employment in Government service on a post except the post which is within the purview of the Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission, in relaxation of the normal recruitment rules if such person:
(i) fulfils the educational qualifications prescribed for the post;
(ii) is otherwise qualified for Government service; and
(iii) makes the application for employment within five years from the date of the death of the Government servant:
Provided that where the State Government is satisfied that the time-limit fixed for making the application for employment causes undue hardship in any particular case, it may dispense with or relax the requirement as it may consider necessary for dealing with the case in a just and equitable manner.
(2) As far as possible, such an employment should be given in the same department in which the deceased Government servant was employed prior to his death.
(3) Each appointment under sub-rule (1) should be under the condition that the person appointed under sub-rule (1) shall unkeep those other family members of the deceased Government servant who are incapable for their own maintenance and were dependent of the above said deceased Government servant immediately before his death.”
11. The observation which was made by High Court in Santosh Kumar Mishra (vide supra), in Paras 9, 14 and 17 are as below:
“9. According to the submission of the learned counsel for the State, a daily-wager or work charge employee who is engaged by the State Government or any department of the State Government cannot be treated as a Government servant within the definition of rule 2 of the aforesaid Rules. Qualifying the above argument, the learned counsel for the State further submitted that though an employee who is not regularly appointed is covered by the definition in view of Sub-cl. (ii) of rule 2(a) but in that case such employee must have put in three years continuous service, that too in regular vacancy in such employment. Since the petitioner's father was earlier a daily-wager or muster-roll employee and later on worked as work charge employee, therefore, it cannot be said that he was appointed regularly or had worked in regular vacancy.
14. The practice of appointing daily-wagers or work charge employees is very much prevailing in the State of Uttar Pradesh and instances are no less in number where the daily-wager or work charge employees in the Government department have been allowed to continue for years together, namely, 15 years, 20 years and 25 years or till they actually reach the age of superannuation to which they may not be entitled, not being a Government servant but they are disposed with their engagement on attaining the age of superannuation. The practice of appointing such daily-wagers and work charge employees has constantly been a matter of great concern for the judiciary and for that matter, the Apex Court has many a times issued directions for framing schemes so as to accommodate all daily-wagers of long standing duration and work charge employees as a regular employees. It would be needless to mention that such a scheme has been ordered to be framed by the Court in the department of Rural Engineering Services in the Forest Department and many other department.”
17. In the instant case, one more redeeming feature in favour of the petitioner is that persons junior to the petitioner's father who were similarly appointed and were taken on the work-charge establishment were regularised against regular vacancies by means of order, dated 2 November, 1998, but the case of the petitioner's father was not considered and thus he was deprived the benefit of regularisation. In case, the petitioner's father had been considered at that time, he would have been regularised before he died on 1 April, 1999. Since the petitioner's father was entitled for regularisation after putting in such a long service and his case has not been considered for regularisation, the petitioner cannot be deprived of giving the appointment on compassionate ground because the opposite parties themselves did not consider the case of the petitioner's father for regularisation.”
12. In the case of Saroj Devi (vide supra), this Court has directed the entitlement of writ-petitioner to be given employment on the compassionate ground under Dying-in-Harness Rules acknowledging the claim of the petitioner in view of the fact that the husband of the writ-petitioner had died in while working on temporary basis against the substantive vacancy.
13. A woman cannot be denied appointment under this rule on the alleged ground that her deceased husband was not working on regular basis in view of Meena Devi Chaudhary v. Chief Engineer, Uttar Pradesh Public Works Department, Lucknow, [2000 (2) U.P.L.B.E.C 1421]:
Delay in appointment—What amounts to.—When a dependant attained the age for appointment on compassionate ground, it will count not as delay for moving an application for consideration of appointment.
14. In Smt. Maya Devi, [1998 (3) L.L.N 633] (vide supra), where the writ-petitioner's husband had worked satisfactorily under the Director Government Press, Allahabad, for about 10 years as a daily-wager until his death, on her claim the writ-petitioner was directed to be accommodated on compassionate ground under the Dying-in-Harness Rules relying on the judgment of Smt. Pushpalata Dixit (vide supra), where it was held as under:
“The main contention of the petitioner's counsel is that in pursuance of the Government order she is entitled for the appointment in the said department. On behalf of the State a counter-affidavit has been filed and it is stated that the husband of the petitioner was not regular employee. On behalf of the petitioner. Government Order No. 6/12-1973 Niyukt 4, Lucknow, dated 7 October, 1974, has been produced showing that rule of Dying-in-Harness is fully applicable on the person who is not regularly appointed and died in harness. The main object of the rule is to provide an employment to the family of the person who died-in-harness. The employment is given on the compassionate ground and, therefore, in my opinion, it would not be proper to say that the husband of the petitioner has not been regularly appointed but he has worked 17 years in the department and died-in-harness. Therefore, the heir of the deceased is entitled to get benefit of Dying-in-Harness Rules, 1974.”
15. Similar view was also taken by this Court (Hon'ble R.B Misra, J.) by the order, dated 26 September, 2003, passed in Writ Petition No. 18172 of 1994, Smt. Anju Mishra v. General Manager, Kanpur Jal Sansthan, Benajhawar Road, Kanpur, where while rendering 11 years of service as daily-wager in Jal Sansthan, Kanpur, the petitioner's husband died before his regularisation where as one other dependant of a daily-wager who also died after serving a considerable number of years as a daily-wager was given appointment then in reference to the provisions of Art. 14 the writ-petitioner was directed to be given similar treatment in respect of appointment as a dependant on compassionate grounds in reference to “Rules, 1974”.
16. I have heard learned counsel for the parties. I find that if the similarly situated persons while working along with the husband of the petitioner were regularised and the petitioner's husband had worked for more than 15 years died before regularisation leaving behind the petitioner/widow, the benefit of appointment on compassionate ground could be extended to her, provided the vacancy is available and petitioner is in possession of the minimum qualification and age as required for appointment to the post of Class IV category. However, the age shall not debar the petitioner for appointing provided the petitioner should not be below 18 years and should not be more than 58 years.
17. In view of the above observations, the writ petition is disposed of in view of the observations made above with the direction to the respondents to consider the case of the petitioner in respect of giving employment to Class IV category within three months from the production of the certified copy of this order before Executive Engineer, Tubewell Division 1, District Allahabad.
18. No order as to cost.
Alert