Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Smt. Ram Pyari v. State Of U.P And Another

Allahabad High Court
Mar 3, 2000
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Opinion — Amarbir Singh Gill and Kamal Kishore, JJ.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was employed as Child Development Project Officer, Bhagwanpur (Hardwar) and challenged an order of dismissal dated 26.4.1999. A charge-sheet dated 11.7.1994 (Annexure-2) was issued to the petitioner, to which she submitted a reply on 21.7.1994. The petitioner alleges that she repeatedly requested copies of documents referred to in the charge-sheet and other evidence (through the District Programme Officer and to the Additional Director), but such copies were never supplied. A show cause notice dated 28.1.1998, accompanied by a copy of the enquiry report, was served. The petitioner contends that no proper enquiry was conducted, no witness statements were recorded, and the order of dismissal was passed without affording an effective opportunity of defence, contrary to Article 311 of the Constitution and Rule 55 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules. The opposite parties asserted that opportunities were given, dates for enquiry were fixed and the petitioner did not cooperate; they also alleged that evidence had been supplied, but no documentary proof of those communications was placed on record.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the non-supply of copies of documents referred to in the charge-sheet (despite repeated requests) and failure to provide an effective opportunity to inspect or obtain documents vitiates the departmental enquiry.
  2. Whether an enquiry in which no statements of witnesses were recorded and findings are made essentially on the charge-sheet and the delinquent's preliminary reply (finding charges proved because they were not disproved) can sustain a dismissal, in view of Article 311 of the Constitution and Rule 55 of the C.C.A. Rules.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner asserted she was served a charge-sheet dated 11.7.1994 and replied on 21.7.1994 but was never supplied copies of the documents referred to in the charge-sheet despite repeated requests (letters identified as Annexures-5, -7, -11).
  • She contended that no statements of witnesses were recorded, no evidence was recorded during the enquiry, and that the impugned order of dismissal was passed without affording an effective opportunity of defence, violating Article 311 and Rule 55.
  • The petitioner asserted that the enquiry officer concluded charges were proved merely because she failed to disprove them, and she had stated that a detailed reply could be filed only after inspection/supply of documents.

Opposite Parties' Arguments

  • The opposite parties contended that the petitioner was granted every opportunity and was informed of dates fixed for the enquiry, but she did not cooperate.
  • They claimed that the petitioner had been supplied all evidence in support of the charges by a letter dated 11.7.1994 from the District Programme Officer, Dehradun, and was afforded opportunity to submit defence by letter dated 28.1.1998; they also referenced letters dated 30.10.1995, 26.10.1995 and 4.11.1995 as fixing dates for the enquiry.
  • However, the opinion notes that the opposite parties did not place copies of any such letters on record to substantiate those claims.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chandrama Tewari v. Union of India, 1987 Supp SCC 518 : AIR 1988 SC 117 Principle that failure to supply copies of documents referred to in the charge-sheet vitiates an enquiry; where copies cannot be supplied, the delinquent must be informed of the alternative remedy of inspecting the documents. The Court relied on this principle to hold that non-supply of documents (and absence of an express offer to permit inspection) prejudiced the petitioner's defence and vitiated the enquiry.
Kashinath Dikshita v. Union of India, (1986) 3 SCC 229 : AIR 1986 SC 2118 Reinforces the settled principle that documents referred to in a charge-sheet must be made available or inspection permitted to enable an effective defence. Applied as part of the authority establishing that non-supply of documents undermines the fairness of the disciplinary process in this case.
State of U.P. v. Mohd. Sharif, (1982) 2 SCC 376 : AIR 1982 SC 937 Supports the settled principle regarding requirements of fairness in departmental enquiries (as cited alongside the other landmark cases). Placed with other authorities to support the conclusion that natural justice requires effective opportunity, including access to documents or inspection.
State of U.P. v. Shatrughan Lal, (1998) 6 SCC 651 Specifically endorses that if copies of documents cannot be supplied, the enquiry officer must expressly inform the employee of the alternative of inspecting the documents; failure to do so vitiates the enquiry. The Court relied on this authority to require either supply of copies or an express offer of inspection; since neither occurred here, the enquiry was held to be vitiated.
Avatar Singh v. State of U.P., 1989 (7) LCD 199 Holds that reasonable opportunity includes opportunity to cross-examine witnesses and to lead evidence; an order based only on the charge-sheet and explanation violates Article 311 and C.C.A. Rules. The Court invoked this decision to underscore that the petitioner was denied a reasonable opportunity because no oral evidence was recorded and the order rested on charge-sheet and reply alone.
Mahesh Kumar Pandey v. Upper Pradhan Prabandhak, U.P.S.R.T.C., 1997 ALJ 1501 Affirms that the right of defence guaranteed by Article 311 (and Articles 14 and 21) and natural justice is substantive and full; a mere opportunity to admit or deny allegations is insufficient. The Court cited the quoted principle to support the conclusion that the petitioner was entitled to a full and effective defence, which she did not receive due to non-supply of documents and lack of recorded evidence.
Mahmoodul Hassan v. State of U.P., 1983 (1) LCD Held that penalty based solely on the charge-sheet and replies without oral hearing or enquiries violates Article 311; such orders may be quashed. The Court used this authority to reinforce that reliance only on charge-sheet and replies (without oral hearing) cannot sustain disciplinary penalties.
Ministry of Finance v. S.B. Ramesh, 1998 SCD 1046 Establishes that even documentary evidence must be proved in the enquiry by examining witnesses; documents alone, without proof, cannot be treated as conclusive evidence of guilt. The Court referred to this to emphasize that documentary references in a charge-sheet are insufficient unless supported by examined evidence; here no witnesses were examined and no evidence recorded.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a structured manner:

  1. Scope of Judicial Review: The Court recognized that interference in findings of fact in domestic disciplinary enquiries is limited — the Court cannot act as an appellate authority — but judicial review is available where findings lack evidentiary support, are perverse, or reflect dictation from a superior authority.
  2. Quasi-judicial Character and Principles of Natural Justice: Departmental disciplinary proceedings are quasi-judicial; they must comply with service rules and, absent specific rules, satisfy principles of natural justice. A key principle is that the delinquent must be given an effective (not illusory) opportunity of hearing.
  3. Requirement of Supply or Inspection of Documents: The Court relied on controlling authorities to state that when a charge-sheet references documents to be relied upon, copies should be supplied or, if not possible, the delinquent must be expressly offered the alternative of inspecting the documents. Failure to supply or offer inspection undermines the ability to mount an effective defence.
  4. Application to the Record: The charge-sheet here expressly referred to documents and oral evidence. The petitioner produced documentary proof (Annexures-5, -7, -11) of her repeated requests for documents and of the enquiry officer's directions to the District Programme Officer (Annexures-8, -9, -10) to supply them. Annexure-11 (dated 1-8-96) stated the documents were not supplied. The opposite parties failed to place any document on record proving supply of the materials or that witness statements were recorded.
  5. Defects in the Enquiry: It was admitted that no witness statements were recorded. The enquiry officer confined himself to the charge-sheet and the petitioner's preliminary reply and concluded the charges were proved because the petitioner failed to disprove them. The Court characterized this approach as procedurally improper and unknown to departmental proceedings.
  6. Evidentiary Standard: The Court emphasized that findings must be based on some evidence pointing to guilt; suspicion cannot substitute for proof. Since there was no evidence recorded to sustain the charges, the enquiry report was found to be vitiated and the findings perverse.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The petition is allowed and the impugned order of dismissal dated 26.4.1999 (Annexure-1) is QUASHED.

Direct consequences and remedial directions:

  • The petitioner shall be deemed to be in service as Child Development Project Officer as if the dismissal order was never passed.
  • It is open to the opposite parties to hold a fresh enquiry against the petitioner in accordance with law (i.e., complying with service rules and principles of natural justice, including supply of documents or offering inspection and recording of evidence where appropriate).

Broader implications: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond applying established authorities; the decision's practical effect is the quashing of the specific dismissal and permitting a lawful fresh enquiry.

Show all summary ...

Amarbir Singh Gill and Kamal Kishore, JJ.:— The petitioner, who was working as Child Development Project Officer, Bhagwanpur (Hardwar) has challenged the order dated 26.4.1999 of her dismissal from service. The case of the petitioner in brief is that she was served with charge-sheet dated 11.7.1994, copy of which is Annexure-2. She submitted reply to the same on 21.7.1994 Without holding an enquiry, she was served with a show cause notice dated 28.1.1998 along with a copy of the enquiry report. The petitioner approached the Additional Director through District Programme Officer, Moradabad for supplying her the copies of documents and evidence relied against her to enable her to submit an effective reply. She, however, was never supplied any copies of the documents referred to in the charge-sheet neither any evidence was recorded during the enquiry. She made repeated requests for supply of copies of documents. However, no such document was supplied to her ever. The impugned order of dismissal has been passed without affording any opportunity of defence to her and the charges were held to be proved merely on the ground that the petitioner has not been able to disprove the charges. The Impugned order is thus arbitrary in nature, since no opportunity was afforded to her as envisaged in Article 311 of the Constitution and Rule 55 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules.

2. The case of the opposite parties, however, is that the petitioner was granted every opportunity. She was informed of the date fixed in the enquiry but she did not co-operate and the order of dismissal has been passed considering the charges, the records and the reply of the petitioner in accordance with law. Heard the learned counsel for the parties.

3. The order of dismissal of the petitioner has been challenged mainly on two grounds; firstly, that the copies of documents referred to in the charge-sheet were not supplied to the petitioner to enable her to reply effectively to the charges as also the show cause notice; secondly, that no enquiry worth the name was conducted in this case.

4. The scope of interference in findings of fact arrived at in a disciplinary proceedings by the enquiry officer is limited in the sense that the Court cannot sit in appeal over those findings and assume the role of appellate authority but this does not mean that in no circumstance, the Court can interfere. The power of judicial review available to the High Court under the Constitution takes in stride the domestic enquiry as well and it can interfere with the conclusion reached therein if there was no evidence to support the findings or the findings recorded were such as could not have been reached by an ordinary prudent man and the findings were perverse and made on the dictate of superior authority.

5. The nature of the departmental disciplinary proceedings is of quasi-judicial, which Implies that it has to be conducted in accordance with the service rules and in the absence of any specific rules, it must satisfy the principles of natural justice. One of the principles of natural justice is that the delinquent has to be given opportunity of hearing, which opportunity is required to be effective and not a mere pretence. In the departmental enquiries, the charge-sheet is issued and documents which are supposed to be utilised against the delinquent official are indicated in the charge-sheet but if the copies thereof are not supplied to him inspite of his request and he is at the same time called upon to submit his reply, it cannot be said that he was afforded effective opportunity to defend. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Chandrama Tewari v. Union of India, 1987 Supp SCC 518 : AIR 1988 SC 117; Kashinath Dikshita v. Union of India, (1986) 3 SCC 229 : AIR 1986 SC 2118 and State of U.P v. Mohd. Sharif, (1982) 2 SCC 376 : AIR 1982 SC 937, has settled this principle. Even in cases where copies of the documents referred to in the charge-sheet are not possible to be supplied, the enquiry officer has to inform the employee expressly that he has alternative course of inspecting documents. Such an enquiry stands vitiated, if it is without supplying him the copies of the documents referred to in the charge sheet or informing him expressly of the alternative remedy of Inspecting documents (see State of U.P v. Shatrughan Lal, (1998) 6 SCC 651).

6. A perusal of the charge-sheet, copy of which is Annexure-2, indicates specifically the reference to the documents sought to be proved in support of the various charges as well as oral evidence relevant for such purpose. The petitioner in support of her allegation that she was not supplied the copies of documents has placed on record letters Annexure-5, Annexure-7 and Annexure-11 which indicate that the petitioner had been demanding the supply of documents as well as the summoning of Sri J.P Rastogi, District Programme Officer, Hardwar. Letters Annexures 8, 9 and 10 of the enquiry officer refers to the letter written by the petitioner for supply of the documents and contains direction to the District Programme Officer for supply of the documents sought by the petitioner. In her letter Annexure-11 dated 1-8-96, the petitioner has categorically stated that despite direction from the enquiry officer, the District Programme Officer has not supplied her the documents. There is no document placed on record by the opposite parties which could Indicate that documents sought by the petitioner were supplied to her. In the circumstances, there is no scope but to hold that the petitioner could not defend the charges against her in the absence of the documents and non-supply of the documents has seriously prejudiced her case and thereby she was not afforded the opportunity muchless reasonable one as envisaged under Rule 55 of Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules as well as Article 311 of the Constitution. The opposite parties no doubt, in the counter-affidavit claim that the petitioner vide letter dated 11.7.1994 of the District Programme Officer, Dehradun was supplied all the evidence in support of the charges and thereafter she was given opportunity to submit her defence by letter dated 28.1.1998 and also refers to the letter dated 30.10.1995, 26.10.1995 and 4.11.1995 fixing date in the enquiry. However, no copy of any such letter has been placed on record even to substantiate the plea that the petitioner was supplied the copies of documents or any dates were fixed in the enquiry. Even otherwise, it is admitted that no statement of any witness was recorded during the enquiry. It is thus clear that the enquiry officer only considered the allegations as contained in the charge-sheet and the preliminary reply of the petitioner to the charge-sheet denying all the allegations and came to the conclusion that since the petitioner failed to disprove the charges, the charges were proved against her. A reference to the report of the enquiry officer which is with the covering letter Annexure-4 speaks volumes about the conduct of the enquiry officer in this case. The enquiry officer has referred to every charge individually and considered the explanation of the petitioner and without referring to any evidence, documentary or oral, has found the charges proved. The petitioner, no doubt, submitted a reply to the, charge-sheet but a perusal of the same would indicate that she has specifically mentioned after denying all charges as false and frivolous that detailed reply can only be filed after the copies of the documents are supplied to her and on inspection of the records. The enquiry officer while considering the charge against her and her reply has observed that the petitioner should have filed reply only after inspection of records. The enquiry officer nowhere mentions that he has perused the records and her allegations in the reply are not supported from the record despite the fact that the petitioner during the pendency of enquiry or even after the show cause notice was not supplied with the copies of the documents referred to in the charge-sheet. The conduct of the enquiry officer that he held the charges proved only on consideration of the reply of the petitioner is deprecated, as such a procedure is unknown to the departmental proceedings.

7. This Court in Avatar Singh v. State of U.P. 1989 (7) LCD 199 has held that concept of reasonable opportunity Includes opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses examined against him and lead evidence in his defence and if the order of punishment is based only on the charge-sheet and the explanation filed by the official, the same is in violation of Article 311, C.C.A Rules and principle of natural justice. In Mahesh Kumar Pandey v. Upper Pradhan Prabandhak, U.P.S.R.T.C, 1997 ALJ 1501, it has been observed:

“Right of defence which is guaranteed to a Government servant under Article 311 of the Constitution and to other citizens under Articles 14 and 21 as also by the rules of natural Justice is a substantive right which has to be full and complete. Mere opportunity to admit or deny a particular factual allegation amounting to a charge of misconduct alone is not the defence which is envisaged by the Constitution and rules of natural Justice.”

8. In Mahmoodul Hassan v. State of U.P 1983 (1) LCD, a reversion order resulting in reduction in rank was quashed which was passed on the basis of the enquiry report which referred to the charge sheet and replies of the petitioner and it was held that penalty of reduction in rank based on finding of guilt on the basis of formal disciplinary enquiry without giving opportunity of oral hearing or enquiries is clearly violative of Article 311 of the Constitution. Even in cases where the charges are based on documentary evidence, no such document can be considered as evidence or proof of the charge against the delinquent official unless the documents are proved by examining the witnesses (see Ministry of Finance v. S.B Ramesh, 1998 SCD 1046).

9. As already observed above, the disciplinary proceedings are of quasi-judicial character. Therefore, It is necessary that any findings on the charges against the delinquent official should be arrived on the basis of some evidence, i.e, such evidence which points to the guilt of delinquent and does not leave the matter in suspicious state as suspicion cannot take the place of proof even in domestic enquiries. If, therefore, there is no evidence to sustain the charges framed against the delinquent, he cannot be held to be guilty, as in that event the findings recorded by the enquiry officer would be perverse being not supported by any evidence on record.

10. The enquiry report in this case thus is vitiated being not based on any evidence. The impugned order of dismissal passed on such enquiry report only cannot stand the judicial scrutiny and is required to be quashed.

11. In the light of the observations made above, this petition is allowed and the impugned order of dismissal dated 26.4.1999 (Annexure-1) is quashed. The petitioner shall be deemed to be in service as Child Development Project Officer as if the aforesaid order was never passed. It shall, however, be open to the opposite parties to hold a fresh enquiry against the petitioner in accordance with law.