Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ajib Singh And Others Etc. v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Another

Allahabad High Court
Jul 23, 1992
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Two writ petitions were filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenging:

  • The notification dated 22-6-1983 issued under Section 4(1) read with Section 17(4) of the Land Acquisition Act; and
  • The notification dated 23-6-1983 issued under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act (published in the U.P. Gazette on 28-6-1983).

The Section 4 notification stated the land was required for construction of a godown, residential quarters for workers and allied works by the Bazpur Co-operative Sugar Factory Limited, Bazpur (district Nainital), and declared the land urgently required such that the enquiry under Section 5-A was dispensed with.

Initially the State of U.P. and the Collector/Land Acquisition Officer, Nainital were respondents. Subsequently Bazpur Co-operative Sugar Factory Limited was impleaded as a respondent. The petitions challenged validity of the impugned notifications on several grounds. The court heard the petitioners' counsel, the State Standing Counsel, and counsel for the newly impleaded respondent.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the absence of a public notice of the substance of the Section 4 notification (in the locality) invalidates the notification when the notification was issued under Section 4(1) read with Section 17(4), dispensing with Section 5-A.
  2. Whether acquisition proceedings are invalid because the acquisition is for a company and (allegedly) Chapter VII of the Land Acquisition Act (and Company Rules) was not complied with.
  3. Whether the State Government applied its mind before dispensing with Section 5-A (i.e., whether the decision to treat the acquisition as urgent was arbitrary or mala fide).
  4. What remedy is appropriate if there were constructions on the land prior to the date of the Section 4 notification (whether exemption for those portions should be considered).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • No publicity or public notice: The Collector did not publish the substance of the notification at any conspicuous place, did not publicise it in the locality, and did not serve notice on the petitioners or other tenure-holders whose land was sought to be acquired; therefore the notifications are invalid.
  • Non-compliance with Chapter VII / Company rules: Because the acquisition was for a company, the respondents failed to comply with Chapter VII of the Land Acquisition Act (and related Company Rules), rendering the proceedings illegal.
  • No application of mind / mala fide: The State Government did not apply its mind on urgency when dispensing with Section 5-A and the direction dispensing with Section 5-A was arbitrary and mala fide.
  • Pre-existing constructions: There existed constructions on the land prior to the Section 4 notification; in the interest of justice those portions should be exempted and the Collector should have considered this before acquisition.

Respondents' Positions (State / Collector / Bazpur Co-op Sugar Factory Limited)

  • The District and Land Acquisition Officer denied the petitioners' allegations that publicity and notices were not given; but acknowledged that under the Land Acquisition (U.P. Amendment and Validation) Act VIII of 1974 the public notice of the Section 4 notification was not required where Section 17(4) had been invoked.
  • Regarding Chapter VII, the District Land Acquisition Officer stated the Section 6 notification explicitly declared that part of the compensation would be paid out of public revenues of the State; on that basis it was asserted that the provisions of Chapter VII and Company Rules 1963 were not applicable where part of the amount is payable by the State.
  • The State filed a detailed counter-affidavit showing that the Government considered the acquisition proposal carefully, noted prior proceedings (an earlier notification of 24-2-1976 which was not finalized), and observed that expansion of the mill and erection of a distillery made storage (godown) and workers' quarters urgently needed; sugar's perishable nature and hardship to labour were relied on as justification for dispensing with Section 5-A.
  • No allegation of mala fide was specifically pleaded by the petitioners in the petition, according to the court's recital.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Manubhai Jethalal v. State of Gujarat ((1983) 4 SCC 553; AIR 1984 SC 120) Held that even a contribution of Re. 1 from public revenue was adequate to hold that acquisition was for a public purpose; consequentially provisions of Part VII (Company Acquisition Rules) would be effective in such an acquisition. The court stated the principle was fully applicable to the present facts, observed that the purposes (godown, labour quarters) are on their face public purposes and that part of the compensation is to be contributed by the State; on that basis the court found the petitioners' contention about applicability of Part VII to be unsubstantial.
State of U.P. v. Smt. Pista Devi ((1986) 4 SCC 251; AIR 1986 SC 2025) The Supreme Court observed that housing accommodation can be a matter of national urgency and that judicial notice could be taken; therefore, in proceedings for land acquisition for housing sites it could be appropriate to dispense with Section 5-A. The court relied on this authority to support the view that dispensing with Section 5-A in cases involving urgent needs for housing (and related public purposes) may be appropriate; this authority contributed to rejecting the petitioners' challenge that the State had not applied its mind or that the dispensing was arbitrary.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in distinct steps, each tied to the petitioners' submissions and the statutory framework:

  1. Textual and statutory interpretation of Section 4(1): The court quoted Section 4(1)'s requirement that a notification be published in the Official Gazette and that the Collector cause public notice of the substance of the notification to be given at a convenient place in the locality. It then considered the amendment made by the Land Acquisition (U.P. Amendment and Validation) Act VIII of 1974 which inserted a clause deeming that, where a direction under Section 17(4) dispenses with Section 5-A, the Collector's obligation to give public notice of the substance of the notification is not applicable.

    Conclusion: The statutory amendment removes the requirement of giving public notice of the substance of the notification in cases where Section 17(4) has been invoked. Consequently, absence of such public notice did not invalidate the Section 4 notification in this case.

  2. Applicability of Part VII / Company Rules: The court examined the Section 6 notification which stated that the compensation would be paid partly out of public revenue. The District Land Acquisition Officer had averred this in the counter-affidavit and no affidavit in the petition denied that part of the compensation would be borne by the State's public revenue.

    Having regard to the Manubhai Jethalal principle (even a token contribution from public revenue can make the acquisition public in character), the court treated the acquisition as for a public purpose and concluded the petitioners' challenge on the ground of non-compliance with Chapter VII/Company Rules was not substantiated.

  3. Whether the State applied its mind or acted mala fide in dispensing with Section 5-A: The court noted there was no pleaded allegation of mala fide. The State's counter-affidavit set out factual reasons: earlier proceedings and notification of February 1976 that had not been finalized, subsequent expansion of the co-operative mill, erection of a distillery, continuing inability to construct godown and workers' quarters for seven years causing hardship, and the perishable nature of sugar as factors establishing urgency.

    On these facts and in light of the Pista Devi authority, the court concluded the State had applied its mind and the decision to dispense with Section 5-A was not arbitrary.

  4. Pre-existing constructions on the land: The court recognized petitioners' claim that constructions existed prior to the Section 4 notification and considered this a matter that should be investigated at the Collector level. Rather than annulling the acquisition, the court framed a remedial process: petitioners may make representations; the Collector must investigate, survey the plots, consider materials and the record, and decide; if constructions pre-dated the notification, the Collector would recommend exemption for the relevant portions to the State Government. Further recourse to the Government is permitted if the Collector's decision is adverse.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petitions were dismissed.

Direct Consequences / Directions (as ordered by the Court)

  • Petitioners were permitted to make representations to the Collector for exemption of any portion of their land on which constructions (residential, commercial or industrial) existed prior to the Section 4 notification; such representations must be filed within two months from the date of the judgment.
  • If representations are filed, the Collector must investigate, survey the concerned plots, consider the petitioners' material and the Collector's record, provide intimations to concerned parties of the date of consideration, and decide the matter — preferably within two months from receipt of the judgment. The Collector shall communicate the decision to concerned parties within two weeks thereafter.
  • If the Collector finds the constructions were pre-notification, he will recommend to the State Government exemption of only those portions where constructions exist. If the Collector decides against any petitioner, the petitioner may make a representation to the Government within one month of the Collector's decision; the Government will consider the grievance and pass appropriate orders expeditiously.
  • Till the Government decides the question of grant of exemption, status quo as on the date of the judgment shall be maintained by the parties.
  • Each party to bear their own costs.

Wider Legal Implications

The court applied existing statutory amendment (Land Acquisition (U.P. Amendment and Validation) Act VIII of 1974) and binding precedents (Manubhai Jethalal; State of U.P. v. Smt. Pista Devi) to reject the petitioners' challenges. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new principle of law; it relied on established authorities and statutory text to resolve the disputes in the petitions and confined relief to procedural directions for dealing with claims of pre-notification constructions.

Show all summary ...

S.D Agarwala, J.:— These are two petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenging the notification dated 22-6-1983 issued under Section 4(1) read with Section 17(4) of the Land Acquisition Act (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) as well as the notification dated 23-6-1983 issued under Section 6 of the Act. The notification under Section 4 of the Act was published in the U.P Gazette on 22-6-1983 and the notification under Section 6 of the Act was published in the U.P Gazette on 28th of June 1983.

2. In the notification issued under Section 4 of the Act, it was categorically stated that the land in dispute was required for the construction of godown, residential quarters for its workers and other allied works by the Bazpur Co-operative Sugar Factory Limited Bazipur in district Nainital. In the notification, further, it was stated that the land was urgently required for the above public purpose and consequently, the enquiry under Section 5-A of the Act was being dispensed with.

3. Initially, when the petition was filed the State of U.P and the Collector/Land Acquisition Officer, Nainital were made respondents in the petition. Thereafter, the applications were made on behalf of the Bazpur Co-operative Sugar Factory Limited Bazipur, district Nainital for whose purpose the land was sought to be acquired for being impleaded as respondent in these petitions. Bazpur Co-operative Sugar Factory Limited was allowed to be impleaded as a respondent in these petitions.

4. We have heard the learned counsel for the petitioners in both these petitions and the learned Standing Counsel and Sri A.K Misra learned counsel for the newly added respondent, Bazpur Co-operative Sugar Factory Limited. Learned counsel for the petitioners have raised various contentions before us challenging the impugned notifications. The first submission raised by the learned counsel is that since the Collector did not publish any notice of the substance of the notification at any conspicuous place in the locality nor any publicity was given to the said notification nor any notice was served on the petitioner or any other tenure-holder whose land was sought to be acquired and as such the impugned notifications are invalid in law and cannot be given effect to.

5. In support of the petitioners' contention, the only allegation made in the petition is in paragraphs 8 and 9. In paragraph 8, it has been stated that no publicity was given nor any notice was issued under the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act in regard to the notifications. In paragraph 9, however, it has been stated that the Collector did not publish any notice of the substance of the notifications at any conspicuous place in the locality nor any notice was given to the persons whose land was sought to be acquired.

6. Sri J.C Kukreti, District and Land Acquisition Officer, Nainital has filed a counter-affidavit. In paragraph 7 of the counter-affidavit, the contents of paragraphs 8 and 9 of the petition have been denied. In paragraph 8 of the petition, however, it has been categorically stated that in view of the Land Acquisition (U.P Amendment and Validation) Act VIII of 1974 the public notice of the notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act was not required where the provisions of Section 17(4) of the Act have been invoked. The resultant effect is that it is not disputed that the public notice as required under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act was not given.

7. The question that arises for consideration is whether in the absence of the public notice, the notification under Section 4 of the Act can be given effect to.

8. Section 4(1) which is relevant for determining the present controversy reads as follows:

“Publication of Preliminary Notification and Powers of Officers Thereupon — (1) Whenever it appears to the (appropriate Government) that land in any locality (is needed or) is likely to be needed for any public purpose (or for a company), a notification to that effect shall be published in the Official Gazette (and in two daily newspapers circulating in that locality of which at least-one shall be in the regional language) and the Collector shall cause public notice of the substance of such notification to be given at convenient place in the said locality (the last of the dates of such publication and the giving of such public notice, being hereinafter referred to as the date of the publication of the notification)”.

9. By the Land Acquisition (U.P Amendment and Validation) Act VIII of 1974, in sub-section (1) of Section 4, between the words “and” and the “Collector” the following clause was inserted and be deemed always to have been inserted, namely:

“except in the case of any land to which by virtue of a direction of the State Government under sub-section (4) of Section 17, the provisions of Section 5-A shall not apply.”

10. On a reading of sub-section (1) of Section 4 along with the amendment made by the 1974 Act, it is clear that the public notice as contemplated by Section 4(1) of the Act is not applicable to a case where the notification has been issued under Section 4(1) read with Section 17(4) dispensing with the provisions of Section 5-A of the Act. In view of this position of the law, it is, therefore, clear that merely because public notice was not given of the substance of the notification under Section 4 in the locality it would not invalidate the notification. Since Section 5-A of the Act has been dispensed with, the question of issuing notices to the persons whose land were sought to be acquired does not arise. Consequently, we do not find any substance in the first submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioner.

11. The second submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioner is that the acquisition being for a company and the respondents have not complied with the provisions of Chapter VII of the Land Acquisition Act, the entire acquisition proceedings are invalid and bad in law.

12. In paragraph 16 of the writ petition, a bald allegation has been made that since the acquisition is for a company and no compliance having been made with the requirement of Chapter VII of the Land Acquisition Act, the acquisition proceedings are illegal. There is no specific allegation as to which part of Chapter VII of the Land Acquisition Act has been complied with.

13. In the counter-affidavit of Sri J.C Kukreti, the District Land Acquisition Officer, Nainital, reply of this paragraph has been given in paragraph 13 of the counter-affidavit in which it has been categorically stated that in the notification under Section 6 of the Act, it has been categorically stated that the amount of compensation to be awarded is to be paid partly out of the public revenues of the State and consequently the provisions of Chapter VII of the Land Acquisition Act and Company Rules 1963 are not applicable in a case where a part of the amount is payable by the State.

14. We have examined the notification under Section 6 of the Act. In the said notification, it has been categorically stated that the amount of compensation to be awarded for compensation of the acquisition of the land shall be paid partly out of the revenues of the State. There is no averment in the petition or in any other affidavit filed in this Court denying that part of the compensation has not been paid out of the public revenue of the State. In the circumstances, the question which we have to consider is as to whether the provisions of Part VII of the Land Acquisition Act is applicable in a case where the part of the compensation is paid out of the public revenues of the State in a case where acquisition is made for public purpose.

15. In Manubhai Jethalal v. State of Gujarat reported in (1983) 4 SCC 553 : AIR 1984 SC 120, it has been categorically held that even a contribution of Re. 1/- from the said revenue was held adequate to hold that the acquisition was for public purpose and consequently, the provisions of Part VII in the Company Acquisition Rules would be effective in such an acquisition. The principle laid down in this case is fully applicable to the facts of the present case. The purpose for which the instant acquisition is made is for the purpose of constructing godown, residential quarters for its workers and other allied works by the Bazpur Co-operative Sugar Factory Limited. These purposes, on the face of it, are public purpose and consequently, one part of the compensation is being contributed by the State. Thus the question of the applicability of the provisions of Part VII of the Land Acquisition Act and Company Rules does not arise. The second submission made by the learned counsel, in our opinion, is not substantiated.

16. The third submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioner is that in the instant case the State Government did not apply its mind on the question of urgency and consequently, the direction issued dispensing with the provisions of Section 5-A of the Act is wholly arbitrary. In this connection, it has been further urged that the action of the State Government in dispensing with the provisions of Section 5-A of the Act is mala fide.

17. So far as the question of mala fide is concerned, there is no allegation in the petition and as such, it is not open to the petitioner to take this ground. So far as the question of the applicability of the mind by the State Government is concerned, the factual position is as follows:

18. In paragraph 13 of the writ petition, it has been alleged that there was nothing on the record before the Governor to form an opinion that it was a matter of urgency in which dispensing with the requirement of Section 5-A of the Act was necessary. In paragraph 15 of the petition, it has been further stated that the impugned notification has been issued arbitrarily and without application of mind. Sri R.K Gupta has filed a counter-affidavit on behalf of the State in which detail facts have been given as to why the State Government thought it fit to dispense with the provisions of Section 5-A of the Act. It has been stated that the State Government considered the proposal of acquisition of the land in question in great depth and after satisfying itself that the acquisition was urgently needed for the construction of sugar godown and constructions of labours quarters, the provisions of Section 5-A of the Act has been dispensed with. It has been further stated that the notification in respect of the land was no doubt earlier issued on 24-2-1976. The final notification could not be issued due to various reasons and the proceedings were dropped. Since then the co-operative sugar mill, Bazpur was expanded and a distillery has been erected by the Mills but the godown and quarters of workers could not be constructed for the last seven years resulting in great hardship for storage of sugar and providing accommodation to labour class. Sugar is a perishable item which can be easily damaged by moisture and rains and needs proper storage facilities. Similarly, labours are also to be provided with the proper residential accommodation. It was after considering these facts that the State Government came to the conclusion that it was a matter of urgency and provisions of Section 5-A of the Act be dispensed with.

19. From the facts stated in the counter-affidavit on behalf of the State Government, we are of the opinion that it cannot be said that the State Government did not apply its mind for dispensing with the provisions of Section 5-A of the Act and neither it can be said that the said decision was arbitrary. In the State of U.P v. Smt. Pista Devi, (1986) 4 SCC 251 : AIR 1986 SC 2025, the Hon'ble Supreme Court had an occasion to consider the validity of the notification under Section 4 of the Act wherein Section 5-A of the Act had been dispensed with. It has been observed by the Supreme Court that the provisions of housing accommodation has become a matter of national urgency. Judicial notice can be taken of this fact and as such it took the view that in the case of proceedings relating to acquisition of land for providing housing sites, it would be appropriate to dispense with the provisions of Section 5-A of the Act. In the facts and circumstances of this case, we are of the opinion that the third submission raised on behalf of the petitioner is not substantiated.

20. The last submission which has been made by the learned counsel for the petitioner is that there was certain constructions already existing on the land prior to the date of the issue of the notification under Section 4 of the Act. If that be so, in the interest of justice, we think it proper that the said question should have been considered by the Collector before acquiring the land.

21. In the result, both the writ petitions fail and are dismissed with the following directions:

22. It will be open to the petitioners to make representation before the Collector concerned for exemption of their land on which there existed constructions, residential commercial and industrial before publication of the impugned notification under Section 4 of the Act, within two months from today. If such representations are filed before the Collector, he will investigate into the matter and get the plots concerned surveyed and thereafter decide it on the basis of the material produced by the petitioners and its own record, after sending intimations to the concerned parties of the date on which the matter will be considered by it. This decision shall be taken by the Collector as far as possible within two months from the date of receipt of the judgment. The decision so taken shall be communicated to the concerned parties within two weeks thereafter. In case, the Collector finds that the petitioners' constructions were pre-notification constructions, it will make necessary recommendation to the State Government for exemption of only that portion of the land on which the constructions exist. However, if the Collector decides against any of the petitioners, it will be open to them to make representation before the Government within a month after the decision of the Collector. The Government will look into the grievance of the petitioners and pass appropriate orders expeditiously. This order will apply only to that land where the constructions already exist and which are prior to the date of the issue of the notification under Section 4 of the Act.

23. Till the Government decides the question of grant of exemption, status quo, as on today, shall be maintained by the parties.

24. The parties are directed to bear their own costs.

25. Petitions dismissed.