Court Filter
FEDERAL COURTS
STATE COURTS
Apply Filter
Judge Filter
Filter by Judge Name (Beta)
Motion Filter
Filter by Motion (Beta)
*Please select motion
Other Filters
2010 Onwards41588
From 2000 To 201016361
From 1990 To 20006284
From 1980 To 19903382
From 1970 To 19801655
From 1960 To 1970539
From 1950 To 1960296
Before 1950421

Cases cited for the legal proposition you have searched for.

Loading..

Showing 100 of 4707 results

...requested phone monitoring will invade the target's Fourth Amendment rights."); Cell Site Information, 2005 WL 2739208, at *26 ("to the extent the government asserts that i.... Some might argue that historical cell ...government sought my permission and I required it to show probable cause. The government claims a warrant is never required because cell site information does not implicate the Fourth Amendment...

...question is whether the issuance of a court order for cell site information under section 2703 and the Pen Register Statute is unconstitutional because it violates the Fourth Amendment's prohibition agains..., inter alia, information pertaining to the location of cell site towers receiving a signal from a particular cellular telephone for a period of 60 days. The Court's Order expired on December...cell site information with respect to the same target telephone. The relevant portions of the application seek, for a period of 60 days, "cell site activations" for the telephone...

...precedent, “[c]ompelled warrantless disclosure of cell site data violates the Fourth Amendment.” Id. at 846. The Government filed objections with the district court to the...lowers the standard the Government must meet to compel disclosure of historical cell site information below that required by the Fourth Amendment. Second, it claims that the magistrate judge's... Historical Cell Site Data, 747 F.Supp.2d at 846 (concluding that “[c]ompelled warrantless disclosure of cell site data violates the ...

...privacy test to decide what Fourth Amendment rights people have in cell-site location information, explaining that "no single rubric definitively resolves which expectations of privacy are entitle...information from a third party does not overcome Carpenter's claim to Fourth Amendment protection. The Government's acquisition of the cell-site records was a search within the meaning of the ...collected by the FBI because he had shared that information with his wireless carriers. Held: 1. The Government's acquisition of Carpenter's cell-site records was a Fourth...

...government cannot demonstrate that cell site tracking could never under any circumstance implicate Fourth Amendment privacy rights, there is no reason to treat cell phone tracking differently from...rights under the Constitution. The government may sincerely believe that it is free to engage in warrantless monitoring of cell site information, but it has not attempted to do so here. Indeed, judicial...SUBSCRIBER INFORMATION AND/OR CELL SITE INFORMATION. No. M 05-1093 (JO). United States District Court, E.D. New York. October 24...

...constitutional rights under the Fourth Amendment by failing to demonstrate probable cause before obtaining cell-site information under the SCA. ( Id.) The Court will now turn to that.... II. FOURTH AMENDMENT CLAIM Defendant and amici curiae argue that the government obtained cell-site data in violation of the Fourth ...private home then it might raise Fourth Amendment concerns). Among the courts that have come to the opposite conclusion that the use of cell-site data obtained without a warrant based...

...presented here concern the Government's supplemental application for prospective cell-site information. Because of the complexity and significance of these legal issues, the court invited the Electronic...otherwise subject to interception under this chapter.") II. The Government's Request for Prospective Cell-Site Information... On August 19, 2008, after it appealed Judge Orenstein's Amended Orders, the Government made a supplemental application to this court for prospective cell-site information...

...the Fourth Amendment by doing so because a search warrant is mandated to obtain such records. Specifically, Defendant argues that because obtaining the historical cell site information from the third...search warrant to acquire them. Although the Seventh Circuit has not explicitly addressed the issue of whether historical cell site information raises Fourth Amendment issues thus... that have addressed a Fourth Amendment challenge to obtaining cell site information have analyzed the request under the third party/business reco...

...prosecutor to seek a Rule 41 search warrant. Because the government cannot demonstrate that cell site tracking could never under any circumstance implicate Fourth Amendment privacy rights, there is no...word about the Fourth Amendment implications of cell site tracking is in order here. The government contends that probable cause should never be required for cell phone tracking because there is no...of certain customer records including historical cell site data. However, the order denied access to prospective cell site information, for reasons explained more fully in this opinion...

...defendant's historical cell site information by requesting an Order Authorizing Disclosure of Cellular Telephone Billing Records and Cell Site Number and Location.... Historical cell site information involves records that identify the relay tower or towers through which a customer's calls are handled, thereby identi...phone records to find his historical physical location, in violation of his Fourth Amendment rights. Since there are no facts in dispute, we review the legal issue...

.... §§ 2701 et seq. The Magistrate Judge allowed the government access to the customer's subscriber information but refused it permission to access historical cell site information.... Subscriber information includes a customer's name and address, as well as telephone connection and billing records. Cell site information encompasses...records identifying the relay tower or towers through which a customer's calls were handled. Magistrate Judge Alexander held that access to cell site information may be obtained only pursuant to a...

.... Fourth Amendment Based on her assumption that the cell site information soug...) Authorizing Release of Subscriber Information and/or Cell Site Information. No. 06-5021M-01. United States District Court, W.D. Louisiana, Shreveport...prospective information disclosing the location of cell site/sector (physical address) at call origination (for outbound calling), call termination (for incoming calls) and, if reasonably available...

...HISTORICAL CELL SITE INFORMATION FOR MOBILE IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS: (XXX) XXX-AAAA, (XXX) XXX-BBBB, and (XXX) XXX-CCCC. Nos. MJ07-264-JLA [(XXX) XXX-AAAA], MJ07-265-JLA [(XXX) XXX-BBBB...has before it the Government's application for three orders compelling a telecommunication service provider to disclose to federal law enforcement agents historical cell site information. The..., questions the applicability of the "specific and articulable facts" standard to historical cell site information. As more fully detailed below, after careful consideration of the pertinent statutes...

...historical cell site information. With regard to the issue of applying the Fourth Amendment to the acquisition of these records, Judge...CELL SITE INFORMATION. Graham, 846 F.Supp.2d at 404, 2012 WL 691531, at *18...to obtain what has been termed “historical cell site information” that is, data from the telephone provider's records relative to two telephone numbers which are assigned to two cellular telephones...

...), compelling the production of a third-party telephone company's business records containing historical cell tower location information, violated Davis's Fourth Amendment rights and was thus unconstitutio...disclose cell tower location information does not violate a cell phone user's rights under the Fourth Amendment any more than a court order compelling a bank to disclose customer account ..., which authorized the government to obtain the cell site information, satisfied the reasonableness requirement of the Fourth Amendment. See...

...”). Defendant argues his Fourth Amendment rights were violated when law enforcement obtained historical cell tower site location information transmitted from his cell...information constituted a search under the Fourth Amendment, and required a warrant. Whether the retrieval of cell tower site location information, triggered by Defendant's use of his ...States has not decided whether historical cell tower site location information raises Fourth Amendment issues. Similarly, this issue appears to be a case of first impression for North Carolina appellate...

...disclosure of cell site data violates the Fourth Amendment under the separate authorities of Karo and Maynard. Accordingly, the Government's requests for that information under the S...), 2010 WL 3463132 (E.D.N.Y. Aug. 27, 2010) (holding that historical cell site information is protected by the warrant requirement of the Fourth Amendment...to historical cell site data. Rather than definitively resolving the Fourth Amendment issue, the court remanded the case to the district court...

.... Amicus next argues that permitting the disclosure of cell site information under the Pen Register Statute and the Stored Communications A...argues that there is no Fourth Amendment problem because cell phone users have no legitimate privacy interest in information they voluntarily turn over to third parties. It relies chiefly on Smith vs... IN RE: APPLICATION OF THE UNITED STATES FOR AN ORDER FOR PROSPECTIVE CELL SITE LOCATION INFORMATION ON A CERTAIN CELLULAR TELEPHONE. No. 06...

...cell site tower location information (hereinafter "cell site data") at the inception and termination of a call made and received by an identified cellular telephone. While the cell site d...Obtain Cell Site Location Information (hereinafter "Government Memorandum") at page 2 and note 3. (Docket #4). The government asserts that non-historical...Information and/or Cell Site Information, 396 F. Supp. 2d 294 (E.D.N.Y. 2005); In re Application of the United States for an Order Authorizing the...

...of information to a third party does not implicate the Fourth Amendment"). Some other courts have concluded, unpersuasively, that cell-site-location records should be treated..., violates the Fourth Amendment rights of those who have a justifiable interest in the privacy of the residence." Karo, 468 U.S. 713-18. There, the Court held that use of an electronic tracking device...that is protected by the Fourth Amendment. The proposed sealed order directs the cell-phone service provider to "disclose recorded information identifying the base station towers and sectors that...

...cell site location information occurred only when his vehicle was on public roads where it “ ‘could have been observed by the naked eye,’ so no Fourth Amendment violation occurred during Tracey's..., the use of real time cell site location information to track Tracey violated the Fourth Amendment because probable cause was required, but not provided, to access and use that information...or based on the Fourth Amendment, for an order requiring disclosure of real time cell site location information to be used by law enforcement to track a subscriber's cell phone. In 1967, long befo...

...' intent to protect cell site location information from utilization as a tracking tool absent probable cause under the Fourth Amendment"); Adelman ED Wis. 2006 Opinion at *5 (concluding that "[i]f...requiring the disclosure of prospective cell site information allowed the government to `track' a suspect . . . into a protected area like a home" no "reasonable Fourth Amendment expectation of privacy...prosecutor to seek a Rule 41 search warrant. Because the government cannot demonstrate that cell site tracking could never under any circumstance implicate Fourth Amendment privacy rights, there is no reas...

...re Application (Fifth Circuit)) (holding the government can use “[s]ection 2703(d) orders to obtain historical cell site information” without implicating the Fourth Amendment (emphasis omitted..., Tied Up in Knotts? GPS Technology and the Fourth Amendment, 55 UCLA L.Rev. 409, 455 (2007). Much like long-term GPS monitoring, long-term location information disclosed in cell phone...without triggering Fourth Amendment protection. The records to the right of that line list the cell phone towers used at the start and end of each call—information the majority now holds is protected...

...Court—whether regardless of any federal or state statutory provisions, the use of real time cell site location information to track Tracey violated the Fourth Amendment because probable cause was...statutory scheme or based on the Fourth Amendment, for an order requiring disclosure of real time cell site location information to be used by...authorizing statutes—is whether accessing real time cell site location information by the government in order to track a person using his cell phone is a Fourth Amendment search for which a warran...

.... § 2703(d), compelling the production of a third-party telephone company's business records containing historical cell tower location information, violated Davis's Fourth Amendment rights and was...violated his Fourth Amendment rights by obtaining historical cell tower location information from MetroPCS's business records without a search warrant and a showing of probable cause. Davis contends...court order compelling a telephone company to disclose cell tower location information would not violate a cell phone user's rights under the Fourth Amendment even in the absence of the protection...

.... . ., 402 F.Supp. 2d 597, 605 (D. Md. 2005) ("The government claims a warrant is never required because cell site information does not implicate the ...privacy and therefore constitutes a Fourth Amendment search. However, the precision of GPS and cell site location technology considered in combination with other factors demonstrates that pinging a.... . ., 396 F. Supp. 2d 294, 323 (E.D.N.Y. 2005) ("Because the government cannot demonstrate that cell site tracking could never under any circumstance implicate ...

...cell site location information under the SCA does not categorically violate the Fourth Amendment as to historical information, but expressly limiting this holding to historical ...(2014) (holding police officers' use of “real-time” cell tower site location information to track defendant was a search falling under the purview of the Fourth Amendment...tracking him via [cell site location information] technology”). The Eleventh Circuit's en banc decision reiterated long-standing Fourth Amendment principles...

...the federal courts have addressed the question with conflicting results. Appellant contends that the real time interception of his cell phone signal violates his Fourth Amendment rights as incorporated...cellular phone and find his approximate position via real time cell site location information. Detective Chris Kolarchno defined pinging at the suppression hearing as determining the real time...(emphasis added). The critical inquiry in this case is whether the government must have probable cause to locate a person through real time cell site location information from the person's cellular phone...

...a beeper in a private residence, a location not open to visual surveillance, violates the Fourth Amendment rights of those who have a justifiable interest in the privacy of the residence." Id...location information through the "hybrid" theory. See, e.g., In re Application of the United States for an Order for Prospective Cell Site...that historical cell site information provides only a rough indication of a user's location at the time a call was made or received. The Government correctly notes that Agent Shute did not state that...

... IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA FOR AN ORDER AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF HISTORICAL CELL-SITE INFORMATION. 10-MJ...issuance of a warrant for historical cell-site information pursuant to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 41, id. at 2 n. 1, but it nevertheless has expressly declined to seek such relief.... As the caption suggests, the information at issue is commonly referred to as "historical cell-...

...' argue that the cell site location data acquired by the Government in the present case must be suppressed because it was obtained in violation of Title III of ECPA and the Fourth Amendment. Defendant...combination of statutory and Fourth Amendment analysis, the majority of federal courts examining the requirements for the acquisition of real-time cell site location data mandate that the government make a...obtain real-time cell site location data. C. Fourth Amendment Defendants also argue that the acquisition of cell site location data without a ...

...applied Knotts and/or Karo to cell-site data are divided. Some have found that the government's use of cell-site information to get a general location does not violate the Fourth ...36 in Eatontown.” (Emphasis added). We cannot find sufficient credible support in the record for the factual finding that the cell-site information was accurate within a one-mile radius. See...F.Supp.2d 113, 119–20 (E.D.N.Y.2011) (seeking long-term, historical information); Historical Cell Site Data, supra, 747 F.Supp...

.... Notably, the court did not specifically hold that Fourth Amendment protections apply to cell-site information, see id. at 323, or that the probable-cause standard would.... Five years later, the same court extended Fourth Amendment protection to historic cell-site information. In re Application of the U...Rule 41 governs the request for prospective cell-site information and finding a Fourth Amendment privacy interest in location); In re Application of United States for an Order Authorizing Disclosure...

...obtain cell-site records for the 4017 phone. Nor has the court been able to identify any Connecticut or federal court decision holding that section 54–47aa violates the Fourth Amendment in the context...whether the requests for historical cell-site data constituted Fourth Amendment searches, Laurent's motion to suppress is DENIED. A. Background....) B. Legal Standard Laurent contends that the Government obtained this historical cell-site data in violation of the Fourth Amendment. (Omnibus Mot. at...

...the precision that would be required to implicate Fourth Amendment concerns. Thus, Congress could authorize disclosure of limited cell site information on a showing of less than probable cause if it...calling features, and the capture of limited geographic or cell site information, all for a period of sixty days from the date of the order. (Docket No. 37, 39). The court has issued sealed orders...granting the government's applications as to all requests except the requests to obtain limited geographic and cell site information, which was denied without prejudice for the government to resubmit its...

...historical cell site location data, without a warrant but pursuant to the Stored Communications Act, was in violation of their Fourth Amendment rights and must be suppressed. The Defendants do not argue...presented, i.e., whether a defendant's Fourth Amendment rights are violated when the government acquires historical cell site location data without a warrant based on probable cause, is one of...question presented in this case: Whether the defendants' Fourth Amendment rights were violated when the government acquired historical cell site location data pursuant to an Order of a Magistrate Judge of...

...communication contents under the authority of the Pen/Trap Statute. The second is whether limited cell site information may be obtained.... II. Limited Cell Site Information Invoking the same legal theory rejected by this court last fall..., the Government again seeks to obtain an order authorizing access to prospective cell site information as part of a criminal investigation. This time, the Govern...

... search under the Fourth Amendment depending on the location (Karo) and, potentially, quantity (Knotts) of that information." Historical ...holding that section 54-47aa violates the Fourth Amendment in the context of a request for historical cell-site data. Cf. O'Meara v. Terra, No. 10-CV-1424 (MRK...12-13.) Since the court agrees that the good faith exception to the exclusionary rule applies, regardless of whether the requests for historical cell-site data constituted Fourth Amendment searches...

...court decision holding that section 54–47aa violates the Fourth Amendment in the context of a request for historical cell-site data. Cf. O'Meara v. Terra, No. 10–CV–1424 (MRK...Fourth Amendment searches, Laurent's motion to suppress is DENIED. A. Background Laurent's motion concerns historical cell-site data...the Government obtained this historical cell-site data in violation of the Fourth Amendment. (Omnibus Mot. at 2.) The Fourth Amendment guarantees that “[t]he right of the people to be secure in th...

...providers to disclose "cell site information concerning the physical location of antenna towers associated with the beginning and termination of calls to and from the subject cellular telephone" and...), outlining its position that an order to obtain prospective cell site information can be entered upon less than probable cause pursuant to the combined authority of...because the proffered statutory authority is insufficient. Unless and until Congress takes further action, the court may only authorize disclosure of prospective cell site information upon a showing...

...Fourth Amendment. So he moves to suppress the cell-site data. (Dkt. 56, Mot. to Suppress Cell Site Location Information.) (His motion is joined by Pembrook (Dkt. 57), Briley (Dkt. 58), an...530 (1984), Calhoun also argues that cell-site data has the potential to reveal information about a person's home and is thus shielded from warrantless searches by the Fourth Amendment. (Mot. to...warrant was required to obtain the cell-site data associated with Calhoun's accounts, the Court cannot say that the Government recklessly disregarded Calhoun's Fourth Amendment rights by proceeding...

...court found that “the use of the Hailstorm violates the Defendant's Fourth Amendment rights,” and “any information generated from the use of the Hailstorm [must] be suppressed.” The court continued on..., 2015, in which he challenged the BPD's surreptitious use of the Hailstorm cell site simulator to search Andrews's phone, without a warrant, under the Fourth Amendment to the United States...” under the Fourth Amendment. The State maintains that the circuit court's decision “was based upon both factually unreasonable conclusions about how the cell site simulator worked in this case, and...

... ORDER AFFIRMING DENIAL OF APPLICATION FOR HISTORICAL CELL SITE LOCATION INFORMATION ...18 U.S.C. § 2703(d) authorizing the government to obtain historical cell site location information (“CSLI”) associated with [Redacted] target cell phones. ECF No. 4.... Sanders's records reveal 11,517 calls for which location information was logged, comprising 23,034 cell site location data points. Id. ¶ 9. Carpenter and Sanders, respectively, placed or received...

.... Specifically, Magistrate Judge Smith granted the request for a pen register and trap — and trace device but denied access to cell-site information and post-cut-through dialed digits...). The Government's applications provide definitions of "cell-site information," "call-detail records," and "post-cut-through dialed digits." "...and Use of a Pen Register Device, a Trap and Trace Device, and for Geographic Location Info., 497 F. Supp. 2d 301 (D.P.R. 2007) (denying access to cell-site information...

...alia, a court order authorizing the use of a pen register to capture and report prospective cell site information for the purpose of tracking a fugitive. Upon reading the application, I found that...cell site information can be entered upon less than probable cause pursuant to the combined authority of 18 U.S.C. § 3121 et seq. (the "Pen/Trap...cell site information, and, to the extent the application seeks such information, it is hereby DENIED. I do note that the application seeks data other than prospective cell site ...

...) orders to obtain historical cell site information” without implicating the Fourth Amendment (emphasis omitted)). And although the fourth of our sister courts opined that “[a] cell phone...government can acquire without triggering Fourth Amendment protection. The records to the right of that line list the cell phone towers used at the start and end of each call—information Defendants...concur in Judge Motz's fine opinion. The court rightly holds that obtaining historical cell site location information (CSLI) from a third party cell phone provider is not a search under the Fourth...

...."After hearing argument, the circuit court found that "the use of the Hailstorm violates the Defendant's Fourth Amendment ....2d 294, 323 (E.D.N.Y.2005)("Because the government cannot demonstrate that cell site tracking could never under any circumstance implicate Fourth Amendment privacy rights, there is no reason to...including exhibits—on June 30, 2015, in which he challenged the BPD's surreptitious use of the Hailstorm cell site simulator to search Andrews's phone, without a warrant, under the Fourth Amendment to the...

...agents violate Subdiaz–Osorio's Fourth Amendment rights when they procured his cell phone location information without first obtaining a court order...Subdiaz–Osorio's Fourth Amendment rights. ¶ 70 Seeking and obtaining the defendant's cell phone location information is assumed to be a search in this opinion because of the privacy...) (holding that the government must demonstrate probable cause in order to obtain cell site tracking information due to Fourth Amendment privacy concerns...

...violated the Fourth Amendment and suppressed the evidence. The Court of Appeals assumed, for the sake of argument, that use of a cell site simulator by law enforcement officers is a search for purposes of.... It granted the motion on the ground that the use of the cell site simulator to locate the phone was a search for purposes of the Fourth Amendment and tha...down into three parts: (1) Search - Was use of the cell site simulator in this case a search for purposes of the Fourth Amendment? (2...

...and trap-and-trace device and authorizing the release of subscriber and other information, including cell-site information. Three types of cell-site information are sought: call originati...standards in the statutes the government invokes to authorize access to cell-site information, 18 U.S.C. §§ 3121- 27 (the "Pen Register Statute") and...information may not be obtained "solely pursuant" to the Pen Register Statute, 47 U.S.C. § 1002(a)(2). These courts permit the government to obtain cell-site...

...opposed to private, areas. Decisions that have applied Knotts and/or Karo to cell-site data are divided. Some have found no violation of the Fourth Amendment, while others have found...that the Fourth Amendment requires that police get a warrant to obtain cell-site data. A more recent decision of the United States Supreme Court rested on principles of trespass. United States v...and seizures than the Fourth Amendment. When people make disclosures to phone companies and other providers to use their services, they are not promoting the release of personal information to others...

...Fourth Amendment), and United States v. Davis, 754 F.3d 1205 (11th Cir.2014) (obtaining cell site location data without a warrant violates the...year a divided Fifth Circuit panel held that orders for historical cell site records under the SCA do not categorically violate the Fourth Amendment..., among other information, cell site data for a target phone “on a continuous basis contemporaneous with” the beginning and end of a call, and if reasonably available, during the call as well...

...time” or prospective cell site location information (“CSLI”). We hold that there was no Fourth Amendment violation, because law enforcement used real time CSLI to track Tracey's location only on...Guipson Vilbon's cell phone; Vilbon was arrested at the same time as Tracey but was not prosecuted. FN4. See Adam Koppel, Note, Warranting a Warrant: Fourth Amendment Concerns Raised by... did not mention the collection of real time cell site location information. The circuit court granted the...

...the “majority rule” that Criminal Rule 41 governs the request for prospective cell-site location information and finding a Fourth Amendment privacy interest in location..., 125 S.Ct. 1050, 160 L.Ed.2d 1001 (2005) (holding that “pinging” the defendant's cell phone to gather cell site location data did not violate the ...particular points in the past ... [but] Fourth Amendment concerns might be raised if cell-site data were used to track the present movements of individuals in private locations.”); In re Application...

...whether use of a cell site simulator is a search for purposes of the Fourth Amendment or whether the court order authorizing its use fell short of a search warrant, the detectives in this case acted in...as well as his statements to police. He asserted that the Police Department's use of a cell site simulator was a warrantless and unreasonable search in violation of the Fourth Amendment and that the...Circuit Court ruling. Citing its previous decision in Andrews , the intermediate appellate court held that the use of the cell site simulator was a Fourth Amendment search and that the order...

...erred in denying his motion to suppress evidence derived from "real time" or prospective cell site location information ("CSLI"). We hold that there was no Fourth Amendment violation, because law...to hold that historical cell site information "does not implicate Fourth Amendment protections." Here, the monitoring of the CSLI occurred only when Tracey's vehicle was on...the cell phone company to provide the sheriff's office, "[i]n accordance" with 18 U.S.C § 2703(d), "historical Cell Site Information indicating the...

...Fourth Amendment and Cell Phone Location Tracking: Where Are We?, 29 HASTINGS COMM. ENT. L.J. 421, 426-27 (Spring 2007); Recent Development, Who Knows Where You've Been? Privacy Concerns...contend that "[p]rosecutors appear to routinely take the view that the government can obtain cell site location information without a warrant, by simply presenting to a magistrate `specific and...Information Act, seeking to obtain documents relating to the government's use of cell phone location data in criminal prosecutions. The district court directed the release of certain specified documents...

...the GPS location information emitted from his cell phone was a warrantless search that violated the Fourth Amendment.” United States v. Skinner..., 81 (D.Mass.2007) (no Fourth Amendment interest in prospective cell-site data). In large part, the Sixth Circuit relied upon the fact that “Skinner was.... The Government expressly reserved its right to argue that it could obtain prospective cell-site information without showing...

... Fourth Amendment and Cell Phone Location Tracking: Where Are We?, 29 Hastings Comm. & Ent. L.J.. 421, 426–27 (Spring 2007); Recent Development, Who Knows Where You've Been? Privacy.... The plaintiffs contend that “[p]rosecutors appear to routinely take the view that the government can obtain cell site location information without a warrant, by simply presenting to a magistrate...plaintiffs brought this action against the Department of Justice under the Freedom of Information Act, seeking to obtain documents relating to the government's use of cell phone location data in criminal...

...that [law enforcement] acquired the CSLI [cell site location information] in violation of Defendant's Fourth Amendment rights, the Leon good faith exception, as further applied by...cell phone violated his Fourth Amendment rights. The government opposes the motion, contending that no search occurred and that if it did, it was justified by exigent circumstances, a reasonable good...visual surveillance, violates the Fourth Amendment rights of those who have a justifiable interest in the privacy of the residence.” Id...

...private residence, a location not open to visual surveillance, violates the Fourth Amendment rights of those who have a justifiable interest in the privacy of the residence”). We similarly have...Constitution, the Commonwealth may obtain from a cellular telephone service provider (cellular service provider) historical cell site location information (CSLI.... The term “cell site location information” (CSLI) refers to a cellular telephone service record or records that contain “information identifyin...

... IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA FOR AN ORDER AUTHORIZING THE DISCLOSURE OF PROSPECTIVE CELL SITE INFORMATION...disclosure of prospective cell site information exclusively pursuant to 18 U.S.C. §§ 2703 and 3122..., including cell site information, from the target telephone for incoming and outgoing calls for a period of sixty (60) days from the date of this order." (App. at 4.) What makes this particular...

...tracked his cell phone using cell site information and a stingray because the tracking constituted a search that violated the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution and Article I, Sect...issue of whether tracking through cell site information and a stingray “violates a subjective expectation of privacy that society recognizes as reasonable” is not before us because the State has...Amendment comes into play when obtaining cell site information in part because any electronic documents have necessarily been shared with a third party. See...

...government violated his Fourth Amendment rights when it obtained real-time cell-site location information (CSLI) for his phone from his telecommunications provider. Also not involved in this case ...argued in this appeal that his Fourth Amendment rights were violated when the government obtained cell-site location information from cellular providers...." II. Discussion Mr. Jones claims that the government's use of a cell-site simulator violated his Fourth Amendment rights and that the trial...

...omitted). Thus, even though the DEA believed that the use of the cell-site simulator would reveal the location of a phone associated with criminal activity, the Fourth Amendment requires the Government to.... The use of a cell-site simulator constitutes a Fourth Amendment search within the contemplation of Kyllo. Absent a search warrant, the Government may not turn a citizen's cell...its business purposes."). II. Fourth Amendment Considerations The Government argues that, even if the use of the cell-site simulator...

..., appellant has not argued in this appeal that his Fourth Amendment rights were violated when the government obtained cell-site location information from cellular providers. See United States v...cell-site simulator violated his Fourth Amendment rights and that the trial court erred in failing to grant his motion to suppress. In deciding this Fourth Amendment claim, we defer to th...government's acquisition of historical cell-site location information (CSLI) from a suspect's cellphone provider is not a search under the Fourth Amendment. United States v...

...18 U.S.C. § 3121(c), as the service provider may have available, to capture and report all call-identifying and Cell Site Location Information...developing topic. Four decisions address the specific request made here, which is to obtain Cell Site Location Information. Magistrate Judge Gorenstein...denied an application inApplication of the United States of America for an Order Authorizing the Release of Prospective Cell Site Information, 407 F. Supp.2d 134, 2006 WL...

...private property for the purpose of obtaining information. We have no doubt that such a physical intrusion would have been considered a “search” within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment when it was...) and in the locations of the Jeep on the public roads, which were visible to all. But we need not address the Government's contentions, because Jones's Fourth Amendment rights do not rise or fall with...whether the action in question would have constituted a “search” within the original meaning of the Fourth Amendment. Where, as here, the Government obtains information by physically intruding on a...

...-fares. Knotts. His challenge rests solely with whether the warrantless installation of the GPS device, in and of itself, violates the Fourth Amendment."). Thus prompted, the Seventh Circuit...L.Ed.2d 774 (1989), which arose not under the Fourth Amendment but under the Freedom of Information Act, 5 U.S.C. § 552. There the respondents had...reasonably required to complete that mission"), and (2) unreasonably searched the van, all in violation of the Fourth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States. The district court held the...

...settled law. Further, the Government disputes Wilford's argument that cell phone pinging violates Maryland law and the Fourth Amendment, and maintains that, in any event, the pinging orders comported... UNITED STATES of America, v. Richard Anthony WILFORD. Susan Freiwald, Cell Phone Location Data and the Fourth Amendment: A Question...use of GPS tracking technology violated his Fourth Amendment rights. Additionally, Wilford asserts that, despite court authorization obtained under Maryland's pen register and trap and trace statute...

... IN RE APPLICATION OF THE UNITED STATES FOR AN ORDER FOR PROSPECTIVE CELL SITE LOCATION INFORMATION ON A CERTAIN CELLULAR TELEPHONE. No. 06 Crim.... (Sealed Application of A.U.S.A. Christine Y. Wong, 2/22/06.) The Government's application also seeks prospective cell site location information, specifically an order...law enforcement agencies) ("Cell Site Location Information"), for all calls made to or from the CELLPHONE; . . . (2/22/06 A.U.S.A. Wong Application ¶ 2.) The...

...conclusion that the Government's acquisition of cell site location data is not a “search” within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment. See, e.g... The Government explains that there are two ways to obtain historical cell site data. In the typical case, the Government requests information connected to a particular cell phone...Release of Historical CellSite Information, 809 F.Supp.2d 113, 122, 126–27 (E.D.N.Y.2011) (hereinafter In re E.D.N.Y. Application ) (holding that “ cumulative cell-site—location...

...disclosure of the historical cell-site information amounted to a search for the purpose of the Fourth Amendment, requiring a showing of probable cause. (Def. CellSite Mot. at 4.) Defenda...the Fourth Amendment, requiring a warrant issued upon a showing of probable cause. See In re Historical CellSite Info, 809 F.Supp....2d at 116. In In re Historical CellSite Info, this court explained that, in determining whether governmental action constituted a “search” for the purpose of the Fourth Amendment, two...

...Court held that "[t]he monitoring of a beeper in a private residence, a location not opened to visual surveillance, violates the Fourth Amendment rights of those who have a justifiable interest in the...convey the cell-site simulator results to DEA agents, who then had to come up to the apartment from the street. Second, a surreptitious Fourth Amendment violation should reasonably extend the time...site location information ("CSLI") for a target cell phone. Pen register information is a record from the service provider of the telephone numbers dialed from a specific phone. CSLI is a record of...

...cell users had a Fourth Amendment reasonable expectation of privacy in historical cell site location data. Id. at 6. He pointed to several courts, including one magistrate judge in this...decision considers only the Fourth Amendment question, and the court finds that collecting cell site location data does not constitute a search under that amendment. Background...case, the Fourth Amendment required the government to obtain a warrant in order to obtain the cell tower information. Dkt. No. 9 at 6. The Defendant's Objection The...

...for them to rely on the magistrate's Orders granting them access to the information. The officers who obtained the CSLI did not violate Hardrick's Fourth Amendment rights "deliberately, recklessly or.... Hardrick is now moving to suppress cell-site location information ("CSLI") that police officers obtained on two occasions during the course of their investigation.... In his applications, Detective Wischan certified that the subscriber and cell-site location information...

...present case. B. Fourth Amendment In addition to his statutory contentions, Garner argues that the cell-site data and all resulting evidence should...within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment when they obtained Garner's cell-site data. C. Warrantless arrest...Amendment to the United States Constitution. The cell-site data and resulting evidence, Garner claims, should therefore have been suppressed. Forest joins in Garner's claims under Title...

...enforcement officers violated the Fourth Amendment when they obtained Defendant's cell site data pursuant to a state court order.../dispatch services" and the disclosure of subscriber, cell site and call detail information and GPS and E911 location information for two cellular telephone numbers registered in Defendant's name ("pen...cell site information for the period of July 2, 2013 through July 16, 2013 and real-time cell site information for the period of July 17, 2013 through September 15, 2013 for telephone number (910)...

...obtaining cell site location data without a warrant violates the Fourth Amendment. ECF No. 20 ¶ 3. In Riley, the Court stated that “[m]odern cell phones, as a category, ...the business records/third-party doctrine by the Fourth Circuit, the Court finds that Giddins's Fourth Amendment rights were not violated when the government obtained his cell site location data...Historical Cell Site Location Data Giddins contends that the government's warrantless gathering of cell site location data violated Giddins's Fourth Amendment right to privac...

...warrantless collection of historical cell site data violates a criminal defendant's Fourth Amendment rights. The Davis court condu...probable cause to obtain prospective cell site data, and (2) the Fourth Amendment requires a showing of probable cause to obtain historical cell site data. The government disagrees, relying on a "...do so violates his rights under the Fourth Amendment. Conversely, the government argues that it need only comply with the SCA's required showing of "specific and articulable facts...

...Constitutions by Gathering Historical Active Cell-Site Location Information without a Warrant. Zanders argues that police violated his Fourth Amendment and Article 1, Section 11...double-edged swords, increasing convenience at the expense of privacy. Each time they make or receive calls, they leave a trail of digital crumbs known as historical cell-site location information...disagree. Under federal precedent, the Fourth Amendment does not require police to obtain a search warrant to gather information an individual has voluntarily relinquished to a third...

...magistrate judge denied each of the government's applications and held that "warrantless disclosure of cell site data violates the Fourth Amendment." In re U.S...cell site information, prospective cell site data falls outside the purview of the Fourth Amendment. As such, "the SCA's authorization of § 2703(d) orders for [prospective] cell .... concurring)). Whether obtaining prospective cell site data constitutes a search within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment is still an open question in this Circuit...

.... Defendant cites to the Supreme Court in arguing that the cell site location data at issue here violates the Fourth Amendment. Defendant points to the case of United States v. Karo...that the government does not violate the Fourth Amendment in acquiring cell site location data from a service provider. Id. The court finds the reasoning underlying these...locating an individual's cell phone "falls within the ambit of the Fourth Amendment when it reveals information that could not have been obtained through visual surveillance." United States v. Karo...

..., without disclosure of the government's investigative practices, they would have no way of knowing whether their Fourth Amendment rights were being trampled. Invoking the government's "almost...to safeguard Fourth Amendment rights generally through its deterrent effect. . . ." United States v. Leon, 468 U.S. 897, 906...concur in the result the majority reaches, I write separately to provide clarification concerning whether Warshak's emails, obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment, should have been excluded from...

...information sought by the Twitter Order and that warrantless disclosure of that information violated the Fourth Amendment. Specifically, she rejected Petitioners' argument that the IP address...Expectation of Privacy in IP Address Information As a general rule, the Fourth Amendment forbids warrantless searches. City of Ontario, California v. Quon, ––– U.S...Petitioners' use of Twitter. Doc. 45 at 20–24. The government responds that Petitioners have no Fourth Amendment interest in IP address information because the mere possibility that IP address records...

.... Streett's Fourth Amendment rights." Supp. Motion at 2. Streett states that the Supreme Court of the United States held in Carpenter v. United States "that the prosecutor's request for cell...on a person's property to obtain information. A Fourth Amendment search may also occur where the government violates a person's subjective expectation of privacy that society recognizes as reasonable...residence," and, thus that "evidence obtained as a result of th[is] unreasonable search . . . was wrongfully obtained in violation of Mr. Streett's Fourth Amendment rights, and should be excluded...

..., relied on the Katz v. United States test to determine that the United States violated the defendant's Fourth Amendment rights by obtaining his cell-site records without a warrant. See...searches and seizures." U.S. Const. amend. IV. Fourth Amendment rights are enforceable against state actors through the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause. See Mapp v. Ohio...the motion to suppress had his own Fourth Amendment rights infringed by the search and seizure which he seeks to challenge." 439 U.S. at 133...

...it to date. This failure to address the privacy rights for the Fourth Amendment concerns of these innocent subscribers whose information will be compromised as a request of the cell tower dump is..., some courts have rejected arguments that probable cause and the Fourth Amendment must be applied to requests for historical cell site data. See...-phone users maintain a reasonable expectation of privacy in long-term cell-site-location records and that the Government's obtaining these records constitutes a Fourth Amendment search...

...government are not protected by the Fourth Amendment. Doc. 873 at 41. Courts have rejected Defendant's arguments that historical cell-site records cannot be..., 690 F.3d 772, 777 (6th Cir. 2012) (holding that locating defendant through a phone's cell-site records is not a Fourth Amendment search). Contrary to Defendant's arguments, federal courts..., the district court explained that "this Court knows of no federal court that has held that the use of prospective cell-site records constitutes a search under the Fourth Amendment, or of any federal...

...facts” standard, some courts have rejected arguments that probable cause and the Fourth Amendment must be applied to requests for historical cell site data. See...expectation of privacy in long-term cell-site-location records and that the Government's obtaining these records constitutes a Fourth Amendment...States for Historical Cell Site Data, 747 F.Supp.2d. at 835–37. Consequently, cell site data are protected pursuant to the Fourth Amendment from warrantless searches. Id. at 838–40....

...Amendment search). [31] Although historical location data is content-free, it is more than simple routing information. The cell-site data tracks a cell phone user's location across specific points in time..., violated his Fourth Amendment Rights. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY [4] On January 31, 2015, at...the historical location data from Zanders' cell phone for its own records, and the State merely requested copies of those business records. Contrary to well-established Fourth Amendment doctrine, the...

...Four, there were three subclaims: 1. The ping order and related search warrants violated Ayers' Fourth Amendment rights. 2. Mr. Goldberg, who was suppression counsel, provided ineffective assistance...and (2) Authorizing Release Of Subscriber Information And/Or Cell Site Information, 396 F. Supp. 2d 294, 307-309, 314 (E.D.N.Y 2005)(Orenstein, M.J...Numbers and the Production of Real-time Cell Site Information, 402 F. Supp. 2d 597, 600-602 (D. Md. 2005)(Bredar, M.J.); In the...

...ORDER: (1) AUTHORIZING THE INSTALLATION AND USE OF A PEN REGISTER AND TRAP AND TRACE DEVICE; (2) AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF SUBSCRIBER AND OTHER INFORMATION; AND (3) LOCATION OF CELL SITE ORIGINATION AND...whereabouts of the cellular caller, while the second request seeks "historical" cell site location information. Either way, the Government is requesting an order requiring cellular phone companies to.... In re . . . Cell Site Information, 412 F.Supp.2d 947 (E.D.Wis. 2006) ("Wisconsin Decision"). ...

...circumvent the exception in the CALEA is contrary to Congress' intent to protect cell site location information from utilization as a tracking tool absent probable cause under the Fourth Amendment. The...ORDER: (1) AUTHORIZING THE INSTALLATION AND USE OF A PEN REGISTER AND TRAP AND TRACE DEVICE; (2) AUTHORIZING THE RELEASE OF SUBSCRIBER AND OTHER INFORMATION; AND (3) LOCATION OF CELL SITE ORIGINATION AND...the duration of the call presumably to "track" the whereabouts of the cellular caller, while the second request seeks "historical" cell site location information. Either way, the Government is...

...the definition of "call-identifying information." As the agency explains in its brief, a mobile phone "sends signals to the nearest cell site at the start and end of a call. These signals, which are...legal authority to intercept individual telephone calls and to obtain certain "call-identifying information." In this proceeding, telecommunications industry associations and privacy rights...(e.g., answering party). Interim Standard/Trial Use Standard J-STD-025, at 5. Because cell phone location information and the four challenged punch list...

...” as part of the USA PATRIOT Act. See In re Application of the United States for an Order for Prospective Cell Site Location Information.... In re Application of the United States for an Order for Prospective Cell Site Location Information on a Certain Cellular Telephone, 460 F.Supp.2d at 455. No...F.Supp.2d at 438–39;see also In re Application of the United States for an Order for Prospective Cell Site Location Information on a...

...Authorizing Disclosure of Historical Cell Site Information for Telephone Number [Redacted] Steven B. Wasserman, U.S. Attorney's Office...MAGISTRATE JUDGE Pending before the Court is a Renewed Application pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2703(d) that seeks historic cell site location information (“CSLI...”). See Renewed Application for Disclosure of Historical Cell Site Information Pursuant to Title 18 U.S.C. Section 2703(d) [# 2] (under seal). After careful consideration and a...

...his motion to suppress the cell site location information and the admission of that evidence violated his constitutional rights under the Fourth Amendment. Second, he argues that the prosecutor's...by the Fourth Amendment and was properly obtained under a court order. As we suggested above, the question whether cell site location information is protected by the Fourth.... In short, we hold that cell site location information is within the subscriber's reasonable expectation of privacy. The obtaining of that data without a warrant is a Fourth Amendment...

...) 2014-04-17 In the Matter of the Application of the United States of America for an Order Authorizing Disclosure of Historical Cell Site Information for Telephone Number...seeks historic cell site location information (“CSLI”). See Renewed Application for Disclosure of Historical Cell Site Information Pursuant to Title 1...Cell Site Information for Telephone Number [Redacted], 1:13–MC–199, 1:13–MC1005, 1:13–MC–1006, 2013 WL 7856601, at *5–6 (D.D.C. Oct. 31, 2013...

...), as support for his contention that obtaining cell site location data without a warrant violates the Fourth Amendment. ECF No. 20 ¶ 3. In Riley, the Court...Historical Cell Site Location Data Giddins contends that the government's warrantless gathering of cell site location data violated Giddins's Fourth Amendment right ...subscriber information, historical call records, and historical GPS/cell site information. Id.; see also ECF No. 23–1. On that same...

Loading..
Loading..

Please log in or register for a free trial to access these features.

s Register now

Got It