- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kamta Prasad v. Smt. Om Wati .
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent filed a petition under Sec. 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act seeking dissolution of the marriage and a decree for the return of ornaments and other articles worth Rs. 2,700 belonging to her. The suit was contested, but the trial court decreed judicial separation and ordered the return of the ornaments. The husband appealed, and the lower appellate court dismissed the appeal, affirming the concurrent findings that the husband was a drunkard with vicious habits, treated the respondent with cruelty, inflicted a knife blow on her abdomen, and turned her out of the house.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the courts had jurisdiction and power under Sec. 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act to order the return of ornaments and other articles that did not jointly belong to both the husband and wife.
- Whether the decree for judicial separation and return of ornaments was legally valid and sustainable.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant contended that under Sec. 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act, the court had no power to order the return of ornaments and other articles because these did not jointly belong to both husband and wife.
- The appellant argued that unless the property jointly belonged to both parties, the court could not exercise powers under Sec. 27.
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent's counsel submitted that no objection was raised at trial regarding misjoinder of causes of action relating to the ornaments and valuables.
- He argued that if such objection had been raised, the respondent could have elected to file a separate suit for the return of ornaments.
- He maintained that there is no provision under the Hindu Marriage Act prohibiting the court from passing the decree for return of ornaments and valuables.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the scope of Sec. 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act, which empowers the court to make provisions regarding property presented at or about the time of marriage that may belong jointly to both husband and wife. The court held that this section does not exclude the court’s power to pass decrees concerning property belonging exclusively to either party. The court reasoned that such power is inherent in proceedings under the Hindu Marriage Act and supported by procedural provisions under the Code of Civil Procedure, including its inherent powers under Section 151 and Order VII, Rule 7, to grant relief deemed just and proper. The court rejected the appellant’s argument that the court lacked jurisdiction to order the return of ornaments not jointly owned, clarifying that Sec. 27 confers enabling powers but does not restrict the court’s jurisdiction solely to jointly owned property. The court also noted that no procedural objection was raised regarding the joinder of causes of action, but even if it had been, it would not bar the decree. Therefore, the decree for judicial separation and return of ornaments was found to be legally valid and sustainable.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is dismissed with costs.
The court affirmed the trial and appellate courts’ decrees for judicial separation and the return of ornaments and other articles to the respondent. The decision clarifies that courts under the Hindu Marriage Act possess inherent jurisdiction to order return of property belonging exclusively to one spouse, notwithstanding the language of Sec. 27 which specifically mentions jointly owned property. No broader precedent was explicitly set beyond the affirmation of this jurisdictional interpretation. The direct effect is the upholding of relief granted to the respondent and dismissal of the husband's appeal.
A.K Kirty, J.:— The respondent filed a petition under Sec. 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act against the appellant seeking dissolution of the marriage and also a decree for return of ornaments and other articles belonging to her worth Rs. 2,700/-. The suit was contested, but the trial court decreed the suit for judicial separation and also for return of the ornaments etc. The husband filed an appeal, which has been dismissed by the lower appellate court.
2. The courts below have recorded concurrent findings to the effect that the husband was a drunkard and addicted to other vicious habits. There is also a concurrent finding that the appellant used to treat the respondent With cruelty and had given her a knife blow in the abdomen and had also turned her out of his house. On these findings the suit was rightly decreed for judicial separation. That part of the decree, therefore, must be affirmed.
3. Coming now to the question of the legality of the decree for return of the ornaments etc. it may be mentioned that the courts below have recorded a clear finding that the husband did deprive wife of the ornaments and other valuable articles. No dispute has been raised in regard to the value of the ornaments and the articles. An argument, however, has been raised to the effect that under Sec. 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act the court had no power to pass the decree, as the ornaments and other valuable articles did not jointly belong to both the husband and the wife. The contention of the appellant is that unless the ornaments or other articles jointly belonged to the husband and the wife the court is not competent to exercise the powers conferred on it under Sec. 27 of the said Act This argument appeals to be plausible. But, in my opinion, the argument really has no force. Sec. 27 aforesaid reads as follows:
“In any proceeding under this Act, the court may make such provisions in the decree as it deems just and proper with respect to any property presented, at or about the time of marriage, which may belong jointly to both the husband and the wife.”
4. Sec. 27, to my mind, does not exclude the jurisdiction or the power of the court to pass an appropriate decree in regard to the property which may belong either solely to the husband or solely to the wife. This power in the nature of things, in my opinion, is inherent in the legal proceedings which appropriately arise under the Hindu Marriage Act. In such cases generally there should be no difficulty in dealing with the property belonging exclusively to the husband or the wife. Difficulties are likely to arise in cases where there are properties which belong jointly to both of them. In such cases the court has to adjust the equities between the parties having regard to all the material circumstances, and it was to ensure the making of such equitable adjustments that specific powers had to be conferred on the court under Sec. 27 of the said Act. Therefore, I am of opinion that Sec. 27 does not exclude the general power of the court to pass an appropriate decree in regard to the property belonging exclusively to either the husband or the wife.
5. Sec. 21 of the Act provides:
“Subject to the other provisions contained in this Act and to such rules as the High Court may make in this behalf, all proceedings under this Act shall be regulated, as far as may be, by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.”
6. It will thus be seen that in proceedings under the Hindu Marriage Act the court concerned has all the powers of the Civil Court, subject, however, to the special provisions contained in the Act. By virtue of Sec. 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure the court retains its inherent power to make such orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the court Order VII, Rule 7 of the Code makes it further clear that the court has the power to grant general or other relief which it may think just under the circumstances established in a given case. I am, therefore, of the opinion that the decree of the court below, in so far as it relates to the return of the ornaments and other articles also, does not suffer from any illegality.
7. Even Sec. 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act does not contain any express provision in regard to the power of the court to pass an appropriate decree in regard to the property belonging to either the wife or the husband exclusively. The expression “which may belong jointly to both the husband and the wife” indicates that Sec. 27 confers a wider and enabling power on the court to deal also with properties which jointly belong to the husband and the wife. But it does not restrict the powers of the court only to such properties.
8. Mr. Saxena, learned counsel for the respondents, further submitted that in the trial court no objection was also raised as to misjoinder of causes of action. It was urged by him that had such plea been taken, his client would have been in a position to elect as to whether she will file a separate suit in regard to the return of the ornaments and other valuables. It is not necessary to go into this question as, in my opinion, as indicated above, there is nothing under the Hindu Marriage Act which prohibits the passing of the decree which the court has passed for return of ornaments and other valuables.
9. The appeal is dismissed with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert