Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kamta v. Gaya Prasad

Allahabad High Court
Aug 24, 1971
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The revision arises from an order of the court below which corrected a prior order and, by its terms, permitted the plaintiff to withdraw the suit under Order 23, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). The defendant-applicants challenged that order in revision, contending that they had acquired a vested right under a decree of dismissal by the trial court and that the appellate court should not have allowed withdrawal of the suit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Order 23, Rule 1, sub-rule (1) of the CPC confers an unqualified right on a plaintiff to withdraw a suit, including at the appellate stage.
  2. Whether permitting the plaintiff to withdraw the suit at the appellate stage defeats any vested rights the defendants claim to have obtained under a decree of dismissal by the trial court.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant-Applicants' Arguments

  • The defendants argued that they had secured a vested right under the decree of dismissal by the trial court, and that the appellate court ought not to have permitted the plaintiff to withdraw the suit because that would defeat the defendants' vested right.
  • They relied on the decision in Kedarnath v. Chandra Kiran, AIR 1962 All 263, which was said to hold that Order 23, Rule 1, sub-rule (1) does not give an absolute right to withdraw at the stage of second appeal and that the matter is within the court's discretion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kedarnath v. Chandra Kiran, AIR 1962 All 263 Held that Order 23, Rule 1, sub-rule (1) does not give an absolute right to withdraw at the stage of second appeal and that the court has discretion. The court noted this authority but found it rendered nugatory by the subsequent Supreme Court decision in Hulas Rai; it did not follow Kedarnath's restrictive view.
Hulas Rai v. K.B Bass & Co., AIR 1968 SC 111 Observed that Order 23, Rule 1, sub-rule (1) gives an unqualified right to a plaintiff to withdraw a suit; if sub-rule (2) permission is not sought, the plaintiff is liable for costs and is precluded from instituting a fresh suit under sub-rule (3). The court relied on this Supreme Court observation to conclude that sub-rule (1) confers an unqualified right to withdraw (including at appellate stage) and that defendants are protected by sub-rule (3) against fresh suits.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court, exercising revisional jurisdiction, declined to interfere with the order below. It observed that the impugned order was effectively a correction of an earlier order but also allowed withdrawal of the suit under Order 23, Rule 1. The defendants' contention—that they had a vested right under a decree of dismissal and that allowing withdrawal would defeat that right—was noted and supported by reference to Kedarnath v. Chandra Kiran. The court examined the language of sub-rule (1) and followed the Supreme Court's observation in Hulas Rai v. K.B Bass & Co. that sub-rule (1) gives an unqualified right to withdraw and that where sub-rule (2) permission is not sought the plaintiff becomes liable for costs and is precluded from instituting a fresh suit under sub-rule (3). Relying on Hulas Rai, the court held that the Single Judge's contrary view in Kedarnath was rendered nugatory. Because withdrawal without seeking permission under sub-rule (2) bars fresh proceedings on the same subject-matter, the court found that no prejudice or jeopardy was caused to the defendants by permitting withdrawal; the defendants retain protection against a fresh suit under sub-rule (3).

Holding and Implications

Revision dismissed

Direct effect: the revision by the defendant-applicants was dismissed with costs; the order below permitting the plaintiff to withdraw the suit under Order 23, Rule 1 was upheld. The court applied the Supreme Court's view that sub-rule (1) confers an unqualified right to withdraw and noted that a plaintiff who withdraws without seeking sub-rule (2) permission is liable for costs and is precluded from instituting a fresh suit under sub-rule (3). Consequently, the defendants' claimed vested rights were not considered to have been prejudiced by the withdrawal.

Show all summary ...

1. Having heard the learned counsel for the defendant-applicants, I do not think in the exercise of my revisional jurisdiction I should interfere with the order of the Court below. In fact the order of the Court below is merely an order of correction of a previous order but at the same time it is true that by the terms of the impugned order the suit has been allowed to be withdrawn at the instance of plaintiff, under Order 23, Rule 1 of the CPC.

2. The argument, however, raised on behalf of the applicants was that the defendants having secured a vested right, under the decree of dismissal of the suit by the trial court, the appellate court ought not to have given permission to the plaintiff to withdraw the suit as that would defeat the right of the defendants which enured to their benefit under the decree of dismissal of the suit. Reference was made to a learned Single Judge's decision of this Court in the case of Kedarnath v. Chandra Kiran, AIR 1962 All 263, in which it was held that Order 23, Rule 1, subrule (1) does not give an absolute right to the plaintiff to withdraw a suit at the stage of second appeal and the matter lay within the discretion of the court. It appears to me that sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 of Order 23 of the CPC, confers an unqualified right on the plaintiff to withdraw the suit at any time.

3. Since an appeal is continuation of the suit, the right of the plaintiff to withdraw from the suit inheres even at the appellate stage. On the language of sub-rule (1) it is difficult to hold that the plaintiff had only a qualified right to withdraw from the suit. The Supreme Court in the case of Hulas Rai v. K.B Bass & Co., AIR 1968 SC 111, observed as follows:—

“The language of Order 23, Rule I, sub-rule (1) of the CPC gives an unqualified right to a plaintiff to withdraw from a suit and if no permission to file a fresh suit is sought under sub-rule (2) of that rule, the plaintiff becomes liable for such costs as the court may award and becomes precluded from instituting any fresh suit in respect of that subject-matter under sub-rule (3) of that rule. There is no provision in the Code of Civil Procedure which requires the court to refuse permission to withdraw the suit in such circumstances and to compel the plaintiff to proceed with it ………”

4. The above quoted observation of the Supreme Court, in my judgment, rendered the view taken by the learned Single Judge of this Court, in the case of Kedarnath v. Chand Kiran (supra) nugatory. When the plaintiff withdraws from his suit without seeking permission, contemplated under subrule (2), he is precluded from instituting any fresh suit in respect of the subject-matter or the claim made in the suit so withdrawn. In this context of the law it is difficult to appreciate the argument that any vested right of the defendant, under the decree of dismissal of the suit by the trial court, is being taken away or being put in jeopardy. In law, the defendant gets absolute protection as the plaintiff will not be able to file a fresh suit relating to the same subject-matter or the same claim. No prejudice has been caused to the defendant by the impugned order of the court below.

5. Accordingly, I dismiss this revision with costs.

6. Revision dismissed.