Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Controller Of Estate Duty v. Anari Devi Halwasiya

Allahabad High Court
Sep 20, 1971
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion by R.S. Pathak, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellate Tribunal made a reference under Section 64(1) of the Estate Duty Act, 1953 asking whether, on the facts of the case, the deceased (Tribeni Devi) had any interest in two-thirds of the Hindu undivided family (HUF) properties and, if not, whether her interest was one-sixth of the total HUF assets. The HUF comprised D.P. Halwasiya, his two wives (Tribeni Devi and Anari Devi), a son and three daughters. D.P. Halwasiya died on December 22, 1957; Tribeni Devi died on December 5, 1958. The matter concerned the estate duty payable on Tribeni Devi's death.

The Assistant Controller of Estate Duty calculated Tribeni Devi's interest by treating (a) a 1/6th share (as if upon partition on husband's death) and (b) an additional 1/18th under Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, resulting in inclusion of both shares for estate duty purposes. On appeal, the Zonal Appellate Controller rejected the 1/6th claim under the Hindu Women's Rights to Property Act, 1937, but accepted a 1/18th interest under Section 6 of the 1956 Act. Two appeals were taken to the Appellate Tribunal (one by the accountable person and one by the Assistant Controller). The Departmental Representative conceded that, on the husband's death, Tribeni Devi was entitled to a 1/30th share. The Appellate Tribunal accepted that view for the devolved interest and held she had no interest in the remainder of the family property; the appeals were disposed of accordingly. The present opinion answers the reference by the Appellate Tribunal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was right in holding that the deceased had no interest in the two-thirds of the Hindu undivided family properties?
  2. If the Tribunal was not right in that conclusion, whether the deceased's interest was one-sixth of the total Hindu undivided family assets?

Arguments of the Parties

Assistant Controller of Estate Duty

  • Held that on the husband's death the widow was entitled to a one-sixth share if partition had occurred; and, applying Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, she was entitled to share equally in the husband's interest assuming a notional partition. On that basis he included a 1/6th share and a 1/18th share of the family property as the interest passing on her death for estate duty purposes.

Zonal Appellate Controller

  • Contended that under the Hindu Women's Rights to Property Act, 1937 the deceased did not have any share in the HUF property, and thus the Assistant Controller was wrong to award a 1/6th share under that Act.
  • Applying Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, he held that the husband would have been entitled to a 1/3rd share (on the notional partition) and that Tribeni Devi therefore took a 1/6th share of that interest — resulting in a 1/18th interest in the family property.

Controller of Estate Duty (as argued before this Court)

  • Contended that during the husband's lifetime Tribeni Devi enjoyed a limited interest by virtue of the Hindu Women's Rights to Property Act, 1937 (a "Hindu Woman's estate"), which became an absolute estate by virtue of Section 14 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
  • Also contended that she acquired a share in her husband's interest in the HUF property by virtue of Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.

Departmental Representative / Appellate Tribunal

  • During the appeals, the Departmental Representative conceded that on the basis of the interest devolving on Tribeni Devi upon her husband's death she was entitled to a 1/30th share of the HUF property; the Appellate Tribunal found accordingly and also held she had no interest in the balance of the family property after carving out the husband's share.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hosbanna v. Devanna, ILR 48 Bom 468 : AIR 1924 Bom 444 To support the proposition that the expression "wife" in relation to sons includes their stepmother. Used to justify inclusion of stepmothers within the meaning of "wife" when assessing shares on notional partition (thus affecting how many equal shares arise on partition).
Dular Koeri v. Dwarka Nath, (1905) ILR 32 Cal 234 To support the principle that where there is more than one wife, each wife is entitled to a share equal to that of a son on partition. Applied in determining that on the notional partition the husband, two wives and the son would take equal shares (daughters taking none on partition), which led to the husband having a one-fourth interest.
Saheb Rai v. Shafiq Ahmad, AIR 1927 PC 101 To support the statement that the term "mother" includes stepmother for purposes of succession and related rights. Relied upon in discussing when a widowed mother acquires a share and in assessing whether widows had any interest in the joint portion of the coparcenary property absent partition.
Har Narain v. Bishambhar, ILR 38 All 83 : AIR 1915 All 340 Also cited for the proposition that "mother" includes stepmother and related principles about maternal entitlement on partition. Used alongside Saheb Rai to support the legal proposition that a mother (including stepmother) does not have an interest in coparcenary property so long as there is no partition among sons.
Pratapmull v. Dhanbati Bibi, AIR 1936 PC 20 To establish that in a suit for partition the mother does not become owner of the share allotted to her by the preliminary decree until the decree is carried into effect and metes and bounds division occurs. Applied to demonstrate that a mother (or widowed mother) acquires no immediate proprietary interest in the joint coparcenary property absent actual division; supports the conclusion that widows had no interest in the three-fourths of property that remained joint.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by determining which statutory provision governed Tribeni Devi's interest and then applying the relevant rules to the family composition and the notional partition required by statute.

  1. Applicability of the Hindu Women's Rights to Property Act, 1937:

    The Court observed that Section 3(2) of the 1937 Act confers a Hindu woman's estate only upon the death of her husband, and does not give her any interest while the husband is alive. Thus, prior to the husband's death she had no interest under that Act.

    Because the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 came into force on June 17, 1956 and by Section 4(1)(b) the provisions of the 1937 Act inconsistent with the 1956 Act ceased to apply, the Court held that the 1937 Act could not be relied upon to establish an interest that would affect devolution under the 1956 Act.

  2. Application of Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956:

    Section 6 provides that when a male Hindu dies after commencement having an interest in Mitakshara coparcenary property, his interest devolves by survivorship unless he is survived by a female relative in Class I, in which case his interest devolves by testamentary or intestate succession under the Act.

    Explanation 1 deems the interest of the coparcener to be the share he would have received if a partition had taken place immediately before his death (a notional partition).

  3. Determination of the husband's notional share:

    Under Mitakshara principles applying to an immediate-notional partition, the husband, his two wives and his son would take equal shares; daughters take no share on partition. Consequently, the husband’s notional share was one-fourth of the coparcenary property.

  4. Devolution of the husband's interest under intestate succession (Section 10 and rules):

    Section 10 and the Rules specify distribution among Class I heirs: the widows together take one share; each surviving son and each surviving daughter and the mother take one share each. For this family there are five shares in all (widows together = 1 share; son = 1; three daughters = 3), so the widows together take one-fifth. Tribeni Devi, being one of the two widows, thus took one-tenth of the husband's interest.

    One-tenth of the husband's one-fourth interest equals one-fortieth of the overall coparcenary property; that is the precise quantum the Court found to have devolved on Tribeni Devi under Section 6 of the 1956 Act.

  5. Interest (or lack thereof) in the remaining coparcenary property:

    The Court distinguished the carved-out one-fourth (the husband's interest) from the remaining three-fourths which continued as joint coparcenary property. Absent a partition among the sons, widowed mothers do not acquire an interest in the joint portion. Reliance was placed on authorities indicating that until actual metes-and-bounds division occurs a mother does not become owner of the share allotted to her by a preliminary decree. Therefore Tribeni Devi had no interest in the three-fourths of the property that remained joint.

  6. Conclusion of analysis:

    On the statutory construction and factual application to this family, the Court concluded that Tribeni Devi had a one-fortieth interest in the HUF property at the time of her death and no other interest in the remaining joint property.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Tribeni Devi was held to have a one-fortieth (1/40) interest in the Hindu undivided family property at the time of her death; the reference was answered accordingly.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The accountable person is entitled to costs of Rs. 200, and counsel's fee is assessed at Rs. 200 (as awarded by the Court).
  • The Court's decision limits Tribeni Devi's devolved interest to the one-fortieth share computed under Section 6 (and attendant rules) of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 and rejects reliance on the Hindu Women's Rights to Property Act, 1937 for generating an interest that would survive into the 1956 Act's regime in this case.
  • No broader or novel precedent was announced beyond the application of the cited statutory provisions and established authorities to the facts; the opinion applies existing rules of statutory construction and succession to determine the quantum of devolved interest.

Reference answered by R.S. Pathak, J. (costs assessed as stated). This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add any information beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

R.S Pathak, J.:— This is a reference made by the Appellate Tribunal under Section 64(1) of the Estate Duty Act, 1953. The question referred is:—

“Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the Tribunal was right in holding that the deceased had no interest in the 2/3rd of the Hindu undivided family properties? If not whether her interest was 1/6th of the total Hindu undivided family assets?”

2. There was a Hindu undivided family consisting of D.P Halwasiya, his two wives Tribeni Devi and Anari Devi, a son and three daughters. D.P Halwasiya died on December 22, 1957. Thereafter, Tribeni Devi died on December 5, 1958. This reference is concerned with the estate duly payable on the death of Tribeni Devi.

3. The Assistant Controller of Estate Duty determined the extent of the interest held by Tribeni Devi in the Hindu undivided family property. He observed that on the death of her husband she was entitled to a one-sixth share had there been a partition, and that she was also entitled under Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 to share equally with the other members in her husband's interest in the Hindu undivided family property assuming a notional partition. On that basis, he included a 1/6th share and a 1/18th share of the family property as the interest passing on her death for the purposes of estate duty.

4. On appeal by the accountable person, the Zonal Appellate Controller expressed the view that the deceased did not have any share in the Hindu undivided family property under the Hindu Women's Rights to Property Act, 1937 and, therefore, on that account the Assistant Controller was wrong in holding her entitled to a 1/6th share. But applying Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, he held that as the husband upon partition before his death would have been entitled to a 1/3rd share in the family property, a 1/6th share in this interest devolved on Tribeni Devi, and therefore, she would have been entitled to a 1/18th share in the family property. Two appeals were filed before the Appellate Tribunal, one by the accountable person and the other by the Assistant Controller. During the hearing of the appeals, the Departmental Representative conceded that on the basis of the interest devolving on Tribeni Devi upon her husband's death she was entitled to a 1/30th share of the Hindu undivided family property. The Appellate Tribunal found accordingly. The Appellate Tribunal also held that she did not have any interest in the balance of the family property left after carving out the husband's share. The appeals were disposed of accordingly.

5. It was contended before us on behalf of the Controller of Estate Duty that during the life time of her husband Tribeni Devi enjoyed a share in the property by virtue of the Hindu Women's Rights to Property Act, 1937, that this interest although originally a limited interest known as a Hindu Woman's estate became an absolute estate under Section 14 of the Hindu Succession Act. In addition, it is contended, she became entitled to a share in the interest of the husband in the Hindu undivided family property by virtue of Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act.

6. We have carefully considered the matter, and it seems to us that the position in law is as follows:—

Under the Hindu Women's Rights to Property Act. 1937 no interest could be said to devolve on Tribeni Devi. Section 3(2) of that Act confers an interest on a female in Hindu undivided family property governed by the Mitakshara law only upon the death of her husband. Upon his death, as his widow she is entitled to the same interest in the property as he himself had, it being a limited interest known as a Hindu Woman's estate superadded to it is the same right of claiming partition as a male owner. Section 3(2) does not come into play while the husband is alive. Therefore, while the husband is alive a Hindu woman under the Mitak-shara law cannot be said to enjoy any interest in the Hindu undivided family property. Tribeni Devi's husband died on December 22, 1957, but meanwhile the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 had come into force on June 17, 1956. By Section 6, it provided a rule of devolution of the husband's interest in the coparcenary property which was inconsistent with the corresponding provisions in the Hindu Women's Rights to Property Act. Consequently, by Section 4(1)(b) of the Hindu Succession Act, those provisions of the Hindu Women's Rights to Property Act ceased to apply. Any reference to the latter enactment there after became irrelevant. Accordingly, Tribeni Devi cannot be said to have enjoyed any interest in the family property by reason of the Hindu Women's Rights to Property Act, 1937.

7. Did Tribeni Devi acquire any interest in the Hindu undivided family property under the Hindu Succession Act? Upon the death of her husband on December 22, 1957 Section 6 came into play. It provides:—

“When a male Hindu dies after the commencement of this act, having at the time of his death an interest in a Mitakshara coparcenary property, his interest in the property shall devolve by survivorship upon the surviving members of the coparcenary and not in accordance with this Act.

Provided that, if the deceased had left him surviving a female relative specified in class I of the Schedule ……… the interest of the deceased in the Mitak shara coparcenary property shall devolve by testamentary or intestate succession as the case may be, under this act, and not by survivorship.

Explanation 1.— For the purposes of this section the interest of a Hindu Mitakshara coparcener shall be deemed to be the share in the property that would have been allotted to him if a partition of the property had taken place immediately before his death, irrespective of whether he was entitled to claim partition or not.”

8. D.P Halwasiya had at the time of his death an interest in the coparcenary property. He left surviving him two widows and three daughters. They are female relatives specified in Class I of the Schedule. Therefore, his interest in the coparcenary property devolved by intestate succession and not by survivorship. What was the extent of his interest? According to Explanation 1 to Section 6, his interest must be deemed to be the share in the property that would have been allotted to him if a partition of the property had taken place immediately before his death. Under the Hindu law, if a partition of coparcenary property takes place, the husband, the wife and the sons are entitled to a share. A wife cannot herself demand a partition, but if a partition does take place between her husband and a son she is entitled to receive a share equal to that of a son. (Hindu Law 13th Edn. p. 365, paragraph 315). The expression “wife” in relation to sons includes their step mother, (Hosbanna v. Devanna, ILR 48 Bom 468 : (AIR 1924 Bom 444)) and it would be seen that where there is more than one wife, each wife is entitled to a share equal to that of a son. See Dular Koeri v. Dwarka Nath, (1905) ILR 32 Cal 234. And a son is entitled to a share equal to that of the father (Mulla, ibid page 369 paragraph 321). Consequently, upon the notional partition contemplated by Explanation 1 to Section 6, the coparcenary property would have to be divided equally between D.P Halwasiya, his two wives and his son, the daughters having no share upon partition. Therefore for the purposes of Section 6. D.P Halwasiya, must be taken to have enjoyed a one fourth share in the property. This one fourth interest in the property devolved by intestate succession. Section 10 declares:—

“The property of an intestate shall be divided among the heirs in class I of the Schedule in accordance with the following rules:—

Rule 1.— The Intestate's widow, or if there are more widows than one, all the widows together, shall take one share.

Rule 2.— The surviving sons and daughters and the mother of the Intestate shall each take one share ………”

9. According to R. 1, both the widows of D.P Halwasiya together take one share. The son and three daughters each take one share. There are five shares in all. Therefore, the two widows together take a one fifth share. And Tribeni Devi, as one of the two widows, was entitled to a one-tenth share. She was entitled to a one tenth share in the interest of D.P Halwasiya in the coparcenary property. As that interest amounted to a one fourth share in the coparcenary property, Tribeni Devi took a one fortieth share in the coparcenary property. That was the extent of the share taken by Tribeni Devi as her husband's heir pursuant to Section 6 of the Act.

10. Now, as we have shown one-fourth of the coparcenary property representing the interest of D.P Halwasiya was carved out for the purpose of intestate succession. The balance of the coparcenary property, representing three-fourths of the original property, continued to remain joint. It continued as coparcenary property. Can it be said that Tribeni Devi enjoyed any interest in that property? Upon D.P Halwasiya's death the Hindu undivided family consisted of the two widows, the son and three daughters. The son undoubtedly had an interest in the coparcenary property. The daughters had none. As regards the widows, they had no interest either. Under the Hindu law, it is only if a partition takes place between the sons that the widowed mother becomes entitled to a share. Her share is then equal to that of a son in the coparcenary property (Mulla, ibid page 366 paragraph 316). The term ‘mother’ includes step mother. See Saheb Rai v. Shafiq Ahmad, AIR 1927 PC 101 and Har Narain v. Bishambhar, ILR 38 All 83 : (AIR 1915 All 340). So long therefore, as there is no partition between the sons, the widowed mother enjoys no interest in the coparcenary property. In Pratapmull v. Dhanbati Bibi, AIR 1936 PC 20 the Privy Council held that in a suit instituted by a son for the partition of joint family property impleading his mother and other members of the family as defendants the mother does not become owner of the share allotted to her by the preliminary decree until the preliminary decree is carried out and there is a division by metes and bounds.

11. Therefore, a mortgagee suing on a mortgage before the property is actually divided can obtain a valid mortgage decree without impleading the mother. In the present case, in the absence of any partition the widowed mothers could not be said to have any interest in the balance of the coparcenary property remaining joint. Accordingly, we must hold that Tribeni Devi had no interest in the three fourth part of the coparcenary property which remained joint upon the death of D.P Halwasiya.

12. In our opinion, Tribeni Devi had a one fortieth interest and no more, in the Hindu undivided family property at the time of her death. The question referred is answered accordingly. The accountable person is entitled to her costs which we assess at Rs. 200/-. Counsel's fee is assessed in the same figure.

13. Reference answered accordingly.