- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
New Indian Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Smt. Hemlata Biswas And Others
K.M Dayal, J.:— This First Appeal From Order No. 2 of 1977 has been filed by the insurance company against the award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Gorakhpur, arising out of Motor Accident Claim No. 72 of 1915. A cross-objections has been filed by the claimants for enhancement of the compensation.
2. Smt. Hemlata Biswas and her two daughters filed a claim for Rs. 2,42,800/- on account of death of Sri Santosh Kumar Biswas, husband of Srimati Hemlata Biswas and father of the other claimants. It was alleged that at about 4 P.M on 24th Feb. 1975 Sri Santosh Kumar Biswas was travelling in Mini Bus No. USB 8212 owned by opposite party No. 2 Malkee Singh and insured by opposite party No. 3, New India Assurance Co. Ltd. That Mini Bus collided with Motor Track No. UPK 1951 owned by opposite party No. 1, Dilip Kumar Ahuja and insured by opposite party No. 4, National Insurance Co. Ltd. at Bargadwa Trijunction of Gorakhpur Nautanwa Highway. It was alleged that the truck was being driven rashly and negligently. In the accident deceased Santosh Kumar Biswas was thrown out of the Mini Bus, sustained injuries and succumbed to the same in the hospital. It was claimed that the average income of the deceased was Rs. 660/- per month. The claimants had been put to loss of that income. The damages for mental shock were also claimed. The National Insurance Co. Ltd. and Dilip Kumar Ahuja, owner and insurer of the Truck No. UPK 1951 denied the accident; in the alternative they pleaded that the accident took place due to the negligence of the driver of the Mini Bus. The death of Santosh Kumar Biswas on account of the accident was also denied and the amount of compensation claimed was alleged to be excessive.
3. The defence of the opposite parties Nos. 2 and 3 the owner and insurer of the Mini Bus was also similar. On issue No. 1 relating to the negligence of the driver of the Truck or the Mini Bus the court below held that the accident took place entirely due to the rash and negligent driving of Truck No. UPK 1951. The accident took place on Gorakhpur Nautanwa Highway when the Mini Bus was speeding towards Nautanwa and the Motor Truck arrived at this road from the other side.
4. The Accidents Claims Tribunal awarded Rs. 3750/- to Smt. Hemlata Biswas, claimant No. 1, payable by National Insurance Co. Ltd. Rs. 12,138/- was awarded to Km. Mannu which was payable by National Insurance Co. Ltd., opposite party No. 4. Rs. 11,988/- was awarded to Km. Santu. This amount was to be paid in part by the present appellant. It was directed that the National Insurance Company was liable to the extent of Rs. 6,988/- and the balance of Rs. 5,000/- was payable by New India Assurance Co., i.e, the appellant in the present appeal.
5. The appellant has challenged the award of compensation against New India Assurance Company on the finding that there was no negligence on the part of the driver of Mini Bus No. USB 8212 insured by it. A cross-objection has been filed by the claimant for enhancement of the claim. They have claimed Rs. 2,13,924/- more.
6. The learned counsel for the appellant raised only one question before us. His contention was that the finding in Issue No. 1 was in their favour i.e there was no negligence on the part of the driver of the Mini Bus. The appellant as an insurer was liable to indemnify only the owner or driver of Mini Bus in case they were liable to pay any damage. As the finding of the Tribunal was that the Mini Bus was not at fault the owner or driver of the same could not be liable. Consequently the appellant, the insurer of the Mini Bus also could not be liable to pay any amount as compensation. The compensation was payable solely by the National Insurance Company Ltd. which was insurer of the Truck No. UPK 1951, the driver of which was found at fault. His contention appears to be correct.
7. The notices on the National Insurance Co. Ltd. were served personally but they have not put in appearance in the present appeal. Under the circumstances we have to proceed against them in their absence.
8. The tribunal has not given any reason to show how the appellant was liable to pay Rs. 5,000/-. On the finding that the driver of the truck alone was negligent, the award of Rs. 5,000/- from New India Insurance Company, the appellant was wholly unjustified. Under the circumstances the award of the Tribunal has to be modified in that respect. Kumari Santu has been awarded a sum of Rs. 11,988/- out of which Rs. 6,988/- was awarded against the National Insurance Co. and Rs. 5,000/- against the New India Assurance Co., the appellant. That award is modified and the entire amount of Rs. 11,988/- will be payable by the National Insurance Co. and the appellant will not he liable to pay any amount.
9. Coming to the cross-objection the claimants have claimed further amount. As New India Assurance Co. the appellant has not been held liable for any amount as compensation no amount can be awarded even in cross-objection against the appellant. National Insurance Co. Ltd. has not filed any appeal; consequently no cross-objection can be filed against it. It is only a co-respondent. In the result the cross-objection is not maintainable.
10. In the result, the appeal is allowed. The award of the Tribunal is modified to the extent that the entire amount of Rs. 11,988/- payable to Kumari Santu would be payable by the National Insurance Co. Ltd., respondent No. 4 and no amount will be payable by the appellant. The stay order is discharged.
11. The cross-objection is dismissed. The parties are directed to bear their own costs.
12. Appeal allowed.
Alert