- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chhotey Lal v. Dist. Judge
Summary of the Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
Suit for recovery of rent filed by Sri Sita Ram was decreed. An application for execution of that decree was filed, but execution proceedings were stayed by the Court. During the period of stay Sri Sita Ram died. After the stay was vacated, respondents Nos. 3 to 5 (the widow and two sons of Sita Ram) moved the execution court to bring their names on record in place of the deceased decree-holder so they could continue the execution proceedings. The petitioner (the judgment-debtor and defendant in the original suit) objected to that application. The execution court rejected the petitioner's objection. The petitioner then filed a revision before the learned District Judge, which was dismissed by order dated 28-8-1990. The petitioner challenged the orders of the execution court and the District Judge by filing this writ petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether execution proceedings can be continued by the heirs and legal representatives of a deceased decree-holder without obtaining a succession certificate under S. 214 of the Succession Act.
- Whether, when heirs or legal representatives seek to be brought on record to continue execution proceedings, the period of limitation under Art. 137 of the Limitation Act (three years for "any other application for which no period of limitation is provided") applies — in particular because substitution under Rules 3 and 4 of Order 22, C.P.C. is declared inapplicable to execution proceedings by Rule 12 of Order 22.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- Execution proceedings cannot be continued by the heirs and legal representatives of the deceased decree-holder unless they obtain a succession certificate under S. 214 of the Succession Act.
- Even if Rules 3, 4 and 8 of Order 22 are not applicable to execution proceedings, an application for substitution to bring heirs/legal representatives on record must be made; since there is no other specific provision, such an application must be made under Section 151 of the C.P.C. and therefore must be filed within three years as provided by Article 137 of the Limitation Act.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Manmohan Dayal v. Kailash Nath, AIR 1957 All 647 : 1957 All LJ 578 | Legal representatives of a deceased decree-holder are entitled to ask for continuation of execution proceedings without moving any fresh application for execution. | The Court relied on this Division Bench decision to support the proposition that Order 22 Rules 3 and 4 do not apply to execution proceedings and that heirs need not move substitution to continue execution. |
| S. Khandelwal v. B. Prasad, AIR 1972 All 321 : 1972 All LJ 66 | Section 214 of the Succession Act does not apply to an application by a person seeking to continue execution proceedings after the death of a decree-holder; S. 214 prohibits institution of execution proceedings by a successor but does not bar continuance of proceedings already started by the deceased. | The Court cited this authority to reject the petitioner's first ground that a succession certificate under S. 214 is necessary to continue execution proceedings. |
| Budh Singh v. Additional District Judge, AIR 1986 All 49 | Where no application is required by law to be made in order to continue proceedings (i.e., the legal representatives may simply inform the execution court and proceed), Article 137 of the Limitation Act does not apply; Art. 137 applies where an application is required by law to create or confer a right to proceed. | The Court relied on this decision to hold that Art. 137 is not attracted to the heirs' act of coming to the execution court to continue execution proceedings, and thus the limitation plea (three years) fails. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeded in these steps, using only principles and authorities referenced in the opinion:
- Interpretation of Order 22, Rule 12, C.P.C.: The Court noted that Order 22, Rule 12 expressly provides that Rules 3, 4 and 8 of Order 22 shall not apply to proceedings in execution of a decree or order. Rules 3 and 4 provide for substitution of heirs in suits within a specified time and, if not complied with, could cause abatement of a suit. Because Rule 12 removes Rules 3 and 4 from applying to execution proceedings, abatement does not follow in execution even if heirs are not formally brought on record by a substitution application.
- Effect on substitution requirement: From the Rule 12 exclusion, the Court concluded that legal representatives of a deceased decree-holder are not required to move a substitution application to continue execution proceedings. The Court relied on Manmohan Dayal v. Kailash Nath for this proposition that legal representatives may ask for continuation without moving a fresh application.
- Application of S. 214 of the Succession Act: The Court considered S. 214 and, following S. Khandelwal v. B. Prasad, held that S. 214 prohibits institution of execution proceedings by a successor but does not bar continuance of proceedings already initiated by the deceased decree-holder. Therefore, heirs need not obtain a succession certificate under S. 214 to continue execution already begun.
- Application of Article 137 of the Limitation Act: The Court examined Art. 137 (three years for "any other application for which no period of limitation is provided") and explained that this Article does not apply where the court action required is ministerial or where no application is required by law to create or confer a right to proceed. Relying on Budh Singh v. Additional District Judge, the Court held that where legal representatives merely inform the execution court and proceed (no statutory application for substitution required), Art. 137 cannot be invoked to bar continuation of execution on limitation grounds.
- Conclusion on petitioner's contentions: Applying the above principles, the Court found both of the petitioner's submissions (need for succession certificate under S. 214, and the applicability of Art. 137 limitation) to be without force.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition is dismissed; the impugned orders of the execution court and the learned District Judge are upheld. Writ petition dismissed.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The heirs and legal representatives of the deceased decree-holder (Sita Ram) are entitled to continue the execution proceedings without obtaining a succession certificate under S. 214 of the Succession Act and without being barred by Article 137 of the Limitation Act, in the circumstances described.
- Scope: The Court's decision is grounded on existing authorities cited in the opinion (Manmohan Dayal; S. Khandelwal; Budh Singh) and on the exclusion of Rules 3 and 4 from execution proceedings by Order 22, Rule 12. The opinion does not purport to announce a novel legal principle beyond the application of those precedents to the facts; it affirms the existing legal position as applied to these proceedings.
1. Suit filed by Sri Sita Ram for recovery of rent having been decreed, he filed an application for execution to execute the decree. It appears that execution proceedings were stayed by this Court and during the period of stay Sita Ram died. After stay order was vacated respondents Nos. 3 to 5, the widow and two sons of Sita Ram moved an application before the execution court for bringing their names on record in place of Sita Ram so as to enable them to continue the execution proceedings. Petitioner, who was defendant in the suit and is judgment-debtor, filed objection against the aforesaid application of the heirs and legal representatives of Sita Ram. Objection having been rejected, petitioner filed a revision before the learned District Judge, which has also been dismissed by order dated 28-8-1990. It is against these orders of the execution court and the learned District Judge that this writ petition has been filed.
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner has challenged the impugned orders on the grounds that (i) execution proceedings cannot be continued by heirs and legal representatives of deceased decree-holder unless succession certificate u/S. 214 of the Succession Act has been obtained, and (ii) even if Rules 3, 4 and 8 of O. 22 of the C.P.C are not applicable to the execution proceedings, application for substitution has to be made so as to bring on record the heirs and legal representatives of the deceased decree-holder and there being no other provision for making such an application except S. 151 of the C.P.C this application has to be filed within three years as provided for by Art. 137 of the Limitation Act.
3. Order 22, R. 12 lays down that nothing in Rules 3, 4 and 8 shall apply to proceedings in execution of a decree or order. Rules 3 and 4 of Order 22 provide for making of an application for substituting the heirs of plaintiff and defendant within the time provided by law, with the result that if such an application is not made, suit stands abated. When R. 12 lays down that nothing in Rules 3 and 4 will apply to execution proceedings, it means that even if heirs are not brought on record, execution proceedings will not abate. The legal representatives of the deceased decree-holder are not required to move substitution application and as held by a Division Bench of this Court in Manmohan Dayal v. Kailash Nath, AIR 1957 All 647 : 1957 All LJ 578 they are entitled to ask for continuation of execution proceedings without moving any fresh application for execution.
4. This Court in S. Khandelwal v. B. Prasad, AIR 1972 All 321 : 1972 All LJ 66 has laid down that provisions of S. 214 of the Succession Act do not apply to application of a person seeking to continue the execution proceedings after the death of decree-holder, inasmuch as the legal representatives merely request the execution court for continuation of the execution proceedings already initiated by the deceased decree-holder. This Court declared that S. 214 of the Succession Act prohibits the institution of execution proceedings by a person claiming as successor but it does not bar the continuance of the proceedings if the execution proceedings had already started by the deceased decree-holder. The first plea of the learned counsel for the petitioner as such, cannot be accepted.
5. Regarding the second plea about limitation, it may be mentioned that Rr. 3 and 4 of O. 22 of the C.P.C lay down that application for substitution is to be made within the specified time and as these rules are not applicable to execution proceedings, in view of R. 12 of O. 22, C.P.C period of limitation for permission to continue the execution proceedings cannot be applied. Art. 137 of the Schedule of the Limitation Act prescribes period of limitation of three years for “Any other application for which no period of limitation is provided elso where in this division.” This Article cannot apply to each and every application even if no period of limitation is provided by the Limitation Act for such an application, when what is required to be done by the court is merely an act of ministerial character or when the court is enjoined by law do something on its own accord, this Article may not apply, even if party concerned makes an application and the court passes an order in connection therewith. This Court in Budh Singh v. Additional District Judge, AIR 1986 All 49 has laid down that, when (at pages 49 & 50; AIR 1986 All):
“the decree-holder dies it is open to the legal representatives claiming interest in the estate of the deceased or as being entitled to proceed with the decree, to come up just by way of information to the execution court and thereafter proceed with the execution. Since under the Code no application for substitution or otherwise is required to be made by such legal representatives, it cannot be claimed that the bar of Art. 137 of the Limitation Act is attracted. Art. 137 may be invoked where an application is required under law to be necessarily made in order to confer or create a right to proceed in a matter but where no such application is the requirement of law, the bar of limitation is inapplicable.”
6. The second submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner also lacks force.
7. The writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
8. Petition dismissed.
Alert