- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Manmohan Singh v. Mahindra Kaur
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion, delivered by B.N. Katju, J., concerns an application under section 488, Cr. P.C. 1973. The opposite party filed an application under section 125, Cr. P.C. 1973 dated 6-5-1974 in the court of the C.J.M., Dehradun. The applicant filed a written statement on 4-6-1974. Statements of the opposite party and the applicant were recorded on 23-11-1974 and 6-2-1975 respectively. The C.J.M., Dehradun by order dated 3-8-1975 directed the applicant to pay Rs. 300/- per month to the opposite party with effect from 7-5-1974. The applicant filed Criminal Revision No. 33 of 1974 against that order; the Sessions Judge, Dehradun allowed the revision in part by order dated 2-9-1975, reducing maintenance to Rs. 150/- per month with effect from 7-5-1974. The present application challenges those orders.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, under section 125(1)(a), Cr. P.C. 1973, maintenance may be granted to a wife who has not alleged or been found to be unable to maintain herself.
- Whether the orders of the C.J.M., Dehradun (3-8-1975) and the Sessions Judge, Dehradun (2-9-1975) are lawful where the opposite party did not allege inability to maintain herself and no such finding was recorded.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the statutory scheme: under section 125(1)(a), Cr. P.C. 1973, maintenance is available only to a wife who is unable to maintain herself, marking a departure from section 488 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, under which every neglected wife was entitled to maintenance irrespective of ability to maintain. The court noted that the opposite party's application and her statement did not allege that she was unable to maintain herself, and neither the C.J.M. nor the Sessions Judge recorded any finding of inability to maintain. On that statutory basis, the court concluded the impugned orders lacked the required factual foundation and were therefore illegal.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The application is allowed and the orders of the C.J.M., Dehradun dated 3-8-1975 and of the Sessions Judge, Dehradun dated 2-9-1975 are set aside.
Implications: The direct effect is that the maintenance orders against the applicant were vacated. The opinion notes the change in entitlement under section 125(1)(a) compared to the earlier section 488, but does not purport to establish broader precedent beyond the facts and statutory interpretation applied in this case.
B.N Katju, J.:— This is an application under section 488, Cr. P.C 1973.
2. The opposite party filed an application under section 125, Cr. P.C 1973 against the applicant dated 6-5-1974 in the court of C.J.M, Dehradun. The applicant filed his written statement on 4-6-1974. Thereafter the statements of the opposite party and the applicant were recorded by the C.J.M, Dehradun on 23-11-1974 and 6-2-1975 respectively. The C.J.M, Dehradun by his order dated 3-8-1975 directed the applicant to pay Rs. 300/- per month to the opposite party as maintenance allowance with effect from 7-5-1974.
3. The applicant filed Criminal Revision No. 33 of 1974 against the aforesaid order which was allowed in part by the Sessions Judge. Dehradun by his order dated 2-9-1975 and the applicant was directed to pay Rs. 150/- per month as maintenance allowance to the opposite party with effect from 7-5-1974.
4. Under section 125(1)(a), Cr. P.C 1973 maintenance allowance cannot be granted to every wife who is neglected by her husband or whose husband refuses to maintain her but can only be granted to a wife who is unable to maintain herself. It may be pointed out that this is a departure from section 488 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 wherein every wife, whether she was able or was not able to maintain herself, was entitled to maintenance if she was neglected or not maintained by her husband. As it was not alleged by the opposite party in her application under section 125, Cr. P.C 1973 and it was also not stated by her in her statement recorded by the C.J.M, Dehradun that she was unable to maintain herself and no finding has been recorded by the C.J.M, Dehradun or the Sessions Judge, Dehradun that the opposite party was unable to maintain herself, the order of the C.J.M, Dehradun dated ???-8-1975 and the order of the Sessions Judge, Dehradun dated 2-9-1975 are clearly illegal.
5. This application is accordingly allow and the order of the C.J.M, Dehradun dated 3-8-1975 and the order of the Sessions Judge, Dehradun dated 2-9-1975 are set aside.
Alert