Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Oriental Fire & Gene... v. Lalta Prasad Srivast...

Allahabad High Court
Sep 8, 1988
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion delivered by K.C. Agrawal, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from three connected appeals against the judgment of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Fatehpur, dated 21-2-1979, deciding Claim Petition No. 1 of 1977. The Tribunal partly awarded compensation to the claimant Lalta Prasad Srivastava against Rohtas Chandra Gupta (owner of Truck No. U.S.F 7229), the driver Rama Shanker Sharma, and Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company Limited (insurer).

At the time of the accident in February 1977, Lalta Prasad Srivastava was aged 39, principal of a college, earning Rs. 1,300 per month, and had seven dependants. He alleged that while riding a cycle near Police Chauki Hariharganj the truck struck him from behind, crushing him under its wheels; he was taken to Swaroop Rani Nehru Medical College, Allahabad, and became permanently disabled. He claimed Rs. 1,60,000 (or Rs. 1,50,000 in one place) as compensation.

The Tribunal found for the claimant on negligence, awarded Rs. 69,000 (broken down into treatment Rs.19,000; loss of agricultural business Rs.4,000; mental agony Rs.10,000; need for two persons to look after claimant Rs.3,600; disability compensation Rs.32,400), and the three parties (owner, driver and insurer, and the claimant in one cross-appeal) filed three appeals: F.A.F.O. No. 407 of 1979 (insurer v. claimant), F.A.F.O. No. 581 of 1979 (claimant v. owner), and F.A.F.O. No. 728 of 1982 (owner v. claimant).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the accident occurred due to the negligence/rashness of the truck driver (Rama Shanker Sharma) and whether the Tribunal's finding to that effect was supported by evidence.
  2. Whether the items of damages awarded by the Tribunal (special and general damages) were correctly categorized and supported by evidence, and whether particular items (including future claims for insurance agency income and examiner remuneration) were sustainable.
  3. Whether the Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company could be held jointly and severally liable for the entire award, or whether its liability was limited to the statutory maximum (Rs. 50,000/-), and relatedly whether a deduction of 33% from the lump sum was applicable.
  4. Whether specific components of the award (notably Rs. 3,600 for nursing) were excessive and liable to reduction.
  5. Whether the insurer, upon being impleaded under S.110-C(2A) and by reason of S.110-D of the Motor Vehicles Act, could contest the claim on grounds not available to the insured (owner) and whether collusion or other statutory limits affected the insurer's rights.

Arguments of the Parties

Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company (Appellant in F.A.F.O. No. 407 of 1979)

  • Contended the Tribunal's award was excessive and liable to be quashed or reduced.
  • Argued that a deduction of 33% from the lump sum awarded should apply (analogous to deductions applied to dependants' lump sums).
  • Maintained that the insurer's liability could not exceed the statutory amount of Rs. 50,000/-, so it could not be held jointly and severally liable for the entire Rs. 69,000/- award.
  • Relied on the statutory scheme (S.110-C(2A) and S.110-D of the Motor Vehicles Act) to define the scope of the insurer's rights to contest claims.

Rohtas Chandra Gupta (Owner / Defendant 1)

  • Denied negligent driving by the driver and alleged that because of a crowd on the road (Shiv Ratri), the claimant lost balance and came before the truck.
  • Alleged contributory negligence by the claimant and contended that the amount claimed was excessive and exaggerated.
  • Contended that the Rs. 3,600 awarded for nursing was excessive given the claimant's family circumstances.

Rama Shanker Sharma (Driver / Defendant 2)

  • Raised a defence (as per his written statement and oral evidence) that the accident was not due to negligent/rash driving; he alleged brake defects. The Tribunal found his testimony unreliable and self-contradictory.

Lalta Prasad Srivastava (Claimant / Appellant in F.A.F.O. No. 581 of 1979)

  • Claimed Rs. 1,60,000/1,50,000 as compensation for injuries, permanent disability and related losses.
  • Pressed that the Tribunal should have awarded two additional items: Rs. 50,000 as future loss from agency of Life Insurance Corporation and Rs. 4,000 as future loss of examiner's remuneration; argued the Tribunal erred in refusing these.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
British Transport Commission v. Gourley (1956) AC 185 Division of damages in personal injury actions into special damages (pecuniary losses specifically pleaded and proved) and general damages (pain, suffering, and loss of amenities; compensation for loss of earning power where continuing disability exists). The Court relied on this distinction to assess which items awarded by the Tribunal constituted special damages (medical expenses, loss in agriculture) and which constituted general damages (pain and suffering, loss of earning capacity). The Court agreed with the Tribunal's classification and awards under these heads where supported by evidence.
Phillips v. South Western Railway Co. (1879) 4 QBD 406 Principle that damages in personal injury cases must aim to give full and fair compensation once and for all; the court must give the only occasion on which compensation can be given. The Court invoked this principle to emphasize that damages should be full and adequate, and to justify giving a one-time, comprehensive award for the claimant's losses arising from the accident.
The Medians (1900) AC 113 Observation that assessment of damages is a region of great difficulty and uncertainty, but nevertheless juries or tribunals must assess compensation as best as can be done. The Court cited this passage to support the legitimacy of making a reasoned monetary assessment for pain and suffering and other non-pecuniary losses despite inherent uncertainties.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the Tribunal's findings and the record, focusing on whether the Tribunal was correct in finding negligence and in its assessment of damages. The step-by-step reasoning in the opinion is as follows:

  1. Findings on negligence: The Tribunal had believed the claimant (P.W.1) and an eye-witness Ram Bishal (P.W.2). The Tribunal found that the truck's brakes were defective or out of order and that the driver, Rama Shanker Sharma, could not stop the truck; the driver was found unreliable and self-contradictory. The Court examined the witness statements, found nothing to discredit them, and agreed with the Tribunal that the accident resulted from the driver's negligence.
  2. Assessment of damages: The Court explained the legal distinction between special and general damages (citing British Transport Commission v. Gourley). It noted that special damages (out-of-pocket expenses, loss of earnings up to trial) require specific pleading and proof, while general damages (pain and suffering, loss of amenities, prospective loss of earnings) do not require the same specific notice.
  3. Application to the award: The Court found that the claimant had established the special damages awarded by the Tribunal (medical expenses and loss in agriculture). For general damages, the Court accepted evidence of the claimant's physical condition and the Tribunal's observation of him; it agreed that the injuries caused permanent disability and that the Tribunal's award of Rs. 32,400 under that head was supportable.
  4. Rejected speculative claims: The Court addressed the claimant's contention that the Tribunal erred by refusing Rs. 50,000 (future loss from insurance agency) and Rs. 4,000 (future examiner remuneration). The Court found both items speculative and unsupported by evidence and upheld the Tribunal's refusal to award them.
  5. Insurer's statutory arguments and caps: The Court considered the insurer's contentions under S.110-C(2A) and S.110-D of the Motor Vehicles Act concerning the grounds on which an insurer may contest claims. The Court observed that there was no finding of collusion and noted that statutory provisions restrict the insurer's grounds of appeal, but the truck owner had also appealed and could contest the award on all available grounds. On the quantum of liability, the Court found substance in the insurer's argument that its liability could be confined to the statutory amount of Rs. 50,000; it therefore modified the award to make the insurer liable only up to Rs. 50,000 (with interest and costs) and left the excess recoverable from the owner and driver.
  6. 33% deduction argument: The Court rejected the insurer's claim for a 33% deduction from the lump sum, explaining that such a deduction relates to dependants' lump sums and not to the special damages and general damages awarded to the injured person in this case.
  7. Specific item of nursing charges: The Court acknowledged merit in the owner's argument that Rs. 3,600 awarded for nursing was excessive given the family status of the claimant, but found that shifting between heads (e.g., to mental agony and shock) would not materially affect the award. The Court therefore refused to set aside the award on that count.
  8. Overall disposition: Taking the above into account, the Court allowed the insurer's appeal in part (to limit insurer liability) but otherwise maintained the Tribunal's award; it dismissed the claimant's and the owner's appeals insofar as they challenged the Tribunal's award on other grounds. The Court made no order as to costs.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Appeal No. 407 of 1979 (Oriental Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd.) is allowed in part; Appeal No. 581 of 1979 and Appeal No. 728 of 1982 are dismissed.

Implications and direct effects on the parties (as stated in the opinion):

  • The Tribunal's award of Rs. 69,000 in favor of Lalta Prasad Srivastava is otherwise maintained, subject to the modification described below.
  • The liability of Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company Limited is confined to Rs. 50,000 plus interest and costs thereon; the balance of the award (Rs. 19,000) is recoverable from defendants 1 and 2 (the truck owner and the driver).
  • The Court rejected the insurer's request for a 33% deduction from the lump sum and refused the claimant's speculative future-loss claims for which no evidence was produced.
  • The Tribunal's findings on negligence, the unreliability of the driver, and the assessment of both special and general damages were affirmed except as modified to limit the insurer's monetary liability.
  • No broader precedent was declared beyond application of established principles on assessment of damages and the statutory cap on insurer liability as applied to the facts of this case. The Court specifically modified the award rather than setting new law; the award was otherwise maintained and no order as to costs was made.

Order: Appeal No. 407 of 1979 allowed in part (insurer's liability limited to Rs. 50,000 plus interest and costs); Appeals 581 of 1979 and 728 of 1982 dismissed; no order as to costs.

Show all summary ...

K.C Agrawal, J.:— These three connected appeals arise from the judgment of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Fatehpur, dated 21-2-1979, deciding Claim Petition No. 1 of 1977. The Tribunal partly awarded the claim of Lalta Prasad Srivastava against Rohtas Chandra Gupta, Rama Shanker Sharma, and Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company Limited, New Delhi. Against the aforesaid award, the three parties felt aggrieved and have filed three appeals in this Court. The details of these three appeals are being given below Z

2. F.A.F.O No. 407 of 1979, Oriental Fire F General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Lalta Prasad Srivastava; 2. F.A.F.O No. 581 of 1979, Lalta Prasad Srivastava v. Rohtas Chandra Gupta; 3. F.A.F.O No. 728 of 1982, Rohtas Gupta v. Lalta Prasad Srivastava. Lalta Prasad Srivastava was the Principal of Chandra Bhan Intermediate College, Damapur, Fatehpur. He was receiving a monthly salary of Rs. 1300/- in Feb. 1977, when the accident occurred. He was 39 years of age at that time and had seven dependants.

3. According to Lalta Prasad Srivastava, when he was going on a cycle and was on his left near Police Chauki Hariharganj, Truck No. U.S.F 7229 belonging to Rohtas Chandra Gupta, insured with Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company Limited, Asaf Ali Road, New Delhi, struck him from behind. The truck was being driven by Rama Shanker Sharma alias Ram Sajiwan. It was loaded with iron saria and was being carelessly and negligently driven. Without any horn, the truck came from behind Lalta Prasad Srivastava and struck him. The people of the lacality stopped the truck, but Rama Shanker Sharma managed to escape by jumping from the moving vehicle in a manner that he could not be caught. Lalta Prasad Srivastava was crushed, having come under, the wheels of the truck. He was taken to Swamp Rani Nehru Medical College, Allahabad, by an ambulance van where he was kept as an indoor patient initially. As a result of the accident, Lalta Prasad Srivastava suffered serious injuries, on account of which he was permanently disabled. He claimed a sum od Rs. 1,60,000/- as compensation as against the opposite parties, mentioned above.

4. The application was contested by Rohtash Chandra Gupta, defendant 1, Rama Shanker Sharma, defendant 2, and Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company Ltd., defendant 3. Rohtash Chandra Gupta denied that the accident occurred due to the negligent driving of the truck by Rama Shanker Sharma, and further alleged that on account of Shiv Ratri day there was huge crowd on the road, and that Lalta Prasad Srivastava lost his banance and came before the truck. In his written statement, Rohtash Chandra Gupta claimed that Lalta Prasad Srivastava was responsible for contributory negligence to the accident and also contended that the amount claimed was excessive and exaggerated.

5. Another written statement was filed by Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company Ltd. stating that the accident had not occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the vehicle by its driver.

6. On the pleadings of the parties, the Tribunal framed several issues. Out of these, issues Nos. 1 to 3 are important for deciding these appeals. On Issue No. 1, the Tribunal held that the accident occurred due to the negligence of the driver and it was wrong to allege that Lalta Prasad Srivastava came under the truck despite the fact that the driver tried to stop it by using its brakes.

7. The Tribunal believed Lalta Prasad Srivastava who appeared as P.W 1 and his witness Ram Bishal P.W 2 and came to the conclusion that the brakes of the truck were out of order and it was on account of the defect in the brakes that Rama Shanker Sharma could not stop the truck and the accident resulted. The Tribunal found that the brake pipe had not been replaced for a long time, and that there had been its intensive user. The Tribunal concluded that the accident took place as a result of negligence, carelessness and rashness of defendant 2 Rama Shanker Sharma. In this way Issue No. 1 was decided in favour of the claimant and against defendants 1 to 3.

8. Out of the claim for Rs. 1,50,000/-, the Tribunal awarded Rs. 69,000/- to Lalta Prasad Srivastava. The details of Rs. 69,000/- were worked out as below:

1. Treatment … Rs. 19,000.00 2. Loss of agricultural business … Rs. 4,000.00 3. Mental agony arising out of the accident. … Rs. 10,000.00 4. Need for looking after Lalta Prasad by two persons. … Rs. 3,600.00 5. Disability compensation. … Rs. 32,400.00

9. Against the award of the Tribunal, as stated above, the three parties have filed the aforesaid three appeals.

10. Before us, the argument advanced on behalf of Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company Limited was that the award was too excessive and, as such, was liable to be quashed. S. 110-C(2A), gives the grounds on which an Insurance Company can defend a case in the course of any enquiry. Under the sub-sec. (2A), the Claims Tribunal can direct the claimant to implead the insurer and, upon being impleaded, the insurer shall thereupon have the right to contest a claim on all or any one of the grounds that are available to a person against whom the claim has been made. In the present case, there was neither any case nor finding that the person as against whom the claim was made was in collusion with the claimant.

11. Under S. 110-D of the Motor Vehicles Act, an appeal can be filed by a person aggrieved When the pleas on which an appeal can be contested by an insurer are limited, the right of the insurer in the appeal would be confined only to those grounds. In other words, it will not be entitled to contend that the accident did not result on account of the negligence of the truck driver or the insured but due to carelessness of the person receiving injury or killed.

12. In the instant case before us, the aforesaid controversy is not directly of any consequence inasmuch as the appeal has been preferred by the truck owner also, who is entitled under the law to contend that, the award proceeds on illegal grounds or is not substantiated by the evidence on record. The first thing to be noticed by us is whether rashness of the driver, which has been found by the Tribunal, was established from the evidence or not. For establishing rashness, Lalta Prasad Srivastava himself came in the witness box. He was P.W 1. Ram Bishal P.W 2, who was present at the spot, had witnessed the accident. He deposed that Lalta Prasad was struck by the truck and the truck passed off after crushing the cycle and Lalta Prasad Srivastava. His statement has bee believed by the Tribunal. We have gone through the two statements and having found nothing to discredit their testimony, agree with the view of the Tribunal. Lalta Prasad Srivastava received serious injuries and remained in the hospital for several months for treatment. To us it appears that the Tribunal was right in recording the finding that physical pain and mental agony caused to him in the accident in question would certainly shorten his life by nearly ten years. He had become permanently disabled throughout the rest of his life. He could not walk and stand on his feet.

13. From the side of the defendants, Rama Shanker Sharma had been produced. The Tribunal found him to be unreliable and that is our view as well. He contradicted himself and gave a statement which is not believable, that the brake of the truck in question had become defective, as it is clear from the fact that the truck did not stop at the place where the brake was applied. The truck stopped a few paces ahead. We, therefore, find in agreement with the Tribunal that the accident resulted due to the negligence of the driver.

14. In this case, the Tribunal has awarded general and special damages. Special damages require specific pleading and the defendant is to be put on notice of the details. The general damages are presumed to flow from the injuries and the defendant cannot claim any special notice. Loss of earnings, loss of expenses, money spent for treatment are to be specifically pleaded as special damages. On the other hand, claim towards pain and suffering and loss of amenities (non-pecuniary loss) and also prospective loss of earnings fall under the category of general damages.

15. In British Transport Commission v. Gourley, (1956) AC 185, itwas stated by Lord Goddard as follows:

“In an action for personal injuries; the damages are always divided into two main parts. First, there is what is referred to as special damages which have to be specifically pleaded and proved. This consists of out of pocket expenses and loss of earnings incurred down to the date of trial, and so generally capable of substantially exact calculation. Secondly, there is general damages which the law implies and which is not specially pleaded. This includes compensation for pain and suffering and the like and if the injuries are such as to lead to continuing or permanent disability compensation for loss of earning power.”

16. In the present case, the claimant has established the special damages which have been awarded to him by the Tribunal. We are in agreement with the view of the Tribunal that medical expenses and loss incurred in agriculture are the two items covered by the same. For general damages, evidence has been led by the claimant about his physical condition. The Tribunal had also an occasion to see him when he appeared as a witness. As a result of the accident, the injuries received by Lalta Prasad Srivastava were such that the same caused permanent disability, and on account of the same the Tribunal has awarded Rs. 32,400/- under the said head.

17. Before us, arguments were advanced on behalf of Lalta Prasad Srivastava that the Tribunal committed an error in refusing to-awards compensation for two items which consisted as his claim of Rs. 50,000/- as future loss from agency of Life Insurance Corporation and Rs. 4,000/- as future loss of remuneration which he was receiving as ah examiner of the Board of High School and I Intermediate Education, U.P, Allahabad Both of these items were speculative in nature and there was no evidence on record to prove the same. We have also not been shown any such evidence on the basis of which the appellant Lalta Prasad Srivastava could claim the two items.

18. There is no merit in the claim of Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company Limited for deduction of 33 percent out of lump sum awarded to the claimant. It is only from the amount awarded to the dependants that a percentage is deducted out of the lump sum on the ground that the dependants would not have been entitled to get the same benefit immediately as the same could have been obtained during the entire span of life of the deceased. That is not the case here. To special damages, this deduction does not clearly apply. General damages have been also awarded to the person who received injuries. Consequently, the claim for deduction is unfounded.

19. The next argument on behalf of the Insurance Company was that its liability could not be beyond Rs. 50,000/- which was the statutory amount, and, as such, for the toral amount of Rs. 69,000/- awarded, there could not be joint and several liability. This part of the award is required to be modified by confining it to Rs. 50,000/- payable by the Insurance Company and the rest Rs. 19,000/- would be recoverable from defendants 1 and 2. We find substance in this submission. The liability as against the Insurance Company would be confined to Rs. 50,000/- plus interest and costs payable thereon. For the amount of damages over and above Rs. 50,000/-, Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company Limited could not be held liable. But, as stated above, the liability of payment of interest and costs on this Rs. 50,000/- would have to be borne by it.

20. There is substance in the argument of Rohtash Chandra Gupta that the amount of Rs. 3,600/- awarded as special damages for nursing Lalta Prasad Srivastava errs (sic) on the side of excessiveness. While awarding such a claim, the Tribunal is required to look into the family status and background of the person who is making a demand for the same. Keeping in view that Lalta Prasad Srivastava i was a teacher and that he had family members, including his wife, to us it appears that awarding of such a sum was not justified. But, to us, it further appears that under the head of mental agony and shock Lalta Prasad Srivastava was entitled to get more than Rs. 10,000/- awarded by the tribunal, as against which he has filed F.A.F.O No. 581 of 1979. We would shift the amount awarded under this head to one of mental agony and shock. This shifting would not be of any material consequence. Consequently, we refuse to set aside the award on that count.

21. The law as to the general nature of damages has been stated to be the ascertainment of the considerations which will make good to the sufferer, as far as money can do, the loss which he has suffered as the natural result of the wrong done to him. If the original position cannot be restored — as indeed in personal injury or fatal accident cases it can obviously be — the law must endeavour to give a fair equivalent in money, so far as money can be an equivalent and so make good the damage. The two main elements in personal injury actions are: (1) personal loss and (2) pecuniary loss. Damages in personal injury actions are not punitive, still less a reward. They are simply compensation. Damages must be full and adequate and as Field, J. said in Phillips v. South Western Railway Co., (1879) 4 QBD 406:

“You cannot put the plaintiff back again into his original position, but you must bring your reasonable common sense to bear, and you must always recollect that this is the only occasion on which compensation can be given. (The plaintiff) can never sue again for it. You have, therefore, now to give him compensation, once and for all. He has done no wrong; he has suffered a wrong at the hands of the defendants, and you must take care to give him full and fair compensation for that which he has suffered.”

22. The difficulties and uncertainties that attained the task of assessment should not preclude an assessment as best as can, in the circumstances be made. In the Medians, (1900) AC 113, Lord Halsbury said:

“Of course, the whole region of inquiry into damages is one of extreme difficulty. You very often cannot even lay down any principle upon which you can give damages; nevertheless, it is remitted to the jury, or those who stand in place of the jury, to consider what compensation in money shall be given for what is a wrongful act. Take the most familiar and ordinary cases: how is anybody to measure pain and suffering in money counted. Nobody can suggest that you can by any arithmetical calculation establish what is the exact amount of money which would represent such a thing as the pain and suffering which a person has undergone by reason of an accident……But, nevertheless, the law recognises that as a topic upon which damages may be given.”

23. For the reasons given above, Appeal No. 407 of 1979 filed by Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company Limited is allowed in part, and the award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Fatehpur, dated 21-2-1979 is modified to this extent that the liability for payment as against Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company Limited is confined to Rs. 50,000/- plus costs and interest payable thereon.

24. In other respects, the award of the Tribunal is maintained. Appeal 581 of 1979 and Appeal No. 728 of 1982 are dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.

25. Order accordingly.