If a reasonable inquiry does not reveal that such person or entity did in fact have some interest in the subject property or as great an interest as such person or entity conveyed, or if it appears from the context of the situation that the person or entity did not in fact have some such interest, then the examiner may waive objection to the defect caused by the said instrument, if the instrument is not such an instrument as is or could become a root of title under the Marketable Record Title Act.
Authority: Tenneco Oil Co . v. Humble Oil & Refining Co., 449 P.2d 264 (Okla. 1969); See Pearson v. Mullins, 369 P.2d 825-829 (Okla. 1962); 25 O.S. § 13.
Comment: Since the decision in Tenneco, supra, the standard as it existed prior to Tenneco permitting examiners to ignore stray instruments, even with its caveat, and the standard as it was amended in 1976 (see Standard 3.1, 1988 Title Examination Standards Handbook) are not supported by the law and therefore ought not to be continued. While it is true that many stray instruments are the result of a scrivener's error in drafting the description, it is also true that an instrument may appear to be stray because the grantor failed to record the instrument which carried title to said grantor. When the situation is of this latter kind, the case comes under the facts and decision in Tenneco, supra . For this reason the examiner who knows of a stray instrument must make such inquiry that will assure the examiner that the grantor in the stray instrument did not have some interest in the property even though it be not of record.
A stray instrument or abstract thereof which is or could be a root of title under the Marketable Record Title Act, 16 O.S. §§ 71-80, may not be disregarded by the examiner, but must be regarded as creating, or potentially creating, a root of title under the Marketable Record Title Act.
Authority: Mobbs v. City of Lehigh, 655 P.2d 547 (Okla. 1982); 16 O.S. §§ 71-80.
Comment: See Comment, Standard 30.7 and Comment 4, Standard 30.9; see also 60 O.S. § 515.1, relating to condominium unit instruments involving over conveyances.
Otherwise the stray instrument must be regarded as creating or potentially creating, a root of title under the Marketable Record Title Act and creating a valid cloud on title.
Authority: 16 O.S. § 76.
Caveat: 16 O.S. § 76 does not directly address the situation where an otherwise "stray" instrument, as defined under the statute has been of record for more than thirty (30) years and is, at the time, the apparent root of title. However, because of the requirement of Section 76(b)(1), that there must be an "otherwise" valid chain traceable to an instrument "which is a root of title as defined by Sections 71 through 80" of Title 16, it would appear that the mere recording of an affidavit after the stray instrument had already ripened into a root of title would not be sufficient to revoke the status of such stray instrument as a root of title. However, the issue is not directly addressed by the Statute, nor by an reported decision.
Okla. Stat. tit. 16, § 3.1