- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jamuna Dass v. Board Of Revenue And Others
Judgment Summary — G.C. Mathur, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The dispute concerns the one-third share of Budha in ancestral holdings that included 'Sir' and 'Khud-Kasht' land (later converted to Bhumidhari on zamindari abolition) and tenancy land (referred to as 'sirdari'). Tusli originally owned these lands and on his death his three sons — Nathu Ram, Tega Lal and Budha — each inherited one third. In 1949 Tega Lal, Budha and Smt. Sita were murdered. Tega Lal's one third share passed to his widow Smt. Bhagwati; Nathu Ram's one third later passed to his son Jamuna. The primary contest concerns Budha's one-third share and who succeeded to it.
Jamuna filed two suits under Sec. 176 of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act for partition of the joint holdings — one suit for Bhumidhari holdings and one for sirdari holdings — claiming a two-third share. Smt. Bhagwati resisted, asserting that Nathu Ram had murdered Tega Lal, Budha and Smt. Sita and was therefore disqualified from inheriting Budha's share; she claimed Jamuna's share was only one third.
At trial the court found that the murder by Nathu Ram was not proved and held that, on the death of Smt. Kamla (who had been held by lower courts to have acquired Budha's share upon his death), Jamuna succeeded as a brother's son and therefore was entitled to two-thirds; the trial court decreed the suits accordingly. The Additional Commissioner upheld the trial court. On second appeals the Board of Revenue found that Nathu Ram had committed the murders, held that Jamuna was disqualified from succession under Hindu law because he succeeded through Nathu Ram, and awarded Smt. Bhagwati a two-third share. Jamuna filed a writ petition challenging the Board's decision in respect of the Bhumidhari plots (he confined the writ to Bhumidhari at a hearing).
The Single Judge held that Smt. Kamla had acquired Budha's share in her own right and that succession to her share was governed by Sec. 174 of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act; the Single Judge concluded neither Smt. Bhagwati nor Jamuna were heirs under Sec. 174 and therefore held that Kamla died heirless, resulting in the share devolving equally on the two co-tenure holders (Jamuna and Bhagwati) — one half each. Jamuna appealed from the Single Judge's judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether one writ petition is maintainable against the common judgment of the Board of Revenue in two suits (Bhumidhari and Sirdari) arising from connected proceedings.
- Whether Jamuna is disqualified from inheriting Budha's share because his father, Nathu Ram, was found by the Board of Revenue to have murdered Budha (and others), and whether a rule excluding a murderer and those claiming through him from succession applies.
- Whether the judgment of a criminal court convicting Nathu Ram (or other criminal findings) is relevant or conclusive in the civil succession proceedings under the revenue/statutory scheme.
- Whether succession to the share of Smt. Kamla is governed by Sec. 174 of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act and, if so, whether Jamuna (as Kamla's brother's son) is an heir under that section.
- Whether the Board of Revenue erred in applying principles of Hindu law (and specific provisions of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956) or equitable rules (as in the Privy Council decision) to succession governed by the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (Jamuna)
- Claimed a two-third share in both the Bhumidhari and sirdari holdings as successor to his father Nathu Ram and, by virtue of being the brother's son, to Smt. Kamla.
- Challenged the Board of Revenue's finding that Nathu Ram was the murderer and contention that that finding disqualified Jamuna from succession (one of the proposed additional grounds sought to be added under Order 41 Rule 2 CPC).
- At the writ hearing, counsel for Jamuna erroneously (and without instructions) stated the writ would be pressed only as to Bhumidhari plots; on appeal the court treated that concession as not binding because it was made without instructions and after no objection had been raised in the counter-affidavit at the earlier stage.
Respondent (Smt. Bhagwati)
- Asserted that Nathu Ram had murdered Tega Lal, Budha and Smt. Sita and, therefore, both he and his son Jamuna were disqualified from inheriting Budha's share — limiting Jamuna's entitlement to one third (the share inherited from Nathu Ram).
- Relied on the Board of Revenue's conclusion (which relied upon a Privy Council precedent) that a murderer and those claiming through him are excluded from succeeding to the estate of the victim; sought a two-third share on that basis.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mall Singh v. Smt. Laksha Kumari Khaitan (Full Bench of this Court) | Rule that one writ petition is maintainable against the judgment of the Board of Revenue in two suits (as cited by the opinion). | The Court invoked this Full Bench decision to conclude that one writ petition could lie against the Board's common judgment, and used that to hold the appellant's counsel's concession at the writ hearing (to press only Bhumidhari) should not be binding; the appellant was permitted to press the appeal in respect of the sirdari holding as well. |
| Anil Behari Ghosh v. Smt. Latika Bala Dassi, A.I.R. 1955 S.C. 566 | Principle (as relied upon by trial court) that the judgment of a criminal court is not necessarily relevant to establish certain facts for civil succession (the trial court relied upon this decision to exclude the criminal judgment's conclusiveness). | The trial court and the Additional Commissioner relied on this Supreme Court decision to hold that the criminal court's judgment convicting Nathu Ram was not relevant to establish in the civil revenue suit that Nathu Ram had murdered his siblings; the Board of Revenue did not refer to this decision when it reached the opposite conclusion. |
| Kenchaya Kom Sanvellappa Hosmani v. Girimalappa Channappa Satnasagar, 1924 P.C. 209 (Privy Council) | Rule that a murderer and anyone claiming through him are excluded from succeeding to the estate of the victim (grounded in principles of equity, justice and good conscience). | The Board of Revenue relied on this Privy Council rule to disqualify Jamuna from succession (because he claimed through Nathu Ram). The Court held this rule inapplicable: succession in the present case was to Smt. Kamla's estate (not Budha's), and statutory succession under the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act governs and cannot be overridden by extraneous equitable exceptions. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first disposed of preliminary procedural points. It held that the counsel's concession at the writ hearing (that the writ would not be pressed for the sirdari plots) was made without instructions, on an erroneous view of the law, and after the respondent had not raised the maintainability objection in earlier pleadings; relying on the Full Bench decision in Mall Singh the Court concluded one writ petition was maintainable in respect of both suits and therefore permitted the appellant to press the sirdari component of the appeal as well.
On the application to add grounds under Order 41, Rule 2 CPC (mainly to challenge the Board's finding that Nathu Ram was the murderer), the Court declined to entertain that further question in this appeal because (a) the trial court and Additional Commissioner had held that the criminal judgment was not relevant (relying on Anil Behari Ghosh), (b) the Board had reversed that conclusion without referring to the Supreme Court decision, and (c) the Single Judge had not based his decision on the Board's finding about the murder. The Court concluded it was not necessary to permit raising the murder issue in the present proceeding and observed the matter could be re-agitated, if necessary, before the Board when the second appeals were re-heard.
Concerning the merits, the Court found the Single Judge's factual and legal assumptions to be incorrect. The Single Judge had assumed Smt. Kamla acquired Budha's one-third share by prescription and proceeded to apply Sec. 174 of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act to conclude neither Jamuna nor Smt. Bhagwati were heirs. The Court examined the revenue courts' records and found no basis for treating Kamla's acquisition as by prescription. Crucially, the Court interpreted Sec. 174 and concluded that a "brother's son" is indeed an heir under that provision; Jamuna, being the brother's son of Kamla, therefore qualifies as an heir under Sec. 174. Consequently the Single Judge erred in holding Kamla died heirless and in applying survivorship under Sec. 175.
The Court found the Board of Revenue's decision to suffer from "manifest errors of law." The Board had relied on the Privy Council decision (Kenchaya) to exclude Jamuna from succession, treating the matter as though the rule excluding a murderer and those claiming through him could be grafted onto statutory succession. The Court rejected this approach for two principal reasons given in the opinion:
- Succession in the present case was to the estate of Smt. Kamla, not to the estate of the victim Budha; the Kenchaya rule concerned succession to a victim's estate and was therefore not directly applicable.
- Succession here is governed by the statutory provisions of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act. Where legislature prescribes a line of succession and does not provide for exclusions on particular grounds, it is not permissible to engraft exceptions based on equity, justice or good conscience. Equitable principles operate only where statutory provisions do not govern; they cannot override the statutory scheme.
The Board also erred in holding that provisions of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (Secs. 25 and 27) applied to succession under the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act. The Court held that those sections apply only to succession under the Hindu Succession Act itself and not to succession under other enactments; additionally, the Hindu Succession Act was enacted in 1956, whereas succession in this case opened in 1954, so the provisions could not have applied prospectively to the present succession.
Finally, the Board's conclusion that Smt. Bhagwati would take Kamla's property in the absence of Jamuna was also incorrect: Bhagwati, as the widow of Kamla's brother, is not an heir to Kamla under any provision of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act cited in the opinion.
Holding and Implications
Holding: Appeal allowed.
The Court allowed the appeal, modified the judgment of the learned Single Judge (holding it unsustainable for the reasons stated), quashed the Board of Revenue's judgments allowing the two second appeals, and directed that the Board, after giving the parties a fresh opportunity of being heard, decide the second appeals in accordance with law and in the light of the observations made in this judgment. The parties were ordered to bear their own costs.
Implications: The direct effect is that the Board of Revenue's decision disqualifying Jamuna (by relying on equitable exclusion of a murderer and those claiming through him) is quashed and the matter is remitted to the Board for fresh consideration consistent with statutory succession rules (notably Sec. 174). The judgment does not purport to lay down a new general principle overriding the statutory scheme; rather it enforces that succession under the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act must be determined by the statutory provisions themselves, and not by extraneous equitable rules or inapplicable provisions of the Hindu Succession Act. The opinion does not announce any new precedent beyond these clarified applications; it directs the Board to re-hear in accordance with the observations made.
Appeal allowed.
G.C Mathur, J.:— The relationship between the partities appears from the following pedigree table:
2. Tusli owned some ‘Sir’ and ‘Khud-Kasht’ land and some tenancy land. Upon his death his three sons Nathu Ram, Tega Lal and Budha inherited these each getting a one third share therein. In 1949 Tega Lai, Budha and Smt. Sita were murdered. Tega Lai's one third share was inherited by his widow Smt. Bhagwati. Upon the death of Nathu Ram his one third share was inherited by his son Jamuna. The dispute relates to the one third share dispute relates to the one third share of Budha.
3. The ‘Sir’ and ‘Khud-Kasht’ land as well as the tenancy land, however, remained joint. Upon the abolition of Zamindari the ‘Sir’ and ‘Khud-Kasht’ became Bhumidhari and the tenancy became ‘sirdari’. Jamuna filed two suits under Sec. 176 of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act for partition of the joint holdings. One suit was in respect of the Bhumidhari holdings and the other was in respect of the ‘sirdari’ holdings. Jamuna claimed a two third share in both the holdings. The suit was resisted by Smt. Bhagwati the widow of Tega Lal. She set up a case that Nathu Ram father of Jamuna had murdered Tega Lal, Budha and Smt. Sita and, therefore, he and his son Jamuna were disqualified from inheriting the share of Budha. She asserted that Jamuna's share was only one third which he had inherited from Nathu Ram. The two suits were connected and tried together. All the courts below have proceeded on the basis that upon the murder of Budha in 1949 his one third share went to his sister Smt. Kamla. Smt. Kamla died in 1954. The trial court held that it was not proved that Nathu Ram had murdered Budha and, therefore, Nathu Ram or Jamuna were not disqualified from inheritance. It further held that on the death of Smt. Kamla, Jamuna being the brother's son of the last male holder Budha, succeeded to her. Thus Jamuna was entitled to two third share. The trial court accordingly decreed the suits for a two third share. Against the judgments and decrees of the trial court, Smt. Bhagwati preferred appeals. The Additional Commissioner upheld all the findings of the trial court and dismissed the appeals.
4. Smt. Bhagwati then preferred two second appeals before the Board of Revenue. The Board held that Nathu Ram had committed the murder of Budha, Tega Lal and Smt. Sita. It further held that on the death of Smt. Kamla her share in the Bhumidhari plots as well as the Sirdari plots would have devolved upon Jamuna but for the fact that Jamuna was disqualified from succession under Hindu law as he had succeeded, Nathu Ram who was a murderer. The Board of Revenue was of the view that the tenancy law was subject to the general provisions of the Hindu Law unless there was any-specific provision to the contrary. It further held that the share of Smt. Kamla devolved upon Smt. Bhagwati and, therefore, Smt. Bhagwati was entitled to a two third share. The Board accordingly allowed both the appeals and modified the judgments and decrees of the trial and appellate court and decreed the suits only for a one third share. Against the judgment of the Board of Revenue a writ petition was filed by Jamuna.
5. At the hearing of the writ petition a preliminary objection was raised on behalf of Smt. Bhagwati that one writ petition was not maintainable against the judgment of the Board of Revenue in two suits. Upon this, learned counsel for Jamuna made a statement that he pressed the writ petition only in respect of the Bhumidhari plots and not in respect of the sirdari plots. The writ petition was accordingly confined to Bhumidhari plots. The learned Single Judge proceeded on the assumption that Smt. Kamla acquired Budha's one third share after his death in her own right and not by succession. He accordingly held that upon the death of Smt. Kamla the succession would be governed by Sec. 174 of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act and that neither Smt. Bhagwati nor Jamuna were the heirs of Kamla under that section. He further held that since Smt. Kamla died heirless her share would go in equal shares to the co-tenure holders, namely, Jamuna and Smt. Bhagwati. On this basis, Jamuna and Smt. Bhagwati were held entitled to a half share each. The learned Single Judge in this view allowed the writ petition, quashed the judgment of the Board of Revenue so far as Bhumidhari plots were concerned and directed the Board to decide the appeal relating to Bhumidhari rights in the light of his decision. Against the judgment of the learned Single Judge, Jamuna has preferred this appeal.
6. Before considering the merits of the appeal we would like to dispose of the preliminary points. One of the grounds raised in appeal is that the statement of Jamuna's counsel at the hearing of the writ petition that he did not press the claim in respect of the ‘sirdari’ plots, was made without authority and was prejudicial to the interest of the appellant. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that one writ petition was maintainable against the common judgment of the Board of Revenue in the two second appeals and, therefore, the erroneous concession of law made by the appellant's counsel at the hearing of the writ petition, should not be held binding on the appellant. In view of the decision of a Full Bench of this Court in Mall Singh v. Smt. Laksha Kumari Khaitan . ???., one writ petition was maintainable against the judgment of the Board of Revenue in the two suits. In the counter affidavit filed to the writ petition, no objection as to the maintainability of one writ petition was raised, the objection was raised for the first time at the hearing of the writ petition. At that stage the learned counsel for the appellant, without taking any instructions from the appellant, made a statement that he did not press the writ petition in respect of the ‘Sirdari’ rights. This statement was made on the erroneous view of the law that one writ petition was not maintainable in respect of the judgment in the two suits. Since no objection had been raised in the counter affidavit, the learned counsel for the appellant had no opportunity of contacting his client and obtaining his instructions as to whether he would pay one more set of court fee and if not in respect of which property he would elect to press the writ petition. In these circumstances, we are of opinion that the erroneous concession made by the learned counsel for the appellant should not be held binding on the appellant. We have accordingly permitted the learned counsel for the appellant to press this appeal in respect of the suit for division of the ‘sirdari’ holding as well.
7. An application has been filed under Order 41, Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure by the appellant for permission to add additional grounds to the memorandum of special appeal. The main ground sought to be added is that the Board of Revenue has erred in holding that Nathu Ram had murdered Budha as there was no evidence to support such a finding. Before the trial court a copy of the judgment of the Court of Session where Nathu Ram was tried for the murder of Tega Lal. Budha and Smt. Sita, and was convicted for the same and sentenced to death, was filed. Apart from this no other evidence was led in support of, Smt. Bhagwati's assertion that Nathu Ram had murdered these persons. Relying upon the decision of the Supreme Court in Anil Behari Ghosh v. Smt. Latika Bala Dassi . A.I.R 1955 S.C 566., the trial court held that the judgment of the criminal court was not relevant to establish the fact that Nathu Ram had murdered his brothers and sisters. Since there was no other evidence on the question, the trial court held that it was not proved that Nathu Ram had committed the murders. The Additional Commissioner, for the same reasons, also held that Nathu Ram could not be held to be a murderer. The Board of Revenue, however, reversed this finding. It has referred to the judgment of the criminal court but has not referred to the decision of the Supreme Court. It has based its finding merely on the fact that in her written statement Smt. Bhagwati had asserted that Nathu Ram had murdered Tega Lal, Budha and Smt. Sita and that there was no denial of this assertion by Jamuna. In the writ petition, no specific ground was raised regarding the finding of the Board of Revenue that Nathu Ram was the murderer of Tega Lal, Budha and Smt. Sita. The learned Single Judge has not referred at all to the question of the murder or its effect on the rights of the parties. He has based his decision entirely on the assumption which in our opinion is not justified, that under Sec. 174 neither Jamuna nor Smt. Bhagwati were the heirs of Smt. Kamla. In the grounds of appeal also no ground has been raised regarding this question apparently for the reason that the learned Single Judge has not based his decision on the finding of the Board of Revenue. We do not consider it necessary to allow the appellant to raise this further question as in our opinion the question can be reagitated, if necessary, before the Board of Revenue when the second appeals are re-heard.
8. We now come to the merits of the appeal. The learned Single Judge has proceeded on the assumption that Smt. Kamla had acquired the one third share of Budha in her own right by prescription. We have gone through the judgments of the revenue courts and we do not find anything there to justify this assumption. The learned Single Judge has further held that succession to Smt. Kamla would be governed by Sec. 174 of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act and that under this section neither Smt. Bhagwati nor Jamuna are heirs of Smt. Kamla. The learned Single Judge is not right in holding that Jamuna is not an heir of Smt. Kamla under Sec. 174. Under Sec. 174 brother's son is an heir and Jamuna being a brother's son of Kamla would be the heir under Sec. 174. That being so, the further view of the learned Single Judge that Smt. Kamla died without leaving any heir and, therefore, the two co-tenure holders namely Smt. Bhagwati and Jamuna would succeed to Smt. Kamla's share by survivorship under Sec. 175, is also erroneous for these reasons, the judgment of the learned Single Judge cannot be sustained.
9. We have carefully examined the judgement of the Board of Revenue and we find that it suffers from manifest errors of law.
10. According to the Board, succession opened both to the Bhumidhari and Sirdari rights on the death of Smt. Kamla in 1954, that normally Jamuna nor brother's son, would have succeeded to her but that Jamuna was disqualified from succession as he was the son of a murderer. It has relied upon the decision of the Privy Council in Kenchaya Kom Sanvellappa Hosmani v. Girimalappa Channappa Satnasagar . 1924 P.C 209. which lays down that a murderer and anyone claiming through him, is excluded from succeeding to the estate of the victim. The Privy Council based this rule on the principles of equity, justice and good concience. In our opinion, this rule is not applicable to the present case. In the first place, succession in the present case, is not to the estate of Budha, the victim of, the murder, but to the estate of Smt. Kamla. The rule cannot apply to succession to the estate of Smt. Kamla. In the second place, succession is governed by the statutory provisions contained in the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act and the law of succession laid down therein cannot be altered or changed by any rule or principles not contained in the Statute itself. When the legislature laid down a particular line of succession and did not provide for the exclusion of any one in that line on any ground, then it is not permissible to engraft exceptions or exclusions on the ground of equity, justice or good conscience. Rules of equity, justice and good conscience are applicable when the matter is not governed by statutory provisions. The Board has observed that the principles of Hindu Law as ennuciated in Secs. 25 and 27 of the Hindu Succession Act 1956 apply to succession under the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act. This is not correct. The provisions of Secs. 25 and 27 apply only to succession under the Hindu Succession Act and not to succession under other enactments. Further, the Hindu Succession Act which was enacted in 1956, was not even in existence in 1954 when succession in the present case opened.
11. The Board committed another manifest error of law when it said that the property of Smt. Kamla would devolve on Smt. Bhagwati as Jamuna was disqualified. Even in the absence of Jamuna, Smt. Bhagwati could not succeed to the property of Smt. Kainia. Smt. Bhagwati is the widow of Smt. Kamla's brother and under no provision of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act is she an heir of Smt. Kamla.
12. The appeal is accordingly allowed, the judgment of the learned Single Judge is modified and the judgment of the Board allowing the two second appeals is quashed. The Board will, after giving the parties a fresh opportunity of being heard, decide the second appeals in accordance with law and in the light of the observations made in this judgment. The parties will bear their own costs of this appeal.
Appeal allowed.
Alert