- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sunil Kumar v. State Of U.P And Others
Judgment Summary — S.N. Srivastava, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner challenged the rescission of his compassionate appointment and termination of his services, which followed directions in a State Government order dated 2.5.2002. The relevant facts in the record are:
- The petitioner's father, late Hari Prakash, served as a Safai Karamchari in the Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad and died on 28.2.2001.
- Following his death, the petitioner applied for compassionate appointment and was offered appointment to the vacant post formerly held by his father on a daily wage basis by order dated 3.7.2001; he was attached to the Health Department of the Nagar Nigam.
- The State Government issued an order dated 2.5.2002 stating that the benefit of dying-in-harness rules would not be applicable to daily wage employees and directing termination of services of casual employees; this served as the background for the impugned order dated 21.5.2002 rescinding the petitioner's appointment and terminating his services (and a consequential order dated 28.5.2002).
- The petitioner's father had, according to the record and the parties' concessions, put in about 13 years' service in the Nagar Nigam though he remained identified as a daily wage employee at the time of death.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the services of a dependent who had been appointed pursuant to dying-in-harness rules can be dispensed with as a consequence of the State Government order dated 2.5.2002 that denied application of dying-in-harness rules to daily wage employees.
- Whether dependants of a government employee who was a daily wage worker but had put in three or more years' continuous service (and in this case about 13 years) serving against permanent requirements are entitled to the benefits of the U.P. Recruitment of Dependants of Government Servants Dying-in-Harness Rules, 1974.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner's father had completed about 13 years of service in the Nagar Nigam in the post that existed against the permanent requirements of the Nagar Nigam.
- The U.P. Recruitment of Government Servants Dying-in-Harness Rules, 1974 apply to local bodies including the Nagar Nigam, and rule provisions extend benefits to persons appointed temporarily for more than three years.
- The State Government's direction to terminate services of dependents appointed under dying-in-harness rules (on the basis that the father was a daily wage employee) conflicts with the Rules and is therefore impermissible.
- Reference was made to government orders (including one dated 15.10.1998 and one dated 5.11.2002 as per the petitioner's counsel) indicating applicability of dying-in-harness benefits to work-charge employees.
Respondents' Arguments
- The Nagar Nigam and the State contended that because the deceased father was a daily wage employee, the petitioner was not entitled to compassionate appointment under the dying-in-harness rules.
- They conceded that the father had put in about 13 years' service but maintained that his status as a daily wage employee excluded dying-in-harness benefits for dependants.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded from the text of the U.P. Recruitment of Dependants of Government Servants Dying-in-Harness Rules, 1974 and the factual matrix:
- The court referred expressly to Rule 2(a) of the 1974 Rules and quoted the definition of "Government servant" contained therein, which includes clause (iii): a person who, though not regularly appointed, had put in three years' continuous service in a regular vacancy.
- On the facts, the deceased had about 13 years' continuous service and had been working against the permanent requirements of the Nagar Nigam; therefore, the court held that clause (iii) applied even though the deceased bore the label "daily wage employee."
- The court also referred to the Government order dated 18.10.1998 (a clarificatory order) which stated that benefits of the dying-in-harness rules were applicable to work-charge employees; the court found it inconsistent to deny similar benefits to the petitioner when that clarificatory stance had been adopted by the State in respect of work-charge employees.
- Given the statutory text and the 1998 clarificatory government order, the court concluded that the State Government's order of 2.5.2002 (and the subsequent departmental orders relying on it) directing termination of dependants appointed under dying-in-harness rules on the sole basis of the father's daily-wage status could not be sustained.
- Consequently, the rescission of the petitioner's appointment and the termination orders were held to be unlawful on the basis that the petitioner was entitled to the benefits of the dying-in-harness rules in view of his father's continuous service.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The petition is allowed and the impugned orders are quashed.
Specific outcomes ordered by the Court:
- The impugned order dated 21.5.2002 passed by the Upper Mukhya Nagar Adhikari and the consequential order dated 28.5.2002 of the Senior Nagar Swasthaya Adhikari, Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad are quashed.
- The petitioner is held to have been rightly appointed under the dying-in-harness rules and is entitled to be absorbed in the Nagar Nigam and to all consequential benefits flowing from that status.
Broader implications:
No broader or novel precedent was expressly declared beyond the application of the existing Rules and the 1998 government clarification; the opinion confines its effect to recognizing that dependants of an employee who, though described as a daily wage employee, had put in three or more years' continuous service against permanent requirements, are entitled to dying-in-harness benefits. The opinion does not elaborate wider policy consequences beyond the direct effect on the parties.
S.N Srivastava, J.:— The short question that looms large in this petition is whether the services of dependent of a Government servant dying-in-harness could be dispensed with as a sequel to the directions contained in the Government order dated 2.5.2002
2. Matrix of the necessary facts is that petitioner's father, namely, late Hari Prakash, who had been serving as Safai Karamchari in the Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad, died on 28.2.2001 Thereafter, petitioner applied for compassionate appointment and consequently, he was offered appointment on the vacant post held by his father though on daily wage basis vide order dated 3.7.2001 and was attached to Health Department of the Nagar Nigam.
3. It would transpire from the record that State Government issued Government order dated 2nd May, 2002, addressed to Mukhya Nagar Adhikari, Nagar Nigam, Gorakhpur, the text of which was that the benefit of dying-in-harness rules would not be applicable to daily wage employees and as such appointment under dying-in-harness rules on death of a daily wage employee was invalid, attended with further direction to terminate the services of all casual employees under intimation to the Government. It would thus appear that background of the impugned order dated 21.5.2002, thereby rescinding the appointment and terminating the services of the petitioner, is the Government order aforestated.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner began his submission arguing that the father of the petitioner had put in 13 years of service in the Nagar Nigam unto the date of his death and he served all these years in the Nagar Nigam as Safai Karmachari on the post which was born of requirements of the Nagar Nigam. He further canvassed that Dying-in-harness Rules, 1974, had been adopted for application to all the local bodies including Nagar Nigam. He also drew attention of the Court to the relevant provision in the dying-in-harness rules the quintessence of which is that benefit of dying-in-harness rules would extend coverage to a person appointed temporarily for more than 3 years. He assailed the order of the State Government containing direction to terminate the services of the petitioner, who was appointed under dying-in-harness rules, as one militating against the provisions of law and the U.P Recruitment of Government Servants Dying-in-harness Rules, 1974. He also referred to the Government order dated 5.11.2002 (Annexure-4) and also the Government order dated 15th October, 1998, according to which even the work charge employees were entitled to the benefit flowing from dying-in-harness rules. Sri Prem Chand, learned counsel representing the Nagar Nigam and the standing counsel, in unison, contended in opposition that since the father of the petitioner had served in the Nagar Nigam on daily wage basis though at the same time conceded that he had put in about 13 years of service at the time of his death, the petitioner was not entitled to compassionate appointment.
5. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and considered the respective argument of the learned counsel for the parties in all its ramifications. Before delving into analytical examination of the merits of the respective arguments, it is essential to refer to Rule 2(a) of the U.P Recruitment of Dependants of Government Servant Dying-in-Harness Rules, 1974, which concededly is intended and has been made applicable to all the local bodies inasmuch as the assertion on this count specifically made in paragraph 6 of the writ petition has not been repudiated in para 8 of the counter-affidavit. In Rule 2 of the Rules, expression ‘Government servant’ has been defined in the following manner:
“(a) ‘Government servant’ means a Government servant employed in connection with the affairs of Uttar Pradesh, who:
(i) was permanent in such employment; or
(ii) though temporary had been regularly appointed in such employment; or
(iii) though not regularly appointed; had put in three years' continuous service in regular vacancy in such employment.”
6. It would crystallise from perusal of Rule 2(a)(iii) that if a person though not regularly appointed, had put in three years' continuous service in regular vacancy in such employment, dependants of such employees would be entitled to the benefits flowing from dying-in-harness rules. Besides, it is also explicit from a perusal of the Government order dated 18th October, 1998, that Government in terms of the provisions of the dying-in-harness rules issued a clarificatory order that the benefits of dying-in-harness rules were also applicable to work charge employees. In the instant petition, the deceased employee had concededly put in about 13 years of service though he could not be redeemed from the epithet of daily wage employee unto his death. It is also obvious from the record and it has not been repudiated that the deceased employee endured in the service of Nagar Nigam all these years against its permanent requirements. By this reckoning, it is beyond the pale of controversy that the deceased employee held the post against permanent requirements of the Nagar Nigam even though for reasons not obvious on record, he wore the badge of daily wage employee unto his death. In the circumstances, I am of the firm view that benefits of dying-in-harness rules must on all fours apply to the dependent of the deceased employee, i.e, the petitioner. To cap it all, it defies logic that when the State Government has made applicable the benefits of dying-in-harness rules to the work charge employees, how could this be denied to the petitioner whose father had served the Nagar Nigam as Safai Karmachari for about 13 years in unbroken continuity. The necessary corollary that follows from the above is that the directions of the State of U.P to terminate the service of dependents who were appointed under dying-in-harness rules merely on the hypothesis that petitioner's father had worked as daily wage employee and the consequential order rescinding the petitioner's appointment and termination of his services, cannot be sustained in law. It is, therefore, held that a daily wage employee working against permanent requirements of the Nagar Nigam for more than 3 years in a vacancy existing for more than 13 years even though he continued to wear the badge of daily wage employee, his dependants are entitled to get the benefits of appointment flowing from dying-in-harness rules.
7. As a result of the foregoing discussion, the petition succeeds and is allowed. The impugned order dated 21.5.2002, passed by the Upper Mukhya Nagar Adhikari and the consequential order of Senior Nagar Swasthaya Adhikari, Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad, dated 28.5.2002 are quashed. As a consequence thereof, the petitioner is held to have been rightly appointed under the dying-in-harness rules and he shall be entitled to be absorbed in the Nagar Nigam and to all consequential benefits.
Alert