- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jaswant Sugar Mills ... v. Sub-Divisional Magis...
Judgment Summary — Jaswant Sugar Mills Ltd. v. Authority under the Minimum Wages Act
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner is Messrs Jaswant Sugar Mills Ltd., Meerut. Several employees of the petitioner filed applications under the Minimum Wages Act claiming (a) wages in lieu of weekly rests and (b) compensation, asserting the employer refused to allow weekly rests with wages as required by rules under the Minimum Wages Act. Ninety such applications were decided by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Meerut (acting as the Authority under the Act) by a consolidated order dated 30-12-1958, which allowed certain sums in lieu of weekly rests and Rs. 5 as compensation in each case. The petitioner challenged that Consolidated order by filing this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution. Initially there were as many as 91 respondents (many names repeated); after amendment, respondents were reduced to 20, including the Sub-Divisional Magistrate as respondent no. 1 and the successful employees before the Authority as other respondents. The writ petition seeks certiorari to quash the Authority's order dated 30-12-1958 insofar as it granted particular reliefs.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a single writ petition by one petitioner (employer) against multiple respondents (employees and the Authority) is maintainable where a single consolidated order of the Authority governs multiple employee claims.
- Whether a notification under Section 3 of the Minimum Wages Act had been issued by the State Government (i.e., whether the statutory precondition for rules and rates existed).
- Whether the Sub-Divisional Magistrate (the Authority) had jurisdiction under Section 20 of the Minimum Wages Act to entertain the employees' claims.
- Whether Rule 23 of the U.P. Minimum Wages Rules (framed under Section 30 of the Act) requires that weekly holidays be granted with wages and, if so, what relief follows where an employer (a) does not pay wages for weekly rests (employees on daily wages) or (b) does not permit weekly rests at all (employees on monthly wages).
- Whether the Authority had jurisdiction under Section 20(3)(ii) to direct payment of additional remuneration (wages) to employees who worked throughout a month without a weekly holiday, or whether only compensation could be awarded for breach of Rule 23 where no statutory provision made additional remuneration due.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (Messrs Jaswant Sugar Mills Ltd.)
- Main contention: There is no rule under the Minimum Wages Act providing for weekly rests with payment; consequently the impugned order was made without jurisdiction.
- Contention that no notification under Section 3 of the Minimum Wages Act had been issued (challenged by the Court as incorrect).
- Contention that the learned Magistrate (Authority) had no jurisdiction to entertain claims under Section 20 of the Act (also rejected by the Court based on a government notification authorizing the Authority).
Employees' Arguments (represented by Mr. S.N. Misra)
- Preliminary objection: A single writ petition against a number of employees is not maintainable; a single writ petition cannot challenge decisions in numerous separate cases (argued by reference to authority).
- Relied upon precedent (Umashankar Roy) for the proposition that joint writs are maintainable only when rights of claimants are joint and inseparable.
- Relied on Section 20(3) of the Act (particularly clause (ii)) to support claims by those who alleged they worked through the month without weekly rest (i.e., seeking relief under sec. 20(3)(ii)).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Umashankar Roy v. Divisional Superintendent, Northern Railway, Lucknow, 1959 A.W.R. 664 | Held that a writ petition can be filed only by one person unless the rights of different claimants were joint and inseparable; a single writ petition by multiple persons was not maintainable in that case. | The Court distinguished this authority: in Umashankar Roy multiple petitioners challenged an order, whereas here there is a single petitioner challenging a consolidated Authority order that governs many respondents. The Court overruled the preliminary objection and held the single writ petition by the employer was maintainable. |
| Port of Bombay v. Authority under the Payment of Wages Act (Bombay High Court decision) | Concerned interpretation of Rule 23 (or related rules) and whether Rule 23 recognized a claim for wages for Sundays; the Bombay High Court held that Rule 23 did not recognize such a claim in that factual context. | Both parties relied on this decision; the Court considered its reasoning but reached its own interpretation of Rule 23, concluding Rule 23 lays down that every employee shall have a weekly holiday with wages (i.e., the Court interpreted Rule 23 as entitling employees to wages for weekly holidays). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded through the following analytical steps, applying statutory provisions and the Rules to the facts presented:
- Maintainability: The Court examined the preliminary objection (that a single writ petition was not maintainable where multiple employee claims were involved). It distinguished the cited authority (Umashankar Roy) on the ground that in that case multiple petitioners sought the writ, whereas here there is a single petitioner challenging one consolidated order of the Authority that governs several cases. Because the challenged decision (30-12-1958) is the same for all connected cases and the points of law are common, the Court held it was convenient and proper to entertain a single writ petition and overruled the preliminary objection.
- Statutory preconditions and jurisdiction:
- The petitioner's contention that no notification under Section 3 of the Minimum Wages Act had been issued was rejected: the State Government had issued a notification under Section 3 on 20-10-1954 prescribing minimum rates and wages (published in the Annual Review of Activities, Department of Labour, U.P., 1954).
- The contention that the Sub-Divisional Magistrate lacked jurisdiction under Section 20 was rejected because the learned Magistrate pointed out he had authority under Government Notification No. 9060 dated 27-11-1957 to entertain such claims; consequently the Authority had jurisdiction.
- Interpretation of Section 13 and Rule 23:
- The Court analyzed Section 13 of the Minimum Wages Act (which allows the appropriate Government to fix working hours, provide for a day of rest in every period of seven days and for payment in respect of such days, and provide for payment for work on a day of rest) and Section 30(2)(f) (which contemplates a rule providing for days of rest and payment).
- Rule 23 of the U.P. Minimum Wages Rules (framed under Section 30) was scrutinized: the Rule provides for weekly holidays generally (the "first day of the week" but allows substitution and guards against more than ten consecutive working days). The Rule also provides that for such holidays an employee shall receive payment equal to his average daily wages during the preceding week.
- The Court concluded that Rule 23 should be seen as covering matters contemplated by Section 13(b) (day of rest and payment) and interpreted Rule 23 as laying down that every employee shall have a weekly holiday with wages.
- Classification of employees and their entitlements:
- The respondents (employees) were classified into two lists by the petitioner: List A — nine employees on daily wages; List B — ten employees on monthly wages.
- Facts agreed: Daily-wage employees (List A) were allowed weekly rest but were not paid wages for those weekly rests. Monthly-wage employees (List B) were not allowed weekly rest at all.
- Application of Section 20 (as amended by Act XXX of 1957) to claims:
- The Court noted that Section 20 (as amended) expanded the Authority's jurisdiction to hear claims "in respect of the payment of remuneration for days of rest or for work done on such days under cl. (b) or cl. (c) of sub-Section (1) of Section 13" and empowered the Authority under Section 20(3) to direct (i) payment in cases of payment below minimum rates with compensation, and (ii) in "any other case" the payment of the amount due to the employee together with compensation (not exceeding ten rupees).
- The Court reasoned that in order for the Authority to direct payment of an amount due under the first part of clause (ii) of Section 20(3), the employee must show that a specific amount is due under the Act or Rules. For the nine daily-wage employees (List A), Rule 23 expressly entitled them to payment for weekly rests (their weekly holidays were allowed but unpaid), so the amount due was identifiable and the Authority acted properly in awarding wages for those rests.
- For the ten monthly-wage employees (List B), however, Rule 23 did not provide for payment of additional remuneration simply because an employee worked throughout the month without a weekly rest. The Act and Rules did not create a specific entitlement to extra wages in such circumstances; therefore, the Authority had no jurisdiction to award wages or additional remuneration under the first part of clause (ii) of Section 20(3). Nonetheless, because the ten employees established a breach of Rule 23 (the employer failed to provide weekly holidays), the Authority was empowered to award compensation under the second part of clause (ii) of Section 20(3).
- Remedy and costs:
- Given the mixed outcome (some claims correctly allowed; others not), the Court concluded the petition should be partly allowed and that parties should bear their own costs in this Court.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The petition was partly allowed.
Direct consequences and specific directions issued by the Court (as set out in the opinion):
- The order of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Meerut dated 30-12-1958 is upheld insofar as it is in favour of the nine respondents enumerated in Annexure A to the affidavit dated 11-3-1960 (the daily-wage employees). Those respondents were properly awarded wages in lieu of weekly rests under Rule 23.
- The order is also upheld insofar as it granted court fee charges, counsel's fee, witnesses' expenses and compensation to the ten respondents enumerated in Annexure B to the affidavit dated 11-3-1960 (the monthly-wage employees).
- The order dated 30-12-1958 is quashed insofar as it granted amounts in lieu of weekly rests (i.e., wages/additional remuneration) to the ten respondents enumerated in Annexure B — because Rule 23 and the Act did not provide for such additional remuneration and the Authority lacked jurisdiction to award it under the first part of Section 20(3)(ii).
- Parties are directed to bear their own costs in this Court.
Implications: The decision clarifies that Rule 23 of the U.P. Minimum Wages Rules provides an entitlement to weekly holidays with wages where the rule expressly so provides (as in the case of employees whose weekly rest was allowed but unpaid), and that the Authority under Section 20(3) may award compensation for breach of such rules even where the Rules do not create a specific right to additional remuneration. The Court did not purport to lay down a broader precedent beyond these statutory and rules-based interpretations; its relief was tailored to the direct effects on the parties involved.
Disposition: Petition partly allowed.
Oak, J.:— This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution is directed against a decision of an Authority under the Minimum Wages Act. Messrs, Jaswant Sugar Mills Ltd., Meerut are the petitioner here.
2. The writ petition has arisen under the following circumstances. Several employees of the petitioner filed applications under the Minimum Wages Act. Their case was that, the employer was bound to provide weekly rests to the employees with wages in accordance with Rules made under the Minimum Wages Act. In spite of repeated demands by the employees, the employer refused to allow weekly rests. The employees, therefore, made claims for payments in lieu of weekly rests, and for compensation. There were in all 90 such applications for payment in lieu of weekly rests and compensation. All these claims were opposed by the employer on a variety of grounds. All the pleas raised in defence by the employer were overruled by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Meerut acting as the Authority under the Minimum Wages Act. He passed a consolidated order on 30-12-1958 allowing the various employees certain sums in lieu of weekly rests and Rs. 5/- as compensation in each case. The present petition by Messrs, Jaswant Sugar Mills Limited, Meerut is directed against the order dated 30-12-1958.
3. Initially, there were as many as 91 respondents in the writ petition. Several names were repeated. By a subsequent amendment, the number of the respondents has now been reduced to 20. Respondent no. 1 is the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Meerut sitting as the Authority under the respondents are the employees who succeeded before the Authority under the Minimum Wages Act.
4. Mr. S.N Misra appearing for the employees raised a preliminary objection that, a single writ petition against a number of employees is not maintainable. He further pointed out that, there were as many as 90 cases before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate. It was, therefore, urged by Mr. Misra that, a single writ petition challenging the decision in 90 cases is not maintainable.
5. Reliance was placed upon a decision by a Division Bench of this Court reported in Umashankar Roy v. Divisional Superintendent, Northern Railway, Lucknow 1959 A.W.R 664. It was held in that case that, a writ petition can be filed only by one, unless the rights of different claimants were joint and inseparable. In case of a common right it is not open to the persons who are affected by a common order to file a joint writ petition. In that case four person filed a joint writ petition on a common ground. It was held by the learned Judges that, a single writ petition by the four persons was not maintainable.
6. In Umashankar Roy's case there was a single writ petition by four persons. In the present case Messrs, Jaswant Sugar Mills Limited are the sole petitioner. It is true that there are several respondents in the case. But there is only one petitioner. So the circumstances of the present case are the reverse of those, which obtained in Umashankar Roy's case. No authority was brought to my notice to the effect that, one person cannot file one writ petition against a number of persons on a common ground.
7. This writ petition is directed against the order dated 30-12-1958 passed by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate Meerut. The same order is to govern all the cases before the authority. If this decision dated 30-12-1958 is quashed, such an order will automatically govern all the connected cases. This is a petition for a writ in the nature of certiorari. It is directed against a certain decision by a Tribunal. I do not see any difficulty in entertaining this petition, although the decision under consideration governs several cases. The points of law involved in all these cases are the same. It will, therefore, be convenient to dispose of all these cases by a single writ petition. I overrule the preliminary objection, and hold that a single writ petition is maintainable.
8. It was urged for the petitioner that, no notification under Sec. 3 of the Minimum Wages Act has yet been issued. This contention is not correct. The State Government issued a notification under Sec. 3 of the Minimum Wages Act on 20-10-1954 prescribing the minimum rates and wages. The notification is published on page 432 of the Annual Review of Activities, Department of Labour, U.P 1954.
9. Another contention on behalf of the petitioner was that the learned Magistrate had no jurisdiction to entertain claim under Sec. 20 of the Minimum Wages Act. This contention is also not correct. The learned Magistrate has pointed out that he had authority under Government Notification No. 9060, dated 27-11-1957 to entertain such claims. The learned Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Meerut had, therefore jurisdiction to entertain the claims by the employees.
10. The main contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner was that there is no rule under the Minimum Wages Act, No. XI of 1948 providing for weekly rests with payment. The impugned order was, therefore, without jurisdiction. In order to appreciate the contention of the parties with reference to this ground, it is necessary to examine the general scheme of the Minimum Wages Act.
11. Minimum Wages Act, 1948 is a Central Act. Sec. 3 of the Act provides for the fixing of minimum rates of wages. Sec. 13 provides for fixing hours for a normal working day etc. Sec. 13 runs thus:—
“In regard to any scheduled employment, minimum rates of wages in respect of which have been fixed under this Act, the appropriate Government may—
(a) fix the number of hours of work which shall constitute a normal working day, inclusive of one or more specified intervals;
(b) Provide for a day of rest in every period of seven days which shall be allowed to all employees or to any specified class of employees and for the payment of remuneration in respect of such days of rest;
(c) provide for payment for work on a day of rest at a rate, not less than the overtime rate.”
12. Sec. 20 deals with claims. Sec. 22 provides for penalties and procedure. Sec. 30 of the Act confers powers on the appropriate Government to make rules. Cl. (f) of sub-Sec. (2) of Sec. 30 contemplates a provision for a day of rest in every period of seven days and for the payment of remuneration in respect of such day.
13. In exercise of the powers conferred by Sec. 30 of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948, the State Government has framed Rules. These are U.P Minimum Wages Rules, 1952. Rule 23 of the U.P Minimum Wages Rules is important. It deals with weekly holidays. Rule 23 runs thus:—
(23) Unless otherwise permitted by the State Government no employee shall be required or allowed to work in a scheduled employment, on the first day of the week (hereinafter referred to as the said day) except when he has had or will have a holiday for the whole day on one of the five days immediately before or after the said day for which he shall receive payment equal to his average daily wages during the preceding week:
Provided that the weakly holiday may be substituted by another day:
Provided further that no substitution shall be made, which will result in any employee working for more than ten days consecutively without a holiday for a whole day.
(2) Where in accordance with the provision of sub-rule (1), any employee works on the said day and has had a holiday on one of the five days immediately preceding it, the said day shall, for the purposes of calculating his weekly hours of work, be included in the preceding week.
Explanation—For the purposes of this rule, “week shall mean a period of seven days beginning at midnight on Saturday night.”
14. It is common ground that, the petitioner did not allow the 19 respondents weekly holidays with wages. The 19 respondents may be divided into two classes. Some are employed on monthly wages. Others are employed on daily wages. The petitioner filed on 11-3-1960 two lists giving me classification of the 19 respondents. Annexure A of the affidavit dated 11-3-1960 contains a list of nine respondents employed on daily rates. Annexure B of the same affidavit contains a list of ten respondents employed on monthly basis. It will be convenient to refer to these two sets of employees as employees of list. A and employees of list B. Parties are agreed that in the case of employees who work on daily wages, weekly rest was allowed. But wages were not paid for such weekly rests. In the case of employees working on monthly basis, no weekly rest was allowed? The question is whether on these facts the Tribunal was wrong in allowing the 19 employees wages in lieu of weekly rests and compensation.
15. We have seen that Sec. 13 of the Minimum Wages Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act) provides for fixing hours for a normal working day etc. Sec. 13 contemplates directions to be issued by the appropriate Government on various matters. Cl. (a) of Sec. 13 deals with the number of hours of work in a normal working day. We are not concerned with Cl. (a) in the present case. Cl. (b) of Sec. 13 deals with a day or rest and for the payment of remuneration in respect of days of rest. Cl. (c) deals with payment for work on a day of rest.
16. Under Rule 23 of Minimum Wages Rules, the State Government has made provision for weekly holidays. Although the rules have been framed under Sec. 30 of the Act, there is no difficulty in looking upon Rule 23 as a direction by the State Government as contemplated by Sec. 13 of the Act. Parties are not agreed about the interpretation of Rule 23 of Minimum Wages Rules. Both the parties relied upon a decision of Bombay High Court reported in “Port of Bombay v. Authority under the Payment of Wages Act.”2 In that case certain employees of the Port of Bombay approached the Authority under the Payment of Wayes Act for wages for Sundays. The Authority allowed the claim by the employees. The port of Bombay took up the matter before the Bombay High Court by two civil applications. Those applications were allowed; and the order passed by the Authority was set aside. It was held that, Rule 23 of the Minimum Wages Rules did not recognize such a claim for wages for Sundays. Rule 28 mentioned payment for a certain day. The question arises whether the payment was to be for Sunday or for some other day. On this point it was observed on page 629 thus:—
“For which, must, in our opinion, refer to the holiday mentioned in the earlier clause.”
17. The first sentence of Rule 23 of the Minimum Wages Rules is rather involved. But the general plan of Rule 23 seems to be dear. Rule 23 lays down that, every employee should get a weekly holiday. Normally the weekly holiday would be on Sundays. But in special cases the weekly holidays may be on a day other than Sunday. Rule 23 makes provision for payment with respect to a holiday. The principle is that although an employee does not actually work on a holiday, he should still receive wages for that day. For applying that principle, it should make no difference whether the actual holiday happens to be Sunday or some other day of the week. The employee should get wages whether his holiday happens to be Sunday or some other day of the week. In my opinion, Rule 23 lays down that, every employee shall have a weekly, holiday with wages.
18. The petitioner conceded that, he did not grant the 19 respondents weekly holidays with wages. Rule 23 was contravened by the petitioner in the case of all the 19 respondents. But the nature of the contravention differed in the two classes of the employees. In the case of the nine employees of list A, the default lay in non payment of wages for the weekly holidays. In the case of the 10 respondents of list B, the default lay in not allowing weekly holidays at all.
19. On comparing Sec. 13 of the Act with Rule 23, we find that certain matters contemplated by Sec. 13 have been covered by Rule 23. Cl. (b) of Sec. 13 contemplates a day of weekly rest and remuneration in respect of such days of rest. This matter has been covered by Rule 23. Ci. (c) of Sec 13 contemplates payment for work on a day of rest: This matter is not covered by Rule 23. Rule 23 does not lay down the procedure, if an employer declines to grant a weekly holiday to his employees. Under Rule 23, the nine employees of list A were entitled to receive payments for the days of rest. But Rule 23 does not provide for additional remuneration for work done by the ten employees of list B throughout the month. It may be that, the employer was liable to a penalty under Sec. 22 of the Act for hot granting the ten employees of list B a weekly holiday as required by Rule 23. But there is no provision in Rule 23 for additional remuneration claimed by these ten employees of list B.
20. The claims by the employees were made under Sec. 20 of the Act. Originally, Sec. 20 of the Act merely provided for claims arising out of payment of less than minimum rates of wages. In the present case there is no grievance about payment of less than the minimum rates of wages. So the claims in question might not have been maintainable under Sec. 20, as it originally stood. But Sec. 20 of the Act has been amended by Act XXX of 1957. By this amendment, the scope of Sec. 20 of the Act has been widened. Sec. 20 of the Act now runs thus:—
“20. (1) The appropriate Government may, by notification in the official Gazette, appoint any Commissioner for workmens compensation or any officer of the Central Government exercising functions as a labour Commissioner for any region, or any officer of the State Government not below the rank of labour commissioner or any other officer with experience as a Judge of a Civil Court or as a stipendiary Magistrate to be the Authority to hear and decide for any specified area all claims arising out of payment of less than the minimum rates of wages or in respect of the payment of remuneration for days of rest or for work done on such days under Cl. (b) or cl. (c) of sub-Sec. (1) of Sec. 13 or of wages at the overtime rate under Sec. 14, to employees employed or paid in that area.
“(2) Where an employee has any claim of the nature referred to in sub-Sec. (1), the employee himself, or any legal practitioner or any official of a registered trade union authorized in writing to act on his behalf, or any Inspector, or any person acting with the permission of the Authority appointed under sub-Sec. (1), may apply to such Authority for a direction under sub-Sec. (3).
Provided that every such application shall be presented within six months from the date on which the minimum wages or other amount became payable:
Provided further that any application may be admitted after the said period of sift months when the applicant satisfies the Authority that he had sufficient cause for not making the application within such, period.
(3). When any application under sub-Sec. (2) is entertained, the Authority shall hear the applicant and the employer, or give them an opportunity of being heard, and after such further inquiry, if any, as it may consider necessary, may, without prejudice to any other penalty to which the employer may be liable under, this Act, direct—
(i) in the case of a claim arising out of payment of less than the minimum rates of wages, the payment to the employees of the amount by which the minimum wages payable to him exceed the amount actually paid, together with the payment, of such compensation as the Authority may think fit, not exceeding ten times the amount of such excess;
(ii) in any other case, the payment of the amount due to the employee, together with the payment of such compensation as the authority may think fit, not exceeding ten rupees,
and the Authority may direct payment of such compensation in cases where the excess or the amount due is paid by the employer to the employee before the disposal of the application.
(4) If, the Authority hearing any application under this section is satisfied that it was either malicious or vexatious, it may direct that a penalty not exceeding fifty rupees be paid to the employer by the person presenting the application.
(5) Any amount directed to be paid under this section may be recovered—
(a) if the Authority is a Magistrate, by the Authority as if, it were a fine imposed by the Authority as a Magistrate, or
(b) if the Authority is not a Magistrate, by any Magistrate to whom the Authority makes application in this behalf, as if it were a fine imposed by such Magistrate.
(6) Every direction of the Authority under this section shall be final.
(7) Every Authority appointed under sub-Sec (1) shall have all the powers of a Civil Court under the Code of Civil Procedure, (V of 1908), for the purpose of taking evidence and of enforcing the attendance of witnesses and compelling the production of documents, and every such, Authority shall be deemed to be a Civil Court for all the purposes of Sec 195 and Chap. XXXV of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (V of 1898).”
21. It will be seen that, in the present form, Sec. 20 covers claims under cl. (b) and (c) of Sec. 13 of the Act. But Sec. 13 of the Act merely enables the appropriate Government to issue certain directions. In the absence of the necessary directions, Sec. 13 by itself does not create any liability against an employer. The liability can arise only under Rule 23 of Minimum Wages Rules. We have seen that under Rule 23, the employer was liable to pay the employees remuneration for days of rest. But under Rule 23 the employer was under no obligation to pay employees additional remuneration for work done through out a month.
22. Mr. S.N Misra relied upon sub-Sec. (3) of Sec. 20 of the Act to support the demand made by the ten employees of list B. The material part of sub-Sec. (3) of Sec. 20 of the Act runs thus:—
“……. foe Authority ……. may direct—
(i)………………………….
(ii) in any other case, the payment of the amount due to the employee, together with the payment of such compensation as the Authority may think fit, not exceeding ten rupees………….”
23. Cl. (ii) of sub-Sec. (3) of Sec. 20 contemplates directions of two kinds. The first direction may be for the payment of amount due to the employee. The second direction is for payment of compensation. Before a direction can be made by the Authority under the first part of cl. (ii) of sub-Sec. (3) of Sec. 20, an employee has to establish that a certain amount is due to him. In the present case the ten employees of list B are claiming extra remuneration on the ground that they worked throughout the month without a break. We have seen that, the Act and the Rules do not contain any provision for such additional remuneration. In the absence of any such provision in the Act and the Rules, it cannot be said that such extra remuneration is due to the employee. The Authority had therefore, no jurisdiction to grant relief to the ten employees of list B under the first part of Cl. (ii) of sub-Sec. (3) of Sec 20 of the Act. We have seen that, although there is no provision for extra remuneration, these ten employees have succeeded in establishing a breach of Rule 23. The breach having been established, they would be entitled to receive compensation under the second part of Cl. (ii) of sub-Sec. (3) of Sec. 20 of the Act.
24. The position, therefore, is that, the nine employees of list A were entitled to receive payment for the weekly rests under Rule 23. In the case of these nine employees, the impugned order is proper. But in the case of the ten employees of list B, the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to grant wages or additional remuneration.
25. It was open to the Authority to direct payment of compensation on the ground of breach of Rule 23. Since the petition partly succeeds and partly fails, parties may be directed to bear their own costs.
26. The petition is partly allowed. The order of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Meerut, dated 30-12-1958 will stand, so far as it is in favour of the nine respondents enumerated in Annexure A to the affidavit dated 11-3-1960. The order will also stand in so far as court fee charges counsel's fee, witnesses expenses and compensation were granted to the ten respondents enumerated in Annexure B to the affidavit dated 11-3-60. But the order dated 30-12-1958 is quashed only in so far as amounts in lieu of weekly rests were granted by the Authority to the ten respondents enumerated in Annexure B to the affidavit, dated 11-3-1960. Parties shall bear their own costs in this Court.
27. Petition partly allowed.
Alert