Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ajai Singh v. Nathi Lal

Allahabad High Court
Mar 6, 1978
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Chaturvedi, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

These are three connected matters referred to the Court because a common question of law arose concerning the interpretation of Section 457(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. The factual and procedural outlines given in the opinion are:

  • Criminal Revision No. 1253 of 1977 (Ajai Singh): Truck No. U.P.U 2645 was seized by Hari Parwat police during investigation of a murder case. Ajai Singh applied for release; the Magistrate allowed release on furnishing two sureties of Rs. 10,000 each and a personal bond of like amount. Nathi Lal filed a criminal revision before the Sessions Judge, Agra. The learned III Additional Sessions Judge set aside the Magistrate's order (24 August 1977). Ajai Singh filed a revision in this Court.
  • Misc. Case No. 3861 of 1976 (Ram Naresh Singh): Tractor No. U.S.M 3558 was seized by Kachhwa police on the night between 27–28 May 1976 because it had been used by alleged dacoits. Ram Naresh moved for release before the Magistrate on 4 June 1976; the Magistrate dismissed the application on 9 June 1976. An application under Section 482 Cr. P.C. was moved in this Court challenging the Magistrate's order.
  • Criminal Misc. Case No. 1169 of 1977 (Abdul Razzaq): Truck No. U.P.I 505 was seized in connection with an offence described in the opinion as under Section 457/380 I.P.C. (31 bags of cotton yarn alleged to be stolen property were transported by the truck). Abdul Razzaq claimed ownership; an application for release was rejected by the Metropolitan Magistrate, Kanpur. A revision to the Sessions Judge, Kanpur, was dismissed. Abdul Razzaq then moved this Court under Section 482 Cr. P.C.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the proper import of Section 457(1) Cr. P.C. — in particular, whether the words "such property is not produced before a Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial" restrict Section 457 to situations only after inquiry or trial (i.e., whether a Magistrate lacks jurisdiction to order disposal or release of seized property during the investigation stage).
  2. Whether the principle laid down in Nannoo Mal v. Sher Mohammad Khan (that a Magistrate has no jurisdiction under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 to deal with seized property during investigation) is a correct statement of law and should govern the three connected matters.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nannoo Mal v. Sher Mohammad Khan The decision held that Section 457(1) Cr. P.C. is applicable only when the seized property is not produced before a criminal court during an inquiry or trial; a Magistrate has no jurisdiction under the 1973 Code to pass orders regarding disposal of seized property during the investigation stage (Katju, J.'s view). The Court examined this authority as the foundation of the impugned orders in the three matters, concluded that the statement of law in Nannoo Mal is too narrow and "not accurate", and refused to follow that restrictive view in the present cases (orders that relied on Nannoo Mal were set aside).
Ambika Roy v. The State of West Bengal The Division Bench held that the expression "such property is not produced before a Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial" in Section 457 refers to the stage of investigation (i.e., Section 457 may be invoked at the investigation stage) and should be read in the context of the provisions in Chapter XXXIV and XXXV of the Code. The Court relied on this authority to support the interpretation that Section 457 can apply at the investigation stage and that the phrase in question is meant to differentiate stages (investigation vs. inquiry/trial), not to restrict Magistrate jurisdiction until after inquiry/trial.
M.S. Jaggi v. Subaschandra Mohapatra The court, following Ambika Roy, held that the expression in Section 457(1) refers to the stage of investigation and not only to the stage of inquiry or trial. The Court cited this decision as confirming the view that Section 457 covers cases arising at the investigation stage and thereby reinforced its conclusion that Nannoo Mal's restrictive rule was incorrect.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in the following steps (stated in the opinion):

  1. Textual and contextual interpretation of Section 457(1) Cr. P.C.: The Court set out the text of Section 457(1) and placed it within Chapter XXXV ("Disposal of property"), noting that Sections 451 and 452 also concern disposal of property but apply to property produced before a Court during inquiry/trial. Section 457 was characterized as a residuary provision applicable to property seized by police but not produced before a criminal court.
  2. Identification of the three conditions in Section 457(1): (1) property seized by a police officer; (2) seizure reported to a Magistrate under the Code; and (3) the property "is not produced before a Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial". The Court observed that the ambit of the last condition depends on the meaning of the words "is not produced before a Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial".
  3. Principle of statutory interpretation applied: The Court invoked the cardinal principle that words should be read in their ordinary, natural and grammatical meaning unless such reading leads to absurdity. It observed that the statute uses the present indefinite tense in passive voice, and therefore the phrase must be read as referring to the state of production of the property at the point in time when the Magistrate is called upon to act.
  4. Temporal focus of Section 457(1): The Court held that "is not produced" refers to whether, at the relevant time when the Magistrate must make an order, the property has been produced before a criminal court during an inquiry or trial. If at that moment the property is produced, the Magistrate lacks jurisdiction under Section 457; if not, Section 457 is available to the Magistrate to make an order.
  5. Identification of possible factual permutations: The Court explained various situations in which Section 457 might be invoked — e.g., (a) while investigation is in progress (before any inquiry/trial) when the owner applies for release; (b) after completion of investigation and submission of police report but before commencement of inquiry/trial; (c) during an inquiry/trial in respect of property not produced before the court conducting that inquiry/trial; and (d) after conclusion of inquiry/trial where property was not produced. The Court emphasised that nothing in the language of Section 457 restricts its application only to the last of these situations.
  6. Assessment of Nannoo Mal: The Court found the Nannoo Mal decision to be too narrow in holding that a Magistrate had no jurisdiction to deal with seized property during investigation under the 1973 Code. The Court preferred the approach in Ambika Roy and M.S. Jaggi which read Section 457 as capable of operating at the investigation stage.
  7. Practical consequences and direction: Having concluded that Section 457 applies to the investigation stage as well, the Court proceeded to dispose of the connected cases accordingly — allowing the revisions/applications and setting aside the impugned orders that had relied upon the restrictive view in Nannoo Mal.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

  • Criminal Revision No. 1253 of 1977: Allowed. The order of the learned III Additional Sessions Judge, Agra dated 24th August, 1977 (which had set aside the Magistrate's order releasing truck No. U.P.U 2645) is set aside and the Magistrate's order is restored.
  • Misc. Case No. 3861 of 1976: The application is allowed and the order of the Magistrate dated 9th June, 1976 is set aside. The opinion notes that the property has already been released by this Court; the Magistrate may, however, pass necessary orders regarding disposal and security.
  • Criminal Misc. Case No. 1169 of 1977: The application is allowed; the orders of the Metropolitan Magistrate, Kanpur and of the VII Additional Sessions Judge, Kanpur are set aside. The property has already been released by this Court; the Metropolitan Magistrate may pass such orders as to disposal and security as warranted by the circumstances.

Implications:

  • The Court concluded that the earlier statement of law in Nannoo Mal v. Sher Mohammad Khan is "not accurate, being too narrow" insofar as it precluded the Magistrate from exercising jurisdiction under Section 457(1) during the investigation stage. The opinion adopts the interpretive approach in Ambika Roy and M.S. Jaggi that Section 457(1) can apply at the investigation stage as well as at other stages where the seized property is not produced before a criminal court.
  • Direct effect on the parties: the impugned supervisory/revision orders that had set aside Magistrates' releases were set aside and the Magistrates' orders restored (or the property released by the Court), with directions permitting Magistrates to pass appropriate orders on disposal and security in the circumstances of each case.
  • The Court's pronouncement clarifies the temporal scope of Section 457(1) as referring to the state of production of property at the time the Magistrate is called upon to act; it thus permits Magistrates to entertain applications for release/disposal of seized property at investigation stage subject to the statutory conditions set out in Section 457.

No other broader policy consequences or additional precedential holdings were stated beyond the interpretation of Section 457(1) and the direct orders in the three connected matters.

Show all summary ...

Chaturvedi, J.:— These are three connected cases. Criminal Revision No. 1253 of 1977 is by Ajai Singh against an order of the learned III Additional Sessions Judge, Agra, dated 24th August, 1977 setting aside the order of the Magistrate dated 2nd August, 1977 releasing truck No. U.P.U 2645. Misc. Case No. 3861 of 1976 is an application by Ram Naresh Singh under section 482 Cr. P.C while Misc. Case No. 1169 of 1977 is an application by Abdul Razzaq under sections 482 and 483 Cr. P.C In these three cases a common question of law arose and, therefore, they were referred to us.

2. The facts concerning Criminal Revision No. 1253 of 1977 are that truck No. U.P.U 2645 was seized by Hari Parwat police during investigation of a murder case. Ajai Singh applicant moved an application for release of the truck. This application was allowed by the Magistrate and the truck was released in favour of the applicant on his furnishing two sureties each of an amount of Rs. 10,000/- with a personal bond in the like amount. Nathi Lal opposite party filed a criminal revision in the court of the Sessions Judge, Agra. The revision was heard and decided by the learned III Additional Sessions Judge, Agra on 24th August, 1977. The revision was allowed and the order of the learned Magistrate releasing the truck in favour or the applicant Ajai Singh was set aside. Ajai Singh, therefore, filed a revision in this Court. The facts relating to Criminal Misc. No. 3861 of 1976 are that tractor No. U.S.M 3558 belonged to Ram Naresh Singh. On the night between 27th and 28th May, 1976 the tractor was seized by the police of Kachhwa Police station as some dacoits who had committed dacoity on the same night at 11.00 P.M in the house of Lalta Prasad in village Ramapur, police station Kachhwa were travelling by it. An application was moved for release of the tractor by Ram Naresh Singh before the Magistrate on 4th June, 1976. It was dismissed on 9th June, 1976. It is against the order of the Magistrate dated 9th June, 1976 that the application under section 482 Cr. P.C was moved in this Court.

3. Criminal Misc. Case No. 1169 of 1977 relates to truck No. U.P.I 505. Abdul Razzaq applicant claimed to be its owner. It was seized by the police in connection with an offence under section 457/380 I.P.C It was alleged that 31 bags of cotton yarn which were stolen property had been transported by the truck. The applicant Abdul Razzaq moved an application for release of the truck before the Metropolitan Magistrate, Kanpur who rejected it. The applicant filed a revision in the court of the learned Sessions Judge, Kanpur. The revision was disposed of by the learned VII Additional Sessions Judge, Kanpur. It was dismissed. It was against the order of the learned VII Additional Sessions Judge, Kanpur that the applicant Abdul Razzaq moved an application under section 482 Cr. P.C

4. The impugned orders in all the three cases were based on the authority reported in Mannoo Mal v. Sher Mohammad Khan1.. In that case the police seized a truck along with its trolley from the possession of the applicant Nannoo Mal in connection with a case under sections 147, 420 and 341 I.P.C Sher Mohammad Khan made an application for release of the truck and the trolley in his favour. The Magistrate allowed the application and released the truck and the trolley in favour of Sher Mohammad Khan. Nannoo Mal filed a revision in the court of Session. The Additional Sessions Judge who heard the same dismissed the revision. Nannoo Mal thereupon made an application under the provisions of section 482 Cr. P.C 1973 which was heard by Hon'ble Katju, J. who was of the view:

“A plain reading of Section 457(1) Cr. P.C 1973 clearly shows that it is applicable only when the property seized is not produced before a criminal court during an inquiry or trial. A Magistrate under this section can make an order regarding the seized property only after the inquiry or trial is concluded and the seized property is in fact not produced in the inquiry or trial. He cannot make an order regarding the seized property under this section during the investigation of the case. Under Section 523(1), Cr. P.C 1898 it was open to a Magistrate to pass orders regarding the disposal of seized property during the investigation of the case. There is however no provision in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 similar to Section 523(1), Criminal P.C 1898. A Magistrate has therefore, no jurisdiction to pass orders regarding the disposal of seized property during the investigation of a case under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. There appears to be a lacuna in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 197 in this regard. It is however, well settled that courts cannot correct mistakes of legislatures and fill in lacuna in statutes. This has obviously to be done by the legislature itself.”

5. The order of the Magistrate and of the I Additional District and Sessions Judge were accordingly set aside.

6. At the time of admission of Misc. Case No. 1169 of 1977 Hon'ble H.N Kapoor, J. doubted the correctness of the decision in the case of Nannoo Mal v. Sher Mohammad Khan2., and he was of the view that the matter required reconsideration by a Larger Bench. Accordingly he made a reference in that case. Similarly a reference was also made in Criminal Revision No. 1253 of 1977 and Misc. Case No. 3861 of 1976. The question for determination in these three cases is, therefore, regarding the import of the provisions of Section 457(1) Cr. P.C 1973 and it is to be seen whether the decision reported in Nannoo Mal v. Sher Mohammed Khan, is a correct statement of law or not.

7. Section 457(1) Cr. P.C 1973 provides as follows:—

“Whenever the seizure of property by any police officer is reported to a Magistrate under the provisions of this Code, and such property is not produced before a criminal court during an inquiry or trial the Magistrate may make such order as he thinks fit respecting the disposal of such property or the delivery of such property to the person entitled to the possession thereof, or if such person cannot be ascertained, respecting the custody and production of such property.”

8. Section 457 is one of the provisions in Chapter XXXV of the Code of Criminal Procedure entitled as ‘Disposal of property’. There are two other Sections—Sections 451 and 452. On the same subject which have some bearing on the interpretation of Section 457. Section 451 empowers the Court to order for the interim custody or disposal of the property produced before it during any inquiry or trial. Section 452 gives jurisdiction to a Criminal Court to order for disposal of property produced before it during any inquiry or trial at the conclusion of the inquiry or trial. Section 457, on the other hand, deals with property seized by any police officer but ‘not produced before a Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial. It is more or less a residuary provision dealing with property not covered by Sections 451 and 452 and is applicable when, (1) the property has been seized by a police officer; (2) such a seizure is reported to a Magistrate under the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure, and (3) the property so seized ‘is not produced before a Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial. The ambit of the last condition depends upon the meaning of the words is not produced before a Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial.

9. The cardinal principal of interpretation of statutes is that, words should be read in their ordinary, natural and grammatical meaning unless such a reading leads to absurdity. If the words are susceptible of another meaning, the Court may adopt the same. In the expression ‘such property is not produced before a Criminal Court during inquiry or trial’ the legislature has used present indefinite tense in passive voice. As such it is not permissible to interpret them to mean ‘may not be produced in Court in an inquiry or trial at any time’ or as ‘will not be produced in an inquiry or trial so that the Magistrate has to wait until an enquiry or trial,’ is held by a Criminal Court and the property is actually not produced in that Court. The words ‘is not produced etc.’ have reference to the point of time when Magistrate to whom seizure has been reported is called upon to make an order for disposal of such property. At the relevant time, i.e when he has to make an order for disposal of property, the Magistrate has to ascertain if the property is produced or not in a Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial. If it is produced, he will have no jurisdiction to deal with it. In case it is not produced before a Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial, he will make an order for its disposal in the prescribed manner.

10. A Magistrate may have to exercise jurisdiction under Section 457 in different situations are circumstances. A person whose property has been seized may apply to the Magistrate for it release while the investigation is still in progress and as such before the commencement of an inquiry or trial and before an occasion to produce the seized property before a Criminal Court arises. Such a situation arose in the case reported in Ambika Roy v. The State of West Bengal3.. A Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court held:—

“On a consideration of the relevant provisions of the Code and in the light of the principles of interpretation of statutes, it is abundantly clear that Section 457 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 is in the context of the earlier provisions laid down in Chapter XXXIV and should not be construed benefit of such context. The words “such property is not produced before a Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial” merely refer to the stage of investigation and not the stage of inquiry or trial. If the property is produced in the Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial, Section 451 of the new Code would apply and not Section 457. The words relied upon by the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Calcutta, therefore do not constitute a bar but a condition precedent not a disqualification but a qualification; and not an exception but an essential ingredient forming the mainspring of such application. The learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Calcutta, has misconstrued the said words to find ultimately that “in this case there is non-production but the non-production is not during trial but prior to trial.” The learned Magistrate proceeded on the purported footing that the inclusion of the aforesaid words in the statute required in the first place the non-production of such property as opposed to production; and secondly that the factum of such non-production must be during an inquiry or trial. It is abundantly clear, however, that ultimately there is no cloud and the legislature in its wisdom merely used the said words in order to differentiate the various stages, viz the stages of an inquiry or trial, completion of trial and that of investigation, etc. In this particular case it appears from the records, that the conditions precedent enjoined in Section 457 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 have been duly fulfilled, viz. that the factum of seizure has been reported to a Magistrate under the provisions of this Code and that the property seized has not been produced during an inquiry or trial but at the stage of investigation”

11. Similar are the facts of the case reported in M.S Jaggi v. Subaschandra Mohapatra4.. Relying upon the authority reported in Ambika Roy's case it was held that the expression “and such property is not produced before a Criminal Court during an inquiry or trial” in sub-section (1) of section 457 refers merely to a stage of investigation and not the stage of inquiry or trial.

12. Again there may be a case where the police after completing the investigation submitted a final report under Section 169 Cr. P.C an aggrieved party might approach the Magistrate although the stage is prior to commencement of an inquiry or trial.

13. A third case may be where one may approach him during an inquiry or trial in respect of property not produced before the court holding enquiry or trial.

14. Again an application may be made for release of property seized, but not produced in court, after conclusion of inquiry or tial.

15. We find nothing in the language of Section 457 Cr. P.C to restrict its application only to the last category of cases, and take away the jurisdiction of the Magistrate until trial or inquiry is held and the property is actually produced in the Court or during investigation of the case. The provision might be availed of in other situations also. In our view, therefore, the statement of law made in Nannoo Mal's case is not accurate, being too narrow.

16. Criminal Revision No. 1253 of 1977 is allowed, the order of the learned III Additional Sessions Judge, Agra dated 22nd August, 1977 is set aside and the order of the Magistrate is restored.

17. Application in Criminal Misc. Case No. 2861 of 1976 is also allowed and the order of the Magistrate dated 9th June, 1976 is set aside.

18. The property has already been released by this Court. The Magistrate may, however, pass such an order as may be necessary in the circumstances of the case regarding its disposal and security.

19. Application in Criminal Misc. Case No. 1169 of 1977 is also allowed and the order of the Metropolitan Magistrate, Kanpur and of the VII Additional Sessions Judge. Kanpur are set aside. The property has already been released by this Court. However, the Metropolitan Magistrate, Kanpur may pass such order as to its disposal and security as is warranted by the circumstances of the case.