Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Balak v. State Of Uttar Pradesh

Allahabad High Court
Jul 26, 1961
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Article 226 challenged Government notifications issued under the Land Acquisition Act. The State of Uttar Pradesh issued three notifications: (i) a notification dated 2 March 1959 under Section 4 for an area of 113.78 acres; (ii) a notification dated 16 April 1959 under Section 6 for the same area of 113.78 acres; and (iii) a third notification under Section 4 relating to a separate small area of 2 acres. Sixty petitioners claimed to be tenants of the land covered by these notifications and sought a writ of mandamus restraining the State from proceeding with acquisition.

The opposite parties filed a counter-affidavit and raised three preliminary objections to maintainability: (1) that a single joint petition by 60 claimants challenging separate notifications was not maintainable; (2) that the petitioners had not established a subsisting interest in the property; and (3) that possession had already been taken prior to filing, rendering the petition ineffective. The Court invited the petitioners to elect which area to press the petition on; they elected to pursue the challenge to the 113.78 acre area. The Court then addressed preliminary objections and proceeded to the merits concerning whether the State could validly initiate acquisition for what was alleged to be a Union purpose.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a single joint writ petition by multiple petitioners challenging separate government notifications (covering different parcels) is maintainable, or whether it is defective for multifariousness.
  2. Whether the petitioners had a subsisting (prima facie) interest in the land sufficient to maintain the writ petition.
  3. Whether the acquisition proceedings were barred by the fact that possession had allegedly been taken before the writ petition was filed.
  4. Whether the State Government validly initiated acquisition proceedings for land said to be required for a Union purpose, specifically whether the 1952 notification (purporting to delegate Central Government/President's powers under Article 258) validly empowered the State to act on behalf of the Union.

Arguments of the Parties

Opposite Parties / State (as summarized in the opinion)

  • The acquisition proceedings and the notifications are valid and lawful.
  • Preliminary objection: a single joint petition by 60 claimants with respect to separate notifications/areas is not maintainable (multifariousness). The Court was referred to Moinuddin v. State of U.P.
  • Preliminary objection: the petitioners had not established a subsisting interest; there was a dispute with Pipraich Sugar Mills regarding sirdari rights and civil litigation pending, and the Mills was recorded as Sirdar of the plots.
  • Preliminary objection: possession of the land was taken by authorities on 3-7-1959, prior to the filing of the writ petition on 13-7-1959.
  • On the main legal point, the State relied on a Government of India notification dated 29-3-1952 (the "1952 notification") purporting to entrust to the State the functions of the Central Government under the Land Acquisition Act for acquisition for Union purposes, and thus contended the State was empowered to initiate acquisition on behalf of the Union.

Petitioners (as summarized in the opinion)

  • The petitioners claimed to be tenants and asserted a right to challenge the notifications; they established prima facie tenancy/interest (revenue court recognition was relied upon).
  • The petitioners disputed the State's claim of prior physical dispossession and asserted that if there was any transaction of delivery of possession it was only on paper and that they continued in actual physical possession.
  • On the principal legal issue, counsel for petitioners contended the acquisition was for a Union purpose and therefore only the Central Government (the appropriate government for Union purposes) could validly act under Section 4; accordingly, the State had no power to issue the impugned notifications unless a valid delegation existed under Article 258.
  • Petitioners challenged the validity of the 1952 notification on the ground that it purported to be an order by the Central Government and did not refer to the President, and therefore did not validly delegate powers under Article 258(1).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Moinuddin v. State of U.P, AIR 1960 All 484 The proposition that a joint petition containing a prayer for mandamus cannot be filed on behalf of several petitioners (illustrating multifariousness and non-maintainability of a single joint writ in certain circumstances). The Court accepted that there was force in this contention as the notifications covered separate parcels and many petitioners. The Court invited the petitioners to elect which area to press; the petitioners elected to press the matter with respect to the 113.78 acre area, and the Court confined further proceedings to that area.
State of Bombay v. Purushottam Jog Naik, 1952 SCR 674 : AIR 1952 SC 317 Addressed whether an executive order expressed as being by the Government could be treated as an order in the name of the Governor (substantial compliance with formal requirements for executive action expressed in the name of the constitutional head). The Court discussed this authority while considering whether the 1952 notification could be treated as an order by the President despite not mentioning the President. The opinion noted the Naik case outcome but distinguished it: in Naik there was substantial compliance with contextual requirements; here the 1952 notification made no reference to the President and could not be treated as a valid delegation under Article 258.
Muhammad Raza Saheb v. Sadasiva Rao, AIR 1926 Mad 297 Authority for the proposition that an order issued in the name of the Government and authenticated by the Secretary to Government was held to be properly issued under the statutory scheme (concerning form and authentication of governmental orders). The Court referred to this case to illustrate situations where orders expressed to be by a government and authenticated were held valid; it was part of the comparative discussion on formal requirements for governmental orders and delegation, supporting the analysis that formal expression in the name of the constitutional executive matters.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded sequentially through the preliminary objections and then the substantive issue.

1. Multifariousness / Maintainability: The Court found force in the objection that a single petition by 60 claimants concerning separate notifications (two notifications for 113.78 acres and one for 2 acres) raised multifariousness. Relying on Moinuddin v. State of U.P., the Court required an election. The petitioners elected to press the petition only with respect to the 113.78 acre area, and the Court confined further consideration to that area.

2. Subsisting Interest: The State pointed to a dispute between the petitioners and Pipraich Sugar Mills regarding sirdari rights and civil litigation pending. The Court noted, however, that the revenue court had recognized the petitioners' claim as tenants. On that basis the Court concluded that the petitioners were prima facie tenants and had established a prima facie interest sufficient to maintain the writ petition; they were not required to await the outcome of separate civil litigation between the petitioners and the Sugar Mills.

3. Possession: The opposite parties alleged possession was taken on 3-7-1959, prior to the writ filed on 13-7-1959. The petitioners countered that any apparent delivery was a paper transaction and that they continued in actual physical possession. Given the conflicting affidavits, the Court found it difficult to determine who had actual possession at the relevant moment and therefore declined to give dispositive weight to this preliminary objection.

4. Merits — Power to Acquire Land for a Union Purpose: The pivotal legal question was whether the State could validly initiate acquisition proceedings for land said to be required for a Union purpose (construction of staff quarters for the North Eastern Railway Headquarters Scheme). The Court analysed the statutory and constitutional framework:

  • Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act requires publication of a preliminary notification by the "appropriate Government".
  • "Appropriate Government" (Section 3 clause (ee) of the Act) means the Central Government when the acquisition is for Union purposes; otherwise it means the State Government.
  • Because the impugned acquisition was alleged to be for a Union purpose, the "appropriate Government" was the Central Government; therefore only the Central Government could take action under Section 4 in the ordinary course.

The opposite parties relied on a 29-3-1952 notification purporting to entrust to the State Government the functions of the Central Government under Article 258 of the Constitution, thereby authorising the State to act on behalf of the Union. The Court examined Article 258(1), which authorises the President (with the consent of a State Government) to entrust functions to that Government. The Court observed constitutional provisions (Articles 53 and 77) making executive power of the Union vested in the President and requiring Union executive action to be expressed in the name of the President.

Critically, the Court emphasised that the 1952 notification purported to be issued by the Central Government and made no reference to the President of India. The petitioners argued, and the Court agreed, that Article 258(1) contemplates delegation by the President (expressed or identifiable as such), and there was nothing in the Constitution to permit orders that must be by the President to be validly issued in the name of the Central Government in the absence of expression or authentication that they were issued by or on behalf of the President.

The Court considered Naik and Muhammad Raza Saheb authorities (concerning the formal expression and authentication of orders) but found them distinguishable: in Naik there was substantial compliance and the order could be treated as in the name of the Governor; by contrast the 1952 notification made no reference to the President and could not be treated as a valid delegation under Article 258. Consequently, the 1952 notification did not lawfully empower the State Government to exercise Central Government functions under the Land Acquisition Act for Union purposes.

Because there was no valid delegation to the State to act for the Union, the State's actions in issuing the two notifications dated 2-3-1959 and 16-4-1959 (under Sections 4 and 6, and also referenced Section 17 in the order) with respect to the 113.78 acre area were invalid. The Court concluded the petitioners were entitled to restoration to possession if they had been dispossessed pursuant to those invalid notifications.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Petition partly allowed.

Direct orders and immediate consequences announced by the Court:

  • The opposite parties are directed not to give effect to the two notifications dated 2-3-1959 and 16-4-1959 issued under Sections 4, 6 and 17 of the Land Acquisition Act with respect to the area of 113.78 acres (Annexures A & B to the petition); the Court declared those notifications invalid.
  • The opposite parties are directed to restore petitioners Nos. 1 to 53 to possession over the 113.78 acres, if the petitioners have been dispossessed pursuant to those notifications.
  • The petition is dismissed insofar as it related to the other area of 2 acres.
  • The parties were directed to bear their own costs.

Broader implications: The Court's decision invalidated the 1952 notification (purporting to delegate Central Government/President's functions under Article 258) as not being an order by or in the name of the President; as a result, the State had no authority to act in place of the Central Government for acquisition for Union purposes in this instance. The opinion set out the Court's constitutional analysis on delegation under Article 258, but the summary above confines itself to the conclusions and directions explicitly contained in the opinion.

LE/K.S.B
Show all summary ...

1. By this petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution certain Government Notifications issued under the Land Acquisition Act are being challenged. The State of Uttar Pradesh issued a series of notifications to the effect that certain land was to be acquired for construction of staff quarters in connection with the North Eastern Railway Headquarters Scheme. The first notification dated 2nd March, 1959 was under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act (hereafter referred to as the Act), and related to an area of 113.78 acres. The second notification dated 16-4-1959 related to the same area of 113.78 acres and was issued under Section 6 of the Act. The third notification related to a small area of 2 acres and was issued under Section 4 of the Act. There are 60 petitioners. Their claim is that they are tenants of the land covered by the said notifications, and their land is being illegally acquired by the State Government. The petitioners have therefore prayed for a writ of mandamus commanding the opposite parties not to proceed with these land acquisition proceedings.

2. A counter-affidavit has been filed on behalf of the opposite parties. They have maintained that the land acquisition proceedings are valid. Mr. Lakshmi Saran appearing for the State raised three preliminary objections as regards the maintainability of the writ petition. His first contention is that a single petition by 60 claimants with respect to separate Government Notifications is not maintainable. There is force in this contention. In Moinuddin v. State of U.P, AIR 1960 All 484, it was held that, a joint petition containing a prayer for mandamus cannot be filed on behalf of several petitioners. The three impugned Government notifications cover two separate parcels of land. Two notifications relate to an area of 113.78 acres; while the third notification relates to an area of 2 acres. Again, there are as many as 60 petitioners. All of them are not interested in both the parcels of land, According to the affidavit of Dhonrahi petitioner petitioners Nos. 1 to 53 are tenants in the land with an area of 113.78 acres. Petitioners Nos. 34, 37, 48, 52 and 54 to 60 are tenants of land measuring 2 acres. The petition is defective on account of multifariousness. There is, however, reason to believe that 53 petitioners are interested in challenging the acquisition proceedings relating to the area of 113.78 acres. I invited Mr. S.C Khare appearing for the petitioners to exercise option. He elected to press the petition with respect to the area of 113.78 acres. I shall therefore, confine further discussion in this case to this area of 113.78 acres.

3. Mr. Lakshmi Saran's second objection is that, the petitioners have not established a subsisting interest in the property in dispute. In Sch. No. 1 attached to the petition the petitioners have described how they are interested in different portions of the total area of 113.78 acres. According to the petition, 53 petitioners are tenants of this land. In paragraph 3 of the counter-affidavit it is stated:

“There is a dispute between the Pipraich Sugar Mills and the petitioners Nos. 19 to 53 in respecli of the Sirdari rights. It is the Pipraich Sugar Mills which is recorded as Sirdar of the plots. No doubt the Assistant Collector First Class Gorakhpur had passed an order in favour of the petitioners but there is a civil litigation pending between the said Mills and the petitioners in respect of these rights.”

Since the revenue court has recognized the petitioners claim as tenants, they are prima facie tenants of the land in dispute. The opposite parties are hardly concerned with the litigation between the petitioners and the Sugar Mills. The petitioners are not required to await the result of that litigation. The petitioners have established a prima facie interest in the property in dispute. They are, therefore, entitled to file this) writ petition.

4. The third objection against the maintainability of the petition is that, the authorities have already taken possession under the impugned notifications. In paragraph 7 of the counter-affidavit it has been stated that possession was taken over on 3-7-1959. The writ petition was moved. On 13-7-1959. Thus according to the counter-affidavit, the authorities took possession ten days before the writ petition was moved. This allegation has been challenged in the rejoinder affidavit. In paragraph 12 of the rejoinder affidavit it is stated that there might be some paper transaction about delivery of possession. But the petitioners have continued to be in actual physical possession. In view of the conflicting statements in the rival affidavits, it is difficult to say whether possession at the moment is with the petitioners or with the opposite parties. Since there is doubt about actual possession, one cannot give such weight to this preliminary objection raised on behalf of the opposite parties. In paragraph 4 of the counter-affidavit it is stated that petitioner No. 34 is not a tenant in the land covering 2 acres. Since the petition with respect to this area of 2 acres is being dismissed, it is unnecessary to discuss the question whether petitioner No. 34 is interested in this area of 2 acres.

5. Now I proceed to discuss the merits of the writ petition. The main contention of Mr. S.C Khare is that the acquisition proceedings are for a Union purpose. It was not open to the State Government to initiate the acquisition proceedings. The impugned notifications mention that land is being acquired for construction of staff quarters in connection with the North Eastern Railway Head-quarters Scheme. This is a Union purpose. But it has been urged for the opposite parties that the State Government has authority to acquire land for the benefit of the Union.

6. Section 4 of the Act provides for publication of a preliminary notification. Sub-section (1) of S. 4 states:

“Whenever it appears to the appropriate Government that land in any locality is needed or is likely to be needed for any public purpose, a notification to that effect shall be published in the Official Gazette and the Collector shall cause public notice …………”

The expression “appropriate Government” has been defined in Clause (ee) of Section 3 of the Act. The expression “appropriate Government” means in relation to acquisition of land for the purposes of the Union, the Central Government, and, in relation to acquisition of land for any other purposes, the State Government. We have seen that in the instant case it is alleged that land is being acquired for a purpose of the Union. So in the present case “appropriate Government” means the Central Government. So it was the Central Government which could take action under Section 4 of the Act for acquiring land. Action I has, however, been taken by the State Government), and not by the Union Government.

7. It has been urged for the opposite parties that, the State Government has been empowered by the Central Government to take action under the Act whenever necessary. Reliance is placed upon a notification, dated 29-3-1952 issued by the Government of India. Annexure I to the counter affidavit is a copy of that notification dated 29-3-1952 (hereafter referred to as 1952 notification). That notification runs thus:

“In exercise of the powers conferred by cl. (1) of Art. 258 of the Constitution the Central Government hereby entrusts to the Governments of Bombay, Uttar Pradesh ………. the functions of the Central Government under the Land Acquisition Act………… in relation to acquisition of land for the purposes of the Union, within their respective territories.”

According to this notification, the Central Government authorised the U.P Government to initiate acquisition proceedings on behalf of the Central Government.

8. Mr. S.C Khare contended that the 1952 notification is invalid. That notification purports to have been issued under Art. 258 of the Constitution. Clause (1) of Art. 258 of the Constitution is in these-terms:

“Notwithstanding anything in this Constitution, the President may, with the consent of the Government of a State, entrust either conditionally or unconditionally to that Government or to its officers-functions in relation to any matter to which the executive power of the Union extends.”

Under this provision the President may delegate his-functions to a State Government. Mr. Khare pointed out that the 1952 notification purports to be an order by the Central Government. That notification does not refer to the President of India at all. Mr. Khare therefore urged that, that is not a valid notification under Art. 258(1) of the Constitution.

9. Mr. Lakshmi Saran contended that, although the 1952 notification purports to have been issued by the Central Government, it should be taken as delegation by the President. Reliance was placed upon. The State Of Bombay v. Purushottam Jog Naik, 1952 SCR 674 : (AIR 1952 SC 317). Id that case the impugned notification ran thus:

“Whereas the Government of Bombay is satisfied with respect to the person known as J.N…………that with a view to preventing him from acting in a manner prejudicial to the maintenance of public order it is necessary to make the following order:

Now, therefore ………… the Government of Bombay is pleased to direct that the said J.N be detained.

By order of the Governor of Bombay

(Sd.) V.T.D

Secretary to the Government of Bombay, Home Department.”

10. The High Court of Bombay held that the order was defective, as it was not “expressed to be in the name of the Governor” within the meaning of Art. 166(1) and was not accordingly protected by Art. 166(2). That decision was reversed by the Supreme Court in appeal. Their Lordships held in appeal that, the order was not defective merely because it stated that the Government of Bombay was satisfied and that the Government of Bombay was pleased to direct that J.N be detained. The order was really one expressed to be taken in the name of the Governor of Bombay within Art. 166.

11. The impugned order in Naik's case, 1952 SCR 674 : (AIR 1952 SC 317), was issued under the Preventive Detention Act, 1950. According to Section 3 of that Act, action for detention could be taken if the State Government was satisfied as regards certain matters. The initial condition was the satisfaction of the State Government. The impugned order expressly mentioned that the Government of Bombay was satisfied about the necessity of detaining J.N So, in terms, that order complied with the requirement of Section 3 of the Preventive Detention Act, 1950, Further, it was being issued under directions of the Governor of Bombay. There was, therefore, substantial compliance with Art. 166 of the Constitution. In the present case the impugned notification of 1952 does not refer to the President of India at all. In Muhammad Raza Saheb v. Sadasiva Rao, AIR 1926 Mad 297, the Government order was expressed as by order of the Government, Ministry of Local Self-Government. The order was signed by the Secretary to the Government. It was held that the order was validly issued. According to R. 37 of the District Municipalities Act, an order had to be issued by the Governor-in-Council. On the other hand, according to section 49 of the Government of India Act, orders had to be expressed as made by the Government of the Province and authenticated as prescribed. The impugned order in that case was issued in the name of the Government. It was authenticated by the Secretary to Government. That appears to be in accordance with the directions issued by the Governor in that respect. So it was held that the order was properly issued.

12. We have to consider whether the 1953 notification can be considered to be an order by the President of India, although the notification purports to have been issued by the Central Government. Under Art. 53 of the Constitution, the Executive power of the Union shall be vested in the President and shall be exercised by him either directly or through officers subordinate to him in accordance with the Constitution. According to cl. (1) of Art. 77 of the Constitution, all executive action of the Government of India shall be expressed to be taken in the name of the President. Under this Article, even if action is taken by the Central Government, the relevant order ought to be issued in the name of the President. I do not find in the Constitution the converse proposition. There is no provision to the effect that, orders to be issued by the President might be issued in the name of the Central Government. We have seen that under cl. (1) of Art. 258 of the Constitution, it is the President who can delegate his functions to the State Government. There is nothing in the Constitution to suggest that the Central Government may act on behalf of the President for purposes of Art. 258. It is true that, under Art. 74 of the Constitution, the President is aided by a Council of Ministers.

13. It was open to the Council of Ministers to advise the President for issuing an order under Art. 258 of the Constitution. But ultimately the order had to be issued by the President, or in the name of the President. In the instant case the 1952 notification was issued by the Central Government, and not by the President. I agree with Mr. Khare that the notification dated 29-3-1952 is not a valid notification delegating powers under Art. 258 of the Constitution. The 1952 notification did not empower the State Government to take action under the Act on behalf of the Union Government. In the absence of any such delegation of powers, action in the instant case ought to have been taken by the appropriate Government (the Central Government). It was not open to the State Government to issue notifications under Section 4 and 6 of the Act on behalf of the Union Government. The two notifications dated 2-3-59 and 16-4-59 with reference to the area of 113.78 acres are invalid. The authorities have tried to dispossess the petitioners on the strength of these notifications. The petitioners are entitled to be restored to possession, in case the authorities have already dispossessed the petitioners. Since the petition partly succeeds, the parties may be directed to bear their own costs.

14. The petition is partly allowed. The opposite-parties are directed not to give effect to the two notifications, dated 2-3-59 and 16-4-59 issued under Sections 4, 6 and 17 of the Act with respect to the area of 113.78 acres (Annexures A & B to the petition). The opposite-parties are directed to restore the petitioners Nos. 1 to 53 to possession over this area of 113.78 acres, in case the petitioners have been dispossessed by this time. The petition is dismissed as regards the other area of 2 acres. Parties shall bear their own costs.

LE/K.S.B

15. Petition partly allowed.