- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Income-Tax Officer, Manipuri v. Rani Ratnesh Kumari.
Summary of Legal Opinion — R.R. Rastogi, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
This reference under section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 concerns the assessment year 1971-72. The Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Allahabad Bench, referred the following question to the High Court: whether the excess profit of Rs. 14,254 (as referred by the Tribunal) arising from a particular transaction should be treated as income chargeable under the head "Capital gains" or as income arising out of an "adventure in the nature of trade".
Relevant facts found and described in the opinion: the assessee (an individual) purchased a house property in Jaipur (about 20,000 sq. yards, comprising two bungalows, servant quarters and a large area of vacant land) on 12 February 1968 for Rs. 87,999. The assessee subsequently divided a portion of the vacant land into sub-plots, made improvements and sold a total area of 10,830.75 sq. yards by means of six sale deeds executed in the period described in the text (sale deeds executed between the assessment years noted in the opinion). The total consideration received for all sales was Rs. 1,74,145. In the relevant previous year the assessee sold 1,842 sq. yards for Rs. 21,990.
The Income-tax Officer (ITO) was of the view that the activity amounted to an adventure in the nature of trade and brought to tax Rs. 14,354 in respect of the transaction in question, rejecting the assessee's contention that the profit constituted capital gains. The assessee appealed to the Additional AAC (Appellate Assistant Commissioner or AAC), which accepted the assessee's written submissions that the property was purchased primarily for residence and use, not with a profit-making intention, and held the profit to be capital gains. The Revenue appealed to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal but remained unsuccessful. The Tribunal then made the reference to this Court for opinion.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances, the excess profit of approximately Rs. 14,254/14,354 (as described in the opinion) in the assessment year under consideration constituted the assessee's income assessable under the head "Capital gains" and not as income arising out of an "adventure in the nature of trade"?
Arguments of the Parties
Revenue's Arguments
- Although the assessee's initial intention at the time of purchase may have been to use the property for her own residence, her subsequent conduct—within about a year dividing a substantial part of the vacant land into sub-plots, developing that area, laying out roads, and over about a decade executing six sale deeds selling almost half of the total area (10,830 sq. yards)—shows a change in conduct inconsistent with an investment holding. The revenue pointed to the later conduct and argued that the AAC and the Appellate Tribunal erred by deciding the matter solely on the basis of the assessee's initial intention and failing to consider subsequent change in conduct.
- The revenue asked that the question be decided on all facts and circumstances, and suggested that the matter be remitted to the Appellate Tribunal for fresh consideration in light of the subsequent conduct.
Assessee's Arguments
- The assessee contended she bought the property for residence and to make further constructions; the vacant land was intended for her own use (including cultivation) and there was no primary intention to make profit by resale at the time of purchase.
- It was argued that resale occurred only later because of need for money, and that there was no profit motive at purchase; the profit should therefore be treated as capital gain. The assessee pointed out that she constructed a residential house and let out part of it to a bank, supporting the character of the holding as investment/use rather than trading.
- In submissions before this Court (by counsel), it was argued that resale in changed circumstances would be a realization of capital and would not alter the initial intention of the purchaser; reliance was placed on decisions supporting that view. The Court, however, declined to enter into this aspect because the lower authorities had not considered subsequent conduct.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| G. Venkataswami Naidu & Co. v. Commissioner of Income-Tax, [1959] 35 ITR 594 (SC) | The initial intention to resell is a relevant factor but not conclusive; the character of a transaction must depend on all relevant facts and circumstances, including subsequent conduct. | The Court relied on this decision to hold that the decision about character of a transaction cannot be based solely on an abstract test of initial intention and that subsequent conduct must be considered. |
| Cit, Nagpur v. Sutlej Cotton Mills Supply Agency Ltd., [1975] 100 ITR 706 (SC) | Reiteration of the principle that initial intention is relevant but the totality of facts must be considered. | The Court cited this case as a reaffirmation of the same principle concerning initial intention and totality of facts. |
| A.N. Seth v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Patiala, [1969] 74 ITR 852 (Delhi High Court) | Followed the dictum laid down in G. Venkataswami Naidu (initial intention test and its limits). | The Court noted that the Delhi High Court followed the Supreme Court's dictum in Venkataswami Naidu. |
| Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Raunaq Singh Swaran Singh, [1972] 85 ITR 220 (Delhi) | Held (by the Delhi Court) that to classify an operation as an adventure in the nature of trade it must be shown that the sole intention at the time of purchase was to resell for profit. | The Court rejected this narrower proposition as not being correct law; it emphasized that the initial intention is important but not conclusive and that subsequent events and conduct must also be considered. |
| Saroj Kumar Mazumdar v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, West Bengal, [1959] 37 ITR 242 (SC) | Where a transaction is not in the line of business and is an isolated single instance, the onus is on the department to prove that it was an adventure in the nature of trade. | The Court relied on the dictum to explain the nature of onus and to observe that the question whether the transaction was isolated or part of a series is relevant; in the present case the transactions were not in the line of business but also were not isolated, affecting the onus analysis. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first accepted the general legal principle (derived from cited authorities) that the initial intention of the purchaser is an important and relevant factor in determining whether a purchase-and-resale transaction amounts to an adventure in the nature of trade, but that it is not conclusive. The Court emphasized that the character of the transaction must be determined by considering the initial intention together with the subsequent conduct of the assessee and all other relevant facts and circumstances.
The opinion notes that the ITO had found material facts showing substantial post-purchase changes in conduct by the assessee: almost within a year of purchase the assessee divided substantial vacant land into sub-plots, developed the area and laid out roads, and thereafter over a period of about a decade sold 10,830 sq. yards out of the total 20,000 sq. yards by six sale transactions. These facts were present in the written submissions of the assessee before the AAC and were not disputed by the assessee, yet neither the AAC nor the Appellate Tribunal referred to or considered these subsequent events and the change in conduct when deciding the nature of the transactions. Instead, the lower authorities decided the matter primarily on the basis of the initial intention as found in the assessee's submissions.
Applying the precedents, the Court held that because the subsequent conduct and the series of transactions were relevant and had not been considered by the lower authorities, the matter required fresh consideration. The Court observed that the transactions were not in the line of the assessee's business but they also did not represent an isolated single instance, which bears upon the question of onus (i.e., the department must prove adventure in the nature of trade in such circumstances). Given these unexamined factual matters and the governing legal principles, the Court determined that the proper course was to remit the case to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal to determine the facts in accordance with the principles laid down and then decide whether the transactions amounted to an adventure in the nature of trade or were transactions of investment (capital gains).
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The Court returned the referred question unanswered and remitted the matter to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal for fresh determination in accordance with the observations made by this Court.
Implications:
- The Tribunal is to reconsider the matter, taking into account both the assessee's initial intention and the subsequent conduct and all other relevant facts and circumstances (including the ITO's findings regarding division of land, development, laying out of roads, and the six sale transactions).
- The question whether the profit should be taxed as capital gains or as income from an adventure in the nature of trade must be decided by the Tribunal after such factual determination; the High Court did not make a conclusive finding on that substantive point.
- The Court made no order as to costs.
- The Court's decision applies established principles (as cited) that initial intention is important but not conclusive; the opinion does not purport to create a new legal precedent beyond applying those principles to remit for proper fact-finding.
R.R Rastogi, J.:— This reference under s. 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereafter “the Act”), relates to the assessment year 1971-72. The Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Allahabad Bench, has referred the following question for the opinion of this court.
“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal was correct in holding that the excess profit accruing on the transaction amounting to Rs. 14,254 for the assessment year under consideration constituted assessee's income assessable under the head ‘Capital gains’ and not as the income arising out of an adventure in the nature of trade?”
2. The brief facts are that the assessee, an individual, had purchased a house property of an area of about 20,000 sq. yards comprising of two bungalows, servant quarters and a vast piece of vacant land, in the city of Jaipur, on February 12, 1968. The consideration was Rs. 87,999. Later on, the assessee divided a portion of the vacant land in sub-plots and made some improvements therein and sold a total area of 10,830.75 sq. yards by means of six sale deeds executed between the assessment years 1961-62 and 1972-73.
3. It may be noted that the previous year of the assessee ends on 31st of October. In other words, these sale deeds were executed in between 1959-60 and 1970-71. The total consideration received was Rs. 1,74,145. In the previous year, relevant to the year under consideration, the assessee had sold 1,842 sq. yards for a sum of Rs. 21,990. The ITO being of the opinion, that the activity of the assessee amounted to an adventure in the nature of trade, brought to tax Rs. 14,354 in respect of the aforesaid transaction. He did not accept the assessee's contention that this profit amounted to a capital gain only.
4. The assessee appealed and submitted written submissions before the AAC. The case taken by the assessee there, was that she had purchased this property for her own residence and for making further constructions and the vacant land was to be used by her for her own cultivation. It was stated that it had never been her primary intention at the time of the purchase of this property to make any profit out of it by resale of any portion thereof and it was only later on when she was in need of money, she sold some portions of the vacant land. There was absolutely no profit motive in the mind of the assessee when she purchased this property. It was urged that from the sale price received the assesses constructed a residential house and let out a portion of the same to some bank. The AAC accepted the submission and held that the intention of the assessee at the time of the purchase of this property was not to resell any portion thereof and thereby earn any profit. Subsequently, however, when she found that the land appurtenant to the house was much more than what she required, she thought of selling a portion of the same and if thereby she earned some profit, that would not make the transaction an adventure in the nature of trade. In the opinion of the AAC, in order to bring a transaction in this category, the onus was on the department to prove that the intention of the assessee was to resell the property later on at a profit and that the department had failed to discharge such onus. He, thus, held that the profit which the assessee earned on a part of that land would constitute a capital gain and not a business profit.
5. The revenue took up the matter in appeal before the Appellate Tribunal but remained unsuccessful and now at its instance the present reference has been made to this court.
6. It was submitted before us by the learned counsel for the revenue that on the facts and circumstances found by the authorities below what could be inferred was that the intention of the assessee at the time of the purchase of this property was to bring it to her own use. However, soon after she changed her mind and developed a portion of the vacant land by carving out small plots and by laying out roads and then she sold as much as 10,830 sq. yards of land by means of six sale deeds during the period of about a decade. The land sold represented almost half of the total area of the property purchased. Further, she constructed a building on a portion of the vacant land and leased it out to the bank. Now, the AAC and the Appellate Tribunal, both decided the nature of the transactions on the basis of the initial intention of the assessee. They did not refer to the subsequent change in the conduct of the assessee. It was, further, urged that the question is to be decided on a consideration of all the facts and circumstances obtaining in a case and hence the case might be remitted to the Appellate Tribunal for fresh consideration.
7. After hearing counsel for the parties we find that there is considerable substance in what has been urged before us by the learned departmental counsel. As regards the initial intention of the assessee at the time of the purchase and its subsequent??????lling the land on profit the Supreme Court in G. Venkataswami Naidu & Co. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax , [1959] 35 ITR 594, observed at page 610 as follows:
“It is often said that a transaction of purchase followed by resale can either be an investment or an adventure in the nature of trade. There is no middle course and no half-way house. This statement may be broadly true, and so some judicial decisions apply the test of the initial intention to resell in distinguishing adventures in the nature of trade from transactions of investment. Even in the application of this test distinction will have to be made between initial intention to resell at a profit which is present but not dominant or sole; in other words, cases do often arise where the purchaser may be willing and may intend to sell the property purchased at profit, but he would also intend and be willing to hold and enjoy it if a really high price is not offered. The intention to resell may in such cases be coupled with the intention to hold the property. Cases may, however, arise where the purchase has been made solely and exclusively with the intention to resell at a profit and the purchaser has no intention of holding the property for himself or otherwise enjoying or using it. The presence of such an intention is no doubt a relevant factor and unless it is offset by the presence of other factors it would raise a strong presumption that the transaction is an adventure in the nature of trade. Even so, the presumption is not conclusive; and it is conceivable that, on considering all the facts and circumstances in the case, the court may, despite the said initial intention, be inclined to hold that the transaction was not an adventure in the nature of trade. We thus come back to the same position and that is that the decision about the character of a transaction in the context cannot be based solely on the application of any abstract rule, principle or test and must in every case depend upon all the relevant facts and circumstances.”
8. Thus, the dominant or even sole intention to resell is a relevant factor and raised a strong presumption, but by itself is not a conclusive proof. The initial intention in conjunction with the conduct of the assessee and other circumstances should all be looked into with a view to determine the real character of the transaction. In Cit, Nagpur v. Sutlej Cotton Mills Supply Agency Ltd., [1975] 100 ITR 706 (SC) the same principle was reiterated. The Delhi High Court in A.N Seth v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Patiala, [1969] 74 ITR 852, followed the dictum laid down by the Supreme Court in G. Venkataswami Naidu & Co. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax , [1959] 35 ITR 594. In a later case of Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Raunaq Singh Swaran Singh, [1972] 85 ITR 220 (Delhi), though that court referred to the decision in Venkataswami Naidu, [1959] 35 ITR 594 (SC), but laid down a slightly different proposition and it was that in order to bring a transaction within the category of an adventure in the nature of trade it has to be shown that the sole intention at the time of the purchase was to sell the property purchased later on at a profit. With respect to their Lordships of the Delhi High Court, who decided that case, we do not think that that is a correct proposition of law. Initial intention of the purchaser is certainly a very important and relevant material for determining the nature of a transaction with regard to the property purchased, made subsequently; but that is not conclusive. The subsequent events and the conduct of the assessee are also important factors and the question is to be decided on a totality of all the facts and circumstances. There is no doubt that the onus is on the department to prove that the transaction in question was an adventure in the nature of trade. For the nature of onus we may refer to the dictum laid down in Saroj Kumar Mazumdar v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, West Bengal , [1959] 37 ITR 242 (SC). That dictum is that where a transaction was not in the line of the business of the assessee but was an isolated or single instance of the transaction the onus was on the department to prove that the transaction was an adventure in the nature of trade. It would be seen that it cannot be laid down as a matter of absolute proposition that the onus is on the department to prove that the initial intention of the purchaser was to resell the property purchased, later on at a profit. The relevant facts to be seen in this behalf are: firstly, as to whether the transaction in dispute was not in the line of the business of the assessee and secondly, whether it was an isolated or a single instance of the business or there was a series of similar transactions. In the present case, of course, the transactions entered into by the assessee in respect of the property concerned were not in the line of her business but they do not represent an isolated or a single instance of the business. The department had brought out certain material and it was that almost within a year of the purchase of the property the assessee divided a substantial part of the vacant land into sub-plots. That area was developed and roads were laid out and thereafter within a decade by means of six sale-transactions as much as 10,830 sq. yards of land out of the total area of 20,000 sq. yards was sold away. In the written submission made by the assessee before the AAC, these facts were not disputed by the assessee. Neither the AAC nor the Appellate Tribunal referred to those facts which had been found by the ITO. In other words, the case was not examined in the light of the subsequent change in the conduct of the assessee. Thus, it is a case in, which certain essential facts have not been considered by the Appellate Tribunal and, therefore, it is a case which should be remitted to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal to determine the facts in accordance with the observations, made by this court as above and determine whether the transaction was an adventure in the nature of trade or was a transaction of investment.
9. An attempt was made on behalf of the assessee by Sri Bharat Ji Agrawal to show that even if the facts found by the ITO are taken into consideration, this transaction would not amount to an adventure in the nature of trade. It was submitted that a resale in changed circumstances would only be realization of capital and would not alter the initial intention of the purchaser when the property was purchased. It was also submitted that the assessee is not a dealer in land or property and if because of financial necessity and change of circumstances she sold away some of the vacant land, it would not make any difference. Reliance was placed on certain decisions in this behalf. We should not enter into this aspect of the matter because, as we have noted above, neither the AAC nor the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal considered the nature of the transaction with reference to the changed circumstances and the subsequent conduct of the assessee. They were merely guided by the initial intention of the assessee when the property was purchased and regarded it as conclusive. That view is erroneous in law as we have shown above. In our opinion, therefore, the proper course for us would be to remit the case to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal to determine the nature of the transaction with reference to all the facts and circumstances obtaining in the case and in accordance with the observations we have made above.
10. For the reasons, stated above, we return the question unanswered and in the circumstances of the case make no order as to costs.
Alert