- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Oriental Bank Of Commerce v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The opinion concerns a group of writ petitions challenging a common arbitral/tribunal award dated 17.7.1996; the petitions raise identical questions of fact and law and were consolidated, with Writ Petition No. 35145 of 1996 as the lead case.
Facts in brief: Oriental Bank of Commerce, Kanpur (the Bank) appointed the respondent workmen as clerks for limited periods in 1981 (periods from 5.5.1981 to 22.7.1981 and from 4.8.1981 to 13.8.1981). From 14.8.1981 onwards they were not permitted to continue in those posts. The workmen raised an industrial dispute which the Central Government referred to the Tribunal on 20.8.1986. Both parties filed written statements and led evidence.
The Tribunal found (inter alia) that: the workmen were appointed to clear vacancies and had performed work of a permanent nature though for 80–90 days; the case related to 1981 and the Section 2(bb)(oo) change (effective 7.8.1984) did not apply; the terminations amounted to retrenchment; Sections 25-G and 25-H are independent provisions; there was no proof of breach of Section 25-G but there was a breach of Section 25-H because no opportunity to offer re-employment was afforded and fresh recruits were taken; the workmen were not entitled to back wages because delay in disposal was attributable to them; they were entitled to reinstatement. Aggrieved, the Bank filed these petitions under Article 226.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the termination of the workmen's employment in 1981 amounted to "retrenchment" within the meaning of the Industrial Disputes Act and whether Section 2(bb)(oo) (which came into force on 7.8.1984) applies to the 1981 terminations.
- Whether the Bank breached Sections 25-G and/or 25-H of the Industrial Disputes Act by not affording retrenched workmen an opportunity for re-employment and by recruiting fresh employees in their stead.
- Whether, given the Bank's recruitment policy (including recruitment through the Banking Service Recruitment Board) and bipartite settlement provisions, the Tribunal was correct in directing reinstatement (and whether any testing by the Recruitment Board should be ordered).
- What relief (reinstatement and/or back wages) is appropriate where a breach of Section 25-H is found but there has been substantial delay in the proceedings.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's (Bank's) Arguments
- The Bank submitted that the workmen were engaged for a fixed period to fill leave vacancies (temporary appointments) and that the appointments ended by efflux of time; therefore the terminations did not amount to retrenchment.
- It argued that Section 2(bb)(oo) covered such terminations and that Sections 25-G and 25-H did not apply if there was no retrenchment.
- The Bank relied on a recruitment policy and the Banking Service Recruitment Board (BSRB) procedure for clerical recruitment, submitting that the workmen could not be inducted permanently without passing the required examination; reliance was placed on Union of India v. Bishambhar Dutt (JT 1996 10 S.C. 329).
- The Bank also placed reliance on paras 20.7 and 20.8 of the bipartite settlement of 1966 to argue that temporary engagement for short periods was permissible and not illegal.
Respondents' (Workmen's) Arguments
- The respondents contended that the Bank indulged in unfair labour practice by terminating their employment and then engaging other temporary hands without giving the retrenched workmen an opportunity to offer themselves for re-employment, contrary to Section 25-H.
- They argued they were not given the opportunity to appear in any test for permanent recruitment and that Section 25-H had been violated; reliance was placed on Management of State Bank of Bikaner and Jaipur v. Their Workmen (Civil Appeal No. 7029 of 1994) as authority.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Union of India v. Bishambhar Dutt (JT 1996 (10) S.C. 329) | Cited by the Bank to support the proposition that where rules/procedure prescribe recruitment method, appointments not made according to such rules cannot be sustained. | The court considered the decision but held the present facts distinguishable: in Bishambhar Dutt there were Rules providing a mandatory recruitment procedure; in the present case the Bank's policy did not completely prohibit direct recruitment and thus the Tribunal's reinstatement order could stand. |
| Management of State Bank of Bikaner and Jaipur v. Their Workmen (Civil Appeal No. 7029 of 1994) | The respondents relied on this Supreme Court authority in support of their unfair labour practice/entitlement arguments. | The judgment is referenced as relied upon by respondents' counsel; the opinion does not elaborate further application or detailed reliance by the court beyond noting the reliance. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court reviewed the Tribunal's findings and the documentary record (including the Bank's recruitment policy filed as Annexure 3) and proceeded in steps:
- Characterisation of terminations: The Tribunal found that the terminations in 1981 amounted to retrenchment. The court accepted that finding, noting that Section 2(bb)(oo) (which narrows the concept of retrenchment) came into force only on 7.8.1984 and therefore did not apply to the 1981 events.
- Independence of Sections 25-G and 25-H: The Tribunal had held that Sections 25-G and 25-H are independent; there was no evidence of violation of Section 25-G, but there was a breach of Section 25-H. The court accepted the Tribunal's record that fresh hands were engaged after termination and that the Bank did not afford the retrenched workmen an opportunity to offer themselves for re-employment.
- Statutory/regulatory obligation: The court examined Section 25-H of the Industrial Disputes Act and Rule 78 of the Industrial Disputes (Central) Rules, 1957 (which requires at least ten days' prior notice to retrenched workmen about vacancies). The court concluded that Rule 78 imposes an obligation on the employer to notify retrenched workmen irrespective of whether the future employment is temporary or permanent. There was no evidence that the Bank complied with this obligation.
- Examination of Bank's recruitment policy: The Bank's own policy (Annexure 3) discouraged temporary appointments and required approvals; para 2 stated temporary clerical appointments should normally be requisitioned through the Banking Service Recruitment Board or local Employment Exchange, with branches permitted to make their own arrangements only when those sources could not supply candidates. The court found no record showing compliance with these norms or that the Bank had given retrenched workmen any opportunity under the policy.
- Remedy and fairness: The court considered the appropriate remedy. Although the Bank argued that workmen should undergo recruitment testing by the Banking Service Recruitment Board, the court observed there was no averment as to how the posts had been filled and that the Bank's policy did not absolutely prohibit direct recruitment. Given the long delay (about 15 years) since the events, the court concluded it would be neither proper nor just to send the workmen to any test now to judge their suitability.
- Distinguishing authority relied upon by the Bank: The court distinguished Union of India v. Bishambhar Dutt on the ground that in that Supreme Court matter there were Rules prescribing recruitment procedure that precluded appointment otherwise; that factual distinction led the court to uphold the Tribunal's reinstatement direction here.
- Relief limitations: The Tribunal's finding that the workmen were not entitled to back wages (because delay in disposal was attributable to them) was noted and accepted by the court. The court thus upheld reinstatement but did not award back wages.
Holding and Implications
Final Disposition: Petitions Dismissed.
Implications and direct effects:
- The court upheld the Tribunal's award dated 17.7.1996 finding a breach of Section 25-H of the Industrial Disputes Act and ordering reinstatement of the concerned workmen.
- The court confirmed that no back wages were payable to the workmen because the delay in disposal of the case was attributable to them.
- The court clarified that Rule 78 and Section 25-H require an employer to give retrenched workmen an opportunity to offer themselves for re-employment (including notice ten days before vacancies are filled), and this obligation applies irrespective of whether the subsequent employment is temporary or permanent.
- The court distinguished a Supreme Court decision relied upon by the bank (Union of India v. Bishambhar Dutt) on factual grounds and did not apply it to defeat reinstatement in this case.
- No broader constitutional or legal precedent was articulated beyond the application of existing statutory provisions; the decision's practical consequence is the reinstatement order being sustained and the petitions being dismissed. The opinion does not announce a new legal principle or wider precedent beyond the case-specific application of Sections 25-H and Rule 78.
The court ordered that there would be no order as to costs.
R.R.K Trivedi, J.:— All the aforesaid writ petitions are directed against the common award dated 17.7.1996 and questions of facts and law involved are identical. All the petitions can thus be conveniently disposed of by a common judgment to which parties have no objection. Writ petition no. 35145 of 1996 shall be the leading case.
2. Facts, in short, giving rise to these petitions are that Oriental Bank of Commerce, Kanpur (hereinafter referred to as the Bank) appointed respondents workmen in these petitions as clerks for the period 5.5.1981 to 22.7.1981 and then from 4.8.1981 to 13.8.1981 from 14-8-1981 they were not allowed to work on these posts. The concerned workmen raised an industrial dispute which was referred by the Central Government to the Tribunal vide order dated 20.8.1986 Both the parties filed their written statements and adduced evidence. The case of the workmen was that there were permanent vacancies of clerks on which they were appointed for a definite period. Their appointment was to meet the work of permanent nature though the appointment was temporary one and they were entitled to continue on the posts. However, by adopting unfair labour practice opposite parties did not allow them to work on their posts though juniors were allowed to continue. In their place fresh hands were recruited but they were not given opportunity. In this way the employer bank committed breach of Sections 25-C and 25-H of Industrial Disputes Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act). The action of the employer was also against the provisions of bipartite settlement, Shastri Award and Desai award. The case of the petitioner bank, on the other hand, was that the claim of the workmen is highly belated. Their appointment was for a specific period in leave vacancies. As the appointment came to an end by efflux of time, it was not a case of retrenchment and it was covered by the provisions of Section 2(bb)(oo) of the Act. As it did not amount to retrenchment, Sections 25-G and 25- H of the Act have no application. It has also been submitted that recruitment to the post of clerk is made through the Banking Service Recruitment Board and the concerned workmen could not be inducted in service without successfully appearing in the examination.
3. The Tribunal, after hearing both the parties, recorded finding that the claim of the workmen is not stale and is not liable to be rejected on the ground of delay. All the concerned workmen were appointed in clear vacancies and were discharging work of a permanent nature. However, they worked in the bank for the period of 80 to 90 days. Then it was also found that as the dispute is ft respect of the period 1981 and provisions of Section 2(bb)(oo) of the Act came in force on, 7.8.1984, the provision will not be applicable and termination of employment of the workmen amounted to retrenchment; that Section 25-G and 25-H of the Act are independent and their application is not dependent on the application of Section 25-F of the Act. There is no evidence to establish the violation of Section 25-G of the Act. However, the bank committed violation of Section 25-H of the Act as the concerned workmen were not afforded opportunity and fresh recruitments were made. It may be true that the recruitment on the post of clerk is made through the Banking Service Recruitment Board but the claim of the concerned workmen can be defeated only when it is shown that they were given opportunity to appear in the test and they failed to pass it. The concerned workmen are responsible for the delay in disposal of the case and they are hot entitled for any back wages. However, there was violation of Section 25-H of the Act and they are entitled to reinstatement in service. Aggrieved by the aforesaid award dated 17.7.1996, petitioners have filed these petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
4. Shri Krishna Mohan, learned counsel for petitioner has submitted that the respondents-workmen worked for total 79 days in the year 1981. Their appointment was for a fixed period in leave vacancy and it cannot amount to retrenchment. The view taken by the Tribunal is incorrect and suffers from manifest errors of law. Learned counsel has also submitted that the policy adopted by the bank as directed by the Central Government is that recruitment on the post of clerk shall be made through the Banking Service Recruitment Board and as none of the workmen has passed the test, the award directing their reinstatement is unjustified. Reliance has been placed in the judgment of Hon'able Supreme Court in case of Union of India v. Bishambhar Dutt. JT 1996 10 S.C 329. Learned counsel also placed before the Court the bipartite settlement of 1966. Learned counsel referred to paras 20.7 and 20.8 and submitted that temporary engagement could be made for a short time and it cannot be said that by giving employment to workmen for short period the bank committed any illegality.
5. Learned counsel for respondents, on the other hand, submitted that the petitioner indulged in unfair labour practice as after terminating the employment of the workmen, they again engaged temporary hands without giving any opportunity to the respondents workmen who were retrenched employees. They were not given any opportunity to appear in any test for permanent recruitment on the post and the violation of Section 25-H of the Act has been fully established. Reliance has been placed in a judgment of Hon'able Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 7029 of 1994 Management of State Bank of Bikaner and Jaipur v. Their workmen
6. I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties. From a perusal of paragraphs 20.7 and 20.8 of the bipartite settlement of 1966 there is no doubt that Bank could engage temporary hands in the circumstances mentioned in the aforesaid paragraph. However, their own document, annexure 3 to the writ petition, which has been stated to be a policy adopted for making recruitments, provides certain norms, para 1 whereof provides that as far as possible temporary appointment should have to be avoided and in no case such appointment should be allowed in casual leave arrangement. No temporary appointment should however, be made without approval of the Regional Heads in advance in case of appointment in clerical grade. Para 2 provides that the requisition of candidates for temporary appointments in clerical cadre should be made through respective Banking Service Recruitment Boards. If the Banking Service Recruitment Board is not in a position to provide approved persons, the candidates should be requisitioned from the local Employment Exchange. If the Board as well as the Employment Exchange wherever these exist, are not able to provide candidates, the branches may be allowed to make their own arrangements strictly according to the norms. Here there is nothing on the record from either side to show that the aforesaid norms were complied with. However, the Tribunal has recorded a finding that the appointment of the concerned workmen was not against any leave vacancy. The petitioner could not adduce sufficient evidence to prove this fact. It has also been proved that after terminating the employment of respondents-workmen, again temporary hands were engaged ignoring their claim. The relevant finding recorded by the Tribunal in para 12 may be reproduced here:
“However, it has been proved from the evidence of V.N Sekhari and other witnesses that subsequent to termination of concerned workmen, new hands have been taken and no opportunity to the concerned workmen was given. Indeed this fact was not disputed on behalf of the management even during the course of arguments. In this way, it is held that when the new hands were recruited in place of concerned workmen, they were not afforded opportunity. In this way, there has been breach of Section 25-H of the I.D Act. In the case it has been held that because of breach of Section 25-H of the I.D Act, their termination would be void in law. It is held accordingly.”
7. In the facts and circumstances of the case, there remains no doubt that petitioner committed breach of Section 25-H of the Act which reads as under:
“25-H. Re-employment of retrenched workmen.—Where any workmen are retrenched, and the employer proposes to take into his employ any persons he shall, in such manner as may be prescribed, give an opportunity to the retrenched workmen who are citizens of India to offer themselves for reemployment, and such retrenched workmen who offer themselves for reemployment shall have preference over other persons.”
8. Rule 77 of the Industrial Disputes (Central) Rules, 1957 (hereinafter referred to as the Rules) creates as obligation on the part of the employer to prepare a list of all workmen in a particular category from which retrenchment is contemplated. Rule 78 provides for re-employment of the retrenched workmen. The rule has a material bearing in the present case which is being reproduced below:
“78. Re-employment of retrenched workmen.—(1) At least ten days before the date on which vacancies are to be filled, the employer shall arrange for the display on a notice board in a conspicuous place in the premises of the industrial establishment details of those vacancies and shall also give intimation of those vacancies by registered post to every one of all the retrenched workmen eligible to be considered therefor, to the address given by him at the time of retrenchment or at any time thereafter.”
9. From a perusal of Rule 78 it is clear that as it was a case of retrenchment, the petitioner was under a legal obligation to give notice to the respondents-workmen ten days before the vacancies are to be, filled to offer themselves for re-employment. Rule 78 does not create any distinction between temporary employment or permanent employment. If there was a case of retrenchment in both the cases, the petitioner was under obligation to give opportunity to the concerned workmen to offer himself for reemployment, and he was also entitled for a preference over others. However, this was subject to the test if any, prescribed for such appointment. There is nothing on record to show that petitioner bank discharged this legal obligation created by Section 25-H read with Rule 78 before making fresh recruitment on the post either on temporary or permanent basis. In the circumstances the breach of Section 25-H of the Act has been fully established and the workmen were entitled for the relief.
10. The vital question now for consideration is what relief could be granted to the concerned workmen in the facts and circumstances of the present case. As clear from the policy adopted for the recruitment on the post of clerks, which has been filed as Annexure 3 to the writ petition, and has been mentioned above, it is clear that the petitioner could employ clerks directly also in case the Banking Service Recruitment Board or Employment Exchange is not in a position to provide approved persons. Para 2 of the policy is very material which is being reproduced below:—
“Para 2: Further the requisition of candidates for temporary appointments in clerical cadre should be made from the respective Banking Service Recruitment Boards. If Banking Service Recruitment Board is not in a position to provide approved persons, the candidates should be requisitioned from the local Employment Exchange. If the Boards as well as the Employment Exchanges, wherever these exist, are not able to provide the candidates, the branches may be allowed to make their own arrangements strictly according to the norms.”
11. There is no averment in the writ petition as to in what manner the posts on which the respondent-workmen had worked were filled. The policy adopted does not contain a complete prohibition that the recruitment to such post could be made through the Banking Service Recruitment Board and not otherwise. In the circumstances, after this long period of 15 years it will neither be proper not just nor in the ends of justice to relegate the concerned workmen to any test conducted by the Banking Service Recruitment Board to judge their suitability for the post. In my opinion the facts of the present case are distinguishable from the facts of the case before Hon'ble the Supreme Court reported in Judgment Today 1996 (10) S.C 329. In case before Hon'ble Supreme Court there were Rules providing procedure for recruitment against which appointment could not be made. Thus, the Tribunal was perfectly justified in giving relief of reinstatement to the respondents workmen and the award does not suffer from any error of law. The petitions have no merit and are accordingly dismissed. However, their will be no order as to costs.
12. Petitions Dismissed.
Alert