- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Saghir Ahmad v. State
Factual and Procedural Background
Saghir Ahmad, born in Gorakhpur district in January 1937, was sent to Pakistan as a minor during the communal riots of 1947 without his parents' consent. He returned to India in 1955 on a Pakistan passport and a short-term visa but overstayed and was deported in 1956. Subsequently, he re-entered India without a passport or permit and was found residing in Gorakhpur in 1957. He was convicted by a first class Magistrate under Section 14 of the Foreigners Act read with Section 7 of the Foreigners Order and sentenced to six months' simple imprisonment. The conviction and sentence were confirmed on appeal by the Temporary Civil and Session Judge of Gorakhpur. During the trial, the Magistrate referred the question of the applicant’s nationality to the Central Government, which declared that Saghir Ahmad had voluntarily acquired Pakistani citizenship.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Saghir Ahmad, by obtaining a Pakistan passport as a minor, had validly renounced or forfeited his Indian citizenship.
- Whether the provisions of Schedule III of the Citizenship Rules, which treat the acquisition of a foreign passport as conclusive proof of foreign citizenship, are constitutionally valid.
- Whether the applicant was correctly convicted under the Foreigners Act given the above considerations.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sharafat Ali Khan v. State of U.P. | Minor cannot change nationality without guardian's consent. | Applied to hold that the applicant’s Pakistan passport obtained as a minor was invalid for renouncing Indian citizenship. |
| Mohammad Khan v. Government of Andhra Pradesh, A.I.R 1957 A.P 1047 | Unreasonable restriction on fundamental rights by irrebuttable presumption of foreign citizenship based on passport possession. | Supported the court’s view that Schedule III of the Citizenship Rules is unconstitutional as it deprives a person of rights without due enquiry. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by recognizing that the applicant was an Indian citizen by birth and that the prosecution bore the burden of proving renunciation or forfeiture of citizenship. It emphasized that the applicant was a minor when he obtained the Pakistan passport and that minors cannot change nationality without guardian consent, which was absent. The court noted that deportation does not terminate citizenship and that statutory methods for termination under the Citizenship Act (Sections 8, 9, and 10) were not properly followed.
The court critically examined Schedule III of the Citizenship Rules, which presumes conclusive proof of foreign citizenship from possession of a foreign passport or permit. It held that such irrebuttable presumptions violate Article 19 fundamental rights by arbitrarily depriving individuals of Indian citizenship without proper enquiry, thus breaching Article 13(2) of the Constitution. The court distinguished between prima facie evidence and conclusive proof, rejecting the latter as unconstitutional in this context.
Relying on precedent, the court found that the Central Government’s determination of the applicant’s citizenship, based on the contested rules of evidence, was void and must be disregarded. Consequently, the applicant was not a foreigner and could not be convicted under the Foreigners Act.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED the conviction and sentence of Saghir Ahmad under the Foreigners Act.
The court set aside the conviction and allowed the criminal revision application, holding that the applicant remained an Indian citizen and had not committed an offence under the Foreigners Act. The decision directly affects the applicant by restoring his rights and invalidating the Central Government’s prior determination of foreign citizenship based on unconstitutional evidentiary rules. No new precedent beyond the case facts was established regarding citizenship law or constitutional interpretation.
Broome, J.:— Saghir Ahmad, the applicant in this criminal revision, has been convicted by a first class Magistrate of Gorakhpur for an offence under Sec. 14 of the Foreigners Act read with Sec. 7 of the Foreigners Order and has been sentenced to six months' simple imprisonment. His conviction and sentence were confirmed in appeal by the Temporary Civil and Session Judge of Gorakhpur.
2. The facts of the case are as follows. Saghir Ahmad was born in Gorakhpur district in January 1937, but at the time of the communal riots that followed partition in 1947 he was attending school in Delhi and was sent to a refugee camp and from there to Pakistan, without his parents, who remained behind in India, being consulted in the matter. Eventually he got in touch with his parents and came back to India on 15-2-1955 on the basis of a passport issued on 3-11-1954 and a visa in category B valid for two months. He remained on in this country after the period noted in his visa had expired and was deported to Pakistan on 1-12-1956. Thereafter he came back to India without obtaining any passport or visa, and on 10-11-1957 was found living in a village in Gorakhpur district without any permit for his stay there.
3. The applicant was clearly an Indian citizen by reason of his birth and the burden lay on the prosecution to prove that he had in some way renounced or forfeited his Indian citizenship, before he could be convicted for an offence under the Foreigners Act. When he was sent to Pakistan in the first place, he was only 10 years of age and even when he obtained the Pakistan passport on 3-11-1954, he was still a minor. As pointed out by me in Sharafat Ali Khan v. State of U.P, 1 a minor cannot change his nationality without action being taken or consent being given by his guardian; and in the present case there is nothing whatsoever to suggest that the applicant's father, who went on living in Gorakhpur, ever wished him to renounce Indian Nationality or to be come a Pakistan national. The declaration which he presumably must have made for the purpose of obtaining the Pakistan passport therefore was absolutely invalid and ineffectual and can have no value in the eye of the law, since it was made at a time when he was still a minor and legally incapable of changing his nationality of his own accord. It is clear therefore that when the applicant re-entered India on the first occasion on 15-2-1955 he had not validly renounced his Indian citizenship and must be deemed to have still been an Indian national on that date. Thereafter in 1956 he was deported to Pakistan against his will; but this action on the part of the authorities could not possibly have had the effect of depriving him of his citizenship. The methods by which Indian citizenship can be terminated are set forth in Secs. 8, 9 and 10 of the Citizenship Act, namely renunciation, deprivation and termination by voluntary acquisition of the citizenship of another country. In the present case there is no suggestion that the applicant ever renounced his citizenship or was deprived of it in accordance with the procedure referred to in Secs. 8 and 10 of the Act; and as regards his alleged requisition of Pakistan nationality (which according to Sec. 9 would have the effect of terminating his citizenship), I have already pointed out that the declaration which he made in the year 1954 in order to obtain a Pakistan passport could not have any legal effect, in view of the fact that he was a minor at the time. It follows therefore that the applicant was still an Indian citizen and not a foreigner when he returned to India for the second time in the year 1957; and whatever offence he may then have committed under the Passport Act by entering this country without any passport or permit, he certainly cannot be said to have committed any offence under the Foreigners Act.
4. It would therefore seem that the prosecution of the applicant under Sec. 14 of the Foreigners Act was entirely misconceived. The legal position however is complicated by the fact that during the pendency of the proceedings the learned Magistrate who was trying this case referred the question of the applicant's nationality to the Central Government, which by its order dated 20-8-1959 held that Saghir Ahmad had voluntarily acquired the citizenship of Pakistan. The reference was made in accordance with Sec. 9(2) of the Citizenship Act read with R. 30 of the Citizenship Rules, whereby the Central Government has been declared to be the authority empowered to determine the question of ‘whether, when or how any person has acquired the citizenship of another country’; and it is obvious that the decision was arrived at on the basis of the rules of evidence incorporated in Sch. III of the Citizenship Rules. Cl. 3 of the Sch. III runs as follows:
“The fact that a citizen of India has obtained on any date a passport from the Government of any other country shall be conclusive proof of his having voluntarily acquired the citizenship of that country before that date.”
5. And Cl. 5 of the same Schedule contains the following provisions:
“a citizen of India shall be deemed to have voluntarily acquired the citizenship of Pakistan:—
(b) if he has obtained any certificate of domicile in Pakistan or declared himself to be a citizen of Pakistan or of Pakistan domicile; or
(d) if he has obtained a temporary permit for entry into India from Pakistan.”
6. Under these clauses, the mere obtaining of a Pakistan passport or of a temporary permit for entry into India from Pakistan is taken as conclusive proof of the acquisition of Pakistan citizenship; and such acquisition by virtue of Sec. 9(1) of the Citizenship Act involves automatic termination of Indian Citizenship. The question is, can an Indian citizen be deprived of his fundamental rights (including the right of residing and settling in any part of India, guaranteed by Art. 19 of the Constitution) in this arbitrary and wholly unreasonable fashion? I cannot countenance such a position and in my opinion Cl. 3 and Cls. 5(b) and (d) of Schedule III of the Citizenship Rules, which in many cases would result in summarily depriving an Indian citizen of his citizenship by bringing Sec. 9(1) of the Citizenship Act into play without his ever in actual fact voluntarily acquired any foreign nationality, must be considered null and void by virtue of Art. 13(2) of the Constitution.
7. The view taken by me finds support in Mohammad Khan v. Government of Andhra Prasad . A.I.R 1957 A.P 1047. in which it was remarked:
“The rule, by the device adopted, completely bars the appellants from establishing that they have not acquired the citizenship of Pakistan. The irrebuttable presumption from the fact, which is not legal evidence of the fact of citizenship, much less of the fact of citizenship obtained otherwise than by voluntary acquisition, has certainly the effect of depriving the appellants' right without the enquiry guaranteed by the section, and therefore, amounts to an unreasonable restriction on the fundamental rights of the appellants under Art. 19 of the Constitution of India.”
8. No ruling has been cited before me in which any contrary, opinion has been expressed regarding the constitutional validity of the aforesaid Sch. III of the Citizenship Rules.
9. I should not be understood as laying down the proposition that in no case the obtaining of a foreign passport can prove the acquisition of foreign nationality. There may be cases in which the obtaining of a foreign passport may provide prima facie evidence (rebuttable of course) that the person in question has voluntarily acquired the citizenship of another country; but that is a very different matter from treating the passport as conclusive irrebuttable proof, precluding the person in question from leading any evidence or relying on any circumstances that might go to show that in actual fact he never voluntarily acquired foreign citizenship.
10. In the present case the application of the arbitrary rule of evidence introduced by Cls. 3 and 5 of Sch. III would lead to the iniquitous result of depriving the applicant Saghir Ahmad of his rights as an Indian citizen merely because, while still a minor and legally incapable of changing his nationality, he made a false declaration of Pakistan nationality and thereby obtained Pakistan passport. This would clearly amount to an unreasonable restriction and abridgment of the applicant's fundamental rights and the clauses in question must be struck down, in view of Art. 13(2) of the Constitution. My conclusion therefore is that the decision given by the Central Government on 20-8-1959 regarding Saghir Ahmad's voluntary acquisition of Pakistan citizenship, being based on the rules of evidence incorporated in the offending clauses of Sch. III of the Citizenship Rules, is void and inoperative and must be altogether ignored.
11. The applicant was never a foreigner and cannot have committed any offence under the Foreigners Act. This application is accordingly allowed, the conviction and sentence of the applicant being set aside.
Application allowed
Alert