Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

The Oriental Fire & General Insurance Company & Ors. v. Manju Goel & Ors.

Allahabad High Court
Nov 16, 1990
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Mathura's award dated 17 May 1980, which decreed a total compensation of Rs. 1,09,500/-, payable by Oriental Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. (the insurance company).

On 23 April 1977 Ramesh Chand Goel (aged about 24) died when a truck (No. MPG 9893) driven by Mohan Singh and owned by Ajayab Singh collided with his motorcycle. The Tribunal found the accident caused by rash and negligent driving of the truck. The deceased left a widow, Manju Goel (about 19) and an infant daughter Monika (about 4 months). A claim petition had sought Rs. 12,00,000/-.

The Tribunal awarded Rs. 24,500/- to the widow for the period of widowhood, Rs. 10,000/- for "miseries," and an aggregate of Rs. 75,000/- for the daughter (of which Rs. 50,000/- to be kept in fixed deposit for marriage and Rs. 25,000/- for upbringing). The total award was Rs. 1,09,500/-, to be paid by the insurer (truck comprehensively insured). The insurer and the truck owner (Ajayab Singh) appealed.

During the appeal proceedings interim orders required deposits: Rs. 50,000/- (fixed deposit) by 17.9.1980 and a subsequent deposit of Rs. 59,500/- by order dated 5.5.1981; it was stated these deposits were made and withdrawn by the respondents under subsequent conditions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the liability of the insurance company for the awarded compensation was limited to the statutory amount of Rs. 50,000/- prevailing at the time of the accident, or extended to Rs. 1,50,000/- under the terms of the vehicle's comprehensive insurance policy.
  2. Whether the amounts awarded by the Tribunal — specifically Rs. 24,500/- to the widow, Rs. 10,000/- for "miseries", and Rs. 75,000/- to the minor daughter (with Rs. 50,000/- in fixed deposit for marriage) — were excessive or legally supportable.
  3. Whether the joint appeal by the insurance company and the vehicle owner was maintainable and whether non-joinder of the driver affected the appeal's maintainability.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (Insurance Company and Owner)

  • The deceased's family business continued after his death, so there was no total loss of income; the compensation awarded was excessive.
  • No compensation could properly be awarded for shock, agony or "miseries" to the widow.
  • The insurer's liability was limited to Rs. 50,000/- (statutory limit at the time); the Tribunal's direction that the entire compensation be paid by the insurer was contrary to law.
  • Implicitly (and later expressly), appellants raised that any amount paid by the insurer in excess of its statutory liability should be recoverable from the owner.

Respondents' Arguments (Claimants)

  • The joint appeal by the insurer and the owner was not maintainable due to conflict of interest between them and the appeal was also bad for non-joinder of the driver.
  • The truck was comprehensively insured and the insurance policy extended the insurer's liability up to Rs. 1,50,000/-, so the award against the insurer was proper.
  • Respondents relied on compliance with interim deposit orders and asserted their rights were unaffected; they had withdrawn deposited amounts on furnishing security as permitted.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Padma Devi v. U.P. State Road Transport Corporation (1988 ACJ 667, Allahabad) Principle that no compensation can be awarded for agony suffered by dependants. The court observed that compensation for "agony" is not admissible under this precedent; accordingly, it would not treat Rs. 10,000/- as compensation for mental shock, but reallocated the amount to another permissible head (loss of consortium).
N. Sivammal v. Managing Director, Pandian Roadways Corporation (1985 ACJ 75, SC) Same principle as above: no compensation for agony suffered by dependants. Reinforced the court's view that the Rs. 10,000/- could not be sustained as compensation for shock/agony and must be recharacterized under a permissible head.
Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Lalta Prasad Srivastava (1989 ACJ 221, Allahabad) Division Bench authority that an amount awarded under one head can be shifted to another head. The court relied on this authority to justify awarding the Rs. 10,000/- to the widow as compensation for loss of consortium (companionship/conjugal bliss) rather than as compensation for mental shock.
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jugal Kishore (1988 ACJ 270, SC) Comprehensive insurance and higher premium do not by themselves increase the insurer's statutory liability for third-party risk; a specific agreement and separate premium are required to extend third-party liability beyond the statutory limit. The court applied this principle to hold that comprehensive insurance showing "personal injury and property damage Rs. 1,50,000/-" did not extend third-party liability to Rs. 1,50,000/-. It concluded the Tribunal erred in fixing insurer liability at Rs. 1,50,000/- for third-party compensation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through a sequence of focused analyses, applying the facts and the legal principles reflected in the record and cited precedents.

  1. Maintainability of Joint Appeal and Non-joinder: The court acknowledged a potential clash of interest between the insurer and the owner but treated the joint memo of appeal and grounds as properly presented. Counsel confirmed representation of both appellants and clarified no rights of respondents would be prejudiced (the awarded amount had been deposited and withdrawn as ordered). Consequently, the appeal was not dismissed for joint presentation. Regarding non-joinder of the driver, the court observed it would have been proper to join the driver but found no liability being fixed on the driver and no contention to do so; therefore non-joinder did not affect maintainability.
  2. Assessment of Awards to Dependants: - Widow: The Tribunal considered only the deceased's share of income for maintenance of the widow and awarded Rs. 24,500/-. The court found this not excessive and maintained it. - "Miseries" / Shock and Agony: The Tribunal had awarded Rs. 10,000/- for miseries. Applying Padma Devi and N. Sivammal, the court held that no compensation can be awarded specifically for shock and agony of dependants. However, relying on Oriental Fire it noted amounts awarded under one head can be shifted to another permissible head. The court found that the widow had been deprived of companionship and conjugal bliss and that an award for loss of consortium should have been made; accordingly, it treated the Rs. 10,000/- as allowable under loss of consortium rather than as compensation for mental shock. - Minor Daughter: The award of Rs. 75,000/- for the daughter did not appear excessive; the Tribunal's direction that Rs. 50,000/- be kept in fixed deposit for marriage, while perhaps inartfully worded, did not vitiate the compensation granted.
  3. Insurer's Liability under the Policy vs. Statutory Limit: - It was undisputed that the statutory third-party liability at the time was Rs. 50,000/-. The key question was whether the comprehensive insurance extended that third-party liability to Rs. 1,50,000/-. - The policy produced had an endorsement (additional premium Rs. 39/-) stating "personal injury and property damage Rs. 1,50,000/-." The court emphasized the principle from National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jugal Kishore that comprehensive insurance or payment of higher premium does not, by itself, enlarge statutory liability for third-party risk unless there is a clear specific agreement and separate premium for that extended third-party risk. - Applying that principle, the court concluded the policy's 1,50,000/- endorsement related to "personal injury and property damage" (not third-party liability) and that the Tribunal erred in fixing the insurer's liability at Rs. 1,50,000/- for third-party compensation.
  4. Practical Outcome Given Interim Orders and Deposits: - Despite the error identified about the insurer's theoretical liability, the court noted the practical posture: interim orders required deposits (Rs. 50,000/- and later Rs. 59,500/-) which had been complied with. Respondents had withdrawn amounts after furnishing security and counsel for appellants stated no refund was being claimed by the insurer. Given these facts, the court determined no interference with the amount ordered to be paid by the insurance company was warranted in the present proceedings. - The court directed that the Rs. 50,000/- already deposited in fixed deposit remain invested until Monika (the minor) attains majority; if marriage occurs earlier, the Tribunal may permit reasonable withdrawal for marriage expenses, considering relevant factors and status. - The insurer was allowed to seek recovery of any amount it paid in excess of its statutory liability from the owner in accordance with law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court MAINTAINED the Tribunal's award of Rs. 1,09,500/- (with costs and interest) and confirmed the apportionment of compensation subject to specific modifications described below.

Direct consequences and practical implications:

  • The award of Rs. 24,500/- to the widow is maintained.
  • The Tribunal's Rs. 10,000/- figure, although not sustainable as compensation for mental shock under precedent, was recharacterized and upheld as compensation for loss of consortium (companionship/conjugal bliss).
  • The Rs. 75,000/- awarded to the minor daughter is upheld. The court confirmed the procedural safeguard that Rs. 50,000/- already deposited must remain in fixed deposit in a nationalised bank until the daughter attains majority; the Tribunal may permit reasonable withdrawals for marriage before majority considering relevant factors.
  • Although the court held that the Tribunal erred in principle in fixing insurer liability at Rs. 1,50,000/- (because the policy did not extend third-party risk beyond the statutory limit), it did not modify the insurer's obligation to pay in this case because of the interim deposit history and the fact that respondents had acted pursuant to the orders; however, the insurer is permitted to recover any excess it paid over its statutory liability from the vehicle owner in accordance with law.
  • No new precedent was created: the court applied existing authorities (as cited) and adjusted the characterization and implementation of awards consistent with those authorities and the peculiar facts of deposit and withdrawals in this case.
  • Parties were ordered to bear their own costs of the appeal.

Note: This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion. No information beyond the opinion text has been added or inferred.

Show all summary ...

1. This is an appeal against the award dated 17th May, 1980 passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Mathura, decreeing the claim for Rs. 1,09,500/- against the opposite parties and the total compensation payable by the Oriental Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. (hereinafter referred as 'the insurance company').

2. Ramesh Chand Goel aged about 24 years died on account of the accident on 23.4.1977. In brief, he was going on motorbike from Refinery Mathura to Mathura and truck No. MPG 9893 driven by Mohan Singh and owned by Ajayab Singh was coming from the opposite side with great speed. It hit the motor cycle at about 3.45 p.m. causing serious injuries to Ramesh Chand Goel. Ramesh Chand deceased died on way to the hospital. From the evidence on record the Tribunal found that the accident was caused on account of the rash and negligent driving of the truck driver. This has not been disputed before us.

2-A. Ramesh Chand deceased was a Government contractor of First Class and had factories at Badopal and Hissar besides other immovable properties and including agricultural land. He left behind his widow Manju Goel aged about 19 and one daughter Monika Goel aged about 4 months at the time of the accident. A claim of Rs. 12,00,000/- was preferred in the claim petition. Manju Goel subsequently remarried with her husband's younger brother on 28th April, 1979. According to the Tribunal the expenditure incurred on Manju by the deceased was not less than Rs. 1,000/- per month. He granted a compensation of Rs. 24,500/- to her for the period of her widowhood. He also granted Rs. 10,000/-by way of compensation for her miseries. As regards the daughter he awarded a sum of Rs. 50,000/- to be kept in fixed deposit in some nationalised bank and to be taken out at the time of her marriage for the purposes of marriage only. He further awarded a sum of Rs. 25,000/- for the minor so that the amount of interest received from this amount may be spent in the bringing up of Monika. He accordingly awarded a sum of Rs. 1,09,500/-to be payable by the insurance company as the truck was comprehensively insured and the liability of the insurance company was limited to Rs. 1,50,000/-. Being aggrieved the insurance company and Ajayab Singh have preferred this appeal.

3. The amounts awarded have been challenged on various grounds on behalf of the appellants. It is contended that as the family business was continuing, it is not a case of total loss of income and as such the amount awarded is excessive. It is also contended that no compensation for shock and agony or miseries could have been awarded to the widow under the law. According to the appellants the liability of the insurance company was limited to Rs. 50,000/-only at that time and as such the direction of whole compensation amount being paid by the insurance company is against the law and the liability of the insurance company should be limited to Rs. 50,000/- only. On the other hand, it is contended on behalf of the respondents that the joint-appeal by the insurance company and the owner is not maintainable, that the appeal is bad for non-joinder of the driver. It was also asserted that in view of the comprehensive insurance policy the liability of the insurance company had extended to Rs. 1,50,000/- and the order passed is proper.

4. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the records.

5. It is contended on behalf of the respondents that the interest of the insurance company and the truck owner, appellant No. 2, are inconsistent and as such joint-appeal by them is not maintainable. No doubt, the liability of the insurance company to the extent of the whole amount is being challenged in the appeal and is sought to be limited to Rs. 50,000/-. On this point it may be said that there is a clash of interest between the appellants. But in our opinion it was a matter to be taken into account by the appellants. Both of them have joined in the appeal. The grounds raised in the memo will, therefore, be taken to have been raised on behalf of the appellants, even though there may be clash of interest. When this was put to the learned counsel for the appellants he has stated at the Bar that he was representing both the appellants and the points raised by him are being raised on behalf of both the appellants. It was also stated that the awarded amount has already been deposited by the insurance company and withdrawn by the respondents. According to him, the rights of the respondents are, therefore, not to be affected at all and the purpose of the appeal is to have a finding regarding the liability of the insurance company in such cases. In view of the above, we are of the opinion that the appeal is not liable to be dismissed on the grounds urged by the learned counsel for the respondents.

6. From the evidence led by the claimants it is clear that the deceased was an affluent man, having vast properties and other resources. The learned Tribunal has considered the income of the share of the deceased only while determining his contribution on the maintenance of his wife. This does not appear to be excessive in our opinion. Therefore, the award of Rs. 24,500/- is maintained.

7. Rs. 10,000/- has been awarded to the respondents by way of compensation for the miseries. It is contended that no compensation under this head was admissible. This contention appears to be correct in view of the principles laid down in the case of Padma Devi v. U.P. State Road Transport Corporation 1988 ACJ 667 (Allahabad) and in the case of N. Sivammal v. Managing Director, Pandian Roadways Corporation 1985 ACJ 75 (SC). According to these cases no compensation can be awarded for agony suffered by the dependants. However, the amount awarded under one head can be shifted to another head as held in Division Bench case of Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Lalta Prasad Srivastava 1989 ACJ 221 (Allahabad). In the instant case the respondent No. 1 was deprived of the companionship and conjugal bliss on account of the death of her husband. No amount has been awarded on account of loss of consortium which should have been awarded in our opinion. Therefore, this amount of Rs. 10,000/- is awarded to her under this head, though not by way of compensation for mental shock and agony.

8. The awarding of the compensation of Rs. 75,000/- to the respondent No. 2 does not appear to be excessive in the facts and circumstances of the case. The same has not been seriously challenged before us. It is contended that the awarding of Rs. 50,000/- solely for the purposes of marriage is unjustified. Even if the observation of the Tribunal in this regard may not be happily worded, in our opinion, this does not affect the awarding of Rs. 75,000/- as compensation to the respondent No. 2.

9. It is contended on behalf of the appellants that the liability of the insurance company is Rs. 50,000/- only. On the other hand, it is contended on behalf of the respondents that the truck was comprehensively insured and the liability of the insurance company was up to Rs. 1,50,000/-. It is not in dispute that at the time of the accident the statutory liability of the insurance company extended up to Rs. 50,000/- only in such cases. Therefore, it has to be seen whether this liability got extended under the insurance policy. It is admitted case that the truck had a comprehensive insurance. The insurance policy has been filed before the Tribunal. It shows that an additional premium of Rs. 39/-has been paid and against this is the endorsement "personal injury and property damage Rs. 1,50,000/-". The mere fact that there is comprehensive insurance of the vehicle will not extend the statutory liability of the insurance company as regards third party risk unless there is a specific agreement between the parties to that effect.

10. In the case of National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jugal Kishore 1988 ACJ 270 (SC), it has been held that:

...such insurance (comprehensive added by us) entitles the owner to claim reimbursement of the entire amount of loss or damage suffered up to the estimated value of the vehicle calculated according to the rules and regulations framed in this behalf. Comprehensive insurance of the vehicle and payment of higher premium on this score, however, do not mean that the limit of the liability with regard to third party risk becomes unlimited or higher than the statutory liability fixed under Sub-section (2) of Section 95 of the Act. For this purpose a specific agreement has to be arrived at between the owner and the insurance company and separate premium has to be paid on the amount of liability undertaken by the insurance company in this behalf. Likewise, if risk of any other nature, for instance, with regard to the driver or passengers etc. in excess of statutory liability, if any, is sought to be covered, it has to be clearly specified in the policy and separate premium paid therefor.

In the case before us the policy shows the liability up to Rs. 1,50,000/- only in case of personal injury and property damage and not with regard to third party risk. Therefore, in our opinion the learned Tribunal has erred in fixing the liability of the insurance company to Rs. 1,50,000/-.

11. However, in this case by an interim order dated 17.9.1980 the stay was granted on the condition of depositing Rs. 50,000/- in fixed deposit account. By a subsequent order dated 5th May, 1981 the further stay was allowed on deposit of Rs. 59,500/- and this amount was to be withdrawn by the claimants-respondents on furnishing adequate security. It has been stated before us that these orders have been complied with. The learned counsel for the appellants has also stated that no refund is being claimed by the insurance company from the respondents therefor. In view of this no interference or modification of the amount awarded to be paid by the insurance company is called for.

12. It is contended on behalf of the respondents that the deposit of Rs. 50,000/-will be multiplied several times and the direction for utilizing the whole of the amount for the marriage purpose of the respondent No. 2 is unwarranted and against the spirit of the times. In our opinion, the contention cannot be brushed aside lightly. In our opinion, the proper course would be to direct that this amount will remain invested in the fixed deposits in a nationalized bank for the period till the respondent No. 2 attains majority. In case her marriage is arranged before she attains majority the respondent No. 1 and in the event of her death the lawful guardian of respondent No. 2 will be permitted by the Tribunal to draw the reasonable amount to be incurred in her marriage. The Tribunal while permitting such amount should take into consideration the relevant factors including the status of the parties.

13. It has been further urged by the learned counsel for the appellants that no relief regarding the refund of the compensation is claimed from the respondents, the appellant No. 1 is entitled to recover the amount paid in excess of its statutory liability from the appellant No. 2. As the contention has been raised by the learned counsel for both the appellants, it should be taken that the appellants inter se have no objection to the same.

14. Lastly, it was urged by the learned counsel for the respondents that the appeal was bad for non-joinder of the driver. No doubt, it would have been proper that the driver should have been joined as a party in the appeal. However, in view of the above discussions no liability for payment is being fixed on the driver nor the appellants have contended so. Therefore, this does not affect the maintainability of the appeal.

15. In the result, the award of the Tribunal with regard to the awarding of the compensation of Rs. 1,09,500/- along with the costs and together with the interest and for payment of the compensation by the Oriental Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd., opposite party No. 3, appellant No. 1, is maintained. However, the apportionment of the compensation as given in the award is also confirmed subject to the modification that the amount of Rs. 50,000/-already deposited in the fixed deposits shall remain in fixed deposit till Monika Goel, respondent No. 2, attains majority and withdrawal of the money for the purpose of her marriage may be made in accordance with the observations made in the judgment. However, it will be open to the insurance company, appellant No. 1, to recover the amount paid in excess by it from the appellant No. 2 in accordance with law.

16. In the circumstances of the case, the parties shall bear their own costs of the appeal.