- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Surendra Nath Mittal v. Dayanand Swarup
Factual and Procedural Background
This revision arises under S. 25 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, filed by the tenant (the revisionist). The plaintiff-respondent had earlier instituted Suit No. 39 of 1979 for arrears of rent and ejectment, which was decreed ex parte on 13 November 1979. The revisionist subsequently applied for restoration of the suit to its original number and, pursuant to the proviso to S. 17 of the Act, made deposits (initially short of the required amount). The plaintiff-respondent objected to the short deposit. The revisionist then made further deposits and filed an application for condonation of delay in making those deposits.
The 1st Additional District Judge, Bulandshahr, by order dated 7 July 1982, dismissed the restoration application for non-compliance with S. 17 within the prescribed time and also dismissed the revisionist's application for condonation of delay in depositing the required amount. The present revision challenges that order dated 7 July 1982.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Court below erred in dismissing the application for condonation of delay solely on the ground that the applicant did not explain each and every day's delay.
- Whether, having eventually deposited the amount required by the proviso to S. 17, the revisionist should have been granted condonation of delay and permitted to be heard on the merits of the suit (noted by the revisionist's counsel, but the court considered this to be for the lower court on merits).
Arguments of the Parties
Revisionist's Arguments
- The Court below acted illegally and with material irregularity by dismissing the condonation application merely because every day's delay was not explained.
- The revisionist had, in fact, deposited the entire amount required by the proviso to S. 17 and therefore the delay should have been condoned so that the revisionist could be heard on the merits of the suit.
Plaintiff-Respondent's Arguments
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the plaintiff-respondent's legal arguments beyond the fact that the plaintiff-respondent objected to the initial short deposit.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Smt. Pari Bai v. Bhagat Ram, AIR 1977 All 549 | Held that it is not necessary to explain each and every day's delay; a court cannot require explanation "with mathematical precision" when considering condonation of delay. | The court relied on this precedent to conclude that the lower court's requirement of explaining every day's delay was erroneous and that the condonation application must be considered on an overall basis; the matter was remanded for reconsideration in that light. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the lower court's judgment of 7 July 1982 and found that the application for condonation of delay was dismissed solely because the revisionist did not explain each and every day's delay. The court observed that the proviso to S. 17 exists to protect landlords from unscrupulous tenants who might deliberately avoid appearance to procure an ex parte decree and then seek to set it aside, and therefore it should be given a protective purpose. At the same time, the court emphasized that the proviso must be liberally construed so that a bona fide depositor is not deprived of the opportunity to be heard on the merits.
Applying the principle from Smt. Pari Bai v. Bhagat Ram, the court held that a requirement to explain delay with "mathematical precision" is inappropriate. Instead, the court should consider the overall explanation and the circumstances that led to the later deposit in compliance with the proviso. The court found the approach of the lower court—requiring day-by-day explanation—wholly erroneous and likely to cause grave injustice.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The revision is allowed: the order dated 7 July 1982 is set aside, and the case is remanded to the Court below for reconsideration of the application for restoration and the application for condonation of delay in making the deposit under the proviso to S. 17 of the Act in accordance with law and the observations made by the appellate court.
Implications:
- The lower court must reconsider the condonation application on an overall basis rather than by requiring an explanation for each and every day's delay.
- The reconsideration should take into account the circumstances of the deposit and the purpose and liberal construction of the proviso to S. 17.
- There is no indication in the opinion that a new binding precedent was intended to be created; the court applied and reiterated existing principles from the cited precedent.
- The parties were directed to bear their own costs.
1. This is a revision filed under S. 25 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act by the tenant. The plaintiff-respondent had filed a suit No. 39 of 1979 for arrears of rent and ejectment. This suit was decreed ex parte on 13th Nov., 1979. The revisionist thereafter moved an application for restoration of the suit to its original number. He also made certain deposits as required under the proviso to S. 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, hereinafter referred to as the Act. The deposit was short and consequently the plaintiff-respondents filed an objection to that effect. Thereafter the revisionist made further deposits and also filed an application for condonation of delay in making the said deposits. The 1st Additional District Judge, Bulandshahr by order dt. July 7, 1982 dismissed the restoration application for non-compliance of the provisions of S. 17 of the Act within the time prescribed. The application moved by the revisionist for condonation of delay in depositing the amount as required by proviso to S. 17 of the Act was also dismissed. It is this order dt. 7th July, 1982 which is the subject-matter of challenge in this revision.
2. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties. Learned counsel for the revisionist has contended that the Court below has acted illegally and with material irregularity in the exercise of its jurisdiction in dismissing the application for condonation of delay merely on the ground that each and every day's delay has not been explained in the application. He has further contended that in fact the entire amount as required by proviso to S. 17 of the Act has been deposited and consequently the Court below should have condoned the delay in depositing the amount and permitted the revisionist to be heard on merits of the suit. So far as the second question is concerned, in my opinion, it is not necessary for me to go into this question as this is the matter which is to be decided by the Court below on merits. The first submission made by the learned counsel for the revisionist in regard to the application for condonation of delay, in my opinion, has substance.
3. I have examined the judgment of the Court below dt. 7th July, 1982. The application for condonation of delay in making the deposit as required by the proviso to S. 17 of the Act has merely been dismissed by the Court below on the ground that each and every day's delay should have been explained by the revisionist. With this observation the application for condonation of delay has been rejected. The Court below has not considered the overall explanation given by the revisionist for condonation of delay as also the circumstances leading to the subsequent deposit of the amount by the revisionist in compliance of the proviso to S. 17 of the Act.
4. The proviso to S. 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act is as follows:—
“Provided that an applicant for an order to set aside a decree passed ex parte or for a review of judgment shall, at the time of presenting his application, either deposit in the Court the amount due from him under the decree or in pursuance of the judgment, or give such security for the performance of the decree or compliance with the judgment as the Court may, on a previous application made by him in this behalf, have directed.”
5. The only object behind this proviso is that the unscrupulous tenants against whom rent is due and who do not appear on the date fixed by the Court, may not take advantage of not paying the rent and thereby causing harassment to the landlord. It is often found that the defendants to a suit do not appear with a purpose that an ex parte decree would be passed and then an application for setting aside the ex parte decree would be made, thereby prolonging the litigation. This proviso, consequently, protects the landlord from further harassment and secures the payment of rent.
6. It is well settled that this proviso has to be liberally construed. In the circumstances, the delay in depositing the amount should also be liberally construed in order to enable the person, who has bona fide deposited the amount gets an opportunity of being heard by a Court of law on the merits of the case.
7. In Smt. Pari Bai v. Bhagat Ram, AIR 1977 All 549, the question came up for consideration whether each and every day's delay should be satisfactorily explained in order to entitle a person for condonation of delay. The Bench held that it was not necessary that each and every day's delay be explained. It further observed as follows:—
“It is true that a person coming to the Court after the prescribed period is required to explain the delay and he can succeed in getting the delay condoned only when he satisfactorily explains it. But a Court of law cannot require such a person to explain the delay with mathematical precision.”
8. In view of the principles laid down in the abovementioned case, the Court below has to consider the application for condonation of delay on an overall consideration of the facts on record and not as a matter of mathematical precision. The approach, in my opinion, of the Court below is wholly erroneous. This approach is likely to lead to a grave injustice and does not advance the cause of justice. It is, consequently, necessary that the application for condonation of delay moved by the revisionist should be considered by the Court below in the right perspective.
9. In the result, I allow the revision, set aside the order dt. Jul. 7, 1982 and remand the case to the Court below for consideration of the application for restoration as well as the application for condonation of delay in making deposit under the proviso to S. 17 of the Act in accordance with law in the light of the observations made above.
10. The parties are, however, directed to bear their own costs.
11. Revision allowed.
Alert