Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Har Dayal Singh v. Ram Ujagar Dube .

Allahabad High Court
Oct 18, 1954
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a reference under Order 46, Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) made by the Judge, Small Causes, Saharanpur. The plaintiff sued in the Court of the Munsif at Saharanpur for recovery of Rs. 124 as arrears of rent in respect of accommodation in house No. 86/3 situate at Lucknow. The defendant did not reside at Saharanpur. The plaintiff instituted the suit at Saharanpur because he alleged the lessee-defendant had agreed to pay rent at the place of the plaintiff's posting; the plaintiff was posted at Saharanpur. The defendant challenged the jurisdiction of the Saharanpur Court, and the learned Munsif referred the question to the High Court for decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit for recovery of rent is maintainable in the Court at Saharanpur in view of Section 20, clause (c) of the CPC, given that part of the cause of action arose at Saharanpur by reason of the defendant's agreement to pay rent at the plaintiff's place of posting.
  2. Whether Section 16, clause (d) of the CPC (providing that suits "for the determination of any other right to, or interest in, immoveable property" be instituted where the property is situate) covers a suit merely for recovery of rent of immovable property.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The defendant had agreed to pay rent at the place where the plaintiff was posted; since the plaintiff was posted at Saharanpur, part of the cause of action arose there and the Saharanpur Court has jurisdiction.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The Saharanpur Court had no jurisdiction to entertain a suit relating to immovable property situated at Lucknow.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first observed that under Section 20, clause (c) of the CPC the suit would be cognizable at Saharanpur because part of the cause of action arose there: the lessee's agreement to pay rent at the plaintiff's place of posting (Saharanpur) gave rise to acts there. The learned Munsif had queried whether Section 16, clause (d) might require the suit to be instituted where the immovable property is situate. The court examined Section 16(d), which states:

“Subject to the pecuniary or other limitations prescribed by any law, suits for the determination of any other right to, or interest in, immoveable property, shall be instituted in the Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the property is situate.”

The court reasoned that a suit merely for recovery of rent from a lessee of immovable property is not a suit "for the determination of any other right to or interest in immovable property." It distinguished the rights enumerated in clauses (a), (b) and (c) of Section 16 (recovery of immovable property with or without rent or profits; partition; foreclosure, sale or redemption in case of mortgage or charge) from a simple rent-recovery claim. The court held that on the allegations in the plaint no question arises for determination of the plaintiff's right to the house itself; and even if the defendant raised such a challenge, that contention would not change the forum. Accordingly Section 16(d) does not cover a suit for recovery of rent.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The court held that the suit for recovery of rent is maintainable in the Court at Saharanpur; the reference is answered accordingly.

Implications: The direct effect is that the Saharanpur Court may entertain the rent-recovery suit despite the immovable property being situate at Lucknow. The opinion does not purport to lay down any broader precedent beyond this determination.

Show all summary ...

Raghubar Dayal, J.:— This is a reference under O. 46, R. 1 of the CPC, by the Judge, Small Causes, Saharanpur.

2. The plaintiff instituted a suit in the Court of the Munsif Saharanpur for the recovery of Rs. 124 as arrears of rent in respect of the accommodation in house No. 86/3 situate at Lucknow. The defendant did not reside at Saharanpur.

3. The suit was instituted in Saharanpur because according to the plaintiff the defendant lessee had agreed to pay rent at the place of the plaintiff's posting. The plaintiff happened to be posted at Saharanpur & therefore he instituted the suit there. The defendant contended that the Saharanpur Court had no jurisdiction to entertain this suit. The learned Munsif felt doubt on the legal position with respect to the jurisdiction of the Court and, therefore, made this reference.

4. The suit would be cognisable by a Court at Saharanpur in view of Section 20, cl. (c) of the CPC as part of the cause of action would arise at, Saharanpur on account of the lessee-defendant's agreement to pay rent at the place where the plaintiff happened to be posted at any particular time. The question is whether Section 16 of the CPC, would cover this suit, and the learned Munsif seems to think that S. 16, cl. (d), may include this suit. Section 16, cl. (d) is:

“Subject to the pecuniary or other limitations prescribed by any law, suits for the determination of any other right to, or interest in, immoveable property, shall be instituted in the Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the property is situate.”

5. A suit merely for the recovery of rent from a lessee of immovable property cannot be said to be a suit “for the determination of any other right to or interest in immovable property”. The rights which have been specifically mentioned in Cls. (a), (b) and (c) of S. 16 are the rights to the recovery of immovable property with or without rent or profits, to the partition of immovable property and to foreclosure, sale or redemption in the case of a mortgage or charge upon immovable property. No question of the determination of the plaintiff's right to the house arises on the allegations in the plaint. Even if the defendant challenges the plaintiff's right to the house in suit, his contention will not determine the forum. We are, therefore, of opinion that the suit for the recovery of rent of immovable property is not covered by Section 16 of the CPC.

6. In view of the above we hold that this suit is maintainable in the Court at Saharanpur. The reference is answered accordingly.

K.S.B

7. Answer accordingly.