Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

The State Complainant- v. Rasool And Others Accused-

Allahabad High Court
Mar 24, 1955
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Mulla, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

Mohammad Urooj, owner and manager of a tannery on Kundan Road (between Unnao and Kanpur), purchased a large number of goat hides known as "Patna Tayari" hides from Gul Mohammad and Brothers of Kanpur. About eight or nine days after arrival, between the night of 13 and 14 December 1951, 389 hides were stolen from the tannery. Mohammad Urooj filed a theft report on 15-12-1951 which did not name any suspects.

The police registered a case under Section 380, Indian Penal Code (IPC). Sub-Inspector Shaukat Husain initially investigated but, before a final report was accepted, the investigation was taken over by Station Officer Salik Ram. On 8-1-1952, at about 10 P.M., Station Officer Salik Ram recovered 388 hides from shop No. 97/9 on Kayasthana Road, Kanpur, belonging to Abdul Rahman; present in the shop were Abdul Rahman, Rasul, Ah Husain, Phuddi and Abdul Razzaq. Two others initially fled but were later recognised as Ghafoor and Salar and arrested. All seven persons were prosecuted under Section 380, IPC.

At the Magistrate's court the charge was altered from Section 380 to Section 411, IPC. Before decision, the trial court again varied its view and held that Section 411 applied only to Abdul Rahman while the others fell under Section 414, IPC. The trial court convicted Abdul Rahman under Section 411 and convicted Rasul, Abdul Razzaq and Phuddi under Section 414; the remaining three accused were acquitted. The trial court stated it acted under Sections 236 and 237 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC).

All convicted persons appealed. The Sessions Judge of Unnao dismissed Abdul Rahman's appeal but allowed the appeals of Abdul Razzaq, Phuddi and Rasul. The State appealed against Rasul, Phuddi and Abdul Razzaq. Before the High Court, the principal contention advanced for the State concerned Rasul: that the recorded evidence established an offence under Section 414, IPC, and the trial court was justified in convicting him under Sections 236 and 237, CrPC. The appeals against Razzaq and Phuddi were not pressed by the State.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction of Rasul under Section 414, IPC could be sustained though he had been charged only under Section 411, IPC, by invoking Sections 236 and 237 of the CrPC.
  2. Whether Sections 236 and 237 of the CrPC may be applied where a different set of facts must be alleged against an accused to sustain conviction under a different offence, and whether the accused was prejudiced by being convicted of an offence for which he was not charged.
  3. Whether the charge as framed satisfied the requirements of Section 222 of the CrPC (i.e., whether the accused was given sufficient particulars to know and meet the case against him).

Arguments of the Parties

State's Arguments

  • The principal submission for the State was that the evidence on record clearly established an offence under Section 414, IPC against Rasul, and that the trial court was justified in convicting him under Sections 236 and 237, CrPC despite the charge having been framed under Section 411, IPC.
  • The State's counsel also contended that a charge need not contain elaborate details of the facts constituting an offence and that those particulars were not necessary in the circumstances of this case.
  • The State did not press the appeals against Razzaq and Phuddi; this omission was recorded and conceded by the State's counsel that the evidence against them did not constitute an offence.

Defence's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the defence's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Makkhan v. Emperor, AIR 1945 All 81 (A) Framing of a charge must enable the defence to focus on the case to be met; a vague charge that fails to bring out necessary ingredients of the offence is defective. The court endorsed this principle, holding that the charge in the present case was defective because it did not disclose the ingredients of the offence for which Rasul was ultimately convicted.
Bejoy Chand v. State of West Bengal, AIR 1952 SC 105 Recognised that, in some circumstances, an accused charged under one section (e.g., S.307 IPC) can be convicted under another (e.g., S.326 IPC) under Sections 236/237 CrPC. The court stated that this authority was not applicable to the facts of the present case because the crucial question was whether the accused had been given a proper opportunity to defend himself when different facts were required to support the alternate conviction.
Ram Prasad v. State, AIR 1952 All 878 Omission to charge an accused with an offence (unlawful assembly) did not vitiate the charge where a clear indication (S.149) was mentioned and the accused was not prejudiced. The court found this decision inapplicable here because, unlike that case, Rasul was prejudiced by the omission and thus could not be convicted under Sections 236/237 CrPC on the present record.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by first explaining the proper scope of Sections 236 and 237, CrPC. These provisions can be invoked where the facts before the court are not in dispute but there is doubt as to which specific statutory offence those same facts constitute. They are not intended to be used where a conviction would require putting forward a different set of facts than those relied upon at the time of charge.

The court identified three factual strands relied on to make out an offence under Section 414, IPC against Rasul:

  1. Noor Mohammad's testimony that Rasul, with another person, came to him with five hides and attempted to persuade him to purchase them at a reduced price;
  2. Noor Mohammad being taken to Abdul Rahman's shop by Rasul and others;

The court focused on process and fairness: Rasul was examined at trial but was not asked any question about the third link (counting and bagging the hides), even though the trial court used that circumstance to reach the conclusion that Rasul had assisted in the disposal of the stolen property. The court observed that the main question put to Rasul at trial framed the alleged offence as being one of possession (i.e., that stolen hides were recovered from his possession), corresponding to the charge under Section 411, IPC. The charge itself alleged that Rasul "dishonestly retained stolen 388 hides" and therefore did not put him on notice that he would be called upon to meet an allegation of assisting disposal under Section 414, IPC.

On the legal sufficiency of the charge, the court held that a charge must contain such particulars as to give the accused a clear idea of the case he must meet; it need not contain elaborate detail but must not leave doubt as to the allegations facing the accused. The charge in this case failed that test and therefore did not comply with the requirements of Section 222, CrPC.

The court reiterated that Sections 236 and 237 can only be applied where the accused is not prejudiced by being convicted under a different section than that charged. Where prejudice exists, conviction pursuant to Sections 236/237 cannot be maintained; instead the proper course is for the trial court to amend the charge under Section 227, CrPC and explain it to the accused so he may adequately defend himself.

Applying these principles, the court concluded that Rasul had been prejudiced because he had not been given adequate notice or opportunity to meet the allegation that he assisted in disposal, and the trial court had relied on circumstances not put to him. Consequently, the conviction under Section 414, IPC could not be upheld.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Holding (core ruling): The High Court held that the conviction of Rasul under Section 414, IPC could not be maintained because Rasul was charged only under Section 411, IPC, was not given adequate particulars or an opportunity to meet the allegation of assisting disposal (the central basis for the Section 414 conviction), and was thereby prejudiced. The court found Sections 236 and 237, CrPC inapplicable in these circumstances.

Direct implications for the parties: The court dismissed the State's appeal. The opposite-parties (the accused) were on bail; their bail bonds were cancelled and they were not required to surrender.

Broader implications: The opinion emphasizes the limits of Sections 236 and 237, CrPC—these sections cannot be used to convict where a conviction requires alleging a different set of facts than those put to the accused at the time of charge. The opinion does not purport to establish a novel legal principle beyond applying established requirements for adequate charge particulars and procedural fairness; no broader precedent beyond the cited authorities is claimed in the text.

D.S.P
Show all summary ...

Mulla, J.:— One Mohammad Urooj, a resident of Kanpur, owned and managed a tenanery on Kundan Road which was on the road between Unnao and Kanpur. He purchased a large number of goat hides from Gul Mohammad and Brothers of Kanpur. These hides were known by the name of “Patna Tayari” hides. About 8 or 9 days after these hides came to his tannery theft was committed in the tannery buildings between the night of 13 and 14-12-1951 and 389 hides were stolen. Mohammed Urooj made a report about this theft on the 15-12-1951.

2. No names were given in this report. The police registered a case under S. 380, I.P.C, but did not succeed in tracing the culprits. Sub-Inspector Shaukat Husain was in charge of the investigation. He was about to file a final report when Mohammad Urooj approached one Noor Mohammad, P.W 3, and tried to trace the stolen hides through him. Before the final report could be accepted, the investigation was taken away from Sub-Inspector Shaukat Husain by the Station Officer Sri Salik Ram, and on 8-1-1952 he recovered 388 hides from shop No. 97/9 on Kayasthana Road, Kanpur which belonged to one Abdul Rahman. This recovery took place at about 10 P.M When this recovery was made, Rasul, Abdul Rahman, Ah Husain, Phuddi and Abdul Razzaq were present in the shop of Abdul Rahman. These hides were subsequently put up for identification, and Mohammad Urooj and other employees of his tannery identified these hides as the hides which were stolen on the night between the 13 and 14-12-1951. It was urged that two other persons were also present in the shop of Abdul Rahman when these hides were recovered but they ran away before they could be arrested.

3. These two persons were, however, recognised, and they were Ghafoor and Salar, the brothers of Rasul. They were also subsequently arrested, and the police prosecuted all the seven persons under S. 380, I.P.C

4. This case was heard by a Magistrate of Unnao but when the time came for framing the charge, he thought that instead of S. 380, I.P.C, the case proved against the accused person fell under S. 411, I.P.C He, therefore, framed a charge against all the seven accused persons under S. 411, I.P.C When the case became ripe for decision, the trial court again changed its opinion and came to the conclusion that S. 411, I.P.C, applied only to the case of Abdul Rahman but the cases of the other accused persons fell under S. 414, I.P.C

5. He thereupon convicted Abdul Rahman under S. 411, I.P.C, and Rasul, Abdul Razzaq and Phuddi under S. 414, I.P.C The other three accused persons were acquitted. The Court purported to act under the provisions of Sections 236 and 237 of the Cr PC.

6. All the convicted persons went up in appeal, and the Sessions Judge of Unnao rejected the appeal of Abdul Rahman but accepted the apeals of Abdul Razzaq, Phuddi and Rasul. The appellate Court found that the facts of the case believed by the trial Court did not constitute an offence under S. 414, I.P.C, and therefore acquitted these appellants. Aggrieved by this order the State has filed the appeal against the three persons, namely Rasul, Phuddi and Razzaq.

7. The main point that was raised before us in this appeal was that the evidence on the record clearly established a case under S. 414, I.P.C, against Rasul, and the trial Court was fully justified in convicting him under that section by using the provision of Sections 236 and 237 of the Cr PC. The appeal against the other two appellants, namely Razzaq and Phuddi was not pressed, and in our opinion rightly not pressed. The evidence against these two appellants did not constitute an offence at all and this was conceded by the Counsel for the State.

8. Sections 236 and 237 of the Cr PC, are really meant to apply to that type of cases where there is no doubt about the facts alleged but there is a doubt as to the applicability of any particular law against the proved set of facts in other words they can be acted upon only where the same facts raise a doubt in the mind of a court whether they constitute one offence or some other offence.

9. They obviously do not apply to those cases where a different set of facts are to be given prominence for coming to a conclusion that a particular offence was committed. Apart from this a conviction arrived at under Section 237 of the Cr PC, can only be maintained and upheld if the Court is satisfied that no prejudice was caused to an accused person and he had a full opportunity of meeting the allegations against him.

10. In our opinion the facts of this case do not disclose that a proper discretion was exercised by the trial Court when it convicted the accused persons of an offence under S. 4.14, I.P.C, although they were charged only for an offence under S. 411, I.P.C The three links as brought out from evidence and on the basis of which a charge under S. 414, I.P.C, is made out against Rasul are the following:

(1) Noor Mohammad deposed that Rasul along with another person came to him with five hides and tried to persuade Noor Mohammad to purchase these hides at a reduced price.

(2) Noor Mohammad was taken to the shop of Abdul Rahman by Rasul and several others; and

(3) When the hides were recovered from the shop of Abdul Rahman, Rasul was counting these hides and putting them in bags.

11. From a recital of the case given above it is clear that the accused should have been given an opportunity to meet this case. Rasul was examined by the trial Court but we find that no question was put to him about his counting the hides and putting them in the bags. The decision of the trial Court, however, clearly shows that he has used this circumstance to come to the conclusion that Rasul was guilty under S. 414, I.P.C We, therefore, find that Rasul was not given an opportunity to meet the case against him. No doubt questions relating to the other two links were put to him but the main questnn put to Rasul was:

“Is it correct that on 8-1-1952 at about 10-30 P.M you and other persons took Noor Mohammad to the shop of Abdul Rahman which is on Kayasthana Road in Kanpur and out of his shop from your possession were recovered 388 hides which were all stolen, from Mohammad Urooj's Tannery?”

12. From a reading of this question it is clear that the charge against Rasul was that he was in possession of these stolen hides and not that he assisted the disposal of these stolen hides. The charge rained by the trial Court also shows the same thing, it runs as follows:

“That you on or about 8-1-1952 at about 10-30 P.M in Mohalla Kaisthana Road, police station Colonelganj, Kanpur in the shop of Abdul Rahman dishonestly retained stolen 388 hides belonging to Mohammad Urooj knowing or having reason to believe the same to be stolen property and thereby committed an offence punishable under S. 411, I.P.C”

13. It is clear from this charge also that no inkling was given to Rasul that he was going to be convicted for assisting the disposal of these hides. The Counsel for the State contested that it is not necessary to give the details of the facts constituting an offence in the charge sheet framed by a Magistrate. In our opinion this contention is not sound at least so far as the circumstances of this case are concerned.

14. A charge must contain those particulars which give the accused an idea of the case which he has to meet. It may not contain elaborate details but there should be no doubt left in the mind of an accused person as to what is the case against him and what allegations he has to meet. The charge framed in this case did not fulfil these conditions and is, therefore, not a proper charge within the meaning of Section 222 of the Cr PC.

15. It does not contain such particulars which would give notice to the accused that he has to meet the accusation of assisting the disposal of these stolen hides. In our opinion Sections 236 and 237 of the Cr PC can only be used where it can be held that the accused was not prejudiced by his conviction under a section for which he was not charged.

16. Where the accused has been prejudiced or can be prejudiced, a conviction with the help of Sections 236 and 237 of the Cr PC cannot be maintained or upheld. Under such circumstances the proper course for the trial Court is to amend the charge under Section 227 of the Cr PC and then explain it to the accused so that he may be in position to defend himself.

17. There is a decision of the Allahabad High Court reported in — ‘Makkhan v. Emperor, AIR 1945 All 81 (A), in which the learned Judge observed:

“The whole object of framing a charge is to enable the defence to concentrate its attention on the case that it has to meet, and if the charge is framed in such a vague manner that the necessary ingredients of the offence with which the accused is convicted are not brought out in the charge, then the charge is defective.”

18. We agree with the view expressed above, and in our opinion the charge framed in this case cannot by any means be said to cover the offence for which the accused was ultimately convicted. The Counsel for the State has referred two decisions to us. The first is reported in — ‘Bejoy Chand v. State of West Bengal.’ AIR 1952 SC 105 (B). This is a Supreme Court decision in which it was held that:

“If an accused was charged under S. 307, I.P.C; he can be convicted under S. 326, I.P.C even though no charge was framed against the accused under latter section.”

19. In our opinion this decision is not applicable to the circumstances of this case. No one disputes the proposition that a person can be convicted of an offence although not charged with it under the provisions of Sections 236 and 237 of the Cr PC.

20. What is disputed is whether a person can be convicted widiout being given a proper opportunity of defending himself; in other words Sections 236 and 237 of the Cr PC are not applicable to those cases where a different set of facts is to be alleged against an accused person for securing his conviction.

21. They are applicable only to those cases where one set of facts is presented before a Court and the only question in doubt is as to which offence is applicable to that set of facts.

22. The second decision cited by the Counsel for the State is also reported in — ‘Ram Prasad v. State’ AIR 1952 All 878 (C).

23. This is a single Judge decision of the Allahabad High Court in which it was held that the omission to charge an accused person for an unlawful assembly will not vitiate the charge as a clear indication was given by mentioning S. 149 in the charge. In our opinion this case also has no application to the circumstances of this case. It was clearly held in that case that the accused was not prejudiced by this omission while we have observed above that the accused was clearly prejudiced in this case. We, therefore, find that this case is not covered by the provisions of Sections 236 and 237 of the Cr PC and the conviction of Rasul cannot be maintained. If the trial Court felt that there was evidence to convict Rasul under S. 414, I.P.C it should have amended the charge under Section 227 of the Cr PC at that stage before pronouncing the judgment. At this stage it is not desirable to reopen the whole case again when the evidence against Rasul is also not free from doubt. We, therefore, dismiss this appeal. The opposite-parties are on bail. Their bail bonds are cancelled and they need not surrender.

D.S.P

24. Appeal dismissed.