- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Lallu v. The Board Of Revenue, U.P, Allahabad And Others Opposite Parties.
Factual and Procedural Background
The Gaon Sabha filed Suit No. 22 under Section 209 of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act against the petitioner. The Gaon Sabha applied to the trial court for permission to withdraw that suit and also prayed for permission to file a fresh suit. On 17 January 1966 the trial court ordered: “Allowed to be withdrawn on payment of Rs. 8/- as costs.” The order was silent as to whether permission to institute a fresh suit was granted. The Gaon Sabha instituted the present suit on 6 July 1966 under the same statutory provision and for the same relief. The petitioner contended that the present suit was barred by Order XXIII, Rule 1(3) of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) because no permission to file a fresh suit had been granted. The trial court held the present suit barred and dismissed it. On appeal, the Commissioner held the suit was not barred, adjudged the merits in favour of the Gaon Sabha and decreed the suit. The petitioner’s second appeal was dismissed by the Board of Revenue. The petitioner then filed the present writ petition challenging those appellate decisions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the suit filed on 6 July 1966 is barred by Order XXIII, Rule 1(3) of the CPC because no specific permission to institute a fresh suit was granted when the earlier suit was withdrawn.
- Whether the Commissioner and the Board of Revenue erred in law and exceeded jurisdiction by holding the subsequent suit was not barred and by entertaining and decreeing that suit.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the present suit was clearly barred by Order XXIII, Rule 1(3) of the CPC. He relied on the text of Rule 1(2) and Rule 1(3), emphasizing that liberty to institute a fresh suit can only be granted where the court is satisfied of the grounds listed in sub‑rule (2) and then passes a specific order granting that liberty; because the earlier order was silent on granting such liberty, sub‑rule (3) precludes a fresh suit.
Board of Revenue / Respondent Position (as recorded)
- The Board of Revenue construed the earlier withdrawal order as incomplete and observed that, by constructive interpretation, the Gaon Sabha's prayer to bring a fresh suit after impleading the State Government "has not been rejected, while the condition of payment of costs has been imposed."
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analysed the statutory scheme of Order XXIII, Rule 1 of the CPC. It explained that sub‑rule (2) permits a court to grant permission to withdraw with liberty to institute a fresh suit only after the court is satisfied that either (a) the suit must fail by reason of some formal defect, or (b) there are other sufficient grounds for allowing the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit. After recording such findings, the court must pass a specific order granting the liberty to institute a fresh suit.
Because the earlier withdrawal order was completely silent on permission to file a fresh suit, the court held that no such specific permission had been granted. The court rejected the Board of Revenue's "constructive interpretation" that permission could be inferred from silence and the imposition of costs. The opinion emphasised the legal principle that where two reliefs are prayed for and the court specifically grants one relief, the only permissible inference is that the other relief has been refused. Applying sub‑rule (3) (which precludes a plaintiff who withdraws without the permission of sub‑rule (2) from instituting a fresh suit in respect of the same subject‑matter), the court concluded that the present suit was barred.
On that basis the court held that both the Commissioner and the Board of Revenue committed a manifest error of law and an error of jurisdiction in holding that the suit was not barred, entertaining the suit and decreeing it.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is allowed and the judgments and decrees of the Commissioner and of the Board of Revenue are quashed.
Direct consequences: the court declared the present suit barred by sub‑rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order XXIII of the CPC; the appellate decisions upholding and decreeing that suit have been set aside. The court ordered no costs. It also directed that any amount deposited pursuant to a stay order be refunded to the petitioner. The opinion does not discuss or purport to establish any broader precedent beyond these effects on the parties.
1. The main question which arises for determination in this writ petition is whether the present suit, under Section 209 of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, filed by the Gaon Sabha against the petitioner is barred by Order XXIII, Rule 1(3) of the CPC. An earlier suit under the same provision being Suit No. 22 was filed by the Gaon Sabha against the petitioner. The Gaon Sabha made an application to the trial Court for permission to withdraw the suit. In the application the Gaon Sabha also prayed that it might be granted permission to file a fresh suit. On January 17, 1966, the trial Court passed the following order on this application:— “Allowed to be withdrawn on payment of Rs. 8/- as costs.” It is to be noticed that the order was completely silent whether the permission was or was not granted to file a fresh suit. The present suit was filed on July 6, 1966. It was under the same provision and for the same relief. The petitioner contested the suit, inter alia, on the ground that it was barred on account of the earlier suit having been withdrawn, without any permission having been granted to file a fresh suit. The trial Court held that the present suit was barred and accordingly, dismissed it On appeal by the Gaon Sabha, the Commissioner held that the suit was not barred by Order XXIII, Rule 1(3) of the CPC. On merits, he found that the petitioner had no claim to the land in dispute. He, accordingly, allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment and decree of the trial Court and decreed the suit of the Gaon Sabha. The petitioner then filed a Second Appeal, but the Second Appeal has been dismissed by the Board of Revenue, Hence this writ petition.
2. The learned counsel for the petitioner has urged that the present suit is clearly barred by Order XXIII, Rule 1(3) of the CPC. Order XXIII deals with the withdrawal and adjustment of suits. Rule 1(1) empowers the plaintiff, at any time after the institution of the suit, to withdraw his suit or abandon any part of his claim against all or any of the defendants, Sub-rule (2) of Rule 1 then provides:—
“(2) Where the Court is satisfied—
(a) that a suit must fail by reason of some formal defect, or
(b) that there are other sufficient grounds for allowing the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit for the subject-matter of a suit or part of a claim,
it may, on such terms as it thinks fit, grant the plaintiff permission to withdraw from such suit or abandon such part of a claim with liberty to institute a fresh suit to respect of the subject-matter of such suit or such part of a claim.”
3. The consequence of the withdrawal are provided by sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, which reads thus:—
“(3) Where the plaintiff withdraws from a suit, or abandons part of a claim, without the permission referred to in sub-rule (2), he shall be liable for such costs as the court may award and shall be precluded from instituting any fresh suit in respect of such subject-matter or such part of the claim.” The order in the earlier suit was silent about the granting of permission to institute a fresh suit. The Board of Revenue thought that this was not a complete order and observed:—
“The constructive interpretation which can be placed on this is that the prayer of the Gaon Sabha to bring a fresh suit after impleading the State Government has not been rejected, while the condition of payment of costs has been imposed.”
4. This view of the Board of Revenue is manifestly erroneous in law. The Court is empowered to grant the liberty to institute a fresh suit only after finding that the suit must fail by reason of some formal defect or that there are other sufficient grounds for granting the liberty. After recording these findings the Court must pass a specific order granting liberty to Institute a fresh suit. If no such specific order Is passed granting liberty to institute a fresh suit, it is not permissible to infer such an order by “constructive interpretation,” as the Board has done. Where two reliefs are prayed for and the Court specifically grants one relief, the only inference that can be drawn is that the other has been refused.
5. That being so, it must be taken that the trial Court in the earlier suit refused to grant permission to file a fresh suit In the absence of such a permission, the present suit is clearly barred by sub-Rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order XXII of the CPC. The present suit being clearly barred, the Commissioner as well as the Board of Revenue have not only committed a manifest error of law in holding that suit was not barred but have also committed an error of jurisdiction in entertaining the suit and In decreeing the same.
6. The writ petition Is, accordingly, allowed and the judgments and decrees of the Commissioner and of the Board of Revenue are quashed Them will bo no orders as to costs.
7. If any amount has been deposited In pursuance of the stay order, the same will be refunded to the petitioner.
8. Petition allowed.
Alert