- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kishan Lal Singhania v. District Judge
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This petition under Article 226 challenged an order dated 15-7-1989 of the District Judge, Kanpur Nagar, which rejected the petitioner’s application seeking dismissal of a suit filed by respondent No. 2 for ejectment and arrears of rent. The plaintiff (respondent No. 2) sued for ejectment and arrears in respect of Flat No. 1 and Flat No. 2 on the third floor of House No. 26/41-42-43, Birhana Road, Kanpur.
Flat No. 1 was originally let to Singhania & Sons Pvt. Ltd. in June 1959 (initial rent Rs. 200, later enhanced to Rs. 270). Flat No. 2 was let earlier (January 1954) to the same tenant (initial rent Rs. 175, later enhanced to Rs. 236.25). Subsequently, the present petitioner, as Managing Director of Singhania & Sons Pvt. Ltd., was permitted by the landlord to occupy the flats; rent receipts remained in the name of the original tenant. After arrears accrued and the tenant failed to pay or vacate following service of notice, the landlord filed the ejectment and rent suit. The petitioner (defendant in the suit) objected to maintainability on grounds of misjoinder/multifariousness of causes of action.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the suit for ejectment and arrears of rent in respect of two flats (Flats Nos. 1 and 2) of the same building is bad for misjoinder or multifariousness of causes of action.
- Whether the landlord could join claims for ejectment and arrears of rent relating to two portions of the same premises in a single suit, given that the tenancies were said to have been created on different dates and for different rents.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The two accommodations (Flats Nos. 1 and 2) were let on different dates and created separate tenancies, so the causes of action could not be joined; the plaint suffers from misjoinder/multifariousness.
- Reliance was placed on Smt. Samundari Devi v. Nand Kishore, 1987 All LJ 255, to support the contention that causes of action could not properly be joined.
Respondent's / Plaintiff's Arguments
This opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments for respondent No. 2 beyond the allegations in the plaint (that arrears accrued, composite notice was served and suit was filed for ejectment and arrears in respect of specified portions).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Smt. Samundari Devi v. Nand Kishore, 1987 All LJ 255 | Discusses joinder of several causes of action against the same defendant under Order II Rule 3. | The court held that this authority did not assist the petitioner; it actually supports the proposition that several causes of action against the same defendant can be joined and that such joinder does not necessarily amount to multifariousness. |
| Subhash Kumar Lata v. R.C. Chhiba, (1988) 4 SCC 709 (AIR 1989 SC 458) | Authority on whether distinct portions of a building occupied by the same tenant constitute a single tenancy (composite tenancy) for procedural/joining purposes. | Used to support the view that two portions leased to the same tenant can constitute one composite tenancy; the court relied on this to find no misjoinder. |
| Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Shyam Co-operative Housing Society, (1988) 4 SCC 747 (AIR 1989 SC 295) | Supports the principle that distinct portions leased to the same tenant may form a composite tenancy for relevant purposes. | Applied alongside Subhash Kumar Lata to conclude that a single tenancy could exist despite separate receipts or different uses for the two flats. |
| Sidramappa v. Raja Shetty, (1970) 1 SCC 186 (AIR 1970 SC 1057) | Principle that a suit must include the whole of the claim which the plaintiff is entitled to make in respect of a cause of action; plaintiff cannot recover omitted portions later by separate proceedings. | Relied upon to emphasize that omission of part of a claim bars subsequently suing for that omitted portion; supports the rule that causes of action may be joined to avoid multiplicity and bar under Order II Rule 2(2). |
| Mohd. Hafiz v. Mohd. Zakaria, AIR 1922 PC 23 | Similar principle on inclusion of whole claim and bar on subsequent suits for omitted portions. | Used to reinforce the rule that a plaintiff who omits part of his claim cannot later sue for the omitted portion. |
| Ambika Upadhyaya v. Nakeched Upadhyaya, AIR 1955 All 112 | Where multiple transactions (mortgages) involve the same parties, claims may be combined under Order II Rule 3. | Applied by analogy — where parties are common, combining claims is permissible and avoids multiplicity. |
| Murari Lal Agarwal v. Mithai Lal, 1977 All WC 41 | Held that termination of multiple tenancies created separately in favour of same defendants by single notice under s.106 of Transfer of Property Act was valid. | Cited to support the validity of proceeding collectively against the same defendants for multiple tenancies/terminations. |
| Ram Chandra v. Judge Small Cause Courts, 1983 All WC 955 (1984 All LJW 143) | Case on joinder/multifariousness decided on its particular facts. | Distinguished and held to be confined to its facts; not of assistance to the petitioner in the present matter. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in structured legal steps, applying the Code of Civil Procedure (the Code) and relevant authorities to the facts:
- Identification of the procedural question: The court framed the point for determination as whether the plaintiff’s suit for ejectment and arrears of rent in respect of the two flats was bad for misjoinder of cause of action.
- Examination of facts: The court noted that both flats had been let to the same tenant (Singhania & Sons Pvt. Ltd.) and later occupied by the petitioner as Managing Director; rents were acknowledged by the same landlord (sometimes by separate receipts), and arrears had arisen leading to a composite notice and suit.
- Statutory framework: The court analyzed Order II Rules 1–3 and Rule 2(1)–(2) of the Code, and Section 11 Explanation 4. It emphasised Order II Rule 1’s aim to frame suits to afford final disposal, Rule 2(1)–(2) requirements that a suit include the whole claim and that omission bars subsequent suit, and Rule 3 permitting joinder of causes of action against the same defendant subject to these constraints. The court also considered the Uttar Pradesh amendment (Explanation II to O.2 R.2) which deems ejectment and rent claims to be claims in respect of distinct causes of action for that State.
- Interaction of rules and amendment: The court observed that even though the State amendment treats ejectment and rent as distinct causes of action, the Code’s bar on subsequently suing for omitted relief (O.2 R.2(2)) and Section 11 Explanation 4's doctrine of res judicata require a plaintiff to claim all reliefs appropriately to avoid multiplicity. Thus distinctness of causes does not automatically preclude joining claims where doing so avoids multiplicity and consequent bars.
- Application to facts — composite tenancy: The court evaluated whether the two flats should be treated as separate tenancies or a single composite tenancy. Citing Supreme Court authorities (Subhash Kumar Lata and Hindustan Petroleum) it concluded that where the same landlord and the same tenant are involved, and the portions form parts of the same premises (third floor), separate dates of letting, different rents, or separate receipts do not necessarily create separate, independent tenancies for procedural purposes. Consequently, the landlord was entitled to treat the matter as one composite tenancy and join the causes of action.
- Rejection of petitioner’s reliance: The court examined the case relied upon by the petitioner (Smt. Samundari Devi) and concluded that it did not help the petitioner; that case also recognizes that a plaintiff can join several causes of action against the same defendant and that such joinder does not necessarily amount to multifariousness.
- Conclusion on maintainability: On the basis of statutory provisions, State amendment, and precedents, the court held the joinder of the two causes of action in the plaintiff’s suit was proper and that the suit was not vitiated by multifariousness or misjoinder.
- Relief under writ jurisdiction: The court further concluded there was no ground for interference under Article 226 — the impugned order showed no error, much less an apparent error on the face of the record.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The petition under Article 226 is DISMISSED.
Implications and immediate consequences:
- The District Judge’s order rejecting the petitioner’s application to dismiss the suit for misjoinder/multifariousness is upheld.
- The interim stay order dated 4-10-1989 (as extended) is vacated.
- There is no order as to costs.
- The court below is directed to dispose of the suit as expeditiously as possible; the opinion records that the petitioner appeared to be prolonging the suit by raising frivolous objections.
Broader legal implication: The judgment applies established principles of joinder under Order II of the Code and res judicata under Section 11 Explanation 4 and does not purport to lay down any novel precedent; the decision resolves the maintainability question on the facts and law presented and confines itself to the consequences for the parties in this litigation.
1. By the present petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India the order dated 15-7-1989 passed by the District Judge, Kanpur Nagar, rejecting the application filed by the petitioner for dismissing the suit filed by respondent No. 2 for ejectment and arrears of rent as in the said suit the relief for ejectment in same suit which was not permissible under law and the suit was bad for multifariousness of the cause of action.
2. The factual matrix of the case is that the plaintiff respondent No. 2 has filed a suit for ejectment and arrears of rent in repect of Flat No. 1 and Flat No. 2 on the third floor of House No. 26/41-42-43, Birhana Road, Kanpur. Flat No. 1 was let out to Ms. Singhania & Sons Pvt. Ltd. in June, 1959 for a rent of Rs. 200/- per month which was later on enhanced to Rs. 260/- and Rs. 270/- per month. Whereas Flat No. 2 was let out to the same tenant on a rent of Rs. 175/- and later on enhanced to Rs. 189/- and Rs. 236.75/- per month. But later on the present petitioner as Managing Director of the said firm was permitted to occupy the said flats by the landlord. However, the rent receipt was issued in the name of original tenant. There were arrears of rent hence a notice to terminate the tenancy was served on the tenant (Annexure 1) and as he failed to pay the rent or vacate the premises, hence the present suit was filed and the aforesaid objection was taken by the defendants about the maintainability of the suit.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner urged that two accommodations, Flat No. 1 and Flat No. 2 were let out on different dates and different tenancy were created hence the cause of action for both the accommodations could not be joined by the plaintiff respondent No. 2 in the same suit, hence the same suit may be dismissed for misjoinder of the cause of action. Reliance was placed on Smt. Samundari Devi v. Nand Kishore, 1987 All LJ 255.
4. Having heard the learned counsel for the petitioner the point for determination is as to whether the suit for ejectment and arrears of rent filed by respondent No. 2 is bad for misjoinder of cause of action as alleged by the petitioner. It is to be noted that as stated in paras 3 and 4 of the writ petition, Flat No. 1 was taken on lease in June 1959 on a monthly rent of Rs. 200/- and the same was later on enhanced to Rs. 270/-. Flat No. 2 was taken on a monthly rent of Rs. 175/- in January, 1954, but the same was later on enhanced to Rs. 236.25/- by Singhania & Sons Pvt. Ltd., who occupied the said two flats for running the firm and particularly for residential purposes. Later there was some difficulty in the working of the firm and the landlord permitted the petitioner to continue as tenant. Even in view of the allegations in the plaint tenancy was created in favour of Singhania & Sons Pvt. Ltd. on different dates and in respect of Flats Nos. 1 and 2 of the same premises on the third floor. The question is that if the landlord wants to institute a suit for arrears of rent and ejectment of the tenant in respect of two portions of the same premises can he file a single suit or join the cause of action in respect of two accommodations to be the part of same building. It is not at present stage the controversy as to who was the tenant and whether the sub-letting was proved or the suit could be decreed on merits or not. But the controversy is about the maintainability of the suit in respect of joinder of the causes of action. Apart from other characteristics of filing suit by the plaintiff in respect of the subject in dispute, particular cause of action is available and there were similar causes of actions in respect of other similar part of the subject in dispute. In the present case the landlord was the same and the tenant was also the same. Even though the tenancy was in respect of Flats Nos. 1 and 2, but they constituted on the spot a specific portion on the third floor of the same building. In such a situation there are certain relevant provisions of the Civil P.C (for short the Code) which require consideration.
5. Order 2, Rule 1 of the Code provides that every suit shall, so far as practicable, be framed so as to afford ground for final disposal upon the subject in dispute and to prevent further litigation concerning them. Even though the expression ‘subject in dispute’ has not been defined in the Code, but for our purposes it refers to the alleged claim by one party against the other with reference to particular local relief or transaction between the parties. In other words, it can be said loosely a cause of action or the subject matter of litigation. Under Rule 1 of Order 2, the plaintiff is required to bring forward his whole case as to the particular legal relation or transaction on which his suit is based, but does not require him to raise in the same suit a matter pertaining to different legal relations. In the present case legal relation between the parties was letting out of Flats Nos. 1 and 2 to the same tenant by the same landlord and enhancement of rent on different dates. Hence in view of Rule 2, Order 2 of the Code the law requires the plaintiff respondent to frame his suit so as to afford ground for final decision of the subjects in dispute and to prevent further litigation concerning them. In case the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner is accepted that there was separate cause of action, even though that was not, as I am of the view that as the same tenant has failed to make payment of arrears of rent and refused to vacate the premises on the composite notice being served that would lead to only one cause of action and not two or different causes of action.
6. Rule 2(1) of Order 2 of the Code provides that every suit shall include the whole of the claim in which the plaintiff is entitled to make in respect of the cause of action, but a plaintiff may relinquish any portion of his claim in order to bring the suit within the jurisdiction of any court. Whereas, Rule 2(2) provides that where a plaintiff omits to sue in respect of, or intentionally relinquishes, any portion of his claim, he shall not afterwards sue in respect of the portion so omitted or relinquished. Under the circumstances I am of the view that in case the plaintiff would have filed one suit for one cause of action and would not have included remaining portion of the cause of action in respect of a portion of the same building (may be Flat No. 1 or 2 of the third floor), the suit could be said to have been barred by O. 2, R. 2(2) of the Code, as in that event the defendant, present petitioner would have raised the objection that the suit was barred by O. 2, R. 2(2) of the Code. Similarly, under Section 11, Explanation 4 of the Code it has been provided that any matter which might and ought to have been made ground of defence or attack in such former suit shall be deemed to have been the matter directly and substantially in issue in such suit and would not be allowed to be re-opened in subsequent suit between the same parties.
7. In a suit for ejectment and arrears of rent the considerations are somewhat different. As the rent fell due to the landlord and the defendant, the present petitioner, refused to vacate the premises, even after service of notice of composite cause of action created in favour of plaintiff-respondent No. 2 to file suit for ejectment and arrears of rent in respect of specified portion of the same building (may be Flat No. 1 or 2 on the third floor), the plaintiff has no option but to join both the causes of action.
8. There is no explanation added to O. 2, R. 3 to the effect that if a person entitled to more than one relief in respect of the same cause of action, may sue for all or any of such reliefs, but if he omits, except with the leave of the Court, to sue for all such reliefs, he shall not afterwards sue for any relief so omitted. There is an explanation thereafter, but in its application to the State of Uttar Pradesh there will be State Amendment as follows:
“Uttar Pradesh — In Order II, Rule 2:—
(a) the existing explanation shall be numbered as Explanation I, and after Explanation I, as so numbered, the following Explanation II, shall be inserted, namely:
Explanation II — for the purposes of this Rule a claim for ejectment of the defendant from immovable property let out to him and a claim for money due from him on account of rent or compensation for use and occupation of that property shall be deemed to be claims in respect of distinct cause of action.” (U.P Act No. 57 of 1976, Section 4 (1-1-1977).
9. In view of the aforesaid State amendment the claim for ejectment of the defendant from the immovable property let out to him and claim for arrears of rent or permission for use and occupation is to be deemed distinct cause of action. But in case in view of the Explanation he omits any relief in respect of rent, he would not be permitted to claim the omitted relief again. In this view of the matter the cause of action maybe distinct, but in view of the requirement of O. 2, R. 2(2) and (3) of the Code, in case the plaintiff omits to sue for any portion of his claim, he shall not sue in respect of the portion so omitted or in case he fails to claim relief in respect of same cause of action, he shall not afterwards sue for any such relief so omitted. Even though the plaintiff may be deemed to have distinct cause of action, but he has to claim his relief and frame suit in view of the provisions of O. 2, R. 1 and O. 2, R. 2 of the Code.
10. In such matters I am of the considered opinion that even though two portions of the same building might have been let out on different dates for different rents, but the landlord was entitled to composite rent of both the flats, may be that amount might have been paid on different dates or in two cheques, but as the tenant has been the same from the very inception of the creation of tenancy, even though the amount was not paid in lump sum or by one cheque or more than one cheque, that would not lead to inference that the tenancy was separated. The same landlord was receiving the amount paid by the same tenant, may be in respect of flat No. 1 or flat No. 2. Even though flats Nos. 1 and 2 might be occupied by the same tenant, one for residential purposes and the other for its Manager or the other for the purposes of the firm carrying out business, the rent was acknowledged by the same landlord, may be under two receipts. It is the only single tenancy which could be said to have come into existence even though in respect of two flats of the same building. As the entire portion of the same building was leased out by the same landlord in favour of the same tenant and where the use of two flats was different by the same tenant, would not be decisive to ascertain the nature of tenancy and the tenancy would continue to be composite tenancy rather single tenancy and the single tenancy can be said to have come into existence. (See Subhash Kumar Lata v. R.C Chhiba, (1988) 4 SCC 709, 714, 715 : (AIR 1989 SC 458, 461, 462); Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Shyam Co-operative Housing Society, (1988) 4 SCC 747, 757 and 758 : (AIR 1989 SC 295, 301 and 302)).
11. To put it differently, every suit must include the whole of the claim which the plaintiff is entitled to make in respect of a cause of action for which plaintiff brought the suit. If the cause of action enabled the plaintiff as in the present case, to ask for a wider and layer relief than that to which he limits his claim, he cannot recover the balance by independent proceedings. (See Sidramappa v. Raja Shetty, (1970) 1 SCC 186 : AIR 1970 SC 1057; Mohd. Hafiz v. Mohd. Zakaria, AIR 1922 PC 23).
12. To be more precise, even at the cost of repetition and in order to take a realistic view the provisions of O. 1, R. 1 (who may be joined as plaintiffs), R. 3 (who may be joined as defendants), R. 9 (no suit shall be defeated by reason of misjoinder and non-joinder of parties, (except in the case of non-joinder of necessary party), and O. II (Two) Framing suit, R. 2 (suit to include the whole claim and if not its consequences), R. III (three) (joinder of causes of action) and S. 11 (Eleven) (Explanation IV) may be read together. All persons have to be joined as plaintiffs where right to relief in respect of or arising out of the same act or transaction or series of acts or transactions is alleged to exist in such persons and similarly those may be joined as defendants where any right to relief in respect of or arising out of same act or transaction or series of acts or transactions is alleged exist against such persons. No suit shall be defeated by misjoinder or non-joinder of parties except, non-joinder of necessary party. In view of R. 3 O. II (two) a plaintiff can unite in the same suit several causes of actions against the same defendant or defendants jointly and any plaintiff may unite causes of action in the same suit. But this is subject to the provisions of O. II (two) R. 2 (two) and S. 11, Explanation IV. In case the plaintiff does to include the whole of his claim or fails to claim only a part of the relief and leaves any portion of his claim, in that event he would not be able to claim the remaining part of relief in a subsequent suit of proceedings. At the same time any matter which might and ought to have been made a ground of attack or defence in a former suit, shall be deemed to have been a matter directly and substantially in issue.
13. I am of the considered opinion that the legislative intendment is manifest by the language employed under O. II, R. III that a plaintiff can join several causes of action in one suit, in order to avoid multiplicity of proceedings or the operation of the bar of O. II, R. II or S. 11 Explanation IV of the Code.
14. In Smt. Samundari Devi v. Nand Kishore (1987 All LJW 255) (supra) relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioner, is a case which does not help him, inasmuch as in that case it was held that in view of the provisions of R. III of O. II of the Code, several causes of action against the same defendant can be joined by the plaintiff and it cannot be said that the joinder of causes of action suffers from any multifariousness.
15. A Full Bench of this court in Ambika Upadhyaya v. Nakeched Upadhyaya, AIR 1955 All 112, held that where there were several mortgages, but the creditors and debtors were the same, in that event in view of the provisions of R. 3 of O. 2, as the creditors and debtors were common, there was no bar to the creditor combining the claim for the money due under the other four mortgages.
16. In Murari Lal Agarwal v. Mithai Lal, 1977 All WC 41, it was held that the termination of three tenancies (three tenants of the same plaintiff landlord) created separately in favour of the same defendants by a single notice under S. 106 of the Transfer of Property Act), was perfectly valid. The case of Ram Chandra v. Judge Small Cause Courts, 1983 All WC 955 : (1984 All LJW 143) was already distinguished in Smt. Samundari Devi v. Nand Kishore (1987 All LJW 255) (supra), and it was observed that the case of Ram Chandra v. Judge, Small Causes Courts (supra), was a case decided on peculaiar facts of that case and that ratio was confined to those facts of that case and that need not be extended any further. Consequently that case is of no assistance to the petitioner.
17. In the present case the plaintiff respondent No. 2, has correctly joined two or more causes of action in the same suit. That has been correctly done. In view of the nature of suit and relief claimed and nature of tenancies and the provisions of O. 2, Rr. 2, 4, 3 of the Code, it cannot be said that there was any multiferiousness or misjoinder of the causes of action.
18. Applying the posteriori and priori reasonings I am of the view that no case for interference under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India has been made out and the impugned order does not suffer from any error much less an error apparent on the face of record.
19. In the result, the petition fails and it is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs. The interim stay order dated 4-10-1989 as extended from time to time, is hereby vacated.
20. The petitioner appears to prolong the decision of the suit by raising frivolous objections. The court below is directed to dispose of the suit as expeditiously as possible.
21. Petition dismissed.
Alert