Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Arjun Sahai v. Pitamber Das And Others

Allahabad High Court
Jan 4, 1962
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit for recovery of the entire amount due on a bond executed by the defendants on 20th September 1931. The bond was payable in 18 six-monthly installments, falling due in the months of Aghan and Jeth each year, with the last installment due on 19th June 1940. The bond contained three key stipulations regarding defaults and the creditor's rights to recover amounts due.

The defendants admitted non-payment of any installments. The creditor filed suit on 2nd June 1943, within three years of the last installment's default, claiming the entire bond amount with interest. The main defense was that the suit was barred by limitation.

The trial court held the suit barred by limitation under Article 74 of the Indian Limitation Act and decreed recovery only for the last installment. On appeal, the Civil and Sessions Judge ruled the suit was within time under Article 80. In second appeal, the High Court held the suit governed by Article 75 of the Indian Limitation Act, as the entire amount became due only after default of the last installment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit for recovery of the entire amount due on the bond is governed by Article 74 or Article 75 of the Indian Limitation Act.
  2. The interpretation and applicability of the default clauses in the bond regarding the creditor's right to sue for installments or the entire amount.
  3. Whether the suit was barred by limitation considering the nature of the defaults and the claim made.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The bond contained two default clauses: one allowing suit for every two installments in default, and another allowing suit for the entire amount on default of all installments.
  • The present suit is essentially for recovery of unpaid installments, thus governed by Article 74 of the Indian Limitation Act and not Article 75.
  • Relied on the Madras High Court decision in V. Narayanswami v. Sri Mohan Prasad Singh Deo (A.I.R 1959 Mad. 82) to support this interpretation.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The suit is for the entire amount due on the bond, which fell due only upon default of the last installment, triggering the creditor's right under the third clause of the bond.
  • Article 75 applies because the entire amount becomes payable on default of one or more installments, and the suit was brought within three years of that default.
  • The Madras High Court decision cited by the appellant is distinguishable on facts and does not apply to the present case.
  • Supported by the Full Bench decision of this Court in Jawahar Lal v. Mathura Prasad (A.I.R 1934 All. 661), which upheld the applicability of Article 75 in similar circumstances.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
V. Narayanswami v. Sri Mohan Prasad Singh Deo (A.I.R 1959 Mad. 82) Interpretation of default clauses in bonds and applicability of Article 74 of the Limitation Act for suits to recover installments. Distinguished on facts; bond in that case allowed suits only for installments in default, not for entire amount due at once.
Sukh Lal v. Bhura (A.I.R 1934 All. 1039) Related to limitation issues in recovery suits under bonds. Not examined in detail due to differing facts.
Munshi Lal v. Sagarmal alias Parmanand (1943 A.L.J 238) Related to limitation and recovery under bonds. Not examined in detail due to differing facts.
Jawahar Lal v. Mathura Prasad (A.I.R 1934 All. 661) Applicability of Article 75 to bonds with default clauses allowing recovery of entire amount on successive defaults. Fully supports the Court's view that Article 75 applies when entire amount becomes due on default of multiple installments.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the terms of the bond and the nature of the creditor's claim to determine the applicable limitation period under the Indian Limitation Act. It emphasized that the applicability of Articles 74 or 75 depends on the bond's default clause and the character of the suit.

Article 74 applies where suits are for recovery of individual installments as they fall due, with limitation periods computed from each default date. Article 75 applies where the entire amount becomes due on default of one or more installments, allowing suit for the whole amount within three years from that default.

In the present case, the bond's third clause granted the creditor the right to recover the entire amount due on default of all installments, which occurred on 19th June 1940. The suit was instituted within three years of this date, thus falling within the limitation period under Article 75.

The Court rejected the appellant's reliance on the Madras High Court decision, finding that the factual matrix and bond stipulations differed significantly. The Court also cited the Full Bench decision in Jawahar Lal v. Mathura Prasad to support its interpretation that Article 75 governs suits where the entire bond amount falls due on default.

Consequently, the suit was held to be within time and maintainable for recovery of the entire bond amount.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED WITH COSTS

The Court dismissed the defendant's special appeal, affirming that the suit for recovery of the entire bond amount was timely under Article 75 of the Indian Limitation Act. The decision confirms that when a bond provides for the entire amount to become due on default of all installments, limitation runs from the date of last default, allowing suit for the whole amount within three years.

No new precedent was set beyond the application of existing principles to the facts of this case. The ruling clarifies the distinction between suits for individual installments under Article 74 and suits for entire amounts under Article 75 based on bond terms.

Show all summary ...

V. Bhargava, J.:— This is a defendant's special appeal arising out of a suit for the recovery of the entire amount due on a bond executed by the defendants on 20th September 1931 The bond was payable in 18 six monthly installments which were to fall due in the months of Aghan and Jeth every year. The last installment fell due on 19th June, 1940. The bond contained three stipulations as follows:

1. If any installment was not paid then from the date of the default upto the date of payment of that installment interest at annas eight per cent per mensem was payable on the amount of the installment;

2. If there was any default in payment of two successive installments the creditor was to have a right to realise the principal and the interest due on those two installments which remained unpaid; and

3. If the creditor so desired he could realise the entire amount of the bond on default of payment of all the installments.

2. It is the admitted case of the parties that the defendants did not pay any installment. The present suit was brought by the creditor on 2nd June 1943, that is, within three years of the default of the last installment claiming the entire amount of the bond with interest. The plaintiffs' case was that the defendants having made default in payment of all the installments the entire amount of the bond fell due on 19th June, 1940 and so they were entitled to a decree for the entire amount.

3. The main defence taken in the case was that the suit was barred by limitation.

4. The trial court upheld the defendants' plea and decreed the suit for the last installment only on the ground that the case was covered by the provisions of Art. 74 of the Indian Limitation Act. On appeal, the learned Civil and Sessions Judge, Kanpur decreed the plaintiffs' suit for the entire amount holding that it was within time and that the suit was governed by Art. 80 of the Indian Limitation Act. The matter came up in second appeal before this Court and the learned single Judge held, and in our opinion rightly, that the suit was governed by Art. 75 of the Indian Limitation Act, because under the terms of the bond the plaintiffs could realise the entire amount of the bond only on default of payment of all the installments and this right accrued to them when the default in payment of the 18th installment was made on 19th June, 1940. The plaintiffs had no right to claim the entire amount earlier than the date of default of the last installment and that in this case the provision along “default in payment of all installments” was fully covered by the expression “default of one or more installments” used in Art. 75 of the Indian Limitation Act.

5. Learned counsel for the appellant has contended before us that there are two default clauses in the document and under the first default clause the creditor was entitled to bring a suit for every two installments which fell due, while under the second default clause the creditor was entitled to claim the entire amount meaning thereby all the unpaid installments of the bond, and, consequently, the present suit by the creditor is in substance a suit to recover the unpaid installments and that to such a case the proper article to apply was Art. 74 of the Indian Limitation Act and not Art. 75. For this purpose reliance has been placed upon a decision of the Madras High Court in the case of V. Narayanswami v. Sri Mohan Prasad Singh Deo . A.I.R 1959 Mad. 82.. He has submitted that the third clause of the bond in suit is similar in terms to the conditions contained in Cl. (f) of the bond which came up for consideration before the Madras High Court. We are unable to accept this contention.

6. The applicability of Art. 74 or 75 of the Limitation Act depends upon the terms of the bond and the nature of the claim or the character of the suit brought in terms of the bond. The mere fact that a bond contains a default clause will not in all cases attract the provision of Art. 75. Art. 75 applies to only those cases where the provision relating to the default clause lays down that on default being made in payment of one or more installments, the whole amount is to fall due. It would not apply in cases where a default clause may exist in a different form, e.g where the right of bringing the suit is confined to recovering the amount of each installment in respect of which default may have been committed. In fact, Art. 74 applies to those cases where the suit is for the recovery of the installments as such and not for the recovery of the whole amount on the basis that it had fallen due because of some default. On the other hand, where the whole amount falls due on one or more defaults being committed and the whole amount is claimed in the suit, the proper article, which will be applicable, will be Art. 75.

7. Thus in a case where money become payable on a particular date in respect of an installment, the suit for recovery of that money would have to be brought within a period of three years computed from the date of that default. That would be a suit for recovery of the amount due in respect of that installment and would be governed by Art. 74. Similarly, if the suit is brought for recovery of the amount due under each successive installment, that suit would also have to be brought within three years from the date of each respective default in respect of the installment and the limitation would be governed by Art. 74. Art. 75 will apply to those cases where, instead of the suit being for individual installments, it is instituted for the recovery of the whole amount of the bond which remained due when the default entitling the institution of the suit was committed. In such a case it remains open to the creditor to waive his right to recover the entire amount on the commission of any particular default, in which case he can again bring a suit for the whole of the amount due on the bond on the commission of a fresh default. In all such cases the period of limitation would be the period of three years with effect from the particular default on the basis of which the creditor claims to recover the entire amount due under the bond. In the case before us the suit was brought not for particular installments but for the whole of the amount due on the bond on the basis of default of an installment on a date which was within three years of the date of institution of the suit. In such circumstances, Art. 75 applied and the suit was within time.

8. The view expressed by the Madras High Court in the case of V. Narayanswami does not appear to lay down any different principle of law. A careful examination of Cl. (f) of the bond of that case will show that the stipulation contained in that clause was quite different from the stipulation contained in the third clause of the bond before us. In that case there was no provision for the entire amount falling due on default of one or more installments. The only provision which was contained in Cl. (f) of the bond was that the creditor could sue only for the installments which had fallen due, whether it was one installment or more. It further appears that the right of suit to the creditor given under the bond was for the recovery of those installments only in respect of which default had been committed. The creditor was also given the option to sue for those very installments which had fallen due earlier at the time when all the installments had also fallen into arrears. In that case the creditor was not given the right to recover the entire amount of the bond as one single sum due under the bond on the basis that, even after the defaults were committed, the integrity of the bond had remained unaffected. The learned Judges took notice of the fact that under Cl. (f) the only right conferred on the creditor was to recover the unpaid installments as such and not the entire debt. The entire debt under that clause never fell due on the commission of any default. Each time, on the commission of a default, the amount due for each installment fell due and the suit had to be brought for the amounts of the installments and not the entire debt. It was in these circumstances that the learned Judges held that the further condition that a suit in respect of earlier installments, which had fallen due on commission of earlier defaults, could be brought within a period of three years computed from a latter default in respect of a latter installment amount to granting an extension for the period of limitation prescribed by the Limitation Act which was not permissible. The case is different where the creditor has been given a right to recover the entire amount on the basis of any one or more of the defaults and he has the option of waiving all earlier defaults and relying on a later default, in which case the period of limitation has to be computed under Art. 75 with effect from the date of the particular default on the basis of which recovery of the entire amount is claimed by the creditor. In such a case the creditor claims the entire amount treating the bond as a bond for the entire amount due with its integrity unaffected. The facts of the case before us are clearly of this nature, so that the decision of the Madras High Court is not applicable at all to the present case. Learned counsel also referred to the case of Sukh Lal v. Bhura . A.I.R 1934 All. 1039 and to the case of Munshi Lal v. Sagarmal alias Parmanand . 1943 A.L.J 238., but both these cases are based on different facts. We do not think it necessary to go into those cases in any detail.

9. On the other hand, the Full Bench authority of this Court in the case of Jawahar Lal v. Mathura Prasad . A.I.R 1934 All. 661 fully supports the view taken by us. That was a case in which an installment bond was executed with a stipulation that in case the fixed installments with the interest thereon were not paid for any two successive months, then, in either case, the creditor would be authorised to realise the entire amount of principal and interest together with costs in a lump sum either within a stipulated period or after it. The learned Chief Justice, while discussing the proposition of law, observed at page 667:

“….. the mere fact that a bond contains a default clause of that nature would not necessarily make Art. 75 applicable if the nature of the claim or the character of the suit be different, for instance, where some other covenant in the document is being sought to be enforced. I can conceive of other cases also where, although there is a bond with a default clause, the appropriate article applicable would be Art. 74, Such an instance would be where the suit is brought for the recovery of the installment that has fallen due and before there is such a default as makes the whole amount become due. In such a case, although the bond is a bond payable by installments and there is a default clause, Art. 74 would never the less be applicable. But I am clearly of opinion that where Col. 1 of Art. 75 is in terms applicable, then Art. 74 cannot be relied upon.”

10. As stated earlier, it is a case which is clearly covered by the provisions of Art. 75 of the Limitation Act because the right to recover the whole amount accrued to the Creditor only upon the default of payment of all the installments and as the present suit had been instituted within three years of the date of default of the last installment payable under the bond, it was rightly held to be within time.

11. We, therefore, find no force in this appeal. It is accordingly dismissed with costs.

Appeal dismissed.