Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shanti v. District Magistrate, Sultanpur

Allahabad High Court
Feb 2, 2000
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

1. Heard learned counsel for the petitioner Sri Lagan Mishra and learned Standing Counsel.

2. The controversy involved in the present writ petition is as to whether the respondent No. 4 viz. (Alp Sankhyak Kalyan Adhikari (Task Force Officer), Block Baldirai, Sultanpur is empowered to hold preliminary enquiry as contemplated under S. 95(1)(g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 read with U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans, Up Pradhans and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1997 (hereinafter referred to as the Enquiry Rules) or not?

3. The petitioner Smt. Shanti is a duly elected Pradhan of Gram Panchayat Saini, Block Baldirai, District, Sultanpur. It is urged by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the respondent No. 4 (Enquiry Officer) is not an authorized person to hold preliminary enquiry under the provisions of S. 95(1)(g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 read with Enquiry Rules, 1997 published in the U.P Gazette Extra Part-IV Section (Kha) dated 9-5-1997 inasmuch as the impugned show cause notice dated 28-12-1999 issued by the District Panchayat Raj Officer, Sultanpur (respondent No. 2) is liable to be set aside. The Enquiry Rules being relevant for the controversy involved in the instant petition are quoted herein below:

4. Preliminary Enquiry: (1) The State Government may, on the receipt of complaint or report referred to in Rule 3, or otherwise order to the District Panchayat Raj Officer to conduct preliminary enquiry with a view to finding out if there is a prima facie case for a formal inquiry in the matter.

(2) The District Panchayat Raj Officer shall conduct the preliminary enquiry as expeditiously as possible and submit his report to the State Government within a fortnight of his having been so ordered.”

4. In this case, the matter in question relates to the preliminary enquiry and not a regular enquiry. The provisions regarding regular enquiry has been given in Rule 5 which is reproduced below:

5. Inquiry Officer: Where the State Government is of the opinion on the basis of the report referred to in sub-rule (2) or otherwise that on inquiry should be held against a Pradhan or Up-Pradhan or Member under the proviso to Clause (g) of sub-sec. (1) of S. 95, it shall, by an order, ask the inquiry officer to hold the enquiry.

5. In the counter-affidavit, it has been stated that vide Notification dated 30th April, 1997, the powers of the State Government have been delegated to the District Magistrates Hence, all the powers of the State Govt, are now vested in the District Magistrates for their respective districts and the Alp Sankhyak Kalyan Adhikari (respondent No. 4) is not below the rank of District Panchayat Raj Officer. It has also been averred in the counter-affidavit that according to Rule 2 read with Rule 4, it is provided that an officer not below the rank of District Panchayat Raj Officer appointed by the State Govt, is competent to conduct enquiry against Pradhans, Up Pradhans and the Members. Learned Standing Counsel has also placed reliance on the same. He has drawn the attention of the Court towards Rule 2(c) where the definition of Inquiry Officer has been given which is as under:

“Inquiry Officer means an officer not below the rank of the District Panchayat Raj Officer, appointed as such, by the State Government.”

6. A bare perusal of Rule 5 indicates that the State Govt, after receipt of the report under Rule 4(2) may hold regular enquiry and for that purpose, an inquiry officer be appointed. Now, the question for determination emerges as to who can be the inquiry officer. For this purpose, the definition clause has been quoted above. Hence, the definition of the inquiry officer is related to Rule 5 and not to Rule 4 i.e the preliminary enquiry inasmuch as in Rule 4, the word ‘inquiry officer’ has not been used but the designation of District Panchayat Raj Officer has only been used which shows that the definition of the inquiry officer in the definition clause has no relevance with the conduct of preliminary enquiry. Therefore, in the matter in hand, where the matter relates to preliminary enquiry only, neither Rule 2 nor Rule 5 would be applicable and only the District Panchayat Raj Officer has been authorized to conduct a preliminary enquiry accordng to Rule 4 of the Rules.

7. A bare perused of the aforesaid rules, it is clear that the aforesaid rules enable the District Magistrate only to order the District Panchayat Raj Officer concerned to conduct preliminary enquiry with a view to finding out if there is a prima facie case for a formal enquiry in the matter. An Alp Sankhyak Kalyan Adhikari (respondent No. 4) in the present case is not compertent to conduct a preliminary enquiry udner Rule 4 of the Enquiry Rules and since no enquiry was held under the relevant rules, the report of the Enquiry Officer (respondent No. 4) cannot be made the basis of an action under the first proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the Act.

8. In view of the above, the District Magistrate may, of course, order a formal enquiry to be held even on the basis of reports received ‘otherwise’ than through the District Panchayat Raj Officer under Rule 4 of the Enquiry Rules but in that event no action can be taken under the First proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the Act until the State Government is satisfied by the preliminary enquiry that on the basis of preliminary enquiry repot, on enquiry should be held against Pradhans, Up-Pradhans and the Members and until a report is received from the Enquiry Officer under Rule 7 of the Enquiry Rules.

9. In view of the facts and circumstances discussed above, I am of the opinion that the action taken by the District Magistrate under the first proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the Act on the basis of the report submitted by the Alp Sankhyak Kalyan Adhikari, Sultanpur (respondent No. 4) in the present case is violative of the constitutional scheme and the provisions of the Act read with the Enquiry Rules, 1997 mentioned above.

10. In the result, the writ petition succeeds and is allowed. The impugned order dated 5-3-1999 passed by the District Magistrate Sultanpur (respondent No. 1) is quashed. However, it will be open to the District Magistrate concerned to proceed in accordance with rules afresh. No order as to costs. After the pronouncement of the judgment, learned counsel for the petitioner has prayed that the office be directed to provide certified copy of this order within three days. The prayer is allowed. The office is directed to supply copy of this order/judgment to the learned counsel for the parties on payment of usual charges within a week.

11. Petition allowed.