- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Balbir Singh v. Sulochana Devi
Factual and Procedural Background
Appellant Balbir Singh filed a petition for probate under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act on 5 March 1963, based on a will executed by Gopal Narain Fadnis on 18 May 1961. Gopal Narain Fadnis died on 19 January 1963, leaving his only daughter, Smt. Sulochana, who filed a written statement contesting the maintainability of the probate application. Issues were framed, evidence was led, and arguments were heard before the trial Judge. Before conclusion, an application for amendment by the appellant was rejected on 16 September 1966. Subsequently, on 19 September 1966, the appellant sought permission to withdraw the probate application with liberty to file another proceeding or suit, citing formal defects in the probate proceeding. The defendant objected to this application. The Additional District Judge permitted withdrawal of the suit but withheld permission to file a fresh suit or proceeding. The appellant appealed against this order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the trial Judge had jurisdiction to grant permission to withdraw the probate suit but refuse liberty to file a fresh suit or proceeding as prayed by the appellant.
- Whether the application to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit can be split and partially granted or must be treated as an indivisible whole.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Veeraswami v. Lakshmudu, AIR 1951 Mad 715 | Where a plaintiff files a petition to withdraw a suit with permission to file a fresh suit regarding the same subject-matter, the court cannot divide the petition and accept the withdrawal but refuse liberty to file a fresh suit in the same order. | The court relied on this precedent to hold that the trial Judge had no jurisdiction to split the prayer and grant withdrawal while refusing liberty to file a fresh suit. |
| Marudachala Nadar v. Chinna Muthu Nadar, AIR 1932 Mad 155 (1) | An application under Order 23, Rule 1(2) for permission to withdraw a suit with liberty to institute a fresh suit must be treated as an indivisible whole; if liberty is refused, the suit should not be dismissed but retained. | The court agreed with this principle, emphasizing that the trial Judge should have either accepted or rejected the joint prayer in toto. |
| Kamini Kumar Roy v. Rajendra Nath, AIR 1926 Cal 233 | Supports the view that withdrawal with liberty to file a fresh suit is an indivisible application and cannot be split. | The court expressed respectful agreement with this dictum in affirming its reasoning. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the appellant's joint prayer to withdraw the probate suit with liberty to file another proceeding. It held that the trial Judge was justified in refusing liberty to file a fresh suit, but erred in splitting the prayer by allowing withdrawal while denying liberty. The court referred to binding precedents establishing that such applications must be treated as indivisible wholes and either accepted or rejected entirely. Consequently, the court varied the impugned order by dismissing the application for withdrawal with liberty to file a fresh suit, thereby restoring the probate proceeding to the trial Judge for disposal according to law.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is allowed in part by varying the order of the Additional District Judge to dismiss the application for permission to withdraw the probate suit with liberty to file any other proceeding or suit.
Implications: The probate proceeding is restored to the trial Judge's file for disposal in accordance with law. The parties are directed to bear their own costs of the appeal. No new precedent was established; the decision reinforces existing principles regarding the indivisibility of withdrawal applications with liberty to file fresh suits.
1. Appellant Balbir Singh had filed a petition for probate under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act on 5-3-1963. On the basis of a will which was alleged to have been executed by one Gopal Narain Fadnis on 18th May, 1961. Gopal Narain Fadnis died on 19-1-1963 leaving his only daughter Smt. Sulochana as his survivor. Smt. Sulochana filed a written statement in the case and inter alia pleaded that the application for probate was not maintainable.
2. Issues were framed, parties led evidence and the case was argued on their behalf on several dates before the trial Judge. Before the conclusion of the arguments however an application for amendment was made by the appellant which was rejected by the Judge on 16-9-1966.
3. On 19-9-1966 an application was filed by the appellant before the District Judge, Lucknow praying that he may be permitted to withdraw the above probate application with liberty to bring any other proceeding or suit as “he may be advised” on the ground that “the above probate proceeding is defective for some formal defects” and “the applicant does not want to further prosecute the above application owing to the defects and for other reasons”.
4. The defendant filed an objection praying that the application be rejected. After hearing the counsel for the parties at considerable length and taking into account the facts and circumstances of the case the learned Addl. District Judge inter alia observed “that the plaintiff has not disclosed in his application the nature of the formal defect ………… and because of the fact that it was argued on behalf of the plaintiff that the provisions of Order 23, Rule 1 do not apply to probate proceedings I permit the plaintiff to withdraw the suit, but withhold the permission to file a fresh suit or proceeding as he may be advised.” Aggrieved by the order the plaintiff has come up in appeal before this Court.
5. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties. There can be no doubt that on the facts and circumstances of the case the learned trial Judge was fully justified in refusing permission to the plaintiff to file a fresh suit or proceeding as he may be advised. It was, however, not open to the learned Judge in law to split up the plaintiffs prayer for withdrawal of the suit with permission to file a fresh suit in two parts. He could have either accepted the application or rejected it in toto. This is obvious from the fact that the plaintiff's prayer to withdraw the probate application was based on his further prayer that he should be permitted to file any other proceeding or suit as he may be advised. It was joint prayer which could have been either accepted or rejected in toto as stated above. The trial Judge, in my opinion, had no jurisdiction to split it up in two parts and to grant one and refuse the other.
6. However, I am satisfied that the trial Judge's refusal to permit the plaintiff appellant to file a fresh suit or proceeding is fully justified. It is not necessary to interfere with that order.
7. In the case of Veeraswami v. Lakshmudu, AIR 1951 Mad 715 it was held that “where a plaintiff files a petition to withdraw the suit with permission to file a fresh suit regarding the same subject-matter ………… The court cannot divide the petition into two and accept the withdrawal and refuse the liberty in the same order.”
8. In the case of Marudachala Nadar v. Chinna Muthu Nadar, AIR 1932 Mad 155 (1) it was held that “an application under O. 23, R. 1(2) for permission to withdraw from suit with liberty to institute a fresh suit on the same subject-matter must be treated as an indivisible whole, and if a party is not allowed liberty to institute a fresh suit, his pending suit should not be dismissed, but the application should be refused altogether and the suit should be retained on the file.”
9. The same view was taken by a learned single Judge of the Calcutta High Court in Kamini Kumar Roy v. Rajendra Nath, AIR 1926 Cal 233. I find myself in respectful agreement with the dictum laid in the aforesaid cases.
10. In the result this appeal is allowed in part. The order passed by the learned Additional District Judge will be varied by substituting therefor an order in these terms “that the application for permission to withdraw the above probate with liberty to bring any other proceeding or suit as the plaintiff may be advised is dismissed with costs”. The result will be that the probate proceeding shall be restored to the file of the trial Judge who will dispose it of in accordance with law. In the circumstances of the case the parties shall bear their own costs of this appeal.
11. Appeal partly allowed.
Alert