- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sita Ram And Others v. State Of Uttar Pradesh
Structured Summary of Opinion — K.N. Seth, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
On 23-8-1971, at about noon, an incident occurred in village Kanaili, police station Sarai Aqil, district Allahabad, in which Ganesh Din was killed and Surya Bali Singh, Daya Ram Singh and Gaya Prasad Singh received injuries. In Sessions Trial No. 91 of 1973 the appellants were found guilty: Sita Ram was sentenced to life imprisonment under Section 302, Indian Penal Code, and four other appellants (Din Bandhu, Lalji, Ram Naresh and Serwan Kumar) were sentenced to life imprisonment under Section 302/149, Indian Penal Code. Additional convictions and concurrent sentences were imposed for other offences arising out of the same incident.
The appellants appealed against the Sessions Court order dated 18-11-1974; the present appeal was filed in this Court on 21-11-1974, and the appellants were enlarged on bail. While the appeal was pending, the original trial record in the court below was destroyed in an accidental fire. Multiple attempts to reconstruct the record were made and ample opportunity was given to both State and appellants, but reconstruction proved unsuccessful. The central procedural difficulty before the Court was whether the appeal could be heard and decided on its merits in the absence of the original record and, if not, what step the Court should take.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellate Court can decide the appeal on its merits when the original trial record has been destroyed and reconstruction efforts have failed.
- If the appeal cannot be decided on merits because of the loss of record, what course the appellate Court should adopt (e.g., ordering a retrial after setting aside the conviction, or acquitting the appellants).
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Queen Empress v. Khimat Singh. 1889 A.W.N 55. | That an appellant is entitled to a hearing in the appellate Court and the loss of the record deprives him of the means to make good the pleas of the appeal. | Relied upon to support the proposition that the appellate Court must peruse the record before exercising powers under Section 386 CrPC, and thus cannot decide the appeal on merits where the record is lost. |
| Abbash Ali v. Emperor. 19 Ind. Cases 182. | The appellate Court must peruse the record before deciding the appeal; a decision based only on the judgment appealed against is not legal. | Used to reinforce the principle that perusal of the record is an essential element of hearing an appeal and that absence of the record prevents lawful determination on merits. |
| Sevugaperumal (Madras High Court decision referred). | Illustrative authority where, following Queen Empress v. Khimat Singh, the Madras High Court ordered retrial after setting aside convictions when the record had been lost. | Serves as an example of ordering retrial in cases where loss of record occurs and the time lapse between incident and retrial was apparently not long; court noted uncertainty in reported decisions as to the exact time elapsed. |
| Madhu Sudhan Pradhani v. The State. 1963 2 Cr. L.J 103. | Example where the appellate Court directed retrial of a murder conviction; the retrial order was passed within two years of the incident. | Used to illustrate that retrial is an appropriate option when the appeal is heard within a relatively short time of the incident and documentary evidence and witnesses are likely to remain available. |
| Zila v. State. 1956 A.W.R 613. | Authority refusing to direct retrial where a long gap (more than six years since incident and five years since conviction) and the absence/weeded-out status of key papers made retrial unjust and impracticable. | Applied as precedent for declining retrial when significant time has elapsed and documentary evidence (e.g., FIR, s.161 statements) is not available, making a fair retrial impossible. |
| Jit Narain v. State (Cr. App. No. 3235 of 1971), decided 15-3-1978. | Example of an appellate outcome where, in similar circumstances of missing record, the appeal was allowed and appellants were acquitted instead of directing retrial. | Referenced as an instance supporting acquittal as an available remedy when retrial would be improper or impracticable due to lapse of time and non-availability of records. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by identifying the statutory framework governing appeals: Section 385 CrPC (notice to parties, furnishing grounds of appeal, and the requirement to send for the record unless the appeal is limited to sentence) and Section 386 CrPC (powers of the appellate Court exercised after perusal of the record and hearing the parties). The Court emphasized authorities (Queen Empress v. Khimat Singh and Abbash Ali v. Emperor) which establish that perusal of the record is an essential element of the appellate hearing and that a decision based only on the trial judgment is not legally sufficient.
Given the destruction of the original record by accidental fire and the failure of reconstruction despite ample opportunity, the Court held that it could not lawfully decide the appeal on its merits because it could not peruse the record and thus could not be satisfied that the conviction was supported by the evidence originally placed on record. The appellants have a right to attempt to show that the trial decision was not supported by the evidence; loss of the record deprives them of the means to make that showing if the appellate Court proceeds without the record.
The Court then examined the two principal remedial courses available where the record is lost: (1) setting aside the conviction and ordering a retrial; or (2) acquitting the accused. In evaluating which course to adopt, the Court considered earlier decisions: some courts ordered retrial where the time lapse between incident and appellate hearing was short (so witnesses and documentary evidence would likely remain available), while other decisions refused retrial where a long lapse and loss/weeded-out status of documents made fair retrial impossible (e.g., Zila v. State).
Applying these principles to the present case, the Court noted the following facts from the record: the incident occurred on 23-8-1971; the Sessions Court's conviction order was dated 18-11-1974; the appeal has been pending in this Court for about six years; copies of the First Information Report and statements under Section 161 CrPC have been weeded out and are not available; reconstruction attempts failed. In these circumstances the Court concluded that affirmation of the conviction was not permissible (because the record could not be perused) and that ordering a retrial would not be just or expedient because of the long lapse of time and the absence of essential papers that would be necessary to test witness statements and prosecute a reliable retrial.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The appeal is allowed; the order of the Court below convicting and sentencing the appellants is set aside and the appellants are acquitted.
Direct consequences for the parties:
- The convictions and sentences imposed by the Sessions Court are set aside.
- The appellants are acquitted and need not surrender; they remain on bail and their bail bonds are discharged.
Broader implications (as addressed by the Court): The opinion explains and applies the existing principle that an appellate Court must peruse the record before exercising its powers under Section 386 CrPC, and it articulates the practical test for choosing between retrial and acquittal when records are lost: retrial may be appropriate when the lapse is short and evidence/documents/witnesses are likely available; acquittal is appropriate where long delay and loss/weeded-out documents make retrial unjust or impracticable. The opinion does not purport to establish a new rule of law beyond applying these principles to the facts of this case.
K.N Seth, J.:— On 23-8-1971 at about noon time an incident took place in village Kanaili, police station Sarai Aqil district Allahabad, in which Ganesh Din lost his life and Surya Bali Singh, Daya Ram Singh and Gaya Prasad Singh received injuries. In Sessions Trial No. 91 of 1973 the appellants have been found guilty for committing the murder of Ganesh Din and causing injuries to Surya Bali Singh and others. For the murder of Ganesh Din Sita Ram has been sentenced to imprisonment for life under Section 302 Indian Penal Code. The remaining four appellants, namely. Din Bandhu, Lalji, Ram Naresh and Serwan Kumar have been awarded the same sentence under Section 302/149 Indian Penal Code. The appellants have further been convicted and sentenced to various terms of imprisonments for other offences committed in the incident. The sentences have been directed to run concurrently.
2. Against the order of the learned Additional District and Sessions Judge, Allahabad, dated 18-11-1974 the present appeal was filed in this Court on 21.11.1974 While admitting the appeal this Court enlarged the appellants on bail. During the pendency of the appeal in this Court the original record was destroyed as a result of an accidental fire that broke out in the Court below. When the appeal was put up for hearing, an attempt was made to reconstruct the record. Ample opportunity was allowed to the State as well to the appellants but the record could not be reconstructed. The question that has cropped up for consideration is whether the appeal can be decided on merit and if not what is the course to be adopted by this Court.
3. Section 385 Criminal Procedure Code provides that if the appellate Court does not dismiss the appeal summarily, it shall cause notice of the time and place at which such appeal will be heard to be given (i) to the appellant or his pleader; (ii) to such officer as the State Government may appoint in this behalf, (iii) if the appeal is from a judgment of conviction in a case instituted upon complaint, to the complainant; (iv) if the appeal is under Section 377, or Section 378, to the accused, and shall furnish such officer, complainant and accused with a copy of the grounds of appeal. Sub-Section (2) provides that the appellate Court shall then send for the record of the case, if such record is not already available in that Court, and hear the parties provided that if the appeal is only as to the extent or the legality of the sentence, the Court may dispose of the appeal without sending for the record. Section 386 prescribes the powers of the appellate Court. That power has to be exercised after perusing the record and hearing the appellant or his pleader, if he appears and the public prosecutor, if he appears. In Queen Empress v. Khimat Singh . 1889 A.W.N 55. this Court observed “the appellant is entitled in law to have a hearing in this Court of his appeal, but the loss of the record has deprived him of the only means of making good the pleas of the appeal ……” A division Bench of the Calcutta High Court in Abbash Ali v. Emperor . 19 Ind. Cases 182., observed that the appellate Court must peruse the record before deciding the appeal. A decision upon a perusal only of the judgment appealed against is not legal.
4. Since it is incumbent on the appellate Court to send for the record and peruse it and hear the counsel for the parties before it can exercise its power under Section 386, the present appeal cannot possibly be heard and decided on merit.
5. The appellants have a right to show to this Court that the decision arrived at by the Court below was not supported by the evidence on record. They can legitimately content that material evidence and circumstances have either been ignored or incorrectly appraised. This right cannot be denied to the appellants. In the absence of the original record it is not possible for us to arrive at a decision that the impugned judgment is supported by the evidence on record and the order of conviction passed and the sentence imposed on the appellants is legally justified and proper.
6. In such a situation two courses are open to the Court: (1) to order retrial after setting aside the impugned judgment; or to (2) acquit the appellants. A situation like the present one arose before Courts earlier also, in Sevugaperumal3, the accused were convicted under Sections 457, 395 and 397, Penal Code, and sentenced to various terms of imprisonment. Following the decision of this Court in Queen Empress v. Khimat Singh (supra) the Madras High Court ordered retrial after setting aside the convictions. From the reports of these decisions it is not clear how much time had elapsed between the incident and the date when retrial was directed. In the Madras case the impugned order of the trial Court was dated 22-6-1942. The appeal was filed on 6-8-1942 and the original record was destroyed by fire on 17-8-1942 The appeal came up for hearing on 5-11-1942. It may be that the time lapse between the date of the incident and the date of decision by the appellate Court was not long. Moreover the Public Prosecutor conceded in those cases that no other course was possible under the circumstances.
7. In Madhu Sudhan Pradhani v. The State . 1963 2 Cr. L.J 103., the appellant was convicted under Section 302 Indian Penal Code and sentenced to imprisonment for life by an order of the Sessions Judge dated 17-4-1962. The incident had taken place on 29-3-1961. The appeal came up for hearing on 12-12-1262. The appellate Court directed retrial of the case. It may be noted that the order for retrial was passed well within two years of the incident.
8. A similar situation arose before this Court in Zila v. State . 1956 A.W.R 613.. In this case the appellants were convicted by the Sessions Judge on 21-1-1951 under Sections 304 and 148 Indian Penal Code in respect of the offence committed on 2-4-1950. The appeal was filed in this Court on 24-1-1951 which came up for hearing in April 1956 when it was brought to the notice of the Court that the entire record of the case had been lost. Attempt was made to reconstruct the record but it proved futile. This Court refused to direct retrial of the case on the reasoning that the case related to an offence which was committed more than six years ago and five years had elapsed since the judgment of the Sessions Judge convicting the appellants, was passed. The Court took into account the further fact that even the copses of the first Information Report and the statements of witnesses taken under Section 161 Criminal Procedure Code were not available as they had been weeded out in the ordinary course.
9. A Division Bench of this Court in Jit Narain v. State (Cr. App. No. 3235 of 1971) decided on 15-3-1978 in similar circumstances allowed the appeal and acquitted the appellants instead of directing their retrial.
10. On a careful consideration of the relevant statutory provisions and the principle laid down in the cases cited before us we are of opinion that where it is not possible to reconstruct the record which has been lost or destroyed it is not legally permissible for the appellate Court to affirm the conviction of the appellant since perusal of the record of the case is one of the essential elements of the hearing of the appeal. The appellant has a right to try to satisfy the appellate Court that meterial on record did not justify his conviction and that right cannot be denied to him. We are further of the opinion that if the time lag between the date of the incident and the date on which the appeal comes up for hearing is short, the proper course would be direct retrial of the case since witnesses normally would be available and it would not cause undue strain on the memory of witnesses. Copies of First Information Report, statements of witnesses under Section 161, Criminal Procedure Code, reports of medical examination etc. would also be normally available if the time gap between the incident and the order of retrial is not unduly long. Where, however, the matter comes up for consideration after a long gap of years it would neither be just nor proper to direct retrial of the case more so when even copies of First Information Report and statements of witnesses under Section 161, Criminal Procedure Code and other relevant papers have been weeded out or are otherwise not available. In such a situation even if witnesses are available, apart from the fact that heavy strain would be put on the memory of witnesses, it would not be possible to test their statements made at the trial with reference to the earlier version of the incident and the statements of witnesses recorded during investigation. Not only that the accused will be prejudicial but even the prosecution would be greatly handicapped in establishing its case and the trial would be reduced to a mere formality entailing agony and hardship to the accused and waste of time, money and energy of the State. In the present case the incident took place on 23.8.1971 The appellants were convicted by the sessions Court by an order dated 18-11-1974. The appeal has been pending in this Court for about six years. We are informed that copies of the First Information Report and statements of witnesses recorded under Section 161, Criminal Procedure Code have been weeded out and are not available. All attempts to reconstruct the record have proved futile. In such a situation it is not permissible for us to affirm the order of conviction of the appellants, since in the absence of the recrod we cannot possibly feel satisfied that the appellants have been rightly convicted. Due to lapse of time and non-availability of papers like First Information Report, statements under Section 161 Criminal Procedure Code etc. We do not consider it either just or expedient to order retrial of the case.
11. In the circumstances the appeal is allowed. The order of the Court below convicting and sentencing the appellants is set aside and they are acquitted. They are on bail. They need not surrender. Their bail bonds are discharged.
Alert