- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Smt. Sudha Srivastava v. Claims Commissioner, Northern Railway, Allahabad And Another
Structured Summary of the Judicial Opinion (R.K. Shukla, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
This is a first appeal under Order 43, Rule 1, C.P.C. and Section 82F of the Railways Act against the order dated 27 April 1979 passed by the ad hoc Claims Commissioner, Northern Railway, Allahabad. The Commissioner had rejected claim petition No. 20 filed by Smt. Sudha Srivastava.
The claim arose from a collision between the 103 Up Delux Express and the UPC Special at Naini Railway Station (Allahabad Division) at 00:15 hours on 10 October 1977. By an application dated 7 January 1978 (presented 9 January 1978) Smt. Sudha Srivastava sought Rs. 5 lakhs as compensation under Section 82F of the Railways Act, alleging that her husband, Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava, was a passenger on the 103 Up Delux Express and died in that collision. She filed the claim on her own behalf and as guardian of her two minor unmarried daughters and four minor sons.
The Railway administration denied that the alleged deceased was a bona fide passenger, stated that his name did not appear in the official list of dead persons, and denied that the applicant was a dependent. On the pleadings the ad hoc Claims Commissioner framed three issues for determination (see below). The Commissioner decided all issues against the appellant, prompting this appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Ram Naresh Srivastava was a bona fide passenger in the train which met with the accident? If so, whether he died as a result of the accident?
- Whether the applicants are dependents of Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava?
- To what compensation, if any, are the applicants entitled?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant (Smt. Sudha Srivastava) alleged that her husband was a passenger on the 103 Up Delux Express and died in the collision; she sought compensation under Section 82F.
- The appellant produced her own testimony, testimony of Sri Satya Narain Varma (who purportedly saw the deceased board the train), and documentary evidence. The appellant also relied on recovery by the Railway of a hand-bag and items identified as belonging to Ram Naresh Srivastava.
- Learned counsel for the appellant contended that the ad hoc Claims Commissioner improperly relied on knowledge derived from another claim (Claim Case No. 3 of 1978) and that such use of external knowledge was impermissible; counsel cited authorities in support of that contention.
Railway Administration's Arguments
- In its written statement the Railway maintained that Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava was not a bona fide passenger on the ill-fated train and that his name did not appear in the official list of dead persons.
- The Railway also denied that the applicant was a dependent of the alleged deceased.
- The Railway produced two Sub-Inspectors of Police who proved FIRs indicating other criminal proceedings and an allegation that the alleged deceased was absconding in relation to those matters.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| M. Lakshmayya v. Sri Rajah Varadaraja Apparow Bahadur, (1912) ILR 36 Mad 168 | Consideration of whether a Judge may rely on personal knowledge of facts (here, facts of economic history) and whether such reliance was illegal. | The Court summarized the case to show that reliance on personal knowledge is not always impermissible, depending on the nature of the facts; this authority was discussed in the context of the ad hoc Claims Commissioner's use of knowledge from another claim. |
| The Lokmanya Mills Barsi Limited v. Barsi Municipal Council, AIR 1968 Bom 229 | Illustration that a Court may take judicial notice of facts of general knowledge (the Bench took judicial notice of three particular facts regarding land and building values). | Referred to define the scope of judicial notice and to contrast permissible judicial notice of general facts with impermissible reliance on unproved specific facts from another case. |
| Abida Khatoon v. State of U.P., AIR 1963 All 260 | Warning that Courts may take judicial notice of "notorious facts" but should not import controversial or debatable matters as notorious facts; the Court must not smuggle its own opinion of controversial situations as notorious facts. | Quoted to support the proposition that the ad hoc Claims Commissioner should not have treated controversial or unproved particulars as matters of judicial notice or as facts known to him personally in reaching his decision. |
| Dhirajlal Girdharilal v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Bombay, AIR 1955 SC 271 | When a Court of fact acts on material partly relevant and partly irrelevant, the resulting finding may be vitiated because it is impossible to determine the extent to which irrelevant material affected the decision. | Applied to underscore that reliance on inadmissible or irrelevant material (for example, facts taken from another claim) can vitiate a finding; the appellate court said it would ignore such material from the other claim. |
| American Jurisprudence, Vol. 20, Art. 18 (Matters of common knowledge) | Describes the test and limits for taking judicial notice—facts must be of common and general knowledge, sufficiently notorious to be assumed without proof. | Referred to as an authoritative description of when judicial notice is appropriate and to support the court's assessment of the ad hoc Claims Commissioner's conduct in referring to external facts. |
| Smt. Sundari Devi v. Union of India, 1984 All WC 438 : AIR 1984 All 277 | Holdings that compensation under the relevant law can be claimed only for a person who was a bona fide passenger; one without a ticket or valid pass cannot be held to be a bona fide passenger. | The court applied this precedent to emphasize that the appellant was required to prove beyond doubt that her husband was a bona fide passenger and died in the accident; since these facts were not established, the appellant could not claim compensation. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court conducted a fact-focused, step-by-step analysis constrained strictly to the evidence on record and explicitly avoided reliance on facts known to the ad hoc Claims Commissioner from a separate claim (Claim Case No. 3 of 1978). The salient points of its reasoning are as follows:
- Evaluation of witness evidence: The Court considered the testimony of Sri N. Varma who said he saw Ram Naresh Srivastava board the train at Mughalsarai on the night of 9-10-1977. The Court found this evidence unreliable for multiple reasons stated on the record: Varma's advanced age (about 72), improbability of his night trip to see off a non-relative young contractor, lack of clarity on several details (when/where they met; ticket payment), Varma's admission that he learned of the accident from newspapers, his delay in taking steps to verify whether Ram Naresh was involved in the accident, and other inconsistencies and omissions in his conduct after the accident. The Court concluded Varma's conduct and evidence were "unnatural, artificial and made only for the purposes of the case" and refused to place reliance on his testimony.
- Conduct and evidence of the appellant: The Court noted appellant's inaction and delays (e.g., not going promptly to Allahabad) after receiving information, that the appellant was not an eyewitness to Ram Naresh travelling, and contradictions between earlier written assertions (identification of a photograph said to be of her husband) and later trial statements in which she abandoned that claim. The Court emphasized that mere recovery of a hand-bag bearing some articles of Ram Naresh Srivastava could not, by itself, establish that he died in the accident.
- Police evidence and FIRs: The Railway produced two police witnesses who proved FIRs. One FIR (28-8-1977) under Section 364 IPC related to an alleged kidnapping and yielded a final report accepted by the Magistrate; another FIR (28-1-1978) under Sections 420/468 IPC was under investigation with the accused stated to be absconding. From this material the Court noted the investigation into other offences and that Ram Naresh was reported absconding in relation to one matter. The Court said that on the basis of the police statements and other evidence it was not satisfied that death of Ram Naresh was proved beyond reasonable doubt.
- Standard of proof and statutory prerequisites: The Court emphasized the legal requirement under Section 82F of the Railways Act that certain prerequisites must be satisfied to claim the statutory benefit; these prerequisites are mandatory. The Court referred to the Full Bench decision in Smt. Sundari Devi v. Union of India holding that compensation is available only for bona fide passengers, and observed that the appellant was required to prove beyond doubt that her husband was a bona fide passenger and died as a result of the accident—facts not proved in this record.
- On reliance on facts from another claim: The Court accepted the appellant's counsel's contention that the ad hoc Claims Commissioner had referred to facts known to him from having tried another claim (Ram Naresh Singh of Nalanda) and that reliance on such specific, unproved facts was impermissible. The appellate Court explicitly disregarded any such extraneous facts and confined itself to the evidence on the record before it.
- Conclusion from analysis: After evaluating witness testimony, documentary evidence, the police material, and applying the legal standards (including precedents on judicial notice and inadmissible material), the Court concluded that neither the fact that Ram Naresh Srivastava was a bona fide passenger nor that he died in the train accident had been proved beyond reasonable doubt.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The appeal is dismissed. The Court held that the appellant failed to establish that Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava was a bona fide passenger on the ill-fated 103 Up Delux Express and failed to prove his death in that train accident beyond reasonable doubt; consequently, the appellant is not entitled to any compensation under Section 82F of the Railways Act.
Direct implications for the parties: The appellant's claim for compensation is rejected and the decision of the ad hoc Claims Commissioner is affirmed insofar as the appellant's entitlement is concerned. The Court ordered that there would be no order as to costs.
Broader implications / precedent: The Court applied and discussed authorities concerning (a) the limits of judicial notice, (b) the impropriety of a judge acting on extraneous or personally known facts from another case, and (c) the necessity of proving bona fide passenger status for claiming compensation under the Railways Act. The opinion emphasizes that statutory prerequisites for Section 82F are mandatory and that the appellant's failure to discharge the requisite proof defeats the claim. The opinion does not purport to lay down any novel legal principle beyond application of these existing authorities.
Order: Appeal dismissed. No order as to costs.
R.K Shukla, J.:— This first appeal from order under O. 43, R. 1, C.P.C and under S. 82-F of the Railways Act is directed against the order dated 27th April 1979 passed by the ad hoc Claims Commissioner, Northern Railway, Allahabad. By this order, the claim petition filed by Smt. Sudha Srivastava was rejected and aggrieved by the same, the appellant Smt. Sudha Srivastava has come up before us by way of this appeal.
2. The brief facts giving rise to this appeal are that 103 Up Delux Express train and UPC Special train collided at Naini Railway Station of Allahabad Division on 10th Oct. 1977 at 00.15 hours. The appellant through an application dated 7th Jan. 1978 presented on 9th Jan. 1978 for grant of Rs. Five Lakhs as compensation u/s. 82F of the Railways Act, alleged that her husband Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava was travelling by the aforesaid 103 Up Delux Express train from Mugalsarai to Kanpur, died as a result of the collision of the aforesaid trains on 10th Oct. 1977. Smt. Sudha Srivastava filed claim petition No. 20 on her own behalf and as a guardian of her two minor unmarried daughters and four minor sons for the alleged death of her husband Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava, who is claimed to have been a passenger on 103 Up Delux Express train. On the other hand, in the written statement filed by the Railway administration it has been stated that the alleged deceased was not a bona fide passenger in the aforesaid train and that the name of the alleged deceased is not borne out in the official list of the dead persons. It has also been denied that the applicant was a dependent of the alleged deceased. On the pleadings of the parties, the following issues were framed by the ad hoc Claims Commissioner Northern Railway Allahabad.
1. Whether Ram Naresh Srivastava was a bona fide passenger in the train which met with the accident? If so, whether he died as a result of the accident?
2. Whether the applicants are dependents of Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava?
3. To what compensation, if any, are the applicants entitled?
3. The appellant has examined herself and Sri Satya Narain Varma. She also filed some documentary evidence in support of her claim and also got summoned from the Railway administration a hand-bag containing a few books, shirt, a letter written by the applicant and a few documents belonging to Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava. The Railway administration examined two Sub-Inspectors of Police S/Sri B.P Gupta and Ram Kumar Dubey who have proved two First Information Reports. One F.I.R is dated 28-8-1977 under S. 364, Penal Code at Police Station Nawabganj, Kanpur and the second F.I.R is dated 28-1-1978 under S. 420 read with S. 468, Penal Code at Police Station Qaisarbagh, Lucknow. After considering the entire evidence on record, the learned ad hoc Claims Commissioner decided all the aforesaid issues against the appellant.
4. According to the evidence on record, it appears that Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava used to work as building Contractor at Aliganj, Lucknow. He had gone to Lucknow from Kanpur on 25-8-1977. On 27-8-1977 the applicant claims to have received information that some persons had abducted away her husband from Lucknow. She had lodged F.I.R on 20-8-1977 u/s. 364, I.P.C According to her (applicant), Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava paid her a visit for 10 or 15 minutes in the night between 3/4-9-1977 probably at 2 A.M or 2.30 A.M and had told her that he was proceeding to Ranchi. From the recitals in the letter of the appellant addressed to her husband found in the hand bag, it is clear that the appellant and her husband were apprehending that cases would be instituted against the latter. Sri R.K Dubey has stated that the case u/s. 420/468, IPC is under investigation as the accused is absconding.
5. Issue No. 1 is the main issue in this case. The first and most important point in this connection is whether Ram Naresh Srivastava was a bona fide passenger in the ill fated 103 Up Delux Express train, which met with an accident on 10th Oct 1977 at 00.15 hours, and whether he died as a result of that accident? In this connection, the appellant produced Sri N. Varma, aged about 72 years, resident of Nawabganj, Kanpur who retired from the post of Agriculture Inspector about some 16 years ago. According to Sri Verma, he had gone from Kanpur to Varanasi on 8-10-1977 to pay a visit to his daughter who lives in Varanasi. He returned to Kanpur from Varanasi on 13-10-1977. He knew Ram Naresh Srivastava resident of Nawabganj, Kanpur and met him last time in Varanasi. In the night of 9-10-1977, he went to Mughalsarai Station to see-off Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava. He purchased a second class railway ticket from Mughalsarai to Kanpur and saw Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava board on the ill-fated train i.e 103 UP Delux Express. According to Sri Varma, the Ticket Collector had assured that he would prepare a reservation ticket in the way. When the train started from Mughalsarai, he returned to Varanasi.
6. In the cross-examination, he stated that Ram Naresh was about 35 to 37 years old. He came to know about this accident through newspaper on 10-10-1977. He returned from Varanasi to Kanpur on 13-10-1977 and met Sri Raj Nath Sinha, father of the appellant on 14-10-1977. He told Mr. Raj Nath Sinha that he saw Ram Naresh Srivastava board the train which met with an accident. Sri Rajnath Sinha had told him that he would go to station and find out. After 2-3 days, Sri Rajnath Sinha had told him that a telegram had come to take the luggage of Ram Naresh Srivastava. According to Mr. Verma, Sri Raj Nath Sinha might have gone to Allahabad four or five days after his talk on 14-10-1977. On a consideration of the above, it does not look probable that a retired person, 72 years of age would have gone from Varanasi to Moghalsarai in the month of October at night time to see off a young man aged about 36 years, who was no relation of his. Why should Shri Ram Naresh, a young man aged about 36 years, not buy the train ticket himself, particularly when he does all the arduous work of a building contractor. This does not appear to be natural or believable. It is also not clear from the evidence as to when, where and at what time Ram Naresh Srivastava had met Sri S.N Verma on 9-10-1977. It is also not clear whether the ticket was purchased by Sri S.N Verma from his own purse or from the purse of Ram Naresh Srivastava. From the evidence, it is clear that he came to know about this incident through newspapers on 10-10-1977. If he was so interested to go to Mughalsarai Station in the night of October to see off Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava then it was natural for him to find out whether Ram Naresh Srivastava was also involved in that accident or not. He had taken no step in this direction till 13th Oct. 1977 at Varanasi On 13th, he may have returned from Varanasi to Kanpur by train. He again did not take any step to find out whether Ram Naresh Srivastava of his Mohalla Nawabganj, Kanpur was involved in the accident either at Mughalsarai or at Varanasi or at Allahabad or anywhere in the way. Even after his reaching Kanpur, he did not go to the house of Ram Naresh Srivastava which is situate in the same mohalla Nawabgunj, where he himself resides. It was only on the 14th Oct. 1977 that he told Rajnath Sinha that he had seen off Ram Naresh in the very train which met with the accident. The purpose of the visit to Varanasi has not been disclosed either, by Sri Verma or the appellant. The whole conduct of Shri Verma appears to us to be absolutely unnatural, artificial and made only for the purposes of the case. Therefore, in our opinion, no reliance can be placed on his evidence that he saw off Ram Naresh in the ill fated train on 9th Oct. 1977 as stated by him.
7. Shri Raj Nath Sinha father of the appellant, to whom Shri Varma narrated the story of seeing off Shri Ram Naresh at Moghulsarai Station, on the 14th Oct. 1977 has not been produced in Court. No attempt was made by the appellant or by Raj Nath Sinha to inquire about Ram Naresh in spite of the information given on the 14th Oct. 1977 by Shri Verma and even after the receipt of the telegram by the appellant on the 17th Oct. 1977. She came to Allahabad, seven days after her father was informed, i.e on the 21st October. This inaction on the part of the appellant and her father and the fact that they did not proceed to Allahabad immediately after the receipt of the information from Shri Verma and the telegram appears in the circumstances of the case to be highly unnatural and improper. It was only after seven days from the receipt of information from Shri Varma and 4 days after the receipt of the telegram that the appellant came to Allahabad. Smt Sudha Srivastava, appellant is not the witness of the fact that Ram Naresh Srivastava had travelled by the ill-fated traia. She did not have any personal knowledge about it. Further, from her own F.I.R it is also clear that the applicant and her husband were apprehending some cases to be instituted against the latter.
8. There is no direct evidence to prove that Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava died as a result of the aforesaid train accident. In her application dated 13-3-1978 — Ex. kha 1, the appellant has clearly stated, “Pati Ka Saman Na Milne Ke Karan Unki Yatra Ke Bisai Me Mai Kuch Bhi Batane Me Asamrth Hun.” From this recital, it appears that the appellant had drawn an inference that her husband had died in that accident on the basis of two facts firstly, recovery of hand-bag and secondly, her identification of a photograph as of her husband from amongst the photographs of those who had died as a result of the accident. She further stated that she was informed that the dead body of the man whose photograph had been identified by her was taken away by Birendra Kumar Singh, son of Ram Nandan Singh of district Nalanda (Bihar). In Ex. Kha 1, there is also recital to this effect. In the application dated 24-10-1977 (paper No. 5-C) addressed to the Divisional Superintendent Northern Railway, Allahabad from Smt. Sudha Srivastava, copy of which was also endorsed to the ad hoc Claims Commissioner, the appellant had claimed that she had identified photo No. 85 as that of her husband. But in her statement in the trial, the appellant has totally given up her case set up in the aforesaid paper No. 5-C and Ex. Kha 1 that she had identified the photograph of her husband from amongst the photographs of the dead bodies of those who had died as a result of accident. Under these circumstances, merely on the basis of recovery of hand bag belonging to Ram Naresh Srivastava containing some of his articles it cannot be said that he died in the aforesaid accident.
9. From the statement of Sri R.K Dubey, S.I (D.W 2) it appears that one Sri B.L Yadav, Executive Engineer filed a written report against Sri R.N Srivastava u/s. 420/468, IPC on 28-1-1978 at P.S Quaisar Bagh, Lucknow. Sri Dubey is investigating that case. Search of Ram Naresh Srivastava is going on and he was absconding to avoid arrest. From the evidence of Sri B.P Gupta, S.I it appears that Smt. Sudha Srivastava had also filed an F.I.R u/s. 364, I.P.C at P.S Nawabganj, Kanpur against Yogendra Singh, Tilak Singh, Satish Chandra Agarwal and an owner of Silk Mill on 28-8-1977 for kidnapping her husband. She has also admitted in her statement about this fact that she had actually lodged the above F.I.R.S.I Sri. B.P Gupta further stated that on the basis of the above F.I.R the case was registered at P.S Nawabganj and the matter was investigated by Amar Singh Chauhan. S.H.O Final report dated 28-8-1978 was sent to Court which has been accepted by the Munsif Magistrate, Nawabganj on 30-8-1978. After going through the statements of these two Police Officers and the evidence of Smt. Sudha Srivastava and Sri S.N Verma, we are not satisfied that death of Ram Naresh Srivastava has been proved beyond reasonable doubt in the aforesaid accident.
10. For the reasons stated above, we are fully satisfied that the appellant has failed to establish the first issue. Therefore, both the parts of this issue are decided in the negative.
11. So far as the second issue is concerned, there is no dispute that the appellant is the wife of Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava and her minor sons and daughters are by Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava. Had Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava died in the aforesaid accident, all of them would have been his dependents. Therefore, this issue is decided accordingly.
12. So far as the third issue is concerned, in view of our finding on the first issue, the appellant is not entitled for any compensation u/s. 82F of the Railways Act. S. 82F has prescribed certain requirements as preliminary to the requisition of benefit conferred by the statute and such prescriptions are mandatory for getting its advantage. Since, it is not proved that Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava was a bona fide passenger and he died as a result of the aforesaid accident, the appellant is not entitled to any compensation.
13. Learned counsel for the appellant has urged that the ad hoc Claims Commissioner, who also decided the claim arising out of the accident of one R.N Singh of Nalanda (Bihar) has wrongly utilized his knowledge derived from the evidence of that case No. 3 of 1978, which is not permissible. In support of his contention, he has cited four decisions namely M. Lakshmayya v. Sri Rajah Varadaraja Apparow Bahadur, (1912) ILR 36 Mad 168; The Lokmanya Mills Barsi Limited v. Barsi Municipal Council*, AIR 1968 Bom 229; Abida Khatoon v. State of U.P, AIR 1963 All 260 and Dhirajlal Girdharilal v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Bombay, AIR 1955 SC 271.
14. In M. Lakshmayya's case (supra), question of interpretation of words ‘nature of savaram land’ was involved. The District Judge imported his own knowledge which he acquired as a past revenue officer and as revenue Court for believing the evidence of plaintiff's witness rather than defendant's 3 witnesses. A Division Bench of the Madras High Court held that the facts for which the District Judge had such knowledge are merely facts of economical history and that he had not acted illegally in relying on it.
15. In Lokmanya's case (AIR 1968 Bom 229) (supra), a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court held that it is well established that the Court is entitled to take judicial notice of the facts which are of general knowledge. Their Lordships took judicial notice of three facts— (1) land values differ very materially in different towns in which municipalities are established under the Boroughs Act; (2) different types of mills and factories require different types of buildings and that their relative values do not vary according to their floor area and (3) buildings of mills and factories are new and some are old and that the value of a building decreases with its age, and held that the impugned provisions were ex facie discriminatory.
16. In Abida Khatoon's case (AIR 1963 All 260) (supra) Mr. Justice S.S Dhawan of this High Court has held as under:—
“……a Court can take judicial notice of what are known as “notorious facts” but the question whether the conditions in U.P in Feb. 1950, so far as communal disturbances were concerned, were fully settled is a matter of opinion and somewhat controversial. The Court cannot smuggle into the evidence its own opinion of controversial situations disguised as notorious facts.”
17. In Dhirajlal's case (AIR 1955 SC 271) (supra) the Supreme Court was called upon to decide as to when decision on question of fact gives rise to the question of law in connection with S. 66 of the Income tax Act, 1922. In that case, the Supreme Court has held as under:—
“It is well established that when a Court of fact acts on material, partly relevant and partly irrelevant, it is impossible to say to what extent the mind of the Court was affected by the irrelevant material used by it in arriving at its finding. Such a finding is vitiated because of the use of inadmissible material and thereby an issue of law arises.”
18. Matters on which judicial notice may be taken by Courts have been very well described in the American Jurisprudence. Volume 20, Art. 18 as under:—
“Matters of common knowledge. The matters of which a Court will take judicial notice must be a subject of common and general knowledge. In other words, judicial knowledge of facts is measured by general knowledge of the same facts. A fact is said to be generally recognized or known when its existence or operation is accepted by the public without qualification or contention. The test is whether sufficient notoriety attaches to the fact involved as to make it proper to assume its existence without proof. The fact that a belief is not universal, however, is not controlling, for there is scarcely any belief that is accepted by everyone. Those matters familiarly known to the majority of mankind or to those persons familiar with the particular matter in question are properly within the concept of judicial notice Judicial knowledge is continually extended to keep pace with the advance of art, science and general knowledge.”
19. Following the ratio of abovementioned cases and authorities, there is no doubt that ad hoc Claims Commissioner, Northern Railway was not right to rely on specific facts not proved by the evidence in the instant case but known to him personally because he tried the other claim case of one Ram Dulari for the loss occasioned in the above accident of her husband Sri Ram Naresh Singh of Nalanda which was registered as Claim Case No. 3 of 1978. Although the ad hoc Claims Commissioner, Northern Railway has casually mentioned those facts in addition to strengthen his arguments in the end but we, as court of appeal, have completely ignored those facts which have been taken into consideration from Claim Case No. 3 of 1978. We have strictly confined ourselves to the evidence available on the record. After careful examination of the evidence on record, completely ignoring the finding of the learned ad hoc Claims Commissioner, Northern Railway, Allahabad, we have come to our own conclusion as Court of appeal that neither Sri Ram Naresh Srivastava was bona fide passenger in the ill-fated 103 UP Delux Express train nor it can be said that his death has been proved in the train accident in question beyond reasonable doubt. After arriving at this conclusion, we have no option but to hold that appellant is not entitled to any compensation.
20. In a recent decision in Smt. Sundari Devi v. Union of India, 1984 All WC 438 : (AIR 1984 All 277), Full Bench of this Court has held that compensation can be claimed only in respect of a person who was a bona fide passenger. Anybody who did not have ticket or valid pass or travel document cannot be held to be a bona fide passenger.
21. In view of the above decision, the appellant had to prove beyond doubt that her husband Ram Naresh Srivastava, for whom she was claiming compensation, was actually travelling by the ill-fated train and he died as a result of aforesaid accident and that he was a bona fide passenger. None of these facts has been established in this case. Consequently, the appellant is not entitled for any claim.
22. Having examined the record of the case we are satisfied that the appeal has no merits whatsoever and it must fail for the above reason.
23. The question whether the appellant was dependent of Ram Naresh Srivastava and was entitled to the compensation does not arise once it is found that there was no proof that Ram Naresh Srivastava was a bona fide passenger and had died in the aforesaid train accident.
24. For the reasons indicated above, we find no force in this appeal which is accordingly dismissed. However, there will be no order as to costs.
25. Appeal dismissed.
Alert