- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Pawankumar Srivastava v. Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, appointed as Chemist Grade-II on 12 August 1977, was regularised and later confirmed in service. He was the General Secretary of the Uttar Pradesh Vidyul Mazdoor Sangh (a registered trade union affiliated to Bharatiya Mazdoor Sangh). Political complaints were made against him by Respondent 6 (City President, Bahujan Samaj Party) alleging harassment and communal activities. These complaints were forwarded through political channels including the Education Minister and to the Chief Minister.
A sequence of official communications followed: the Education Minister wrote requesting transfer; the Secretary to the Chief Minister wrote to the Chairman of the Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board requesting the petitioner’s transfer; the Chairman noted and directed the Secretary to transfer the petitioner. A transfer order dated 14 June 1994 moved the petitioner from Harduaganj to Anpara; a subsequent order dated 16 July 1994 modified the transfer to Tanda.
The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging the transfer orders as mala fide and politically motivated rather than based on administrative exigency or public interest. Respondents filed a short counter-affidavit (stating petitioner was relieved on 18 June 1994) followed by a supplementary counter-affidavit asserting administrative grounds (vacancy for Chemist Grade-II at Anpara, long stay at Harduaganj) and denying that the transfer was ordered on the basis of political letters. The petitioner filed a rejoinder denying service of the relieving order and disputing the genuineness of the stated vacancy demand.
The Court considered the documentary record, parties' affidavits and cited precedents, and ultimately allowed the writ petition, setting aside the impugned transfer orders dated 14 June 1994 and 16 July 1994. There was no order as to costs.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the impugned transfer orders (dated 14 June 1994 and 16 July 1994) were motivated by political considerations and thus vitiated by mala fide.
- Whether the transfer was made on valid administrative exigency or in the public interest, or instead resulted from political influence and complaints without proper administrative enquiry.
- Whether the writ petition challenging the transfers should be allowed and the transfer orders set aside on the ground of mala fide political consideration.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The transfers were prompted by false political allegations made by Respondent 6 and others, alleging harassment of backward classes and communal activities, without any assessment or enquiry into the truth of those allegations.
- The transfer orders were mala fide, motivated by political rivalry, and not justified by administrative exigency or public interest.
- Documents (Annexures) show the transfer was effected on political reference and influence (letters from political actors and ministerial communications), and there was no record of consideration of administrative need or public interest.
- The stated demand for a Chemist Grade-II at Anpara (dated 5 May 1994) was mala fide, given earlier transfers to Anpara in 1992 and 1993 that were subsequently cancelled, suggesting the vacancy claim was being used as a pretext.
Respondents' Arguments
- Initially stated only that the petitioner was relieved on 18 June 1994.
- In a supplementary counter-affidavit, respondents asserted there were earlier complaints and a 1992 recommendation for transfer, and that Anpara had requested a Chemist Grade-II for a vacant post on 5 April 1994.
- Respondents contended the transfer was made due to administrative exigencies: requirement of a Chemist Grade-II at Anpara and the petitioner’s long stay at Harduaganj.
- Respondents denied that the transfer was issued based on political letters or at the direction of the Education Minister, asserting it was issued in the interest of the Board and not under political direction; they also said the place of transfer was later changed to accommodate the petitioner.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sheo Kumar Sharma v. Basic Shiksha Adhikari, Kanpur Dehal [(1991) I UPLEBEC 690] | Minister should not pass transfer orders directly; if a public representative has adverse information, it should be forwarded to competent authority for consideration; direct interference by directing transfer is incompatible with rule of law. | The Court relied on this case to support the proposition that ministerial or political directives effectuating transfers are improper and that transfers should be based on administrative process, not political diktat. |
| Tulsi Ram v. State [1993 HVD Vol. II (All) 79] | Orders passed at the dictate of a Minister (not in the officer's own discretion) are unlawful; suspension quashed where it was at the Minister's dictate. | Used to reinforce that actions taken under ministerial dictate, rather than independent administrative decision-making, are vulnerable to being set aside. |
| Pradeep Kumar Agarwal v. Director Local Bodies, Uttar Pradesh [1994 HVD Vol. I (All) 6] | Transfers must be for administrative exigency and public interest, not on basis of political pressure. | Cited as authority that political pressure is not a proper basis for transfers; Court relied on its reasoning to find the impugned transfers improper. |
| F.P. Rayappa v. State of Tamil Nadu [(1974) 4 SCC 3 : A.I.R 1974 S.C 555] | Chief Minister, as head of government, is politically answerable and may in larger interest shift the Chief Secretary if confidence is forfeited; principles relate to transfer at senior levels. | The Court observed this authority was in the special context of the Chief Secretary and did not lay down general principles applicable to the present case of a lower-level employee; therefore it was not directly applicable. |
| Shanti Kumari v. Regional Deputy Director, Health Services, Patna [1981 — II L.L.N 485] | Transfer may be due to exigency of service or administrative reason and courts generally should not interfere. | The Court noted this principle but considered it inapplicable where mala fide is alleged; the case did not consider a mala fide challenge. |
| Gujarat Electricity Board v. Atma Ram. Sungomal Posham [1989 — II L.L.N 299] | Consideration of consequences of not obeying a transfer order (context-specific). | The Court found this case not applicable to the present dispute, which concerned the validity of the transfer order itself rather than consequences of non-compliance. |
| Smt. Shilpi Bose v. State of Bihar [1992 — I L.L.N 7] | Courts should not interfere with a transfer made in public interest and for administrative reasons unless vitiated by mala fide or violation of mandatory statutory rule. | The Court held this principle did not assist the respondents because the present challenge alleged mala fide political consideration; Shilpi Bose therefore did not help respondents. |
| M. Sankaranarayanan, I.A.S. v. State of Karnataka [1993 — I L.L.N 215] | Case concerned transfer of Chief Secretary; special circumstances of that senior office. | The Court considered it inapplicable to the petitioner's level and circumstances, and thus not helpful to respondents. |
| Union of India v. S.I. Abbas [1993 — II L.L.N 473] | Government guidelines should be considered in transfers but do not create enforceable legal rights; court interference only if order is vitiated by mala fide or statutory violation. | The Court noted this holding but observed respondents could not rely on it because the present case involved an allegation of mala fide political consideration in the transfer. |
| S. Partap Singh v. State Of Punjab, A.I.R 1964 S.C 72 | Law regarding exercise of power and corrupt motive (seven-fold arguments referenced); authority on corrupt motive vitiating administrative action. | The Court relied on this case to support the proposition that where corrupt motive or improper political influence is shown, the exercise of transfer power is vitiated; it contributed to the conclusion that the impugned transfers could not stand. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the documentary trail (political letters, ministerial correspondence and internal notings) and the affidavits filed by the parties. The Court's reasoning proceeded along the following lines:
- Documentary Record: The Court found documentary evidence ( Annexures referred to in the petition ) showing that political actors made complaints and the Education Minister forwarded a request to transfer the petitioner to the Chief Minister. The Secretary to the Chief Minister wrote to the Chairman of the Board asking him to pursue that letter and effect transfer, and the Chairman’s noting directed the Secretary to transfer the petitioner.
- Absence of Administrative Justification: No record was produced showing that any competent authority considered the transfer from the standpoint of administrative exigency or public interest. The denials in the respondents' affidavits were not supported by contemporaneous documents and were not convincing to the Court.
- Chain of Political Influence: The sequence of letters and the notings (Education Minister → Chief Minister → Secretary → Chairman → Secretary) demonstrated that the transfer was effected pursuant to political direction or influence rather than an independent administrative decision.
- Applicability of Authorities: The Court reviewed case law. It distinguished decisions that applied to transfers at the highest administrative levels (e.g., Chief Secretary) and noted that authorities endorsing non-interference in transfers for administrative reasons do not assist respondents where mala fide is alleged. It relied on precedents holding that transfers motivated by political considerations or ministerial dictate are unlawful.
- Conclusion on Mala Fide: On the admitted documents and the absence of credible administrative justification, the Court concluded the transfers were motivated by political complaints and influence and were therefore mala fide. The Court held that no further fact-finding was required because the admitted documentary record sufficed to decide the matter.
Holding and Implications
Writ petition allowed; the impugned transfer orders dated 14 June 1994 and 16 July 1994 are set aside.
Implications:
- The direct effect is that the two specific transfer orders challenged in the petition have been quashed and the petitioner succeeds in the writ petition.
- There was no order as to costs.
- The opinion does not purport to establish a new general precedent beyond applying existing principles: it enforces the rule that transfers effected by political pressure or ministerial dictate without administrative justification are liable to be set aside. The Court distinguished authorities that are inapplicable because of differences in rank or context, and relied on precedents that condemn political interference in administrative transfers.
1. The petitioner has challenged the orders, dated 14 June, 1994 and 16 July, 1994 transferring the petitioner from Hardauganj.
2. The case made out in the writ petition in brief is as follows:
3. The petitioner was appointed on the post of Chemist Grade-II on 12 August, 1977 and was regularised on the post by memorandum, dated 21 January, 1994 with effect from 12 August, 1982 and was confirmed with effect from 1 April, 1986 by memorandum, dated 26 February, 1994. The petitioners service was meritorious and he was twice given the time-bound pay-scale. The petitioner is the General Secretary of the Uttar Pradesh Vidyul Mazdoor Sangh which is a registered trade union and is affiliated to Bhartiya Mazdoor Sangh a federation of trade unions duly recognised by Government of India. The respondent 6, the City President. Bahujan Samaj Party by letter, dated 3 May, 1994, made false allegations against the petitioner to the Chief Minister of the State. The substance of the allegations was harassing the members of the backward class and blackmailing them. The said letter at Annexure 3 to the writ petition also enclosed a letter addressed to the Chief Minister, dated 1 May, 1994, wherein similar allegations were made Respondent 6, the City President of Bahujan Samaj Party handed over his letter, dated 3 May, 1994 to the then Education Minister of Uttar Pradesh. The Education Minister wrote a letter to the Chief Minister, dated 11 May, 1991 (Annexure 5 to the writ petition) wherein complaint was made against the petitioner of communal activities and thereby harassing the members of backward class with a request to transfer the petitioner to some other place. The Secretary to the Chief Minister by his letter, dated 20 May, 1994 addressed the Chairman. Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board, asking him to pursue the letter of Education Minister dated 11 May, 1994 and the request of the Chief Minister to transfer the petitioner from Harduaganj. He further stated that the Chief Minister desired the transfer and so to act accordingly and to intimate the Education Minister about the same. On the said letter the direction of the Chairman. Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board has been noted directing the Secretary to transfer the petitioner to Tanda. Such noting was made on 27 May, 1994. The Said letter itself indicates action taken by the authorities on such direction from the Chief Minister admittedly on the basis of the letter, of the Education Minister. Ultimately, the transfer order., dated 14, June 1994 (Annexure I to the writ petition) was issued transferring the petitioner from Harduaganj to Anpara. The said transfer order was followed by another order dated 16 July, 1994 (Annexure 2 to the writ petition) whereby the earlier transfer order, dated 14 June, 1994 was partially modified by making the transfer to Tanda instead of Anpara. The petitioner contends that the said transfer order is only on complaint from political people against the petitioner because of political rivalry and without any assessment as to the truth of the said allegations by any appropriate authority at all. Thus, the transfer order being absolutely mala fide and not on administrative exigency or in public interest is liable to be set aside.
4. The respondents contested the proceeding initially by filing a short counter-affidavit disclosing the only fact that the petitioner already stood relieved on 18 June, 1994. The said short counter-affidavit was followed by a supplementary counter-affidavit. In the said supplementary counter-affidavit, the respondent contend that on certain complaints against the petitioner of the year 1992 and a recommendation for his transfer on such complaints in the year 1992 and that by communication, dated 5 April, 1994. The Project at Anpara requested for posting one Chemist Grade II for a vacant post there. It has been stated that considering the overall circumstances and administrative exigencies as also the requirement of the Chemist Grade II at Anpara and the long stay of the petitioner at Harduaganj, the impugned transfer order, dated 14 June, 1994 was issued. It has further been stated that upon a communication by the President. Akhil Bhartiya Vidyut Mazdoor Sangh and keeping in view the difficulty of the petitioner the place of his transfer was changed from Anpara to Tanda. The letters at the various levels of the Political people and the Ministers were not denied but it has been contended that the transfer of the petitioner was not issued on the basis of the said letter and that the transfer order was issued only on administrative ground in the interest of the Board and not on complaints, or under the direction of the Education Minister.
5. The petitioner by filing the rejoined affidavit denied service of the letter, dated 18 June, 1994 relieving him from Harjuaganj. The petitioner also contends that two persons. Lekhraj Singh and Sunil Kumar Gupta both Chemist Grade-II were transferred from Harduaganj to Anpara in 1992 and 1993 respectively and the writ petition by Lekhraj Singh challenging such transfer order was dismissed by this Court on 23 September, 1993 but still such transfers were cancelled by order, dated 5 May, 1994, The petitioner contends that the said fact itself shows that the demand for Chemist Grade-II on 5 May, 1994 is mala fide and is being used as a defence.
6. The contentions of the petitioner relying upon the documents annexed to the writ petition particularly at Annexures 1 and 2 indicate that the transfer order was passed on political reference without any enquiry by any competent officer. The Chairman of the Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board appears to have put an instruction upon the Secretary of the Board to effect transfer of the petitioner. No record has been produced showing consideration of any administrative exigency or public interest in respect of the transfer of the petitioner. The denials made in the counter-affidavit do not bear support from any document or records produced at the time of hearing and also do not appear to be convincing. The complaint of the political personnel, its reference by the Education Minister and the instruction of the Chief Minister on than basis followed by the direction of the Chairman of the Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board for transfer upon the letter written on behalf of the Chief Minister show convincingly that the entire matter of transfer of the petitioner was based on political complaint and influence. It does not appear for what reason the Education Minister was acting in the matter of transfer of a employee of Uttar Pradesh state Electricity Board and the only consideration was political. It does not appear that the Chief Minister considered the matter as the Head of the State and no record was produced at the time of hearing showing the consideration of matter by the Chief Minister as Head of the State. On the contrary, the letter at Annexure 6 simply refers to the letter of the Education Minister requesting for transfer of the petitioner which was the basis of the direction of the Chief Minister also the said letter at Annexure 6 itself bears the instruction of the Chairman. Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board, to the Secretary directing transfer of the petitioner from Hardinaganj. In the said ??? of the case. I am convinced that the petitioners transfer was on political consideration and complaints and not at all was considered from the angle of administrative exigency of public interest
7. The learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the case of Sheo Kumar Sharma v. Basic Shiksha Adhikari, Kanpur Dehal, [(1991) I UPLEBEC 690], The observation of the High Court in the said case is as follows:
“It is regretted that a Minister should pass a transfer order which function is to be discharged by the competent authority in the Department. If any thing adverse to the conduct of the incumbent comes to the knowledge of the Vidhayak or some other public representative then he may forward it to the competent authority requesting him to consider the same and do the needful in the matter, but interference by directing transfer straightway is not compatible to the principles of rules of law by which a country having democratic set up is to be governed All the persons in position should know that this is not the Government of the men howsoever high position they may occupy but is the Government of laws.”
8. Learned counsel also referred to the case of Tulsi Ram v. State, [1993 HVD Vol. II (All) 79]. wherein the order of suspension passed by the Food Commissioner was quashed holding that the order was passed not in his own discretion but at the dictate of the Minister and as such is not lawful. The further reference was made to the case of Pradeep Kumar Agarwal v. Director Local Bodies, Uttar Pradesh, [1994 HVD Vol. I (All) 6], Therein the Division Bench of this Court was pleased to hold that transfer is to be done only in administrative exigencies and in public interest not on the basis of political pressure. Considering the facts of the case it was observed by the Division Bench:
“…………transfers are to be done only in administrative exigencies and in public interest, but in the instant case the letter written by the aforesaid Madhya Pradesh Addressed to Minister for Urban Development bearing endorsement of the officers of the State Government indicates that instant transfer has neither been made in administrative exigency nor in public interest. It is not only a matter of surprise but highly objectionable that bureaucrats are dancing at the tunes of such letters ignoring the well settled norms meant for transfer.”
9. On behalf of the respondents reference was made to various cases laying down the law relating to transfer. The first reference was made to the case of F.P Rayappa v. State of Tamil Nadu, [(1974) 4 SCC 3 : A.I.R 1974 S.C 555]. In the said case the transfer of the Chief Secretary of the State was being considered in the background that the Chief Minister as the Head of the Government is in ultimate charge of the administration and it is he who is politically answerable to the people for the achievement and failure of the Government and therefore, if for am valid reason, the Chief Secretary forfeits the confidence of the Chief Minister, the Chief Minister may ultimately in the larger interest of administration shift the Chief Secretary to another post. The said case upon perusal, appears to be on the principles laid down in the aforesaid background and the same does not lay down the general principles of transfer. The next case referred was the case of Shanti Kumari v. Regional Deputy Director, Health Services, Patna, [1981 — II L.L.N 485]. wherein it has been held that transfer of a Government servant may be due to exigency of service or due to administrative reason and the Courts cannot interfere in such matters. The said principle also docs not apply, in my opinion, in the present case as no allegation of mala fide was being considered therein. Similarly, the next case referred to on behalf of the respondents being the case of (Gujarat Electricity Board v. Atma Ram. Sungomal Posham, [1989 — II L.L.N 299] also is not applicable in the present case as the consequences of not obeying the transfer order was the subject-matter of consideration therein. Similarly the case of Smt. Shilpi Bose v. State of Bihar, [1992 — I L.L.N 7]. does not help the respondents as the findings therein is that the Courts should not interfere with a transfer order which is made in public interest and for administrative reasons unless the transfer order is made in violation of any mandatory statutory rule or on the ground of mala fide. The present case, in any event, being one wherein transfer order has been challenged on the ground of political consideration and as such mala fide, the law laid down in the case of Shilpi Rose (vide supra) docs not help the respondents. Similarly, the case of M. Sankaranarayanan. I.A.S v. State of Karnataka, [1993 — I L.L.N 215]. is also the case of transfer of the Chief Secretary and the special circumstances in view of the relation between the Chief Secretary and the Chief Minister being the sole consideration, the law laid down therein docs not help the respondents in the present case. Again the case of Union of India v. S.I Abbas, [1993 — II L.L.N 473]. and relied upon by the respondents does hot help the respondents in the present case as the consideration therein is that guidelines issued by the Government though must be kept in mind while ordering the transfer of Government employee, but the said guidelines do not confer upon the Government employee a legal enforceable right and unless the order of transfer is vitiated by mala fide or is made in violation of any statutory provision, the Court cannot interfere with it.
10. The seven fold arguments of the respondents relying upon the law as aforesaid cannot help upholding the impugned transfer order particularly in view of the fact that the respondents” case of impugned transfer on administrative ground or in public interest, has not been found to be believable. In view of the law laid down in respect of exercise of power and the corrupt motive in Paras. 6 and 7 of the case of S. Partap Singh v. State Of Punjab., [A.I.R 1964 S.C 72], the contentions of the respondents relating to mala fide and consequent maintainability of the writ petition are not tenable. The contention relating to requirement at Anpara also cannot stand as transfer, as it stands ultimately is to Tanda not at Anpara. As to the disputed question of fact relating to administrative ground, the objection cannot stand in view of the fact that the matter can be decided from the admitted documents and no further enquiry is required to be made. The contention relating to the power to transfer even on complaints by political parties treating the same to be administrative ground is in my opinion, misconceived as political considerations have been held to be not proper consideration in the matter of administrative functions particularly in the level of the petitioner. In this respect the observations of this Court referred to hereinabove made in the case of Sheo Kumar Sharma and Pradeep Kumar. Agarwal (vide supra) are relevant.
11. In the aforesaid background on fact as it has been found hereinabove and in law as discussed herein, the impugned transfer order cannot stand. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The impugned orders of transfer at Annexures 1 and 2 to the writ petition, dated 14 June, 1994 and 16 July, 1994, respectively are set aside. There will be no order as to costs.
Alert