- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ram Charan v. Devendra Kumar
Factual and Procedural Background
This case arises from a dispute between two firms engaged in the cloth business: the complainant's firm located at Najibabad, Bijnor district, and the accused's firm operating as commission agents in Delhi. The complainant alleged that the accused firm agreed to purchase 60 bales of cloth from Delhi Cloth Mills and deliver them to the complainant. The accused received Rs. 6,000 by draft and Rs. 72,000 via a railway receipt and a 'hundi' arrangement through Bharat Bank, Bijnor. The complainant claimed that the accused rendered accounts only for Rs. 65,000 of the total Rs. 78,000 received and criminally misappropriated Rs. 13,000. The accused admitted receipt of the sums but contended that they had delivered cloth worth Rs. 64,184.11 and credited the remaining Rs. 12,815.05 as part payment of a previous account.
In the trial court, the accused raised objections that the Bijnor court lacked jurisdiction and that the dispute was civil in nature, not criminal. The trial court rejected both objections. On revision, the Sessions Judge opined that the Bijnor courts lacked jurisdiction and referred the matter to this Court recommending that the trial court's order assuming jurisdiction be set aside.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the trial court at Bijnor has jurisdiction to try the offence of criminal misappropriation or criminal breach of trust under Section 181(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cr PC) when the accused's agent received or retained the property at Bijnor.
- Whether the word "received" in Section 181(2) Cr PC means "actually received" only at the place where the accused personally received the property or if receipt by an agent at a place suffices for jurisdiction.
- Whether the nature of the dispute is criminal or civil for the purposes of jurisdiction.
Arguments of the Parties
Accused's Arguments
- The Bijnor court lacks jurisdiction to try the case.
- The dispute is civil in nature and not cognizable by a criminal court.
- The sum of Rs. 72,000, although paid to Bharat Bank at Bijnor on their instructions, was not "actually received" by them at Bijnor but only later at Delhi, and therefore jurisdiction does not lie with Bijnor courts.
Complainant's Arguments
- The accused firm received Rs. 6,000 by draft and Rs. 72,000 through Bharat Bank, Bijnor, under a railway receipt and 'hundi' arrangement, establishing jurisdiction at Bijnor.
- The accused failed to render full accounts and criminally misappropriated Rs. 13,000.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court focused on the interpretation of Section 181(2) of the Cr PC, which provides that a court has jurisdiction if any part of the property that is the subject of the offence was received or retained by the accused within its local limits. The critical question was whether the sum of Rs. 72,000 was "received" by the accused at Bijnor.
The Sessions Judge had interpreted "received" to mean "actually received," implying personal receipt by the accused at Bijnor, which was not the case here. However, the Court rejected this restrictive interpretation, noting that the statute does not include the word "actually." The Court held that receipt by the accused's agent (Bharat Bank, Bijnor) constitutes receipt by the accused for jurisdictional purposes.
The Court emphasized that the local jurisdiction for trying criminal breach of trust under Section 181(2) is determined solely by where the property was received or retained, regardless of where the dishonest act was ultimately committed. It is sufficient that the property was received at Bijnor through the agent, even if the accused later received it elsewhere or dealt with it dishonestly at another place.
Consequently, the Court concluded that the Bijnor court has jurisdiction to try the offence of criminal misappropriation or criminal breach of trust.
Holding and Implications
The reference by the Sessions Judge recommending the setting aside of the trial court's jurisdictional order is rejected.
The direct effect of this decision is that the trial court at Bijnor retains jurisdiction to try the accused for the alleged criminal offence. The case is remanded to the trial court for further proceedings in accordance with law. The Court did not set any new precedent beyond the interpretation of Section 181(2) of the Cr PC in this context.
1. This is a reference by the Sessions Judge of Bijnor recommending that the trial court's order assuming jurisdiction to try the case be set aside.
2. The complainant Devendra Kumar is a partner in a cloth firm of Najibabad in the district of Bijnor, styled as Yogendra Kumar Devendra Kumar, while the firm of the accused works as commission agents in cloth business at Delhi.
3. The complainant's case was that it had been agreed upon between the two firms that the accused firm was to purchase 60 bales of cloth from the Delhi Cloth Mills at Delhi as agents of the complainant & deliver the same to the complainant's firm at Najibabad; that the accused was to render accounts to the complainant's firm at Najibabad, that in consequence of the agreement the accused had first received the sum of Rs. 6,000/- by means of a draft at Delhi, whereafter 63 bales had been dispatched by them from Delhi to the complainant at Najibabad under a railway receipt “to self” through the Bharat Bank, Bijnor, which Bank was directed by the accused to pass the railway receipt to the complainant on receiving payment of a sum of Rs. 72,000/-; that out of the total receipts of Rs. 78,000/- which had been received by the accused the latter had rendered accounts for Rs. 65,000/- only but did not render accounts, for the remaining amount of Rs. 13,000/- and that this sum was criminally misappropriated.
4. On behalf of the accused it was not disputed that they as commission agents had received the sum of Rs. 6,000/- by means of a draft at Delhi and had also received another sum of Rs. 72,000/- through the Bharat Bank, Bijnor, afler they had sent 63 bales of cloth under a railway receipt, and that this subsequent amount of Rs. 72,000/- had been received under a ‘hundi’ for which the accused had sent a letter dated 18-1-1949. In that letter, the accused-firm had written to the complainant's firm that the former had sent a ‘hundi’ to be honoured by the complainant's firm and that the complainant was to pay the amount of the ‘hundi’ to the Bharat Bank, Bijnor. The case of the accused was that out of the amounts received by them they had purchased and handed over doth worth Rs. 64,184/11/- to the complainant's firm and the remaining sum of Rs. 12,815/5/- which had been left with the accused; had been credited in part payment of some previous account.
5. In the trial court two objections were taken on behalf of the accused: The first was that the court at Bijnor had no Jurisdiction. And the second was that the dispute was essentially of a civil nature and could not be taken cognisance of by the criminal court. The trial court held, that the Bijnor court had jurisdiction and that the matter was not of a civil nature. Upon revision before the learned Sessions Judge, the Sessions Judge has been of the opinion that the courts at Bijnor have no jurisdiction to try the case. The Sessions Judge has therefore referred the matter to this Court with the recommendation that the trial court's order assuming jurisdiction to try the case be set aside.
6. The question turns upon the construction of Section 181(2) of the Cr PC. That section lays down that the offence of criminal misappropriation or of criminal breach of trust may be inquired into or tried by a court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction any part of the property which is the subject of the offence was received or retained by the accused person, or the offence was committed. The question in the present case would be whether the sum of Rs. 72,000/- “was received or retained” by the accused person at Bijnor. The learned Sessions Judge observed that the word “received” in Section 181, sub-cl. (2) of the Cr PC, would mean “actually received” and that the sum of Rs. 72,000/-, although paid to the Bharat Bank at Bijnor under the instructions of the accused, had not actually been received by them at Bijnor but had been received by them actually at Delhi subsequently.
7. The Bharat Bank, Bijnor, acted as the agent of the accused and for all practical purposes the payment that had been made to the Bharat Bank was payment to the accused. Consequently, since that payment was admittedly made at Bijnor, the Bijnor court had jurisdiction to try the case. The word “actually” is not to be found in Section 181, sub-cl. (2) of the Cr PC, and we cannot import into the section something which is not really to be found there in order to support the contention of the accused that money “received” by their agent at Bijnor for them would not come within the four corners of that word in Section 181(2) of the Cr PC, and that word must be restricted in its meaning to the place where the money is actually delivered by the agent to them viz., to Delhi. The decision of the proper venue for the trial of a charge of criminal breach of trust has been taken entirely outside the ambit of S. 179 by the provisions of S. 181(2), and the local jurisdiction of a court to try a charge of criminal breach of trust must be decided solely with reference to sub-s. (2) of Section 181 of the Cr PC. Where the accused is under a liability to deliver goods at a particular place and also to render accounts at that particular place and fails to do so by reason of having committed an offence of criminal breach of trust which is alleged against him, the court, within the local limits of whose jurisdiction that place is situated, may enquire into and try the offence under the provisions of Section 181(2) of the Cr PC. It is not essential under S. 181(2) that at the time the property is said to be received or retained by the accused person he must have a dishonest intention to misappropriate it or to commit criminal breach of trust with reference to it. It is enough for the purposes of the section if the property which is the subject of the offence was received or retained by the accused at a particular place to give jurisdiction to the magistrate of that place to try the case even if the property was received quite properly and innocently at that place and was subsequently dealt with at another place dishonestly. In the present case, the money was received by the accused at Bijnor through their agents. Consequently, the Bijnor court has jurisdiction to enquire into and try the alleged offence of criminal misappropriation or of criminal breach of trust. The reference is accordingly rejected.
8. The record be sent back to the trial court through the Sessions Judge for proceeding with the trial in accordance with law.
9. Leave to appeal is refused.
B/K.S.B
10. Reference rejected.
Alert