- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Raghvendra Mathur v. Allahabad Bank And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion (S.H.A Raza, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The writ petition challenges an order dated December 5, 1988 transferring the petitioner, employed as a Clerk at Allahabad Bank, Lucknow, to the newly established Allahabad Bank branch at Gonda. The petitioner contends that the transfer contravenes the transfer policy in the Shastri Award (specifically Paragraph 534 as initially pleaded and Paragraph 536 as applied in reasoning) and the bank's guidelines on transfer/job rotation for Award Staff dated June 11, 1988 (Annexure 4). The transfer was said by the opposite party to have been passed at the request of the General Secretary of the Staff Association (letter dated September 6, 1988), who requested that the junior-most clerks-cum-cashier be posted at the Gonda region.
The petitioner also relied on suggestions or an agreed settlement (Annexure 5) between the All India Allahabad Bank Employees Co-ordination Committee and the Bank Authorities, which — according to the petitioner — set out seniority-based considerations (employees with 15, 10, and 5 years of continuous service at a branch to be considered in that order). The petitioner claimed he had about one year of service at the branch and that his transfer disregarded the agreed guidelines and settlement.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the impugned transfer order (Annexure 2) is in conformity with the transfer policy contained in the Shastri Award (paras referenced, including Para 536) and with the bank guidelines on transfer/job rotation of Award Staff dated June 11, 1988 (Annexure 4), which were said to be agreed by management and union.
- Whether the transferring authority abused its discretion in effecting the transfer, i.e., whether the transfer was motivated by considerations other than the needs of administration.
- Whether the settlement/agreement (Annexure 5) between the All India Allahabad Bank Employees Co-ordination Committee and the bank authorities operates as a binding condition of service under Section 18(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act (as amended) and whether that settlement prevents the transfer in this case.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The transfer order dated December 5, 1988 contravenes Paragraph 534 (as pleaded) and Paragraph 536 principles of the Shastri Award regarding transfer policy and limits on the number/frequency of transfers.
- The transfer violated the bank's general guidelines on transfer/job rotation for Award Staff dated June 11, 1988 (Annexure 4), which were arrived at by mutual consent between the union and the bank and generally provided that transfer of Award Staff who have not completed five years at a branch will not normally be considered and transfers may be within the same station.
- The transfer disregarded the suggestions / settlement recorded in Annexure 5, which set seniority-based criteria (15, 10, and 5 years) for consideration before effecting transfers; the petitioner had about one year, and others senior to him were retained.
Opposite Parties' Arguments
- Banks have the right to transfer staff according to exigencies of service; management is in the best position to decide distribution of employees among branches.
- The impugned transfer was passed considering the exigencies of the service and was made at the request of the General Secretary of the Staff Association (letter dated September 6, 1988) to post junior-most clerks-cum-cashier at Gonda.
- Reliance upon precedents (including Syndicate Bank case, A.I.R. 1966 S.C. 1283, 1982 U.P. Services cases and SCC citations) to support the management's right to transfer employees.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Management of the Syndicate Bank v. The Workmen (1) | Affirms that banks are entitled to decide transfers based on necessities of banking business and that management is best placed to distribute employees among branches. | The court acknowledged the principle but emphasized that transfers must conform to agreed policies (e.g., Shastri Award) and that management discretion can be abused; thus the Syndicate Bank authority is not absolute where mutual agreements apply. |
| Sri Pradeep Kumar Saraswat v. Zonal Manager (Writ Petition No. 4937 of 1986) | A Division Bench endorsed the view that management has transfer rights after considering Para 534 of the Shastri Award; the Division Bench vacated an interim order and rejected a stay application. | The court noted this endorsement but observed that the cited proceedings did not involve the specific mutual-consent guidelines (Annexure 4) at issue in the present case; the earlier writ petition remains pending. |
| Hindustan Lever Ltd. v. Hindustan Ltd. (3) | Courts should seek to uphold agreements arrived at by mutuality and consensus and prefer maintaining industrial peace by respecting settlements. | The court relied on this reasoning to support the binding nature of the settlement/agreement (Annexure 5) and to prefer upholding the mutual settlement as an inviolable condition of service. |
| A.I.R. 1966 S.C. 1283 | Invoked by opposite parties to support that transfers made considering exigencies of service should be upheld. | The court observed that this authority (and similar cited cases) did not deal with transfer guidelines formulated by mutual consent between union and management (as in Annexure 4/5) and therefore such authorities were not applicable to the facts of the present case. |
| 1982 U.P. Services cases at page 541; (1986) 4 SCC 541; (1986) 4 SCC 131 | Invoked to support the management's full right to transfer employees between branches. | The court held these rulings were not applicable because none of them considered general guidelines on transfer/job rotation that were formulated by mutual consent between union and management; thus they did not govern the present dispute. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by acknowledging the general principle that banks may transfer staff according to the exigencies of service and that management is usually best placed to decide employee distribution among branches. However, this general managerial prerogative is subject to the constraints of any policy agreed between the parties and the Shastri Award.
The court referred specifically to Paragraph 536 of the Shastri Award, which limits the number of transfers a workman should normally be subjected to (normally not more than once a year) and warns that managerial discretion may be abused where transfers are effected on considerations other than administrative needs. The court therefore framed the central question as whether the petitioner’s transfer complied with the Shastri Award and the mutually agreed bank guidelines, or whether the transferring authority abused its discretion.
The court examined Annexure 4 (the general guidelines on transfer/job rotation of Award Staff dated June 11, 1988), accepted as having been issued by Head Office and arrived at by mutual consent between the All India Allahabad Bank Employees Co-ordination Committee and bank authorities. Those guidelines provide that management may transfer employees who have completed more than five years at a branch, but that Award Staff who have not completed five years will not normally be considered for transfer and transfers may be within the same station.
The court noted two relevant admissions by the opposite parties: (1) the guidelines in Annexure 4 were issued by the Head Office, and (2) the impugned transfer was passed on the request of the General Secretary of the Staff Association. The petitioner’s reliance on Annexure 5 (described as a settlement/suggestions setting out priority based on 15/10/5 years) was considered authoritative by the court because the settlement had not been terminated.
The court analyzed the legal effect of such settlements under statutory law. It discussed sub-section (1) of Section 18 of the Industrial Disputes Act (as introduced by the Amending Act of 1956), explaining that settlements arrived at between employer and workmen otherwise than in the course of conciliation proceedings are binding on the parties to the agreement and that terms of settlements become part of the contract of employment of employees represented by their union. The court further observed that even if the settlement was not in the exact prescribed form under Rule 58 of the Industrial Disputes (Central) Rules, 1957, that defect did not invalidate the settlement where there was no dispute challenging it.
The court relied on the authority in Hindustan Lever Ltd. v. Hindustan Ltd. to underscore the judicial preference for upholding agreements arrived at by mutual consent to minimize industrial strife.
Having applied these principles, the court concluded that the settlement/agreement (Annexure 5) and the mutually agreed guidelines (Annexure 4) operate as binding conditions of service. Because the petitioner had not completed five years at the Lucknow branch (about one year only), his transfer to Gonda contravened the mutual guidelines and the settlement, and the management could not properly deviate from the mutual consent reached with the union. The court therefore found the transfer order to be in contravention of the agreed policy and an abuse of discretion in the circumstances.
The court also addressed the opposite parties' reliance upon case law upholding managerial transfer powers (e.g., Syndicate Bank, A.I.R. 1966 S.C. 1283 and the other cited authorities) and explained those precedents did not involve transfer guidelines formulated by mutual consent between union and management; consequently, they were not applicable to the facts of this writ petition.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court found in favour of the petitioner. The writ petition is allowed and the transfer order contained in Annexure 2 is quashed. No order as to costs.
Implications: The direct consequence is that the petitioner's transfer to the Gonda branch is set aside and the transfer order is invalidated. The court treated the mutually agreed guidelines and the settlement (Annexures 4 and 5) as binding conditions of service under Section 18(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act; hence, in similar factual circumstances where a mutual settlement on transfer policy exists and is not terminated, management may be constrained by that settlement. The opinion does not purport to lay down a general new precedent beyond applying established principles concerning the binding nature of mutual settlements and the limits on managerial discretion; it simply applies those principles to quash the specific transfer order in this case.
S.H.A Raza, J.:— This writ petition is directed against the im pugned order dated December 5, 1988 by means of which the petitioner who is employed as Clerk in Allahabad Bank, Lucknow was transferred to Allahabad Bank Branch Gonda in a newly established branch of the said bank. The new grounds upon which the transfer order has been challenged are that the impugned order of transfer has been passed in contravention of Para 534 of the Shastri Award dealing with the trans fer policy of transferring an employee working in the said bank as well as the guidelines, dated June 11, 1988 on transfer job rotation of Award Staff adopted by the said bank.
2. There is no dispute that banks are entitled to transfer its staff on the exigencies of the service from one particular branch to another and the Management is in the best position to judge how to transfer its staff between different branches, but it has to be seen whether the impugned order of transfer is in conformity with the policy regarding transfer which has been agreed upon by the parties and which has subject to the Shastri Award. It is provided in Para 536 of the said award that in all cases the number of transfers to which a Workman is subjected should be strictly limited and normally it should not be more than once in a year. It has also been laid down in the said award that the discretion (from transferring an employee from a particular branch to another branch) may be abused and transfers effected on considerations other than the needs of the administration. Thus, in this case, it has to be seen whether the transfer of the petitioner is in accordance with policy laid down in Shastri Award or not; and whether the transferring authority has abused his discretion in the matter of the transfer. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Management of the Syndicate Bank v. The Workmen (1), has laid down that there is no doubt that the banks are entitled to decide on the considerations of necessities of the banking business whether the transfer of an employee should be made to a particular branch “and further observed that” there is no doubt that the Management of the bank is in the best position to judge how to distribute its employees between the different branches. In Writ Petition No. 4937 of 1986, Sri Pradeep Kumar Saraswat v. Zonal Manager, a Division Bench of this Court consisting of Hon'ble Mr. Justice S.S Ahamad and Hon'ble Mr. Justice Brijesh Kumar, have also endorsed the above view, after considering Para 534 of the Shastri Award and vacated the interim order, dated December 31, 1986 passed in the aforesaid writ petition and rejected the stay application. The said writ petition is still pending for disposal. The other ground which was vehemently argued on behalf of petitioner was that opposite parties have no right to transfer him from Luck-. now Branch to Gonda branch inasmuch as the said order of transfer was in contravention of the general guide lines on transfer/job rotation of the Award Staff, dated June 11, 1988 contained in Annexure 4 issued by the Deputy General Manager Punjab Bank Head Office 2, Netaji Subhash Marg, Calcutta.
3. The opposite party No. 2 in his own counter-affidavit in Paras 17 and 18 has not denied this fact that the aforementioned guide lines were issued by the Head Office of the bank. In Para 18 of the counter-affidavit the opposite party No. 2 has stated that the impugned order of transfer was passed on the request of General Secretary of the Staff Association, who in his letter dated September 6, 1988 has stated that the junior most clerks-cum-cashier be posted at Gonda Region.
4. A perusal of Annexure 4, i.e, the general guide lines on transfer/job rotation of Award Staff which was arrived as a result of natural consent between All India Allahabad Bank Employees Co-ordination Committee and the Bank authorities should show that the Management has the right to transfer an employee who had completed more than five years at a particular branch/office and normally the transfer of ‘Award Staff’ who has not completed five years at a particular branch/office will not be considered and the transfer may be made within the same station.
5. The petitioner has further stated that his transfer was also not in conformity with the suggestions made by the All India Bank Employees Union Co-ordination Committee contained in Annexure 5 to this writ petition. The petitioner has alleged in Para 21 of the writ petition, that the guide-lines contained in Annexure 5 were arrived upon as a result of mutual consent between All India Allahabad Bank Employees Co-ordination Committee and the Bank Authorities which provides that in regard to transfer of an employee who had completed 15 years or more continuous service in branch/office shall be considered. Then employees who have completed ten years or more continuous service in a branch/office shall be considered and then the employees who have completed five years or more in a branch/office shall be considered but in the present case the opposite party No. 3 without any basis or criteria had transferred the petitioner who has completed about one year of service in the bank and on the other hand retained other persons who are working on the post of clerk in the bank, prior to the posting of petitioner at Lucknow Branch. It is further alleged that at present more than 50 employees for the last 20 years are working in the main branch of the bank at Lucknow who are senior to the petitioner. In Para 19(1) of the counter-affidavit the opposite party No. 2 submitted that a perusal of Annexure 5 to the writ petition are mere suggestions from All India Allahabad Bank Employees Coordination Committee and the same have been considered while issuing the general guide-lines on transfer/job rotation of Award Staff, dated June 11, 1988. In view of the aforesaid assertions we have to find out as to whether the transfer of the petitioner is in accordance with general guide lines on the transfer/job rotation Award Staff or not. After giving our serious thought to the general guide-lines on transfer/job rotation Award Staff contained in Annexure 4 which was admittedly arrived at by mutual consent of the Unions and Bank Authorities. We are of the view that opposite party can not deviate or resile from the said mutual consent which agreed upon between the Management of the Bank and the Union. It is admitted by the opposite parties themselves that the aforesaid transfer order was passed at the behest of the General Secretary of the Staff Association.
6. Sub-section (1) of Section 18 of the Industrial Disputes Act, which was introduced by the Amending Act of 1956, was enacted to remedy a defect in the existing law. Prior to the amendment, there was no provision to make such settlements binding even on the parties thereto, with the result that the workmen notwithstanding such a settlement could raise an ‘industrial dispute’ on the identical matter agreed upon by their union. By the same amending Act, the definition of “settlement” was also amended, as the original definition contemplated only ‘a settlement arrived at in the course of conciliation proceedings’. This sub-section provides that a settlement arrived at by the agreement between the employer and the workmen “otherwise than in the course of conciliation” proceedings, as is apparent from the language of this provision shall be binding only “on the parties to the agreement”. Normally, it is the union or the representatives of the employees who enter into agreement with the employer. All the employees do not, as a matter of fact, become parties, to the agreement. But the settlement signed by such representatives binds all those whom they represent. Therefore, the terms of the settlement become a part of the contract of employment of each individual workman represented by such representative. In the instant case none of the parties have disputed or challenged the settlement. Hence even if the said settlement is not in accordance with the prescribed form as contemplated under Rule 58 of the Industrial Disputes (Central) Rules, 1957, it does not suffer from any defect. In workmen of Hindustan Lever Ltd. v. Hindustan Ltd. (3), Hon'ble Desai, J. ruled, the courts by interpretative process must strive to reduce the field of conflict and expand the area of agreement and show its preference for upholding agreements sanctified by mutuality and consensus in larger public interest, namely, to eschew industrial strife, confrontation and consequent wastage”.
7. The agreement or settlement contained in Annexure 5 which has not yet been terminated, will operate as inviolable condition of service of, the petitioner.
8. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the opposite parties has laid great stress that in view of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in A.I.R 1966 S.C 1283 and the order, dated January 15, 1987 passed by a Division Bench of this Court consisting of Hon'ble S.S Ahmad, J. and Hon'ble B. Kumar, J. in the stay matter in Writ Petition No. 4937 of 1986; the writ petition in question deserves to be dismissed as the impugned order of transfer was passed by the opposite parties considering the exigencies of the service. The learned counsel for the opposite party has also relied upon 1982 U.P Services cases at page 541 and (1986) 4 SCC 541 and (1986) 4 SCC 131; in support of his argument that the Management of the Bank has full right to transfer the bank employees from a particular branch to another branch. In none of the aforesaid cases the general guidelines on transfer/job rotation of Award Staff, which were formulated as a result of mutual consent and agreement between the Union and the Management of the Bank were subject-matter of controversy, the aforesaid rulings are not applicable to the facts of this writ petition. Admittedly the petitioner has not completed more than five years at a particular branch at Allahabad-Lucknow Branch hence it is not proper for the opposite parties to transfer him from Allahabad Bank Lucknow Branch of the Bank to Allahabad Bank Branch at Gonda. His transfer order contained in. Annexure 2 was totally in disregard and contravention of the general guidelines contained in Annexure 4.
9. The writ petition is allowed and the transfer order of the petitioner contained in Annexure 2 is quashed. No order as to costs.
Alert