Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ravi Karan Singh v. State Of U.P And Others

Allahabad High Court
Feb 12, 1999
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

M. Katju and Kamal Kishore, JJ.:— This petition has come up before us on a reference made by the learned Single Judge by his order dated 19.12.1997 The point involved is very simple, that is, whether an appointment under the Dying in Harness Rules is a permanent appointment or a temporary appointment. According to the learned Single Judge, this court had earlier held that an appointment under Dying in Harness Rules is a permanent appoint vide Budhi Sagar Dubey v. D.I.O.S . 1993 1 LLJ 798. Gulab Yadav v. State of U.P, 2 and Dhirendra Pratap Singh v. D.I.O.S,3 The learned Single Judge who passed the referring order dated 19.12.1997 disagreed with the above mentioned decisions and hence has referred the matter to a larger Bench.

2. In our opinion, an appointment under The Dying in Harness Rules has to be treated as a permanent appointment otherwise if such appointment is treated to be a temporary appointment then it will follow that soon after the appointment the service can be terminated and this will nullify the very purpose of The Dying in Harness Rule because such appointment is intended to provide immediate relief to the family on the sudden death of the bread earner.

3. We, therefore, hold that the appointment under Dying in Harness Rule is a permanent appointment and not a temporary appointment, and hence the provisions of U.P Temporary Government Servant (Termination of Services) Rules 1975 will not apply to such appointments.

4. The petition is disposed of accordingly.

5. Petition Disposed of.